Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naked children in courtyard cafés

290 replies

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 17:28

Today DH and I took DS to a local beauty spot. Like a National Trust but not actually NT if you get me? Beautiful gardens, old mansion, gorgeous.

We were having a bite to eat in the courtyard cafe near a family with several young children running around. Fine. Except the youngest little girl (roughly 3yo) was running around completely naked.

I'm not a prude, and I'm very sympathetic to parents as I know from experience that kids can be unruly/unreasonable and sometimes decorum has to come second to a child's need (i'm thinking public wees in an emergency kind of scenarios here...)

But I feel like allowing your child to run around completely naked in an outdoor café is a bit much? People are there trying to enjoy their lunch while a little girl is romping around everyone's tables with no clothes on... I know it's hot but it's a cafe FGS

I'd love to know people's thoughts on this because I feel like I'm missing something 🙈😂 Surely they can't think that's acceptable? Or is it?!

OP posts:
bibblybop · 19/07/2021 23:01

@SleepingStandingUp

Well little kid running around naked is different to little naked kid of dubious cleanliness clambering all over the furniture.

So uncomfortable because how well did anyone wipe the tushy now sitting on the cushy i get. Uncomfortable because you can see bare 3 yo tushy i don't

It's not about being uncomfortable because I can see a child's bare bum. I have a toddler and therefore have seen my fair share of bare baby bum, that doesn't phase me. But I wouldn't like to see my son pegging it around our table tackle out, climbing over the furniture and bending over in front of me while I'm eating my lunch. And I wouldn't blame anyone else for feeling the same either.

OP posts:
honeylulu · 19/07/2021 22:55

Oh yuck. For me it's not the nudity per se but the dubiously wiped arse cheeks et al on various furniture/surfaces.

My children liked to be naked and I didn't mind at home if it was incidental (i e dash from bathroom to bedroom) but naked practising gymnastics on the furniture, a firm NO. We actually had a "no bare bums on the sofa rule". I was clear that their bodies were nothing to be ashamed of but no one wants to see wee holes and poo holes in a room where they might be having a meal.

bibblybop · 19/07/2021 22:54

@comebacksunshines

I would argue that the OP mentioned the issue of running around naked several times, not just the nudity However, the main issue appears to be her nudity. I am commenting on that.

I mean...I wrote the post? The two issues are equal because while I think nudity in a courtyard café is a bit much, it was the running around naked in front of everyone eating their lunch which was what I thought was inappropriate.

She's not just sat at her table with her family (which does flag up issues of hygiene amongst other things) but she's in other people's faces completely naked and causing a general nuisance. If her behaviour had been under control then it's fair to argue the nudity would probably have gone unnoticed. Then I could agree with the posters who have said 'don't like it, don't look' but in this case you could see everything wherever you looked.

What I meant when I said 'why do people have this image of a cherubim little girl...' etc was not really calling into question the 'main issue' of the OP but rather the fact that some posters are keen to idealise the situation and see it as an innocent little child minding her own business and being adorably naked regardless of the detail of the OP.

OP posts:
comebacksunshines · 19/07/2021 22:31

I would argue that the OP mentioned the issue of running around naked several times, not just the nudity
However, the main issue appears to be her nudity. I am commenting on that.

SleepingStandingUp · 19/07/2021 21:57

Well little kid running around naked is different to little naked kid of dubious cleanliness clambering all over the furniture.

So uncomfortable because how well did anyone wipe the tushy now sitting on the cushy i get. Uncomfortable because you can see bare 3 yo tushy i don't

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 19/07/2021 21:45

Not appropriate.

I'd also worry about toilet accidents - my kids seem to need the loo when they get naked, like it's a habit or something.

No one wants to see little Persephone have a plop next to their panna cotta

bibblybop · 19/07/2021 21:38

@comebacksunshines

The reality was a little girl racing around the courtyard and clambering over furniture and the modern art display with all out for everyone to see. Not just a little bum bobbing around in the periphery. Because your title and your OP indicated that the main issue was her lack of clothes, not her behaviour.
I would argue that the OP mentioned the issue of running around naked several times, not just the nudity 🤷🏻
OP posts:
Ericaequites · 19/07/2021 20:34

@Susannahmoody- The house ads for empty bits in the New England Yellow Pages used to say, “No matter your business, it pays to advertise.” I’ find Speedos inappropriate except at a competition pool but I’m a prudish Puritan descended American lesbian .

CoolCatTaco · 19/07/2021 20:33

I'm surprised so many people think this is OK...
Three might technically be considered a toddler but it's way too old for that carry on. I wouldn't be uncomfortable but I definitely wouldn't think a random todder's bare ass on a hot day a welcome addition to my lunch. It's really not cute and the parents were dicks.

Macncheeseballs · 19/07/2021 20:11

Are naked dogs OK?

comebacksunshines · 19/07/2021 19:52

The reality was a little girl racing around the courtyard and clambering over furniture and the modern art display with all out for everyone to see. Not just a little bum bobbing around in the periphery.
Because your title and your OP indicated that the main issue was her lack of clothes, not her behaviour.

bibblybop · 19/07/2021 19:43

@comebacksunshines

Most adverts for nappies, for as long as can remember, seem to show plenty of footage of babies bottoms. Renaissance art depicts a lot of unclothed cherubic children. All totally innocent. Surely if the sight of a child's bottom was going to send a paedophile into a frenzy, then they should be starting with Pampers adverts.
Why do people all have an image of a cherubim little girl padding around with her innocent little bottom out?

The reality was a little girl racing around the courtyard and clambering over furniture and the modern art display with all out for everyone to see. Not just a little bum bobbing around in the periphery.

OP posts:
comebacksunshines · 19/07/2021 18:36

Most adverts for nappies, for as long as can remember, seem to show plenty of footage of babies bottoms.
Renaissance art depicts a lot of unclothed cherubic children.
All totally innocent.
Surely if the sight of a child's bottom was going to send a paedophile into a frenzy, then they should be starting with Pampers adverts.

bibblybop · 19/07/2021 18:33

@SleepingStandingUp

I don't really see what's off putting about a naked toddler. I mean is the sight / brief glimpse of a bare toddler bum so disgusting it pits you off your lunch? Or is it the idea of them sitting naked on a chair someone else will habe to sit on?
But it's not just a bare toddler bum? She was climbing all over the furniture. I'll leave it to your imagination.

I'm not saying there's anything wrong with toddlers being naked. I have a toddler. I just think there's a time and place for it and a café isn't one of them. It puts people off their food, makes people uncomfortable, it's unhygienic and as many people have pointed out (and as was my first thought when it happened) you never know who is watching.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 19/07/2021 16:58

I don't really see what's off putting about a naked toddler. I mean is the sight / brief glimpse of a bare toddler bum so disgusting it pits you off your lunch? Or is it the idea of them sitting naked on a chair someone else will habe to sit on?

leonpride · 19/07/2021 16:49

[quote LittleGwyneth]@leonpride Grim as it is to write this, if you happened to be in the same cafe as a pedophile I don't think wearing pants would be that much of a help honestly.[/quote]
I mean, peadophiles may be aroused by kids in summer dresses etc. Sure but I'm not making it more glorious for them by letting my child run nude

A naked child in a cafe is a bit of a spectacle. I just think it's drawing attention when as a parent, sometimes you just have to say "no".

I'm not going to ban swimsuits because a predator might be watching, because my child misses out on a valuable experience (swimming for example). But full frontal is too far, I don't know

paddlingon · 19/07/2021 16:41

I am less convinced that is true.
There is often a sexual thrill associated with boundaries being broken.
I would think it could well have a transgressive thrill being able to view dc's genitalia in public without having to have created the situation.

Given the numbers people who view of indecent images of children on online the chances of them being in any public situation with you is quite high.

LittleGwyneth · 19/07/2021 16:31

@leonpride Grim as it is to write this, if you happened to be in the same cafe as a pedophile I don't think wearing pants would be that much of a help honestly.

postitgirl · 19/07/2021 13:40

I agree with you OP there's something about her being in cafe. Plus even the safety risks if she is running around and there are hot drinks - could cause a nasty accident? I don't know why but I just woulndt want a load of strangers looking at her naked. It doesnt sit right with me. Plus its often cooler to have a light dress on, than to be naked - spoken from experience lol

leonpride · 19/07/2021 12:49

@LittleGwyneth

It's very strange that we would never tell a woman or teenage girl that she shouldn't dress a certain way to avoid being a victim of a sex crime, but apparently we think it's okay to suggest children can't play naked to avoid the same thing.

I agree that a cafe is a bit odd because it's not really the place for running and playing. But I find it so sad that children wouldn't be allowed to play freely in a park or on a beach because of a fear or something which is unlikely to happen. Pedophiles are like sharks, we worry a disproportionate amount about something happening. When it does, it's horrific, but is it really worth never going in the sea to avoid being bitten?

Being nude at the beach is very normal in other European countries and I don't think those children are in any great danger. I do agree about the sunburn though.

They can play freely in just underwear, they don't need to be naked. As PP said, you can't spot a paedo by looks alone. They may not even be a sex offender, just someone aroused by your 3 year old

As a parent, I'm putting something on my child. That's not victim blaming -_-

Neondisco · 19/07/2021 12:43

I'd notice it but it wouldn't bother me. I don't really get why it's rude if I'm honest. I'm not sure it's any more unhygienic than toddlers running around in general.

WoolieLiberal · 19/07/2021 12:34

*or pants/shorts when they were a little older! Lol!

WoolieLiberal · 19/07/2021 12:34

No, I never did let DD’s run around naked in public. Not because there was anything wrong with it but because sadly there might be weirdos out there who had an unhealthy interest in naked kids.

If they wanted to strip off I always made sure they had a nappy on at the very least (and plenty of sun cream!)

Bloodypunkrockers · 19/07/2021 12:10

@Greenmarmalade

I think it’s fine. I would have shared in their joy.
GrinGrin
Nietzschethehiker · 19/07/2021 11:47

It's not an interpretation its a trained clarification. Sex offenders have committed an offence. Paedophile are attracted to children but may not have actually committed an offence. Yet. It doesn't mean they won't. I include child sexual abuse images online in that.

I strongly advise you do not , as your tone suggests try to start a row about me being an apologist. If you had any concept of my previous professions and experiences you would back down now. This is not my opinion. Nor is this pulled from thin air. I have been specifically trained. I have sat in court over and over again in cases. I have sat in therapy sessions with both victims and perpetrators. Do not.

I consider Paedophiles who have not been convicted more dangerous because they aren't on anyone's radar. They absolutely exist. If you could hear some of the things I have you would understand. The point I was making is that you cannot afford the naivete to think this can be predicted. It cannot.

You can bosom hoik at my post all you like. I absolutely assure you if you had heard and seen the victims that I have worked with, and the perpetrators you would understand the complexity.

You are itching to try to prove I am in some way undermining any form of child sexual abuse. You have very very much picked the wrong poster. I don't consider it a highlight of my career to have listened to the in depth thought process of both perpetrators and victims but it has unfortunately been a feature of my career for a variety of reasons. If you had heard what I had you would understand my anger at the implied challenge. Be a keyboard warrior all you like but not with me. If you have experienced it yourself I am truly sorry for your experience but you do not get to try to invalidate what is a very very important distinction.

If "you know" from a an actual trained perspective you would not be playing silly buggers to get a rise out of this. I'm going to exempt myself now because I have very little time for people who play semantics to make themselves feel more important when those wordings provide a structure to identify risk management.

Honestly I have no time or interest to play with keyboard warriors beyond this post who get a kick out of finding offence with someone who has spent 23 years trying to protect vulnerable service users. Go play with someone else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread