Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my neighbour is wrong to play music in the garden?

160 replies

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 11:21

I work from home (always, not just a few days a week or because of Covid) and my office opens onto my garden. The section of garden it opens onto is about three metres or so from the boundary fence that separates our garden from our neighbours'.

This neighbour (who we don't have the best relationship with for a number of reasons - but I should say he's attended anger management courses in the past and other neighbours warned us about him in the past) built some kind of permanent gazebo attached to the fence (which also takes light away from our living room but it's been there for longer than we could now report it so it's there to stay) and given they are a retired couple, they spend most of their days sitting there, smoking and playing music. When their grandchildren come over to use the temporary pool, it's constant shrieking (and throwing stuff into our garden!).

We usually don't say anything but today they have started playing some sort of techno music so loud that the people on my conf calls can hear it through my laptop microphone (I have the door open because of the heat).

I tried to call out 'hello? hello?' in a 'friendly voice' but nobody answered. So they either left the music going and left the garden, or just don't care at all. I am getting more and more annoyed at the fact that I might end up having to close the door because of their music, especially in this heat.

AIBU to think they should be more considerate? That when they built that structure attached to the boundary fence they should have realised they couldn't use it as if it where further from our garden?

And, more importantly, how can I get them to stop playing loud music? Thank you!

OP posts:
melj1213 · 19/07/2021 13:49

It is not a case of one person being totally right and the other person being totally wrong, both sides are being at least a little bit unreasonable.

The neighbours are not unreasonable to want to enjoy their garden without listening to the OPs work calls, they are unreasonable to play music at high volume.

The OP is not unreasonable to want to work from home without music blaring but they are unreasonable to make zero steps - closing the doors, using headphones/mic, moving to a different room or even properly attempting to speak with the neighbours to agree a compromise - to minimise the impact of the noise.

At the end of the day the OP is WFH but the neighbours are trying to enjoy their home - they can't move their enjoyment of their garden elsewhere but the OP can move their work out of their residence - to an office/co-working space etc

MitzyMooo · 19/07/2021 13:43

@JackGrealishIsMyNewManCrush love your username, might change mine then as have a unhealthy crush with Kalvin Phillips! Grin

Immaculatemisconception · 19/07/2021 13:39

It’s really not anti-social to enjoy your own outside space though

Of course it is, as you are effectively stopping others from enjoying their outside space.

Yes anti-social and incredibly selfish.

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 13:39

@MyriadeOfThings

Fwiw, I thik you also need to remember that your NDN probably has been playing music like this for ages. You just didn't know about it - because you were in the office.

You've changed ther way you are working. Fair enough.

You can't then expect people to also adjust THEIR way of living to yours just because it works better for you.
Just like someone who is working shifts might ask their NDN if they could try and avoid music lets' say befopre 11.00am, you might ask for some HELP from your NDN. But asking them to just stop playing music or telling where they should put their speker is a tat controlling imo.

The differece for me is in the attitude: expectation vs asking for help and being appreciative of the ffort made.

I have been working FT from home for nearly 20 years.
OP posts:
InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 13:38

Just to reiterate. I'm not saying they shouldn't play music in their garden - I'm saying they shouldn't play loud music next to the boundary fence. So loud it's being picked up by my microphone. Either turn the volume down or move the speaker closer to your house.

Also, I have worked from home for 20 years, besides different neighbours, and never complained. I totally get you can't expect absolute silence (see point above) and that's not what I'm asking for.

And, again, even if I did use headphones, what would I do when I am not on a conf call? Keep the headphones on with white noise playing????

OP posts:
Returnoftheowl · 19/07/2021 13:38

@oneglassandpuzzled

People who play loud music in the garden are anti-social. They should use headphones.
Absolutely this!

If they are disturbing other people then they are the problem.

MyriadeOfThings · 19/07/2021 13:35

Fwiw, I thik you also need to remember that your NDN probably has been playing music like this for ages. You just didn't know about it - because you were in the office.

You've changed ther way you are working. Fair enough.

You can't then expect people to also adjust THEIR way of living to yours just because it works better for you.
Just like someone who is working shifts might ask their NDN if they could try and avoid music lets' say befopre 11.00am, you might ask for some HELP from your NDN. But asking them to just stop playing music or telling where they should put their speker is a tat controlling imo.

The differece for me is in the attitude: expectation vs asking for help and being appreciative of the ffort made.

cobblers123 · 19/07/2021 13:32

We're trying to sell my dad's property and just lost one sale. I am wondering if they might have gone back for a second look and if it's his neighbours who play music in the garden quite loudly. Dad was a bit deaf and didn't go in the garden but it irritates me a lot when I am round there. Angry

IDidntFloatUpTheLaganInABubble · 19/07/2021 13:32

YABU, yes it's a pain, yes it's hot but I have been on meetings this morning with headphones on they really don't make you hot.

Maggiesfarm · 19/07/2021 13:32

I think it is inconsiderate of your neighbours to play music loudly in the garden, soft music would be OK. I don't know what you can do about it, if anything.

Others have suggested ways of masking the noise. Do you have to work in a room at the back of the house? I doubt you'd hear much at the front.

MyriadeOfThings · 19/07/2021 13:29

There are many many threads around those lines atm.

I think many people who wfh are sudddenly realising its all that easy and comes with its own set of problems.

Imo, a house is a house, not an office. You cant ask your NDN to not play music in his garden because you are working.
If it was blarring at full volume, then you might have a point. Just playing music? Nope.
Same with children playing on a trampoline etc etc....

ChainJane · 19/07/2021 13:27

YANBU at all but very sadly and very predictably it's not a widespread view that you shouldn't disturb the neighbours with your music.

Generally the rule is if the noise is unnecessary and loud enough for people not on your land to hear then it is excessive. All the "get noise-cancelling" headphones advice is nonsense - rather than have a ridiculous situation where dozens of neighbours might need to put on their headphones, the person creating the noise should be wearing them. Apart from anything else music sounds better with headphones on.

The trouble is there is no point even asking the neighbour to turn it down. Reasonable people know they don't want to be a cunt to their neighbours and therefore don't blare music out.

lactofree · 19/07/2021 13:27

I love it when ppl have ndn noise issues and the common response is to get headphones or earplugs

That's skirting around the issue and not tackling it

It's like having a really aggressive dog and just putting a muzzle on it. The aggression will still be there

OP, I think their door needs knocking

MitzyMooo · 19/07/2021 13:26

Yabu, headphones do not make you hot, put them on, why you think he should be considerate because you are working? It's his home, it's not late.

theemmadilemma · 19/07/2021 13:25

It's annoying but it's standard amongst most people I know to use headphones with a noise reduction mic exactly because of the issue of noise when WFH.

I wfh and have done for years also and while your neighbours are inconsiderate I agree, neighbours shouldn't - within reason - have to adjust their lives for you.

OceanTurtles · 19/07/2021 13:25

I hate it when people play it at full volume. That's the most annoying. If it is at a reasonable level then that's fine. Of course people can enjoy themselves in the gardens but people do need to be considerate of others. Just like if you were speaking loud on your work calls then I'd hope you'd also tone it down a bit.

DynamoKev · 19/07/2021 13:24

@pleasedonttextmyman

I think some people are so used to live with noise, they can't even comprehend that not everybody is the same.

Some people live with the tv on permanently, just for the background sound, and add loud music on top. They have forgotten how to keep their voices down, and being basically civilised.

It's awful when you are stuck next to them.

This
DynamoKev · 19/07/2021 13:22

It’s really not anti-social to enjoy your own outside space though…
If “enjoying” your outside space includes polluting mine with your shit music it is.

postitgirl · 19/07/2021 13:21

I personally hate it when people play music in their garden - unless it's a "special occasion" like a birthday or something. Why cant THEY wear headphones?? Why should we all be subjected to their choice of music. I realise I'm a grumpy old woman though, So OP I totally 'get you', but fwiw I think the majority on here will tell you to just suck it up. Grrrrrrrr.

JavaQ · 19/07/2021 13:20

If the speaker is next to the fence, then water the plants you have "next to the fence".

Nanny0gg · 19/07/2021 13:18

@Meruem

For 3 weeks they were digging the road outside my house with noisy machinery 8am until 4pm. I wfh and I couldn’t hear myself think. I ended up wearing headphones and playing storm sounds on YouTube to drown them out! It is what it is. No one can expect silence when wfh. I hate loud music too but it is the day time. You can report them but it’s unlikely to help, that’s the harsh reality. People who are selfish in the first place rarely back down in these scenarios.
That was for three weeks and presumably necessary.

Not the same thing

Nanny0gg · 19/07/2021 13:18

@Toaste

The neighbours can do what they want on their land - if you are so in need of a quiet space why dont you relocate your office? Surely you could move to another room for conference calls and the like if this really is a problem. Or just accept it

Alternatively get an office at another location - I presume you are running a business from home to save money on office costs. Maybe if you want a quiet environment you should work in an office block where other people are working not a residential area? Just a thought?

No they can't.

There are laws and regulations. And there will be one regarding noise nuisance

pleasedonttextmyman · 19/07/2021 13:16

For 3 weeks they were digging the road outside my house with noisy machinery 8am until 4pm.

3 weeks? bloody hell, how wide is your road!

You cannot reasonably compare essential work and antisocial behaviours.

BlackberrySky · 19/07/2021 13:15

There seems to be a few things in play here. On the one hand you appear to live in a built up area yet expect to work from home permanently and not use any other venue, have your door open, not wear headphones and also not be disturbed. Your neighbours, on the other hand, seem to think it's OK to play loud music right by your fence. Would it be possible to ask them to move further down their garden and turn it down a bit? Personally, I hate it when people play music in their gardens near me, so I sympathise on that level, but I do think your expectations are a bit much in high summer.

pleasedonttextmyman · 19/07/2021 13:15

I think some people are so used to live with noise, they can't even comprehend that not everybody is the same.

Some people live with the tv on permanently, just for the background sound, and add loud music on top. They have forgotten how to keep their voices down, and being basically civilised.

It's awful when you are stuck next to them.