Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naked children in courtyard cafés

290 replies

bibblybop · 18/07/2021 17:28

Today DH and I took DS to a local beauty spot. Like a National Trust but not actually NT if you get me? Beautiful gardens, old mansion, gorgeous.

We were having a bite to eat in the courtyard cafe near a family with several young children running around. Fine. Except the youngest little girl (roughly 3yo) was running around completely naked.

I'm not a prude, and I'm very sympathetic to parents as I know from experience that kids can be unruly/unreasonable and sometimes decorum has to come second to a child's need (i'm thinking public wees in an emergency kind of scenarios here...)

But I feel like allowing your child to run around completely naked in an outdoor café is a bit much? People are there trying to enjoy their lunch while a little girl is romping around everyone's tables with no clothes on... I know it's hot but it's a cafe FGS

I'd love to know people's thoughts on this because I feel like I'm missing something 🙈😂 Surely they can't think that's acceptable? Or is it?!

OP posts:
Greenmarmalade · 20/07/2021 15:03

because by climbing about she is displaying more than she ought to in front of people trying to enjoy their lunch

This is so horrible and mean. She’s a toddler.

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 14:55

That's the thing isn't it, it just confuses the whole issue, first of all she's running round naked, then she's running round climbing on things, then she's doing gymnastics, then she's in everyone's face, then she's flailing her genitalia. I'm not sure what she was doing now as it has all got a bit confusing. I'm pretty sure she wasn't flailing her genitalia though.

Unless you wanted to read a 10 page OP I kept it brief with running around naked and then elaborated that she was climbing on things to make the point that the nudity was explicit and not just a little bare bum. It was clear in the OP that she was being a nuisance.

I never said she was flailing her genitalia, I was being sarcastic when someone took umbrage with the fact that I (and most other posters tbh) have stated they don't want to look at naked people when eating.

The running, climbing and being in everyone's face is more or less the same point- it was a naked spectacle whilst people are having lunch. Hardly a massive plot twist so arguably not really a vastly different picture to the OP is it Hmm I'm not sure why you're so befuddled that you can't work out the story here.

As for the gymnastics, I've made it clear she's very young. So if you're genuinely confused as to whether or not she was actually doing flips and handstands I can't help you.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 20/07/2021 14:34

@SleepingStandingUp

So now the 3 yo is doing gymnastics around the cafe ... I mean im not sire the hyperbole is helping the arguement.

I'd be more worried about sunburn in this weather

That's the thing isn't it, it just confuses the whole issue, first of all she's running round naked, then she's running round climbing on things, then she's doing gymnastics, then she's in everyone's face, then she's flailing her genitalia. I'm not sure what she was doing now as it has all got a bit confusing. I'm pretty sure she wasn't flailing her genitalia though.
SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 13:24

Well they're not the op, i can choose to not engage with them

I might give a pass to Chris Hemsworth, he can do naked gymnastics whilst o eat my lunch if he wants 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 13:21

@SleepingStandingUp

But your post was about a 3 yo. People habe replied on that basis. And ive actually agreed with you about the climbing the art installations and all over the furniture although they shouldn't be doing that dressed either.

People big enough to flail their genitals at you are a different issue.

One can make general sweeping statements like 'I wouldn't want to see anyone's bum when I'm eating' even on a thread about a 3yo you know. Quite a few PP have said it yet you haven't come for them with pitchforks Hmm

I do agree, the behaviour in itself is bad but I think the nudity made it worse because by climbing about she is displaying more than she ought to in front of people trying to enjoy their lunch.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 13:13

But your post was about a 3 yo. People habe replied on that basis. And ive actually agreed with you about the climbing the art installations and all over the furniture although they shouldn't be doing that dressed either.

People big enough to flail their genitals at you are a different issue.

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 13:08

@SleepingStandingUp

So now the 3 yo is doing gymnastics around the cafe ... I mean im not sire the hyperbole is helping the arguement.

I'd be more worried about sunburn in this weather

You're wilfully missing the point.

I'm trying to point out to people who think that I'm offended by a naked little girl minding her own business with her family, that the little girl in question was in fact racing around naked, contorting, climbing etc in front of a courtyard full of people eating with all out for everyone to see.

I was also trying to make a point that regardless of age or gender, I don't want to see anyone romping around, pirouetting, doing the highland fling or whatever they deem to be good spirited hot weather fun while I'm eating my lunch.

You can be pedantic about the detail if you want but that only strengthens your case if I'd claimed my OP was a blow by blow of exactly what happened and I've started to change the facts rather than you taking comments out of context.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 13:01

So now the 3 yo is doing gymnastics around the cafe ... I mean im not sire the hyperbole is helping the arguement.

I'd be more worried about sunburn in this weather

SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 12:55

They do if they're doing gymnastics, but you're missing the point... No, 3 year old girls dint have genitalia to flail

I agree with you but you've said kids shouldn't show their bums to strangers which surely is a direct consequence of a lack of clothes? So surely the lack of clothes is a problem here? Well you were talking about bending over and shoving bums in faces. That wouldn't be ok dressed or not. Running around so you might see it but can easily not stare is different

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 12:50

@ancientgran

I just thought it was an odd description, I mean a little girls genitalia doesn't wave or swing wildly even if she's doing cartwheels.

I don't think it adds to your point to use inaccurate or exaggerated descriptions.

I can use hyperbole when I'm being sarcastic, I don't think it detracts from the point at all. You know language can be used expressively and not always literally right?

If I were to say that I mowed someone down in my hurry to get somewhere, would you then come for me and say that was an incorrect use of the word because to 'mow' means to cut grass?

Plus if we're being really pedantic (as you seem to be) I'll just point out that I never said 'I don't want to see a little girl's flailing etc', I said 'someone's' because I was actually referring to general gymnastic nakedness, in light of this girl's exploits.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 20/07/2021 12:22

I just thought it was an odd description, I mean a little girls genitalia doesn't wave or swing wildly even if she's doing cartwheels.

I don't think it adds to your point to use inaccurate or exaggerated descriptions.

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 11:13

@ancientgran

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food.

Do 3 year old girls have flailing genitalia? I think biology has changed since I had kids, I looked it up and the definition was wave or swing wildly. Really?

I mean I don't know why we want to go into the minutiae of this really Hmm

If the little girl is doing gymnastics then you could say her parts were flailing. They don't have to flail independent of the body to be classed as flailing if her whole body is doing cartwheels or jumping around?

But by all means let's have a debate on semantics rather than the actual point of the OP Hmm

OP posts:
ancientgran · 20/07/2021 11:00

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food.

Do 3 year old girls have flailing genitalia? I think biology has changed since I had kids, I looked it up and the definition was wave or swing wildly. Really?

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 10:43

@comebacksunshines

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food. You're starting to sound quite strange now.

Why?

OP posts:
feb2022 · 20/07/2021 10:38

No I don't agree with letting children run about naked, I wouldn't even let mine run about naked on the beach, nappy on yeah that's fine, completely naked... just no!

comebacksunshines · 20/07/2021 10:24

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food.
You're starting to sound quite strange now.

Draineddraineddrained · 20/07/2021 04:53

Fwiw I wouldn't let my child do this in a cafe because it's unsafe (re drinks/sharp objects, table edges, going where I can't see them etc) and because children haring around too close to other people is a bloody nuisance. I think of it like dogs - I bloody hate them so don't want them running past me. Others may feel the same way about children (or at least my children 😁) so I urge them to give others space.

Having said that I think people are totally mad being obsessed with this paedo angle (especially when the REAL risk of harm in the vast majority of cases is so much more insidious, so potentially harmful and far closer to home). Yes they may be there. Yes they may look, be aroused, they may even take a picture and use that picture for gratification. Revolting, revolting behaviour. But the child in question will not (if properly supervised) have come to any harm; which surely is the point? The idea that it is worth actually inhibiting your actual child to prevent the theoretical gratification of a theoretical stranger paedophile seems a bit crazy to me. I mean to what extent does this precaution extend, given paedophiles are also "known" to hang around play areas to serve at children who are fully clothed? Or to get jobs in sports clubs/churches/schools/nurseries in order to view/gain access to children? I'd say enrolling your child in cubs/the local football team is far more risky to their actual safety than letting them be naked in public. Not to mention the vast majority of child abuse is perpetrated within the family, usually by an unrelated male within the home - so any of you who have introduced a step father into your children's lives are taking a far greater risk with their safety than someone letting their 3yo be nude in public. Honestly the assesment of risk just seems utterly weird to me. Everyone frothing about what some imaginary stranger paedo might be thinking while totally oblivious to what nice Uncle Ted who's so good with children is actually doing.

There are creeps who get off on breastfeeding. Doesn't mean I'm exposing my child to abuse by bf her in public. We can't all live our lives based on what someone somewhere may be thinking.

Also as an aside, the OP can't KNOW she was 3yo. She's guessing. So anyone who qualifies this with "a younger child yes, but 3 is too old" needs to remember that. My neice is 8 but in 10yo clothes because she's incredibly tall like her father.

And another thing re hygiene: as any parent of toddlers knows, if it's on their bum/bits it's on their hands as well 😆 ok you can hand wash regularly but it's the work of a moment for any child not in nappies to have a good rummage. It's the relentless nose picking that drives me up the wall and makes me cringe. So unless we're going to be worried about toddlers touching anything at all I think the hygiene issue is a red herring.

Susannahmoody · 20/07/2021 01:01

I wouldn't like to see my son pegging it around our table tackle out, climbing over the furniture and bending over in front of me while I'm eating my lunch

Grin

As you were

bibblybop · 20/07/2021 00:25

@SleepingStandingUp

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food. You said the naked one was a 3 yr old girl. 3 year old girls dont have flailing genitalia.

But I wouldn't like to see my son pegging it around our table tackle out, climbing over the furniture and bending over in front of me while I'm eating my lunch*. Kids shouldn't be running around where people are moving hot beverages for their own sake. They shouldn't have shoes or naked bums on the seats. They shouldn't be climbing over peoples tables and the art regardless of their clothes. They shouldn't be bending over showing their bums to randomers. But beyond bad behaviour, which would be bad on clothes too, i can't get upset about the lack of clothes

They do if they're doing gymnastics, but you're missing the point...

I agree with you but you've said kids shouldn't show their bums to strangers which surely is a direct consequence of a lack of clothes? So surely the lack of clothes is a problem here?

OP posts:
Wearywithteens · 20/07/2021 00:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

imamearcat · 19/07/2021 23:53

I would say that we are a fairly naked household but in England especially tend to keep them covered up as it's not really the thing here!

Wouldn't bother be though I think I'd just think it was funny!

LadyJaye · 19/07/2021 23:48

I grew up in a 'clothes are optional' kind of a family, but - and here's the big BUT - it stops being a thing when other people don't like it.

I'll happily stroll around in my knickers with my mum, sister, niece and nephew and vice versa, but my OH is a little more 'clothes on', so we don't do it in front of him (and I certainly wouldn't go au natural in front of his family).

Other people have boundaries they are allowed to enforce.

SleepingStandingUp · 19/07/2021 23:38

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food. You said the naked one was a 3 yr old girl. 3 year old girls dont have flailing genitalia.

But I wouldn't like to see my son pegging it around our table tackle out, climbing over the furniture and bending over in front of me while I'm eating my lunch*. Kids shouldn't be running around where people are moving hot beverages for their own sake. They shouldn't have shoes or naked bums on the seats. They shouldn't be climbing over peoples tables and the art regardless of their clothes. They shouldn't be bending over showing their bums to randomers. But beyond bad behaviour, which would be bad on clothes too, i can't get upset about the lack of clothes

bibblybop · 19/07/2021 23:19

@MrsKoala

But it's not just a bare toddler bum? She was climbing all over the furniture. I'll leave it to your imagination.

clambering over furniture and the modern art display with all out for everyone to see. Not just a little bum bobbing around in the periphery.

I’m not sure what you see that I don’t but there’s not much other than what looks like one big bum and one small bum joined together. I have a 4 year old knicker refuser and there’s not much to see really.

The idea that it’s so disgusting it might put you off your food is odd to me. If it was a stinky nappy or potty etc I’d agree but toddler bits and bobs are no different than any ther part of the body.,.

The running around and climbing on sculptures is different, whether clothed or not.

Yes I suppose it is odd that someone's flailing genitalia might put me off my food.

OP posts:
MrsKoala · 19/07/2021 23:09

But it's not just a bare toddler bum? She was climbing all over the furniture. I'll leave it to your imagination.

clambering over furniture and the modern art display with all out for everyone to see. Not just a little bum bobbing around in the periphery.

I’m not sure what you see that I don’t but there’s not much other than what looks like one big bum and one small bum joined together. I have a 4 year old knicker refuser and there’s not much to see really.

The idea that it’s so disgusting it might put you off your food is odd to me. If it was a stinky nappy or potty etc I’d agree but toddler bits and bobs are no different than any ther part of the body.,.

The running around and climbing on sculptures is different, whether clothed or not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread