Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naked children in courtyard cafés

290 replies

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 17:28

Today DH and I took DS to a local beauty spot. Like a National Trust but not actually NT if you get me? Beautiful gardens, old mansion, gorgeous.

We were having a bite to eat in the courtyard cafe near a family with several young children running around. Fine. Except the youngest little girl (roughly 3yo) was running around completely naked.

I'm not a prude, and I'm very sympathetic to parents as I know from experience that kids can be unruly/unreasonable and sometimes decorum has to come second to a child's need (i'm thinking public wees in an emergency kind of scenarios here...)

But I feel like allowing your child to run around completely naked in an outdoor café is a bit much? People are there trying to enjoy their lunch while a little girl is romping around everyone's tables with no clothes on... I know it's hot but it's a cafe FGS

I'd love to know people's thoughts on this because I feel like I'm missing something 🙈😂 Surely they can't think that's acceptable? Or is it?!

OP posts:
beigebrownblue · 18/07/2021 20:45

Check CEOP Child Exploitation and Online Protection Agency for up to date stats on safeguarding and measures they are trying to put in place.

www.ceop.police.uk/safety-centre/

Also NSPCC for ways in which they are trying to prevent images being duplicated online . They have a helpline

beigebrownblue · 18/07/2021 20:41

I was referring to the 'stranger danger' mantra.

Obviously the situation is a lot more complicate than a few posts on mumsnet.

If this is what some parents wish to do, then up to them.

Please know you are putting your kids at risk.

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 20:40

[quote LucyLockhearts]@bibblybop Why don't you email the manager/ caretaker of this place?

It's fine to sound off on a forum but if it's something that bothers you a lot, do something constructive.

If this mansion is private property, or even NT or EH, the people in charge have every right to leave notices saying that children must wear clothing if in the fountain or playing, or whatever.

It's a shame that someone else who saw it wasn't a bit bolder to tackle the parents and say' she's a lovely sweet girl, but it's not really appropriate to allow her to run around naked in a cafe.' Or to have spoken to the cafe staff or manager at the time.[/quote]
I wouldn't say I was 'sounding off', more asking whether other people think this is acceptable or whether I was being OTT.

I've never seen it before at this place, and we go here a lot so I don't know how helpful it would be sending an email about this rare occurrence. I can't say I've ever seen it anywhere but a beach.

I wouldn't have approached the parents because I didn't know whether other people would consider this inappropriate or whether it's just me that felt it wasn't socially acceptable. So I would never deign to tell someone how to parent their children unless I felt that my feelings were universal. I wasn't sure in this instance, hence my post.

The last thing you would want when being a vigilante modesty matron would be for the entire courtyard to cry out in unison that it's actually very sweet and they were loving their lunchtime matinee 🤷🏻

OP posts:
beigebrownblue · 18/07/2021 20:39

@onlyconnect

beigebriwnblue do you think there are fewer pedophiles around today than five years ago?
No. But to state that 'no one is doing anything at all' is really offensive to those who as I said, are busting their guts to tackle this.

Including safeguarding staff in schools and youth organisations. I've done the safeguarding training and most recently was a parent governor of a primary school. I did the training . It is difficult. You might try it yourself.

Macncheeseballs · 18/07/2021 20:36

I'm assuming these paedophiles go on beaches too

Nocutenamesleft · 18/07/2021 20:36

@Nietzschethehiker

I wouldn't because I spent a long time working in part with sex offenders. I'm afraid it's palpably not true to say paedophile are usually known to the child. Sex offenders are ..yes...because they need (mostly) to be able to gain trust to access the child. Someone who is that way inclined but can't commit the offence will still be looking inappropriately and would absolutely take the picture. It can take a huge amount to track a picture so you may never know its been taken and used for nefarious means.

I accept my perspective is skewed by my previous profession but I do not ever allow my DC in public even partially clothed let alone naked. They are older now at 8 and 5 but even as toddlers at the absolute basic they had shorts on but it was extremely rare they didn't have a t shirt on as well. That and the sunburn issue.

Honestly I am not judgy and I would have had an issue with the parents but it certainly wasn't an option for my DC. Always carried spare clothes. Frankly I would have rather them continue in dirty clothes (spare clothes were for wet etc that would be uncomfortable).

It's just not needed. It's a rare occasion you can't plan for actual nakedness (and I say that as a middling level parent with both an SEN and a NT child). It's not about different cultures It's just a bloody stupid idea.

Should I have to consider paedophilia when my children are in public? No of course I shouldn't but I do because I'd rather they were protected than pander to my need for naivete.

Agree 100%.

You hit the nail on the head

You’ve also come from a profession of what is known. My father was a police officer and worked on many child murder cases and says the exact same thing.

claralara42 · 18/07/2021 20:35

People are there trying to enjoy their lunch while a little girl is romping around everyone's tables with no clothes on... I know it's hot but it's a cafe FGS

In what way does that child stop you enjoying your lunch? I must be missing something.....

Twistiesandshout · 18/07/2021 20:34

I doubt many are drinking tea in the heat today, and it would bother me regardless if a child got burned (although I don't drink hot drinks so wouldn't be mine :) )

LucyLockhearts · 18/07/2021 20:34

I question whether the approach that tells 3 year old children that they need to cover heir bodies has done anything to prevent harm to children.

You don't 'tell a 3 year old to cover their body' [implying it's shameful to be naked]

You parent them and make sure they are in appropriate clothes for the setting.

Just like it's bad manners to let dogs sit on cafe seats, it's bad manners to allow a naked bottom of a 3 year old on a seat or a table.

Making sure your child is covered up in a cafe with knickers or a dress / shorts is not unreasonable. It's common sense.

onlyconnect · 18/07/2021 20:33

beigebriwnblue do you think there are fewer pedophiles around today than five years ago?

Twistiesandshout · 18/07/2021 20:33

However I wouldn't let DD do it, sunburn, others might be offended, pervs etc

Nohomemadecandles · 18/07/2021 20:32

@Twistiesandshout

if I was in the courtyard cafe it wouldn't bother me at all.
It would if naked child ran into your table and scalded themselves on your tea.
EezyOozy · 18/07/2021 20:32

As a mother of a two and three-year-old girl this would not bother me in the slightest personally, but I would never allow my own children to run around naked in such an environment because I feel that they do need to have some privacy (even if that is just a pair of pants). Id also be worried about sunburn and other people finding full nudity (even in a three year old a bit inappropriate). That said, I wouldn't bat an eyelid myself.

Absolutely no problem with young children running around naked in gardens / on the beach etc

Twistiesandshout · 18/07/2021 20:32

if I was in the courtyard cafe it wouldn't bother me at all.

torquewench · 18/07/2021 20:31

@Marty13

Is it possible that she soiled her clothes and they decided that naked is better than in soiled clothes ? For all you know one of the parents was rushing home for clean clothes at the time...
Even if this is the case, why wouldnt you just take the child home with you instead of leaving her naked in public? Confused
TheFairyCaravan · 18/07/2021 20:31

There was a program on the telly called “Catching Paedophiles” or something along those lines. One of the ones they did catch had left a number on the wall of the seafront toilets with a message which said to call for naked pictures of children. It made my blood run cold. I’d never let my children run round naked anywhere, and I’ve never been one for seeing a paedophile on every corner, however I did wonder just how many children he’d been looking at to photograph. It’s just too risky

onlyconnect · 18/07/2021 20:30

beigebriwnblue I'm not saying that not a single thing has been attempted to prevent harm to children. People are spend their lives working to this end as you say.
I question whether the approach that tells 3 year old children that they need to cover heir bodies has done anything to prevent harm to children.
Children's lives are diminished by not having freedom to play unsupervised, by helicopter parenting and by being taught to fear the world at large. Not letting a 3 year old who wants be be naked be as they want is an early example of that way of bringing up children.
That in itself does nothing to prevent the people who do want to harm children in doing so, but it does give a message to the child.

LucyLockhearts · 18/07/2021 20:28

@bibblybop Why don't you email the manager/ caretaker of this place?

It's fine to sound off on a forum but if it's something that bothers you a lot, do something constructive.

If this mansion is private property, or even NT or EH, the people in charge have every right to leave notices saying that children must wear clothing if in the fountain or playing, or whatever.

It's a shame that someone else who saw it wasn't a bit bolder to tackle the parents and say' she's a lovely sweet girl, but it's not really appropriate to allow her to run around naked in a cafe.' Or to have spoken to the cafe staff or manager at the time.

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 20:27

@MarianneUnfaithful

I can’t stand kids running round my table when I’m eating, but it’s tricky with these courtyards. Was it definitely ‘cafe’ space, or general courtyard in which it was ok to play but also had tables in?

3 year olds outdoors in public play / relaxing areas doesn’t bother me at all.

I mean, it was a cobbled courtyard and no 'play' things so I wouldn't consider it a café-come-play area as it's not exactly child friendly.
OP posts:
TheFairyCaravan · 18/07/2021 20:26

I’ve been to beach cafes all over the world. I’ve yet to see a naked child running round in one.

We’re all well aware of how hot it is today, however it’s not too hot for a pair of cotton knickers and a loose cotton dress while eating. If the child can’t stand to be dressed in that then their own garden is the best place for them, imo.

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 20:25

[quote Dullardmullard]@bibblybop you have no idea why she was naked unless next to their table.

As for folks easy peasy to get clothes on or leave with a 3 year old yeah right bollocks. A kicking screaming 3 year old is like fighting a shark in a swimming pool

As for not knowing where to look ffs not at the child it’s easy.

As for unhygienic you do know all tables and chairs are wiped down now a days with throw away clothes[/quote]
I was well within earshot of their table. I don't know why she didn't have clothes on as we arrived after that but I do know that she'd taken off her pants and refused to put them on again (I say refused, the parents asked once in the time we were there).

The child was running around so it wasn't a case of 'don't look at x table because there's a naked child there' it was a case of 'don't look beyond your table at any point even to daydream lest you accidentally see naked child and look like you're looking at said naked child' if you see what I mean?

And I'm sure the other posters are aware of the difficulties of taming reluctant children but rather their points were that they would take a stand and deal with the ensuing tantrums rather than allow inappropriate behaviour. One poster said if their child kicked off they'd take them home and I have to agree. I'd rather have a stand off with my son and potentially even take him home than allow him to run naked around a café, climbing over furniture while people are eating.

OP posts:
Nietzschethehiker · 18/07/2021 20:17

*wouldn't have had an issue with the parents

PrincessNutella · 18/07/2021 20:16

No, very inappropriate.

Nietzschethehiker · 18/07/2021 20:16

I wouldn't because I spent a long time working in part with sex offenders. I'm afraid it's palpably not true to say paedophile are usually known to the child. Sex offenders are ..yes...because they need (mostly) to be able to gain trust to access the child. Someone who is that way inclined but can't commit the offence will still be looking inappropriately and would absolutely take the picture. It can take a huge amount to track a picture so you may never know its been taken and used for nefarious means.

I accept my perspective is skewed by my previous profession but I do not ever allow my DC in public even partially clothed let alone naked. They are older now at 8 and 5 but even as toddlers at the absolute basic they had shorts on but it was extremely rare they didn't have a t shirt on as well. That and the sunburn issue.

Honestly I am not judgy and I would have had an issue with the parents but it certainly wasn't an option for my DC. Always carried spare clothes. Frankly I would have rather them continue in dirty clothes (spare clothes were for wet etc that would be uncomfortable).

It's just not needed. It's a rare occasion you can't plan for actual nakedness (and I say that as a middling level parent with both an SEN and a NT child). It's not about different cultures It's just a bloody stupid idea.

Should I have to consider paedophilia when my children are in public? No of course I shouldn't but I do because I'd rather they were protected than pander to my need for naivete.

beigebrownblue · 18/07/2021 20:16

as for not doing a 'single thing'
what rubbish.
Safeguarding agencies, the general public, schools and specialist arms of the police child protection are working their arses off to tackle this kind of international activity.

Where have you been for the past five years?

Swipe left for the next trending thread