Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naked children in courtyard cafés

290 replies

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 17:28

Today DH and I took DS to a local beauty spot. Like a National Trust but not actually NT if you get me? Beautiful gardens, old mansion, gorgeous.

We were having a bite to eat in the courtyard cafe near a family with several young children running around. Fine. Except the youngest little girl (roughly 3yo) was running around completely naked.

I'm not a prude, and I'm very sympathetic to parents as I know from experience that kids can be unruly/unreasonable and sometimes decorum has to come second to a child's need (i'm thinking public wees in an emergency kind of scenarios here...)

But I feel like allowing your child to run around completely naked in an outdoor café is a bit much? People are there trying to enjoy their lunch while a little girl is romping around everyone's tables with no clothes on... I know it's hot but it's a cafe FGS

I'd love to know people's thoughts on this because I feel like I'm missing something 🙈😂 Surely they can't think that's acceptable? Or is it?!

OP posts:
bloodyhell19 · 18/07/2021 22:26

@MapGirlExtraordinaire

I'd find it cute tbh. My two have been naked in public many times, they want to and I can't think of a good reason to say no. If it bothers someone else then that's their problem.

Noise and running so close as to cause people aggravation I would put a stop to, but a 3 yr old's little naked bum? Nah, fine in my book.

Safeguarding?! Especially with camera phones everywhere. Christ alive.

OP it's inappropriate. Safeguarding, sunburn.... The fact that young children don't really have the capacity to consent to being naked in public in front of strangers...creates a whole other issue about appropriate boundaries around nudity and strangers.

Some parents are fucking dim.

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 22:15

@Just10moreminutesplease

I would find it weird and wouldn’t let my child do it (sunburn and potential perverts would put me off!), but I’m struggling to see why you were so bothered.

You say that you didn’t know where to look but surely there’s nothing wrong with happening to see a naked child? It’s not as if you were going to stare inappropriately, is it?

There's nothing 'wrong' with it, although I don't want to see anyone naked when I'm eating, adult or child.

But the point with not knowing where to look was that I always ended up looking at her because she's running around making everyone jippy (because it's unsafe) and then you feel uncomfortable for having looked lest it look like you were looking.

You know? 😂

OP posts:
FrownedUpon · 18/07/2021 22:15

It’s inappropriate, but sadly doesn’t surprise me that some parents think it’s fine.

mswales · 18/07/2021 22:05

I would probably leave the cafe in that scenario though to be fair!

mswales · 18/07/2021 22:04

I really don't get all the people saying it's okay on a beach but not in a cafe then list safety as one of the reasons. If kids can be photographed naked in a cafe then they can be photographed on the beach too right?

I have a three year old who loves taking his clothes off, mostly at home or friends' houses but sometimes it's happened at music festivals. Never at a cafe! I would definitely try to get clothes back on him but if he adamantly refused I wouldn't want to turn it into a massive fight and wouldn't want go home over it. I don't like making a huge thing of it because I want to preserve his innocence about nakedness as long as possible. We have such a strong culture of body shame and sex shame in our society. If I turned it into a big thing insisting he HAS to cover himself up because people do NOT want to see him naked and bodies MUST be kept private would be the beginnings of instilling that culture in him which I find really sad.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 18/07/2021 21:52

No way. All it takes is a paedophile or someone who would share images if the price was right with a discreet smartphone. You dont know the people around you. Most people aren't paedophiles obviously, but you don't know who is, and with small children you just don't cross your fingers and let them streak in front of men and women you dont know.

Just10moreminutesplease · 18/07/2021 21:48

I would find it weird and wouldn’t let my child do it (sunburn and potential perverts would put me off!), but I’m struggling to see why you were so bothered.

You say that you didn’t know where to look but surely there’s nothing wrong with happening to see a naked child? It’s not as if you were going to stare inappropriately, is it?

BiBabbles · 18/07/2021 21:43

I wouldn't think it acceptable with the concerns of sunburn and being around hot food and drinks naked while running around. If it was a naked small child sitting in the shade not running around I wouldn't be as fussed, though it would be better if they sat on on towel that could partially cover them (I'm pretty sure I've read writings by nudists/naturalists on the 'politeness' and comfort reasons of not sitting bare on such things).

I'm not British-born, but I do come from the land of 'no shirt, no shoes, no service' and do worry about the staff having to get around it with how the running around is described -- and with the chemicals being used to clean, I'm not sure I'd want those on delicate skin.

Teaching children that have something to fear does them harm. I'm not suggesting that anyone says explicitly to children when they tell them to keep their clothes on that there is something to be frightened of, but the message is there.

Multiple parks near me have big signs on the importance of covering up in the children's areas, with wide gazebos that have images of shirts and hats and suck etched into the wooden posts. They were put up with funds raised by someone locally who has since died from skin cancer as many of our local parks didn't have much shade available and each one has a sign discussing this and the risk factors of skin cancer.

Do you think those cause our children harm? I would think they might help parents of budding nudists to have that very visual support of 'this is a space for clothes'.

Seesawmummadaw · 18/07/2021 21:42

@Bimblybomeyelash

I’d have more of a problem with the running around than I would with the nakedness.
Same
MorriseysGladioli · 18/07/2021 21:39

I wouldn't like it, for a variety of reasons.

Justgettingbye · 18/07/2021 21:36

Unacceptable

  1. Most important because of the creeps/perverts
  2. A side note - the running is just plain dangerous scalds etc
  3. It's unhygienic toddlers don't know where their hands are most of the time and my boy is always fiddling down there so at least put a layer in between
  4. People are trying to eat
  5. I would pick that battle with them that clothes are to be worn in public and let them scream if they don't like it
Booboosweet · 18/07/2021 21:33

If it was a smaller baby I would excuse the nakedness but three is far too old to be naked in public. I also wouldn't fancy eating while a naked person of any age was running around.

cookiecreampie · 18/07/2021 21:22

No it's not acceptable. You never know who is around and it might be uncomfortable for people who don't know where to look and who don't want to be accused of anything.

Greenmarmalade · 18/07/2021 21:11

I think it’s fine. I would have shared in their joy.

NigellaSeed · 18/07/2021 21:04

No way as PP said it's my job to protect DS from sickos! Are the people who say it's acceptable unfamiliar with this concept?

comebacksunshines · 18/07/2021 21:02

Wouldn't particularly bother me seeing a naked child, because there's nothing to see. Kid are unhygienic full stop, so a nappy or pair of shorts isn't doing much. The running about would bother me more.
Stroke of bad luck for a pervert to be in a courtyard cafe at the time some child decided to get naked. Would have thought they'd be more inclined to widen their chances by going to the beach, where everyone seems ok seeing naked children.

beigebrownblue · 18/07/2021 20:57

Quote. Doodlebug.
I don't post photos of me/us anywhere online. Neither does anyone else without our consent.

The number of people who *do post photos, or allow their kids to post photos is shocking, frankly, but that's their choice. The adults, not the kids, obviously.

Me:

I don't post them either. And I completely agree with this comment.

All anyone can do is raise awareness.

Shelovesamystery · 18/07/2021 20:56

As for folks easy peasy to get clothes on or leave with a 3 year old yeah right bollocks. A kicking screaming 3 year old is like fighting a shark in a swimming pool

I have a 3yo (as do/have had probably most posters on this site), he has tantrums when I make him do something that he doesn't want to do. It's hard. But I get on with it and brush his teeth/put his clothes on/remove him from places etc etc because it's part of being a parent Confused

itsgettingwierd · 18/07/2021 20:55

3yo running around naked wouldn't bother me in general.

But I agree with you. Certain places it's just not acceptable - and a public cafe is one of those!

MariposaLilly · 18/07/2021 20:53

My now adult son was very curious when he was little - always asking questions non stop. If he'd have seen her I would have have my meal stopped by having to explain to him that the naked child did not have it's willy chopped off and then on to why girls don't have the same genitals as boys etc etc.

I think I would have just preemptive the whole explanation by telling the parents to cover the child up. It's disgusting in an eating area.

30 C is only 86 degrees fahrenheit!! It's been 116 degrees here - thats 47 C. Would that be an excuse for the adults to get naked in a cafe as well in England?

Here they often have signs that read, 'No shirt, no shoes no service'.

Pottedpalm · 18/07/2021 20:51

@MapGirlExtraordinaire

I'd find it cute tbh. My two have been naked in public many times, they want to and I can't think of a good reason to say no. If it bothers someone else then that's their problem.

Noise and running so close as to cause people aggravation I would put a stop to, but a 3 yr old's little naked bum? Nah, fine in my book.

And therein lies the problem
bibblybop · 18/07/2021 20:50

@claralara42

People are there trying to enjoy their lunch while a little girl is romping around everyone's tables with no clothes on... I know it's hot but it's a cafe FGS

In what way does that child stop you enjoying your lunch? I must be missing something.....

Maybe I'm weird but I just don't want to see naked people when I'm eating. Adults or children. I don't have a problem with naked children at all. Like I don't have a problem with people sneezing but I don't want to watch them do it while I eat.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 18/07/2021 20:49

You don't 'tell a 3 year old to cover their body' [implying it's shameful to be naked]
You parent them and make sure they are in appropriate clothes for the setting
This hits the nail on the head. It's not appropriate to be naked in most settings.

Doodlebug71 · 18/07/2021 20:49

@beigebrownblue

I was referring to the 'stranger danger' mantra.

Obviously the situation is a lot more complicate than a few posts on mumsnet.

If this is what some parents wish to do, then up to them.

Please know you are putting your kids at risk.

I don't post photos of me/us anywhere online. Neither does anyone else without our consent.

The number of people who *do post photos, or allow their kids to post photos is shocking, frankly, but that's their choice. The adults, not the kids, obviously.

Doodlebug71 · 18/07/2021 20:47

@Nietzschethehiker

I wouldn't because I spent a long time working in part with sex offenders. I'm afraid it's palpably not true to say paedophile are usually known to the child. Sex offenders are ..yes...because they need (mostly) to be able to gain trust to access the child. Someone who is that way inclined but can't commit the offence will still be looking inappropriately and would absolutely take the picture. It can take a huge amount to track a picture so you may never know its been taken and used for nefarious means.

I accept my perspective is skewed by my previous profession but I do not ever allow my DC in public even partially clothed let alone naked. They are older now at 8 and 5 but even as toddlers at the absolute basic they had shorts on but it was extremely rare they didn't have a t shirt on as well. That and the sunburn issue.

Honestly I am not judgy and I would have had an issue with the parents but it certainly wasn't an option for my DC. Always carried spare clothes. Frankly I would have rather them continue in dirty clothes (spare clothes were for wet etc that would be uncomfortable).

It's just not needed. It's a rare occasion you can't plan for actual nakedness (and I say that as a middling level parent with both an SEN and a NT child). It's not about different cultures It's just a bloody stupid idea.

Should I have to consider paedophilia when my children are in public? No of course I shouldn't but I do because I'd rather they were protected than pander to my need for naivete.

I wouldn't because I spent a long time working in part with sex offenders. I'm afraid it's palpably not true to say paedophile are usually known to the child. Sex offenders are ..yes...because they need (mostly) to be able to gain trust to access the child.

Go on. Explain the difference. Sex offenders or paedophiles. I know, so am waiting fo ryour interpretation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread