Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you be a good person if you pay for sex? [Content warning: descriptions of sexual abuse]

582 replies

Lave · 18/07/2021 14:15

Do you think there's a grey area or are all men who pay for sex abusive?

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 22/07/2021 00:37

But where are the stats? Who gathered them?

Are they about the umbrella of sex work-
Including paying for sex
But also
Visiting strip clubs/ t**Ty bars and that sort of thing
Doing back office jobs in any number of environments- any sort of office work from pr to manager to cleaning anywhere that has entertainment involving nudity?
Working for an online provider in any number of roles IE a tech company?
And the array of non contact sex related roles...
I mean it's a long list and the push to use the word sex work was clever and seems to have worked to

Support the sex work is work line
Which also sounds somehow more ok. Sex is nice right? Supposed to be. We're all supportive of sex being talked about more generally aren't we?! And work is good. You earn money. You are independent. Etc.

This approach is so successful that universities in freshers week have had sex work stands, being on only fans is seen as so ordinary that (seen on here) it gets suggested by men to women looking for a job (their friends FFS!) and having a 'sugardaddy' is in mainstream news outlets as an essentially harmless way for young women to easily make oodles of money out of silly old geezers...

Maybe more.

NiceGerbil · 22/07/2021 00:26

The idea that women do this and that too is put about usually by men or the providers of various services to make men feel better and to try to say HA! to women who say these things harm women.

PermanentTemporary · 21/07/2021 22:38

Paying for sex is never a good act, no. And repeatedly doing bad things doesn't leave you untouched as a person.

I've been very interested in the 'lots of women pay for sex too' posts on here and I've done a bit of searching; I'd say it's somewhere between absolute bollocks and purposeful lying.

Katie Price talked about something shocking she might do in the future in order to get a headline. Lily Allen apparently paid for sex once - again possibly talked about to get headlines. Again and again when you dig into the article it will be smoke and mirrors with lots of claims about women paying for sex being 'on the rise'.

I read some of Caldwell 2018, a PhD thesis on female sex buyers in Aus. If you can fight your way through the blizzard of claims about 'female empowerment' and general libfem rubbish, you find reviews of surveys suggesting that 0.1-0.3% of women have paid for some kind of sexual activity - type unspecified. The figures o can find suggest 4% plus of men have paid for sex - type unspecified.

Logic tells me that women who are rich enough might do things traditionally associated with power and money held by men. I wonder how many do it more than once or what they feel about it. If a woman - any woman - wants sex, they can get it. Not necessarily good sex in a relationship with somebody nice and no risk of violence, disease, or pregnancy but sex, yes.

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 21:39

Agree with theory v reality.

In theory I have no issues with porn prostitution etc. If things were such that everyone was financially secure and men and women were truly equal.

In reality it's so far from that, that's it's a hard no for me.

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 21:36

This is the fault of men. All the poor behaviour. It's on them.

Yes I agree society supports it so society needs to change.

Individual girls/ women can't by themselves and there are risks.

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 21:35

Anyway it comes with risk.

I have been shouted at, threatened, one drunk man wanted to 'take it outside' ie fight.

I wasn't rude. All I said was things like. No thank you. Sorry we're in the middle of a conversation.

Eg
Can I buy you a drink (at the bar)
No thank you I'm fine
Well you haven't got a drink let me buy you one
No really I'm fine
Why not? What's the problem? It's only a drink!!!
No really but thanks
Why not FFS? I'm not going to hassle you! It's just a fucking drink!
Really no
What's your problem you got a problem with me? Fucking bitch. Who the fuck do you think you are.. etc

Often really aggressive in your face.

I've also had a pint tipped over my head, been followed by a shouting man if I left etc.

Because I said no.

So I totally understand why women and girls play nice because there ARE consequences quite often if you don't.

It's not our fault. It's the fault of the sort of men who feel entitled to do this stuff. And don't read body language. Ignore the obvious atmosphere that often falls when a happy group of women get s man or men like this decide to join in...

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 21:27

Totally agree with the first part of your post Donna!

On the second I totally get where you're coming from.

Yes confidence, sexual coercion is v common and not right just walk. When men do whatever it's 100% on them. And they do whatever it is to lots of others. It's not personal, it's nothing you did etc etc.

All good.

Getting angry is awesome. Notice. Feel pissed off. Care about the position of women and girls around the world. Feeling anger is the right emotion.

However in real life. I never understood why my friends would jolly along awful men who decided to join us in the pub. Why they minimised groping etc. That sort of thing.

Now I get it. If you decide it's not s big problem to have to chat nicely to s dickhead who feels entitled to just randomly sit with a load of women and expect them to be nice to him. If you brush off the stray hands etc as not a big deal then you don't have to face up to a massive uncomfortable reality.

I don't blame them for that. It's easier. Noticing the way men so often behave to women and girls... It's constant and awful and mostly ignored.

I was always pretty fiesty Grin and also noticed from when I was a young girl all this shit.

I didn't play nice. I didn't play the game. I was not prepared to carefully and gently get rid of random blokes demanding my time. Etc etc

DonnaPruMcCullough · 21/07/2021 14:32

@Wearywithteens

At my big old age, and buffered by a family full of lovely men, I’ve only recently come to horrifying conclusion that a significant amount of men don’t see women as actual people with an inner life and mind. They see them as 2 dimensional constructs that exist to serve them. Men who pay for sex fall into the imo.

This isn’t helped by the fact that women often live up to this stereotype by congratulating themselves on being ‘polite’ and ‘kind’ and ‘non confrontational’. This is why we should be teaching our daughters to be authentic, to know their worth, have their own boundaries and not be afraid to be angry.

Great post!
Awalkintime · 21/07/2021 13:23

NiceGerbil
If paying someone is allowed to be deemed as consent then rape will no longer exist in our world. All rapists have to do it throw a tenner at a person and that constitutes consent.

Maggiesfarm · 21/07/2021 09:03

That's a very good post, Upamountain.

Upamountain43 · 21/07/2021 08:58

This is difficult because it does come down to the old theory vs reality debate. In theory as a mature consenting adult i can choose to sell my body for sex - i had a friend who did this as a young single mum- she could work i night and earn far more than working full time and have time with her children etc.

But most of the sex trade is run on an abusive model.

So its one for me that in principle yes you can be a good person and pay for sex but in our present society you would need to know that the woman was making a free rational decision to use her body in this way to earn money rather than in another way. And not that she was being forced to do this either by an individual or societal structures.

Its the same with the drugs trade - as a mature consenting adult i should be able to buy and use drugs and the notion i need to be protected from myself is patronising - but parts of the drug trade in my current society can be very abuse and i would need to know about the process for me to be comfortable doing so.

Maggiesfarm · 21/07/2021 08:31

@hawkehurstgang

And again, I say this as someone who is not at all open about sex work and is pretty horrified even by things like OnlyFans. I'm not PRO any of this stuff. I just don't understand why so many people are anto the men who buy sex but all 'oh poor them they don't know what they're doing they're victims' about the grown, adult women who have chosen this line of work by themselves and might even enjoy it! (And yes, again, not talking about anyone who is in it involuntarily here)
I think the general perception is that the women (and men), who sell sex have someone else pulling their strings, or they have a habit, or both.

That's obviously true of many but certainly not all. There are quite sophisticated women who work independently and enjoy a sense of power. They may employ someone as a driver and sort of minder. They make a lot of money too.

cherrytree63 · 21/07/2021 08:16

I can't get my head round various PP's posting about "friends" and "friends of friends" who absolutely love their sex worker lives.
I've not had many sexual partners, but there's some I'd definitely jump into bed with again and some that make me shudder. Not because of any abuse, simply that the sex wasn't enjoyable for me for whatever reason.
Do "happy hookers", that enjoy their work, somehow vet their punters? Must be clean, fresh breath, comfortable "size", engage in foreplay?

@Lave sorry my phone won't tag you, Flowers, thank you for this thread.

Maireas · 21/07/2021 07:22

@maddy68

A friend if mine has erectile dysfunction. He "uses" sex workers to learn how to perform again.

Another friend of mine is a sec worker. She absolutely loves her job. (She was previously a doctor ). Genuinely she has a spring in het step that had been missing for a long time
Not for anyone to judge

So. A woman who was a doctor, is now a prostitute and is far happier?
UpstreamSwimmer · 21/07/2021 06:36

@NiceGerbil

I'm not comparing anything to anything. What I'm doing is looking at the three moral arguments against using using SWs, and testing these arguments whether they hold out in other situations.

That isn't the same as saying A is exactly like B, only that A shares certain key characteristics with B, and if we ban A because of those characteristics, we ought to ban B.

The arguments, as previously mentioned, are:

  1. The industry has significant coercion. My test for that is nail bars - another industry with significant coercion. If we use nail bars, that shows we don't automatically ban an industry do to coercion existing therein.
  1. Bought consent isn't consent. Especially for yucky jobs. Even more so when the provider is desperate for money.
One test for that is toilet cleaners. Toilet cleaning is yucky, and people only do it because they get paid. And usually it's done by people who are desperate and have no better prospects. Yet we still allow it.
  1. People can't consent to potentially harmful activity.
Well we allow people to join the army.

All the other questions and waffle were simply distractions, and had nothing of substance why using SWs is morally wrong. Certainly not why it's akin to rape.

hawkehurstgang · 21/07/2021 05:57

And again, I say this as someone who is not at all open about sex work and is pretty horrified even by things like OnlyFans. I'm not PRO any of this stuff. I just don't understand why so many people are anto the men who buy sex but all 'oh poor them they don't know what they're doing they're victims' about the grown, adult women who have chosen this line of work by themselves and might even enjoy it! (And yes, again, not talking about anyone who is in it involuntarily here)

hawkehurstgang · 21/07/2021 05:53

The thing I still don't understand is WHY the men are bad for buying the service, in so many people's opinions, but not the women selling the service. I just can not wrap my head around it. If the women were abused or trafficked or something similar, then I can understand this. But what about those women who go into it willingly? Are we really going to patronise them by acting as though they don't knlw what they're doinh and/or are somehow victims for the decisions which they themselves have made about what to do with their own bodies? Do we consider male sex workers equally as victims? And how dare we tell a woman that they don't understand their decisions/feelings? If a man spoke to a woman like this, we would be outraged but as other women its okay for us to insult a woman by claiming she basically doesn't know what she's doing/is a fool/is lying to herself/anything similar.

Aspiringmatriarch · 21/07/2021 04:55

I appreciate there are dirty jobs that I wouldn't want to do, and the only reason people in those jobs do them, is to get paid. Does that preclude me from paying them to do the work for me?

@UpstreamSwimmer, you're openly comparing selling sex to cleaning a toilet - do you think this is how women feel about sex in general, or just the act of selling sex?

When discussing sexual relationships e.g. with young people, they are taught to look for enthusiastic consent. Because that's how sex is supposed to be, ethical sex that is. Sex that someone is there for because they need the money, or approaching as a slightly repulsive chore, can never include true, enthusiastic consent in that sense.

And nobody talks about enthusiastic consent to cleaning a toilet do they, or any other 'dirty work'? Maybe because a toilet doesn't have the potential to rape you, suddenly ask you to do something you didn't include as part of the 'deal', leave a review on intimate aspects of your 'performance', get you pregnant, cause injury etc? Maybe because cleaning a toilet doesn't involve literal penetration of a person's body?

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 02:42

Well it's revealed an awful lot of interesting statements IMO.

Massage is associated with sex full stop.
The worst job imaginable is cleaning toilets.
It's a service like any other except when it isn't.

I'm not sure why you're off tbh.

Maybe he will answer the question.

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 02:39

It's a fair question though.

Note that the underlying experiences that many women have, that underpins their views, is never asked for.

The reason loads of women think it's wrong is because we know what loads of blokes are like. We know how they behave. With women and girls who are not selling sex. Just going about their lives.

The assumption that a man or men in general know better is.. presumptuous. IMO.

LimeRedBanana · 21/07/2021 02:38

Whereas your posts are garnering really helpful responses from him.

I’ll leave you to it, then.

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 02:35

I think that will allow the thread to veer off in an unhelpful direction tbh.

Don't you know that anyone who has concerns about this, unfairly assumes that anyone who's ok with it is a punter?

Proves blah blah stereotypes blah blah don't like men blah blah loads of women think it's fab etc etc etc

3...2...1....

LimeRedBanana · 21/07/2021 02:26

Well I guess he’ll have to confirm whether he’s had sex with a representative sample of sex workers, to draw that conclusion.

Have you @UpstreamSwimmer?

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 02:24

The automatic and apparently standard association with massage and sex acts certainly suggest a certain personal viewpoint.

NiceGerbil · 21/07/2021 02:23

And I'm suggesting that when he says most don't do anal I it could be based on his personal experience.