Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour wants no drilling this afternoon

181 replies

Daisydrum · 19/07/2021 07:06

We are having work done on our house. The workers are only here M-F within normal hours. Our neighbour has asked for no drilling this afternoon because of important calls. Not sure if they are being unreasonable?
We did warn them months ago work was coming and when work was starting.
They have had about 2 years worth of work on and off, often during my important calls (and they’ve had it on evenings and weekends).
I’m not sure if the builders will need to use the drill or not but there will certainly be some banging as we can’t expect them to do no work for the whole afternoon.
Not sure what to say back.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GCandproud · 19/07/2021 17:18

That’s nice of you to agree but I’d make it clear that this is a one-off because it doesn’t seem like it’s anything exceptional and I wouldn’t want them thinking that they can just ask whenever they want. If they get arsey, I’d say something like ‘well, as you remember, your own work was rather noisy so I’m sure you can understand the position I am in’.
If I had had my own works done for 2 years, no way would I dare ask that someone else be quiet unless it really was an emergency.
Good that the builders could be flexible though.

memberofthewedding · 19/07/2021 16:16

Id start off by asking the builders how practical this is and if they can work around it. If they agree I would tell the NDN that you have asked them as a "special concession" but that you are not going to make a habit of it. If the need arises again they will have to make other arrangements.

If the builders say it will impede their progress I would tell them to crack on and send a Mumsnet reply. "Builders say its not possible to gurantee no drilling at this time so I will leave it with you.."

The dont reply to any more messages. Texts can always get lost or not noticed.

Daisydrum · 19/07/2021 16:03

Hi all, thank you for all your responses. They were work calls. They’ve given me a couple of hours where it’s most important.
The request came in this morning. For this afternoon.
I have spoken to the builders and they are going to take a later lunch over the two hour time and won’t be doing any drilling but will do some other work. We can’t afford to lose the time.
These neighbours only ever contact us if they need something.

OP posts:
melj1213 · 19/07/2021 15:07

It's not an unreasonable request for one afternoon. The call could be for any kind of reason not just a work one - I recently had a hospital consultation that I have been waiting 18 months for and there was a lot of information to take in; a friend is a foster carer and has had to attend some important meetings over zoom with sensitive information; someone else I know has parents with worsening care needs and had to spend a whole afternoon making calls to the doctors/care agencies/nursing homes/social services etc and needed to concentrate etc etc

Why are some people acting like builders have zero flexibility with their work at all?

I had my kitchen refitted early this year and I had to do a couple of zoom meetings one morning. I just told the fitters so that they wouldn't come and interrupt me working in my room but they were more than happy to rearrange and do quieter jobs (or at least not the loudest ones) until my meeting was done.

Sometimes jobs have to be done in a specific order and so they might not be able to put it off if other jobs can't be done until it has finished but equally sometimes they have other jobs that can be done without drilling. If the request is put to the builders then they can either say "Sorry, can't move on till the drilling is done so we either carry on or clock off early, which do you prefer?" or "Sure, no problem, we were going to do the drilling today and start the tiling to.orrow but we can just crack on with the tiling now and do the drilling tomorrow"

maddening · 19/07/2021 14:49

"CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson

I'd ask the builders if it was possible to plan their day to avoid drilling this on but if it wasn't then too crack on. And I'd reply to the neighbors saying that you've asked this but obviously having had work done themselves they'll know it might not but possible"

This is perfect.

GCandproud · 19/07/2021 14:42

You’re talking as if builders are lazy idiots who want to sit and drink tea all day and don’t have any autonomy or deadlines to work to.

No I haven’t and you know it.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 19/07/2021 14:31

@GCandproud

Builders are highly skilled tradespeople. They aren’t “instructed” by their customers.

Of course they are instructed. They wouldn’t be there if someone hadn’t paid them to be there because they want an extension or whatever. I know they are skilled ffs. It’s still not going to stop me being annoyed with my neighbour for having lots of drilling work done that impacts on my own ability to work. My beef is with the neighbour.

No, they’re hired by their customer. The customer doesn’t dictate what tools are used for what job and when. You’re talking as if builders are lazy idiots who want to sit and drink tea all day and don’t have any autonomy or deadlines to work to.
GCandproud · 19/07/2021 14:28

“Those who instruct them” you’re talking like people who hire builders are overlords who can dictate what the builders do on any given day.

Well it might not be possible if the builders are on a very tight schedule. Sometimes though it’s a case of those hiring the builders not wanting to pay more money.
Living on a street where lots of people are having noisy work done can be really horrible, especially when trying to work from home. One option could be to restrict planning laws so that it’s harder to get approval extensions to residential property. So many would be up in arms about that though.

GCandproud · 19/07/2021 14:24

Builders are highly skilled tradespeople. They aren’t “instructed” by their customers.

Of course they are instructed. They wouldn’t be there if someone hadn’t paid them to be there because they want an extension or whatever. I know they are skilled ffs. It’s still not going to stop me being annoyed with my neighbour for having lots of drilling work done that impacts on my own ability to work. My beef is with the neighbour.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 19/07/2021 14:19

It’s not the fault of the builders, it’s the fault of those who instruct them.

What are you talking about?

Building work makes noise.

“Those who instruct them” you’re talking like people who hire builders are overlords who can dictate what the builders do on any given day.

Builders are highly skilled tradespeople. They aren’t “instructed” by their customers.

GCandproud · 19/07/2021 14:10

@londonmummy1966

I am on the other side of this atm. We had 3 solid weeks of pneumatic drilling from 8.30 am to 5 pm - it was absolutely unbearable. If you have a lot of drilling going on then I think you do need to be a bit more flexible. The impact of the drilling on the neighbours was really grim - one of my neighbours DDs was sitting her finals online through it, others were struggling with work zooms - barristers zooming in to court, GPs zooming patients etc etc.

Therefore I think that you are being really selfish in not at least trying to meet your neighbour half way.

Yep. It’s impossible for me to record teaching materials if there is drilling going on for example. It’s horrendous. It’s not the fault of the builders, it’s the fault of those who instruct them. Also if we’re talking about being classist, what about people who do night shifts (more likely to be WC) who are completely prevented from getting any rest due to incessant drilling? My neighbours who are having work done pack up their kids every day and go to parents’. They never have to listen to the noise but everyone else on the street does. To suggest it’s classist for someone to ask for an hour’s peace is ludicrous when building a big extension and giving no shits about your neighbours is about the most middle-class thing imaginable. At the same time, in the OP’s case, the neighbours sound just as bad or worse so my sympathy is quite limited.
londonmummy1966 · 19/07/2021 14:03

I am on the other side of this atm. We had 3 solid weeks of pneumatic drilling from 8.30 am to 5 pm - it was absolutely unbearable. If you have a lot of drilling going on then I think you do need to be a bit more flexible. The impact of the drilling on the neighbours was really grim - one of my neighbours DDs was sitting her finals online through it, others were struggling with work zooms - barristers zooming in to court, GPs zooming patients etc etc.

Therefore I think that you are being really selfish in not at least trying to meet your neighbour half way.

ErrolTheDragon · 19/07/2021 14:03

As opposed to drilling that's just for fun?

As opposed to drilling which could equally well be done tomorrow if they can reasonably do something quieter today. Obviously.

GCandproud · 19/07/2021 14:03

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

I see any building work as being the work of the person who instructs them. And therein lies the problem.
Well excuse me for not having the utmost respect for the fact that my neighbour has spent months having building work done to improve the value of his house. Should I ignore the noise and inconvenience out of respect for the builders? Weird argument.
ErrolTheDragon · 19/07/2021 14:01

@Snoozer11

If the calls are so important they shouldn't be being done in someone's house.
Are you living in 2021?ConfusedHmm
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 19/07/2021 13:57

I see any building work as being the work of the person who instructs them.
And therein lies the problem.

GCandproud · 19/07/2021 13:49

If the builders can’t delay by half a day because of other jobs (they would charge OP in any event), OP just has to say no won’t she? Unless she wants a half finished kitchen or something. It’s up to her to decide. It’s not about seeing builders as ‘less important’. I see any building work as being the work of the person who instructs them. So if my neighbour wants to build a great big fuck-off extension to make their already adequate house bigger and it causes loads of noise, I aim my annoyance at the neighbour not the builder and I do think that my quiet enjoyment of the property is more important than my neighbour’s extension (although I know I can’t do anything about it). It’s got nothing to do with respect for builders. They’re only there because someone has asked them to be and whether their work is objectively ‘important’ entirely depends on what they are doing (fixing a collapsed roof vs building the dream extension). At the same time, I know that my teaching work isn’t particularly important to my neighbour so it’s all swings and roundabouts. Noise cancelling headphones are the way forward.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 13:33

@ThinWomansBrain

Is neighbour prepared to pay for a half day lay off?
My thoughts exactly!

And compensate the customer at their next job for the fact that their job will overrun by at least half a day.

My BIL is a builder. He's booked solid for several months, often has trades working at 2 or even 3 jobs at a time. Losing half a day's work on one job would mean delaying others.

Snoozer11 · 19/07/2021 13:28

If the calls are so important they shouldn't be being done in someone's house.

CustardySergeant · 19/07/2021 13:26

@LivingLaVidaCovid

As a one off to be a nice neighbour I'd try and comply if i could.

Following that I'd be going for the "yes yes we understand we will ensure it's essntial drilling only"

As opposed to drilling that's just for fun?
GCandproud · 19/07/2021 13:22

The builders will have a time frame to complete the work because they will have other jobs lines up, which they may lose if they delay.
Why do you assume builders are work-shy slackers with unimportant deadlines?

Bit of a leap there. I never said that. I just said that this is unlikely to affect the builders as much as the OP (she will be the one out of pocket) and is therefore less of a ‘class issue’ than some people suggest. I would expect that if not drilling for an hour or two will affect upcoming scheduled work that they will say that to the OP and she has the choice then of not getting the work finished in time. When people moan about building work, their anger tends to be directed at those employing the builders rather than the builders themselves. After all, the builders are usually only there because some middle class person wants to build an extension.

Fizbosshoes · 19/07/2021 13:15

That should say workplace

Fizbosshoes · 19/07/2021 13:15

I'm pretty sure the road outside my place gets dug up for some reason every year. It's quite annoying but thankfully we dont have meetings or the need for quiet.

HollaHolla · 19/07/2021 13:03

As a one-off, I’d say it’s reasonable.
My friend had a job interview on Friday, and came to mine to do it (via Teams), as BT are digging up her road at present. She could t risk the noise/her internet being cut off, and when she went out to ask them about the work (explaining her job interview), they said they couldn’t pause for an hour. Luckily I’m only a 10 min walk away, and quieter here at the moment.

I don’t think it’s unreasonable for a couple of hours as a one-off, in your situation, OP. Is there other work which can be done in that time with no drilling?

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 19/07/2021 12:58

@GCandproud

Do we have a class issue here? Office work being seen as more important than building works?

Not really. Surely it's whether the neighbour's office work is more important than the OP getting her extension done? The OP isn't doing the building work herself and surely she will have to pay the builders, even if she tells them they need to down tools and have a couple of hours' break. It's presumably no skin off the builders' nose because they will get paid regardless.

The builders will have a time frame to complete the work because they will have other jobs lines up, which they may lose if they delay. Why do you assume builders are work-shy slackers with unimportant deadlines?