Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my neighbour is wrong to play music in the garden?

160 replies

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 11:21

I work from home (always, not just a few days a week or because of Covid) and my office opens onto my garden. The section of garden it opens onto is about three metres or so from the boundary fence that separates our garden from our neighbours'.

This neighbour (who we don't have the best relationship with for a number of reasons - but I should say he's attended anger management courses in the past and other neighbours warned us about him in the past) built some kind of permanent gazebo attached to the fence (which also takes light away from our living room but it's been there for longer than we could now report it so it's there to stay) and given they are a retired couple, they spend most of their days sitting there, smoking and playing music. When their grandchildren come over to use the temporary pool, it's constant shrieking (and throwing stuff into our garden!).

We usually don't say anything but today they have started playing some sort of techno music so loud that the people on my conf calls can hear it through my laptop microphone (I have the door open because of the heat).

I tried to call out 'hello? hello?' in a 'friendly voice' but nobody answered. So they either left the music going and left the garden, or just don't care at all. I am getting more and more annoyed at the fact that I might end up having to close the door because of their music, especially in this heat.

AIBU to think they should be more considerate? That when they built that structure attached to the boundary fence they should have realised they couldn't use it as if it where further from our garden?

And, more importantly, how can I get them to stop playing loud music? Thank you!

OP posts:
nosyupnorth · 19/07/2021 15:51

YANU - I'm fine with everyday life noise like talking or children playing but music, which is deliberately designed as a listening experience, is a different style of noise that causes problems. Many people can have conversations at once, neighbours talking in their garden does not prevent me from also talking in mine, but if neighbours are playing loud music that does mean that I can't play music (over headphones or quietly) because the sound will clash, and it can also be disruptive to conversation or quiet enjoyment.

mygood · 19/07/2021 15:42

if they have now started singing to techno, maybe they are actually doing it on purpose to disturb you op? I'm wfh & have had to had a lot of patience but singing to techno at 3 o clock on a monday.
what age are they???

mygood · 19/07/2021 15:40

@Caesargeezer

Something's changed because no-one played music in their gardens growing up. It's not that those of us who don't like to hear other people's music wouldn't enjoy listening to our own outside, we just know it's selfish and inconsiderate! No-one wants to hear it but you! YOU put the headphones on, just as we do when we want to listen to some. I despair at how entitled so many people are.
in an ideal world yes. But, the world is full of inconsiderate assholes and we cant change their behaviour. We can just control the impact on us.
Coyoacan · 19/07/2021 15:39

They've started singing along now

Hahaha, I can just imagine these old age pensioners singing along to techno.

Sorry OP, it must be very annoying but frankly there is nothing you can do or say to stop them, so the best thing is to make whatever adjustments required

Caesargeezer · 19/07/2021 15:34

Something's changed because no-one played music in their gardens growing up. It's not that those of us who don't like to hear other people's music wouldn't enjoy listening to our own outside, we just know it's selfish and inconsiderate! No-one wants to hear it but you! YOU put the headphones on, just as we do when we want to listen to some. I despair at how entitled so many people are.

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 15:22

@stillcrazyafterall I have a separate camera and mike because I present on video calls and needed better quality, so I'm not using my laptop for that. And yet my separate mike still picks up the neighbour's music because it's so loud.

OP posts:
stillcrazyafterall · 19/07/2021 15:09

I have noise cancelling headphones. How anyone can have conferences using a laptop mic is beyond me!

mygood · 19/07/2021 15:02

@Dentistlakes

YANBU. No one needs to play music in their garden on a regular basis and they should use headphones. It doesn’t matter if you’re working from home or not. Your neighbour is an inconsiderate twat.
yea the neighbour probably is inconsiderate tbh. But given they have alleged anger issues it doesnt sound like they are going to be receptive or care too much about the op wfh needs
mygood · 19/07/2021 15:01

you have a few options you can do but you don't seem to want to?
The bottom line you cannot control what others do. So you have to find your own solution to the problem. Close the doors, put headphones on when your'e on a call, play some music, move to another room. why cant you set up a work space in your living room?
I wfh and have to do all of these and be creative at times depending on what is going on in my house, and also in the street I live. I cant tell the children next door to be quiet. I cant tell the neighbours behind me to turn their music off. I cant tell the lady across the road to stop shouting across to the other neighbour. Everyone is out today enjoying the sun and no one cares that I am wfh. This is a residential area not a office block and I just have to make the best of it.
So I end up with a noise cancelling headset all day & somedays I have to move into a different room.
Like I say I live in a residential area as do you, not an office block. People play music, children scream and dogs bark, that is my problem working from home not theirs so I have to be creative sometimes how to make this work.

Dentistlakes · 19/07/2021 14:57

YANBU. No one needs to play music in their garden on a regular basis and they should use headphones. It doesn’t matter if you’re working from home or not. Your neighbour is an inconsiderate twat.

Member889371 · 19/07/2021 14:48

@HeronLanyon

I don’t think anyone should play music in a garden so neighbours can hear it. Unless it’s a party and neighbours are invited or warned. Think it’s really antisocial/thoughtless. Hope you sort it out op.
Totally agree with this. You are going to have to say something to them op or this will carry on all Summer. Our neighbours started playing heavy metal music yesterday at top volume. I shouted over asking them to turn it down and they did luckily but we couldn’t enjoy our own garden with that racket going on.
InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 14:40

The idea of a note through the door is good but I fear they would turn the volume up, out of spite. The neighbour who told me that my NDN went to anger-manager classes did tell me that my NDN had issues with several other neighbours. They already throw grass leaf cuttings into our garden (not all of it - just handfuls. At first we were wondering what it was and whether it was birds or something. Then we realised it's the neighbours) - we really wouldn't want them doing anything else out of spite.

OP posts:
gogohm · 19/07/2021 14:40

Yabu, it's normal daytime hours and they have as much right to enjoy their garden. Ditto those moaning about kids making noise. If you don't like it then you need to pay for office space in a non residential setting.

Famousinlove · 19/07/2021 14:35

Shazam the song and play it on your speaker but out of time, that'll piss them off

woodhill · 19/07/2021 14:33

It sounds pretty awful. I had the radio on yesterday at the weekend in the kitchen which could be heard in the garden but not blasting.

They sound very inconsiderate

pixietinkdust · 19/07/2021 14:31

@Immaculatemisconception

It’s really not anti-social to enjoy your own outside space though

Of course it is, as you are effectively stopping others from enjoying their outside space.

Yes anti-social and incredibly selfish.

So why shouldn’t people be able to enjoy their outside space as they see fit because some people like quiet?!

There will never be a win for this. If you don’t want any neighbourly noise, move to the middle of a field - it really is the only solution. We have no control over the actions of others.

I have no children and no animals (my choice) but of course children and animal noise is deemed that it has to automatically be acceptable. Well people choose to have children and to have animals, I choose to play music in my own garden at a reasonable level. Luckily I live in an area where people are not within densely populated streets/estates and expect silence outside…

IntermittentParps · 19/07/2021 14:28

Home is home, where families all around you will be living their daily life. It is unreasonable to expect them not to enjoy themselves and play music because you’ve decided to make your home your work too.

Loud music isn't OK whether neighbours are working or not, though. It's antisocial.

nokidshere · 19/07/2021 14:24

The reality is that we can't control other peoples behaviour. Depending on the sort of people they are they will likely apologise and move the speaker or play it louder to annoy more. All you can do is to try and make your life better.

So drop a note through the door explaining how it's affecting you, move your workspace or use headphones. Only you can solve your problem because you have no control over what they do next.

ejhhhhh · 19/07/2021 14:21

If I got on with my neighbours and thought they were reasonable people, I'd ask them to move the speaker or turn it down, I think a polite request is OK. But from your first post it doesn't sound like they would be reasonable, so I don't think you've got much choice but to either ignore it or adjust your working environment. Ultimately they'd be doing you a favour if they did amend their behaviour to accommodate your work. Yes they're annoying, and inconsiderate if it's all the time, but unfortunately there's no law against that kind of activity in private gardens. If your home environment is no longer a suitable working environment because of them, you would just need to adjust your working environment. Move to a different part of the house or use a shared work space. It may not be want you want to do, but your neighbours are under no obligation to accommodate your WFH needs.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 19/07/2021 14:20

People have suggested loads of options and you've just said no to all of them.

So not sure what else you expect anyone else to do about it? You'll just have to wait until the music goes off, then knock on the door and explain.

Abraxan · 19/07/2021 14:12

Surely using a microphone doesn't help, as it will pick up the other loud noise such as the music and the other person on the call will be hearing it anyway.

Abraxan · 19/07/2021 14:10

@Aqua55

I'm probably that neighbour playing music, but I don't really care if it causes a problem these days. Pre pandemic, I would have been more considerate, but not now.
But why would you play loud music so everyone else can hear it? If you want music why not play it quieter, or use headphones?

I don't understand what the pandemic has to do with common courtesy, or rather lack of it?

mantlepiece · 19/07/2021 14:09

OP, if your neighbours are as unreasonable as you say and won’t compromise, your only option is to block the techno music you hate with music you do like. Maybe try a genre that will be an anathema to them.
Dean Martin, Andy Williams, Celine Dion, on a loop.Point the speaker in their direction.
People are so unaware or couldn’t care less about others sometimes.

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 19/07/2021 14:01

They've started singing along now... :-(

On a different note - you can't hear me when I'm on a call because I'm still INSIDE my office. I've tried. WHereas I guess it's because the speaker noise is not obstructed by walls, it travels freely. I don't know but we've checked and you can't hear me if you're standing by the fence when I'm talking in my office on a call.

As for working from a different room: I have loads of paperwork and other stuff I need to access all the time while on calls - it's just not feasible to move everything to the living room for every call.

OP posts:
melj1213 · 19/07/2021 13:53

And, again, even if I did use headphones, what would I do when I am not on a conf call? Keep the headphones on with white noise playing????

Hmm that's entirely your choice ...

When I used to work in an office I could not deal with office noise so I wore headphones all the time - if I wasn't making calls then I would usually either play my music or white noise but sometimes I would play nothing and just use them to cancel out the noise