Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I just let this friendship go?

62 replies

RainbowsAndShit · 19/07/2021 17:36

There is a group of us who've been friends since school, we were very close growing up and still meet up and chat regularly now.

A few of us are married and all but one of the girls has children now.

Friend without DC is married to a man who does not want children at all. She has struggled with this since they've been together and I believe is quite depressed about it. However, she makes it very hard for anyone to help her.

I do feel for her, we've all started to have children around about the same time and I know she struggles with that.

But it's gotten to the point now where we are not allowed to talk about our children at all (we honestly don't go on about them but if we mention them at all she gets upset). She won't attend anything where our children are, which is fine but then also refuses to attend if we try and arrange things without them.

We have a group WhatsApp with her where none of us talk about our kids and we have now made a separate one without her for us to share the occasional things about the kids (a few of us often look after the others DC's so we use it for that ect), which I feel bad about but don't know what else to do. I know she'd be really upset if she knew that.

She is regularly telling us individually how pissed off she is with us for having DC, she knows it's not rational but it annoys her.

Her husband is adamant and has been since they met, I know a few of the girls in the group are confused about why she even continued with him if it was such a big thing for her but I try not to judge. But it is getting to the point where we just don't know what to say to her anymore.

Is it best just to let this go? I don't get the impression she really even likes any of us anymore and is constantly just annoyed or upset with us purely because we have children.

What do I do? I want to be a good friend but I don't know if that's continuing to push or to leave her be?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Baggingarea · 20/07/2021 13:18

OP in your heart of hearts do you want the friendship to continue? If yes, it sounds like she is having a real crisis here and it's too much pressure for you to deal with at the moment. Yes it's unreasonable behaviour but if she's such a good friend do you want to get her help? It sounds like the husband couldn't give a toss. I know you said you don't want to suggest therapy but could you meet up with the sole purpose of asking her what she needs and if she wants to be your friend? I'm not sure ditching her will make either of you happy.

gamerchick · 20/07/2021 12:55

You know what, I'd have the row. You're wanting to fuck her off anyway. Tell her if she wants kids then she needs to ditch the bloke and find someone else, but none of you are going to tip toe around her anymore.

thing47 · 20/07/2021 12:46

Without wishing to sound unsympathetic, I don't think you need to pander to this. When you have children, they do tend to be central to your lives (whether you want them to be or not!), and that is the reality of the situation.

Expecting people not to talk about them, and even to pretend they don't exist, is not reasonable. The friendship is unlikely to be sustainable if that is what she wants so I would say you act normally ie talk about the children, ideally not to the exclusion of every other topic and if she finds that unbearable then the onus os on her to absent herself form such meet-ups.

Saltyslug · 20/07/2021 06:42

I don’t think you need to do anything. Continue as you are, being considerate. She’s clearly really upset about the child aspect and is working things through herself but not coming through the other end. If you’ve any courage maybe you could chat to her, say you notice she’s unhappy and finding the group stressful because of the baby issue and tell her you’re worried that it seems like something she really wants and is it worth leaving her partner and finding someone who wants the same thing

Summerfun54321 · 20/07/2021 00:41

Let the friendship fizzle out. If she’s a really good friend then you can reconnect in a few years time when she’s either accepted her DH or has dumped him and found a new one.

Biscoffbiscou · 20/07/2021 00:17

She sounds really distressed – what a shit dilemma to be in. Could you not have a chat with her and check she’s ok? It’s clearly creating awkwardness already so get how you might be reluctant to broach what’s obviously a sensitive topic, but if she’s a friend you care about, it seems pretty harsh for you all to consider dropping her at the same time. It sounds like she could do with some support ending her marriage tbh.

Saoirse82 · 20/07/2021 00:06

Could she disguising infertility by saying her DH doesn't want children? It seems a bizarre way to behave otherwise because she still has options if he doesn't want children she can leave and likely have them since she's still young. If it was infertility I'd have a lot more sympathy but if she's made this choice herself then I'd speak to her about it or start to distance myself. She's obviously very unhappy if she's behaving like this and if imagine her marriage will struggle to survive if this is how low she is about it.

PrincessNutella · 20/07/2021 00:01

She is being very unreasonable. Kids, while great, are also a big challenge. They take up a huge amount of time and energy and they are right there in the middle of a parent's life. You don't have to love your friend's kids, but you should have their backs as parents, and respect the hard work they are doing.

Dogvmarmot · 19/07/2021 23:56

@Nayday

It depends on how good a friend and what she means to you.

The kindest but hardest thing to do will be to tell her, gently, but tell her the truth about the situation 'I feel for you but I have children, so they will come up in conversation and we are going to meet up with kids because that's part of our friendship too. I'm sorry your DH doesn't want children'.

It's almost like she's not facing the situation with her husband and trying to avoid your kids. You may do her a favor, she clearly isn't at peace with the decision x

that sounds like a good way to go. Its one thing to want to occasionally meet up for adult time but you cannot pretend you dont have children. I am sure she wouldnt pretend not to have a husband if she had single friends. BTW maybe very gently ask her if she is sure she is ok with no children - as sometimes... the time for children passes and DH leaves for another woman and has baby almost immediately. sadly seen it happen. So she had better make sure its her choice in the event the marriage breaks down.
Els1e · 19/07/2021 23:50

It’s tricky. I was once in a similar situation to your friend many years ago. Married and DH at the time not keen on kids but going along with me. Turned out later that I had medical problems making it difficult to conceive. Anyway, I was at that time with a group of long term friends, all who had young children. And that’s ALL they could talk about. It was so boring and monotonous. I eventually realised nothing was going to change, their whole life was their kids, so I distance myself from the group. DH didn’t last but since then been with DP and have step children as well as lots of nieces and nephews who I can spoil. Travelled the world and feel I’ve made the most out of life. I occasionally bump into individuals from that group. They just moan about their teenagers and are still boring.

Graphista · 19/07/2021 23:40

I think I would have a gentle but firm conversation with her saying you understand it's difficult for her and she's clearly struggling and perhaps needs to address that with a professional. Also that she is not being fair to you or others with dc expecting you to behave as if your dc don't exist! I would also point out to her that this IS a choice she's made, by staying with someone who doesn't want dc she is deciding not to have them herself. She has agency in this.

However prickly she may be I think the air needs to be cleared. Either she'll take what you're saying on board and address it in some way. Or she'll take my ridge and cease the friendship which to be honest is probably better sooner than later.

Not discussing with her is really just delaying the inevitable

I lost 3 before dd and was dx with endo, there was a point I really thought I might never be a mother, I had dd but then it turned out I have a rare condition which meant future pregnancies would likely prove fatal and so couldn't have any more.

I went through periods were I couldn't be around pregnant women or babies (and I LOVE babies)

But I recognised it was my issue that I needed to work through and had therapy both times to work through everything in my mind.

What I didn't do was expect people to not get on with their lives and celebrate and enjoy their dc. I avoided certain events when things were too raw like christenings but I sent cards and genuine best wishes, and when and where I was able i explained to people.

The vast majority of people were understanding aside from a dick colleague of ex's who made an unsavoury comment just days after the last mc while I was still in hospital very unwell and ex very nearly lamped him! Frankly I wouldn't have blamed him! Some people are dicks - on both sides of this type of situation.

This sounds like a long term/ongoing issue and not due to a recent thing she has had to get her head around.

While some women (perfectly validly) choose to be child free the fact is most women still have dc at some point, she's going to end up very lonely if she alienates all women, indeed people, with dc

If you're all at the point of walking away anyway you've nothing to lose and may even help her.

How old is she and her husband?

If she were posting on here I'd be warning her about the frequency of men who won't have dc with 1st wife/partner but then in their 40's/50's sod off with someone new and knock them up within a year! Seems to be happening more and more these days.

Her husband is right, she needs to either decide to accept not having dc or leave him and have dc either alone or with someone else.

I'd advise her to do the latter.

This same friend will, if she has a kid in the future, make her kid the centre of everything and expect you all to dote on it and bring it to every meet up

Ohhhh yes! I'm amazed there hasn't been an "accidental" pregnancy already, wouldn't be surprised if there was in the near future either.

JoyOrbison · 19/07/2021 23:08

A pet fly?

Is your friend's name Billy William the third? Grin

However, I would just start chatting at get together about your dc, like people usually do, and if she gets funny use the suggestions from other posters to pull her up on this. She can't keep penalising you for a decision she has made and is unhappy with. If she doesn't want to leave her partner to try and start a new chapter she has no room to complain. The fact her partner is threatening ut us the end if she keeps going on is another risk - she might lose her dp as well.

Honeyroar · 19/07/2021 22:59

I think you’ve indulged her too much for too long. I think you’re going to have to be a little cruel to be kind. Tell her you’ve all been as kind and accommodating as you all could so that she could get used to the fact that the man she’s chosen doesn’t want a family. But tell her that her scathing comments about the fact you all have children are actually very hurtful and upsetting. Say that your children are very important to you and you hate having to pretend they don’t exist to her. Say that she either needs to get help to come to terms with her situation or leave her situation. Say that she’s putting a massive strain on her friendships. She might well take offence and storm out initially, but something might go in when she takes time to reflect. Either way you can’t go on like this any longer..

billy1966 · 19/07/2021 22:43

Let the friendship fade.

She needs to sort her head out.

IMO when you start having children you have enough to juggle without PITA friends.

You need friends who are supportive and who wish you the best.

They certainly don't need to be on the same path as you, but there needs to be mutual support.

Anything else is just more work.

larkstar · 19/07/2021 22:42

I agree with @GreenFingersWouldBeHandy and @FlowerArranger - this is one of those times when true friends should step even if they think their efforts might not be welcomed - you would be acting in her best interests by trying to get her to open up about what she is really feeling - she may well be regretting putting herself in this situation - if this is how she really feels, if having children is important to her she will have to make some big decisions - she'll need friends and support - it's OK for her to have realised her true feelings or changed her mind.

I wish my sister had said something about the difficulties she was having conceiving - she never said a word until it was far too late - not having children completely shapes her character - she is very sad and bitter about it.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 19/07/2021 22:18

She is extremely defensive and I imagine would rather us all just pretend we don't have children.

Well, that's impossible, And In that case, given the title of your post...Then yes, let this friendship go.

Sorry.

DukeofEarlGrey · 19/07/2021 22:16

Oh, and she should definitely get a fly if she doesn’t already have one.

DukeofEarlGrey · 19/07/2021 22:15

I think you have a couple of options here. Either gently move back from the friendship altogether, or try the ‘intervention’ suggested by a PP. I wouldn’t normally support the latter as she doesn’t sound ready to take responsibility for herself yet, but if you are only late 20s/early 30s then she has plenty of time to find a new partner and have children of her own. Not that you need to spend lots of energy getting her to that, but maybe it would help her to have it spelled out as she seems unable to see the wood for the trees. Also, women are fed such bullshit about fertility that she may consider her chances to be over - I was astonished to find that one of my friends thought she needed to ‘get on with it’ because she’d been brought up to believe that women should complete their families by 25.

Nayday · 19/07/2021 22:00

It depends on how good a friend and what she means to you.

The kindest but hardest thing to do will be to tell her, gently, but tell her the truth about the situation 'I feel for you but I have children, so they will come up in conversation and we are going to meet up with kids because that's part of our friendship too. I'm sorry your DH doesn't want children'.

It's almost like she's not facing the situation with her husband and trying to avoid your kids. You may do her a favor, she clearly isn't at peace with the decision x

Bigboysmademedoit · 19/07/2021 21:52

The years you have with your friends having kids together are precious and you are all missing out by not talking about them, meeting up together with them etc. This same friend will, if she has a kid in the future, make her kid the centre of everything and expect you all to dote on it and bring it to every meet up. I’ve experienced this - don’t acknowledge your children but expect the world to revolve around theirs. She’s being unreasonable with her friends and partner - do what suits the group and if she declines to join in then leave her to it. Too much bitterness.

Anyusernameleft · 19/07/2021 21:18

I think you should just ask her to think about your friendship & if it is too hard for her to continue & explain kindly that what she is doing is asking you to be utterly silent about a huge important part of your life and, although she has her personal reasons around this, it is not fair to ask this of you as a friend. I don't think it s okay to want a baby herself so badly but choose a path (with this man) that means she will not have a child if she stays with him but then effectively punishes you for being true to yourself & making a life choice to have children. I am sure it is heartbreaking for her but she needs to accept the consequences of that choice...it is up to her if she can maintain the friendship...if she wants to then it should be real & honest. She doesn't have to be the 'auntie' at the b'day parties & all that...but you can't be silenced about your children or pretend you don't have any in her company. I feel very sorry for her...but there comes a point where you just can't enable any more.

Sarahlou63 · 19/07/2021 21:14

@MouseInCatsClaws

i agree that a gentle but truthful conversation is worth having: "I'm finding it difficult to be friends with someone who is so obviously resentful of a very important part of my life".

If she realises how her friends view this aspect if her, it might give her a push towards accepting her situation, or changing it.

This. If you care about her you owe her this honesty.
drpet49 · 19/07/2021 21:09

* Every time she says she's pissed off you had kids, you need to say, 'We're really fed up with you saying that - it's very hurtful.' 'Did you honestly think we all wouldn't have kids?' She needs to be called out on how ridiculous she's being. I'd also stop arranging things around her. Organise events with the kids without feeling guilty and it's her problem if she misses out. You've all indulged her, but you can't go on like this.*

^Spot on

Motherofking · 19/07/2021 20:58

I do think she is too much. I had a friend who had fertility issues and cried when she found out i was pregnant because of it , so i chose to keep baby related topics away from her. however she has always asked about my son and was very happy when i gave birth. i find it very hard to feel sorry for your friend since she made that choice to not have children

youdoyoutoday · 19/07/2021 20:53

"She is regularly telling us individually how pissed off she is with us for having DC"

I'd drop the friendship based on that! I know it sounds harsh but that would just annoy me!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread