Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish schools would do away with star of the week?

108 replies

Elisannah · 19/07/2021 09:16

So every child in my daughter's class has been given "star of the week" at least 2 or 3 times but she has only had it once, quite near the beginning of the school year.

I get that it's meant to be great for motivation etc but my daughter is fully aware that she's the only one to not have it at least twice and now thinks she must not be good enough. She has been great at being pleased for her friends and she always gets glowing reports yet this ridiculous reward scheme is always looming on her mind. I reassure her that she's doing great and it's more important to choose to be kind and respectful regardless of whether it's noticed or rewarded. I've tried to frame it as a useful life lesson on disappointment but AIBU to wish they'd do away with the whole thing if they're not going to make sure all the children are equally recognised??

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/07/2021 20:21

Have merits gone out of fashion?

When I was in school you got merits. For good work, for effort, for overcoming your own challenges, for good behaviour, for kindness etc. Then there were certificates if you go to 100, 200 etc.

Because each separate merit is a little thing you can hand them out for varied things, reward what you want to reward etc

cafesandbookshops · 19/07/2021 20:19

The problem is that sometimes the teachers don’t even have a say in these things. I worked for a private international school for two years that was all about the shows and awards and I had to pick two kids to receive this soft toy mascot and certificates every week plus every term the kids with top grades won awards. I ended up picking the kids based on how many times they had received it and the grade awards always went to the same kids each time. As a teacher I hated it but had no choice because I was forced into it by the school. I sometimes received angry messages from parents but couldn’t do anything about it. In the end I left. Just saying that teachers don’t always have as much autonomy as people think unfortunately.

WellyBoot12345 · 19/07/2021 20:06

Really interesting thread. I’m a teacher and looking for an alternative to star of the week because I know it causes anxiety and there are some children who genuinely should receive it every week but can’t. But it is an opportunity to celebrate and communicate the behaviours that matter in school and the children look forward to it. And when they get it they are delighted and I don’t want to take that from them. To save me some research over the summer … for those of you know don’t have this, what do you have instead and does it work for you? Thanks.

ElvenDreamer · 19/07/2021 19:48

I feel your pain over this one OP. My kids are utterly cynical about it. DD always goes above and beyond with effort, consistently academically excellent, always gets it last, and it always says exactly the same thing - for consistently producing excellent work. This year for the 1st time in 6 years it actually read for working on a good French accent, she was so excited to feel it actually meant something for a change! DS1 is autistic, ridiculously bright, and makes no effort whatsoever because he doesn't need to. He eventually gets it on the one rare week he puts a bit of effort in, it doesn't encourage him to continue though because he knows that he's had 'his turn'. DS 2 is again utterly indifferent to it because he sees it for what it is, a tool to motivate the naughty kids.

Coffeeisnecessary · 19/07/2021 19:32

Our school does a children's popularity contest (it's not called that but it's nominated and voted by the other children so obviously is generally seen as 'who is liked the best') I hate it!

Prairielake · 19/07/2021 19:28

Still goes on in high school too I’m afraid. DD hasn’t had the form prize once in 3 years despite her best buddy having had it numerous times. DD is not very adult like in her interactions with staff and is very quiet but does well in tests and does more extra curricular stuff than her friend. She also has a health condition which can make life hard for her socially sometimes. Just had a report card that says she should be doing more extra curricular things but no mention of the things she does and no well done either (presumably because the form teacher hasn’t got a clue and she’s not banging on about it).

Ah well. Interestingly it doesn’t help the chosen children socially as they become seen as teachers’ pets. It has also made my DD respect her form tutor a lot less and she just thinks he can’t be bothered to get to know children beyond the yes sir level. Still makes me quietly cross though 😊

FlumpyLump · 19/07/2021 16:39

My 11 year old son has just finished junior school (year 6) after 4 years.
They had the same kids in his class for all 4 years, around 30 approx.
My son got the weekly award once in that whole 4 years he was there and that was at the beginning in year 3.
The other kids in the class have had it multiple times over the years and my son noticed.
I queried it once and was told "he didn't need the award because he was one of the high fliers who did well consistently".
My son still didn't understand why he never got the award and I felt for him.
The final straw for him was when the kid that bullied him for 4 years straight got the award a few weeks ago for being kind to others, despite the school being very aware of the bullying situation.
He came home crying and just couldn't understand why.

MoonlightWanderer · 19/07/2021 15:57

It does all sound a bit stressful. I think something like taking it in turns to do show and tell or having an "on duty" rota with special responsibilities is a better path than star of the week.

Hallyup6 · 19/07/2021 15:47

My daughter is intelligent, quiet, never causes any problems and is one of these children that could easily fly under the teacher's radar. Her class have star of the week for two children, usually a boy and a girl, so she's had it twice this year. They work through the class so every child gets it once before they go back to the top of the list. It usually means that the kids that often cause the problems get it for genuinely doing something good, because the teacher has to find something positive about them before 15 weeks have past, but children like my daughter get it for something generic like trying hard in lessons all week. It makes it feel a bit pointless tbh.

irresistibleoverwhelm · 19/07/2021 14:44

And yes she is lucky, but some children have things happening at home or confidence problems that aren’t obvious, and DD has had a very hard year for various reasons but doesn’t often show it. So the star thing has knocked her internal sense of self-esteem and self-worth a lot - her perception is that even though she tries hard and is top of the class, her teacher doesn’t like her.

soooooooG · 19/07/2021 14:44

Our class have a secret star, that way it can be awarded when needed and only that child will really know about it.

zoemum2006 · 19/07/2021 14:42

insist

zoemum2006 · 19/07/2021 14:42

Star of the week is ridiculous. Almost all schools are trying to teach children intrinsic motivation, so why do they exist on training children to want external rewards?

Kids won't care if no one else is getting the prize.

PaperMonster · 19/07/2021 14:41

It really upset my daughter at first, she asked me what the point of trying really hard was if she didn’t get a certificate. This was at Autumn half term and she was prompted to ask this because the teacher’s child had received it twice already and, according to my daughter, was always messing about. She’s not bothered by it now though! Her current teacher does this thing where classmates choose who should get a certificate and they explain why.

irresistibleoverwhelm · 19/07/2021 14:40

Yeah my DD was crying about this yesterday - we’ve been pinged so she is missing the last week of school and hasn’t got the star at all this year when some kids have got it several times. The thing is that DD is academically extremely good, has her difficulties with friendships and emotions sometimes (she’s 8), but overall she is very capable and working at greater depth in everything so she doesn’t need academic encouragement. But even though I’ve explained to her that it’s about boosting children’s self esteem and that she is lucky to be very able and shouldn’t take it personally, she still feels like it’s a judgment on her for not being good enough.

So I share your feelings - adults can understand why and how teachers use these motivators, but children don’t always and it’s creates a perception of unfairness which is also wrong. Different kinds of motivators should be used IMO.

MyFloorIsLava · 19/07/2021 14:33

@Stompythedinosaur

The reality is that it is there to motivate dc who struggle more. I was upfront that my dc should expect to get it often, as they already have the privilege of finding it easy to be well behaved in a school environment.
I've had to try to explain this to my DD too. Plus her good results and great report are their own reward. There's about 28 in her class and they didn't give it out over lockdown so presumably a few children didn't get it. But it was fucking galling when the boy who had consistently picked on her got star of the week, when she is polite, friendly, hardworking and kind and did every bit of work set over lockdown.
newnortherner111 · 19/07/2021 14:27

I'm pleased to read that you have tried to frame it in a useful way as a life lesson and not bring your child up as a snowflake. I'm a bit on the fence on this one, as competition in a good way should be encouraged, but there is the concern that some teachers may be not rewarding some children and not being aware of factors that could lead to poor performance at school (undiagnosed SN is one that comes to mind).

Hankunamatata · 19/07/2021 14:08

I never got this as my own kids dont give two hoots but my friends dd who is sensitive and wants to please used to try desperately and got very upset over whole thing. Honestly a quick email just saying dd is upset a bit and can you help build resilience

Bunnycat101 · 19/07/2021 14:08

My youngest is in reception and has just had a super report - basically exceeding in everything, delight to be in the classroom etc. She’s had the star of the week just once and she’s noticed it and it makes her sad. I suspect they don’t think she needs the motivation but she’s quite observant and doesn’t understand why she doesn’t get it when she tries so hard etc.

17caterpillars1mouse · 19/07/2021 14:05

I agree OP my reception age daughter hasn't been star of the week at all, where as some children have been several times. There was a teacher change part way through the year but still. Her friend had also not been star of the week so her mum spoke up and they made her star of the week, but it was the last week they were doing it so I can't even go down that route.

I've just tried to really downplay star of the week to my daughter to curb her disappointment. If they must do it surely they need to at least make sure every child gets it, and keep a list of some sort

Elisannah · 19/07/2021 14:01

@Stompythedinosaur

The reality is that it is there to motivate dc who struggle more. I was upfront that my dc should expect to get it often, as they already have the privilege of finding it easy to be well behaved in a school environment.
That's true, I have said that those who have had it more have needed the encouragement. I'll reiterate that if they do it next year (but I really hope they don't!)
OP posts:
Elisannah · 19/07/2021 13:59

I haven't wanted to talk to the teacher about it because I thought it would come across as me being really controlling and over involved. However I might email her to let her know how dd is feeling and ask her to chat with my daughter to explain why it's worked out the way it has. At least then dd can hear from her that it's not because she's done anything wrong. I'll see whether dd feels up to chatting to her first.

OP posts:
Elisannah · 19/07/2021 13:56

@Bibbleybetto

Yanbu - my DCs school has weekly badge awards, star of the day, a daily dream team and if you get enough of the weekly awards you get a trophy!

To be fair I do see how it motivates the kids but it causes regular tears for my always-tries-their-hardest child as its hard for them to shine when they are always doing their best!

Why would your teachers give themselves so much to keep on top of?! Sounds like a nightmare!

This is it, it's hard for children to see things objectively. We can see it logically but they see it as something they're doing wrong. I think my daughter just flies under the radar because she just gets on with things.

OP posts:
Silversun83 · 19/07/2021 11:21

@EatingAllThePies

I could have written this. My youngest got it once and had 2 days off waiting for PCR tests so also got no attendance award. Big brother got star twice this year, attendance certificate and won the big prize in the attendance raffle. That has caused endless meltdowns. I understand the need to encourage and reward but when youngest is the best behaved and hardest trier it feels like a real kick in the teeth for him.
Sorry, totally off-topic, but how come your eldest also didn't have two days off whilst you were waiting for results of your youngest's PCR test?
Bibbleybetto · 19/07/2021 10:59

Yanbu - my DCs school has weekly badge awards, star of the day, a daily dream team and if you get enough of the weekly awards you get a trophy!

To be fair I do see how it motivates the kids but it causes regular tears for my always-tries-their-hardest child as its hard for them to shine when they are always doing their best!