Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my neighbour is wrong to play music in the garden?

160 replies

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 11:21

I work from home (always, not just a few days a week or because of Covid) and my office opens onto my garden. The section of garden it opens onto is about three metres or so from the boundary fence that separates our garden from our neighbours'.

This neighbour (who we don't have the best relationship with for a number of reasons - but I should say he's attended anger management courses in the past and other neighbours warned us about him in the past) built some kind of permanent gazebo attached to the fence (which also takes light away from our living room but it's been there for longer than we could now report it so it's there to stay) and given they are a retired couple, they spend most of their days sitting there, smoking and playing music. When their grandchildren come over to use the temporary pool, it's constant shrieking (and throwing stuff into our garden!).

We usually don't say anything but today they have started playing some sort of techno music so loud that the people on my conf calls can hear it through my laptop microphone (I have the door open because of the heat).

I tried to call out 'hello? hello?' in a 'friendly voice' but nobody answered. So they either left the music going and left the garden, or just don't care at all. I am getting more and more annoyed at the fact that I might end up having to close the door because of their music, especially in this heat.

AIBU to think they should be more considerate? That when they built that structure attached to the boundary fence they should have realised they couldn't use it as if it where further from our garden?

And, more importantly, how can I get them to stop playing loud music? Thank you!

OP posts:
Meruem · 19/07/2021 13:15

For 3 weeks they were digging the road outside my house with noisy machinery 8am until 4pm. I wfh and I couldn’t hear myself think. I ended up wearing headphones and playing storm sounds on YouTube to drown them out! It is what it is. No one can expect silence when wfh. I hate loud music too but it is the day time. You can report them but it’s unlikely to help, that’s the harsh reality. People who are selfish in the first place rarely back down in these scenarios.

Gothichouse40 · 19/07/2021 13:14

I would ban the playing of music in gardens. I would not subject my neighbours to my taste in music. Pity that many people don't seem to feel the same. I think it's pure selfishness to inflict your music on others. We all live too close together nowadays to do this.

MereDintofPandiculation · 19/07/2021 13:10

It’s really not anti-social to enjoy your own outside space though… even more so during the daytime. It is if by doing so you stop someone else enjoying their outdoor space

TheQueef · 19/07/2021 13:07

I know the limit of my capability JG
I can't control others but I am in control of my own actions.
I hate my job already so if I can avoid extra stress I do.
Getting wound up over something you can't control is just a waste of energy.

Sure some threads are just people having a chimf and a grumble, understandable but the reality is you can't control what others do.

MagicSummer · 19/07/2021 13:07

This would drive me crackers, OP. I hate to hear music from other people's gardens when I am trying to have a quiet half-hour with a book and glass of wine. I think it is very selfish to inflict your taste in music on others. It beats me why some people have to have music wherever they go - at home, in the garden, in the car, walking down the road, in shops!

HelenHywater · 19/07/2021 13:07

My neighbour plays music in her garden every afternoon too. It's really annoying and I can't work downstairs because of it, so I get how irritating you find it.

But I think you have to suck it up unfortunately. I actually think it's really selfish to inflict your music on everyone else, but I suspect my neighbours find my dogs and my children pretty irritating too.

AddressLabel · 19/07/2021 13:05

@puffyisgood

Some music, played at sensible volumes, at sensible times, is NBU.

Incessant, deafening, music IBU.

Home working is a bit of a game changer because it's changed many people's idea of what constitutes 'sensible times'. e.g. a neighbour's small back garden backs onto a school playground, you [unsurprisingly] get a right old racket from it during playtimes, she never much cared because she was out at work all day, now it's an issue.

I work from home and this doesn’t bother me as I know it will stop at a certain time. My garden backs onto a nursery, and the primary school is behind that. I can hear the children playing at break times and sometimes I can hear the nursery children singing songs with their teacher and it makes me smile.

It’s the knob heads that think it’s acceptable to inflict their shite taste in music on the rest of the street that piss me off. Yeah it’s your garden, but it’s extremely anti social to force your noise onto other people trying to enjoy their gardens or want to have their windows open. Children playing etc is fine, that’s to be expected. Music? No, there should be a law that bans this if you ask me. Absolutely no need for it.

Weirdwonders · 19/07/2021 13:04

There’s no need for anyone to play music in their garden, ever. It’s noise pollution in any context and it’s not comparable to chatting or child noise. The people who does this are the ones who need to realise they have neighbours, not the other way round.

BruceAndNosh · 19/07/2021 13:03

Playing loud music in the garden is incredibly anti social

FrownedUpon · 19/07/2021 13:00

People shouldn’t play music in their garden full stop. It ruins the peace for everyone else around them. It’s incredibly selfish and ignorant.

WeAllHaveWings · 19/07/2021 12:53

Making noise when enjoying your garden, talking/children playing is all part and parcel of living close together.

Playing music in your garden is antisocial and inconsiderate. If anyone wants to hear music while outside they should use headphones.

Unfortunately, there isn't much you can do about it other than ask and/or put up with those that are inconsiderate.

JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush · 19/07/2021 12:49

@Toaste

The neighbours can do what they want on their land - if you are so in need of a quiet space why dont you relocate your office? Surely you could move to another room for conference calls and the like if this really is a problem. Or just accept it

Alternatively get an office at another location - I presume you are running a business from home to save money on office costs. Maybe if you want a quiet environment you should work in an office block where other people are working not a residential area? Just a thought?

Supremely unhelpful.

There really are some ludicrous comments on here today.

@InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest As I said, just call the council and report your neighbour.

I'm out. Can't deal with the anti social neighbour apologists on here.

Thing is, I don't believe what they say anyway, and strongly believe they would never put up with it themselves. Ignore them. YANBU to be pissed off.

JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush · 19/07/2021 12:47

@WorraLiberty

Why should she HAVE to?!

Because she's a sensible adult and aware that only she can guarantee a positive outcome?

I mean she could spend all day bumping her gums on Mumsnet but what would that change?

Someone else with no joined up thinking. Confused

I think a few of you on here have not woken up yet!

Toaste · 19/07/2021 12:46

The neighbours can do what they want on their land - if you are so in need of a quiet space why dont you relocate your office? Surely you could move to another room for conference calls and the like if this really is a problem. Or just accept it

Alternatively get an office at another location - I presume you are running a business from home to save money on office costs. Maybe if you want a quiet environment you should work in an office block where other people are working not a residential area? Just a thought?

WorraLiberty · 19/07/2021 12:46

Why should she HAVE to?!

Because she's a sensible adult and aware that only she can guarantee a positive outcome?

I mean she could spend all day bumping her gums on Mumsnet but what would that change?

newnortherner111 · 19/07/2021 12:45

Given the anger management issues you describe, call the council about the noise. Or the police if the smoking is not tobacco.

JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush · 19/07/2021 12:44

@Blossomtoes

Why should she HAVE to?!

Because she’s chosen to. Are you always this obtuse?

No, are you?

I am saying WHY should the people who are quiet/well behaved ALWAYS be the ones who have to ADAPT?

No joined up thinking from you. Are you awake dear?

noirchatsdeux · 19/07/2021 12:44

I feel your pain. The wanker who lives downstairs at the bottom corner of our L shaped block of flats started sawing, drilling and hammering in the communal garden...at 7am! He also sets up both a tent and swimming pool in the garden for his granddaughter who then spends the whole day screeching...right below my living/bedroom windows. Add in the radio with Boomer radio on high volume and the noise pollution is incredible. I've no choice but to have all my windows on that side of the flat shut all day. The person I feel most sorry for though is my neighbour on my floor who works nights...

JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush · 19/07/2021 12:43

Why are the people who are behaving well/not being anti social, always the ones who have to ADAPT? Confused

Such bullshit.

@InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest Contact the council about these awful neighbours. Fuck wearing headphones. This is not normal, acceptable noise and the apologists on here bloody well know it.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2021 12:42

Why should she HAVE to?!

Because she’s chosen to. Are you always this obtuse?

JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush · 19/07/2021 12:41

@Blossomtoes

Why? Why is it YOU that adapts?

She literally just said why - i. It disturbs me so it's me that adapts

Why should she HAVE to?!
Nanny0gg · 19/07/2021 12:41

Sorry, loud techno music played in the garden is anti-social

So would loud Mozart be (though at least, melodic)

That can't be compared to the sound of children playing which is perfectly reasonable (though constant shrieking is not)

I'd hate it whether working or not.
Don't inflict your choices on other people

JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush · 19/07/2021 12:41

But why can't her neighbour just have some consideration and play their music more quietly? What's wrong with that? Why do they have to have their music so loud that it becomes an anti-social noise nuisance?

All of you pointing the finger at the OP don't seem willing to address the fundamental questions here: why does this music have to be played so loudly? Why and how does the neighbours right to play music so loudly trump the OP's right to work and have some peace and quiet?

Exactly this. ^

I would hate to live next door to some of the posters on here.

Also, it makes me laugh on this type of thread, when some posters say 'why don't you move into the middle of a field if you want peace and quiet?' The noisy feckers are the ones who need to move into the middle of a field. QUIET people aren't affecting other people around them, NOISY people are!

Natty13 · 19/07/2021 12:40

Perhaps they've positioned the speaker where it is to block the noise of your work calls?! One of my neighbours had a lot of work calls in their garden/in a room with the door and window open with no headset last summer so I got to hear all their business dealings. I never, ever listen to music but you better believe I put some on as I'd rather listen to it in my garden than the neighbours' business strategy.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2021 12:40

Why? Why is it YOU that adapts?

She literally just said why - i. It disturbs me so it's me that adapts