Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you be a good person if you pay for sex? [Content warning: descriptions of sexual abuse]

582 replies

Lave · 18/07/2021 14:15

Do you think there's a grey area or are all men who pay for sex abusive?

OP posts:
tomorrowalready · 26/07/2021 02:46

@ NiceGerbil, Don't you think the common assumption that sex is a 'need' is often used as a justification for prostitution? For example, as I understand it in countries were brothels were legally permitted and controlled (thinking 19/20th century France here) part of the justification was the medically accepted idea that men had sexual needs they had to satisfy for their health but unmarried women should not be seduced and married women were another man's property. Women of course were divided into the two classes whore and madonna. I think the idea that men using prostitutes protects 'good' women is also still used as a serious argument by some. So I don't think it is a trivial mistake some posters are making here and it is generally assumed in society

Sunshinelover2 · 26/07/2021 02:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 02:28

I think s recent poster said it was a need like food etc

But they had very peculiar ideas full stop.

So I wouldn't dwell on that too much.

tomorrowalready · 26/07/2021 02:22

Ha MegaSauseHead, I just composed and thought I had posted a long post asking why some people keep saying sex is a 'need' for anyone. Is it just mental and lexical sloppiness or do they actually believe it?

My main point is no man or woman ever died from lack of sex so it is not a 'need'. Untold millions (women, children and men) throughout history and prehistory have died directly and indirectly from sex and sexually related events: pregnancy, childbirth, disease, violence. And are suffering and dying right now. Nobody is dying from lack of sex.

Loneliness is an unpleasant thing but I don't believe it is usually relieved by sex and neither do I believe it is usually solely responsible for suicide when that step is taken. Yes I do know what I am talking about and yes I do sound heartless. That's the short version!

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 02:20

@UpstreamSwimmer

I found it under the trending threads. And because I'm invested in the argument, I keep going. I could ask you the same question, why do you keep posting?
Fair question.

Many reasons.

I was unfortunately born with the ability to notice the difference in how boys and girls were treated. It would have been s much easier life if I hadn't!

I mean not when I was a baby obv but as long as I can remember noticed. And connected.

For me it's as simple as seeing day to day through my life how women and girls are seen, treated in a load of situations. Some of that is having sheets always noticed how women and girls as soon as through puberty are seen as sex objects by so many men. Rather than whole people.

Due to my lifelong.. inability to not see it and therefore be like all my friends could.

I saw things in the news. I read about what happens to women around the world. And children. And boys and men. For this topic the harm done globally by the sex industry esp men paying for sex. I mean massive outrageous sickening appalling harm all over the world every minute of every day.

And I accept that some people are happy and make s good living etc but that does not negate all the other things.

And I was s girl and am a woman and I know, and I know loads of other women know. How fucking horrible and dangerous men can be. And it's sadly lots of them.

I have s friend who at 15 had sex with 2 men for a bit of weed. She had a really abusive family. I was in the house and didn't think much of it really at that age. She was woohoo I got some weed! We smoked it.

I've also been offered money for sex more than once when I was maybe 17 . 19, 20. At 17 I thought about it for s moment. I was not in a good place.

And we know don't we that loads of women who sell sex start young. How? They meet a man who suggests it. Maybe he grooms. Girls who have been sexually abused, have terrible home lives. Care leavers. Are vulnerable to this.

In the end it's there but for the grace of God.

But my thoughts won't change anything.

They won't make you react I expect except to say prove this and not that and etc.

I care so much about all the women and children and men around the world who are doing this when they do not really have any choice. Or literally have no choice.

My view is that any man who pays for sex is not s good man. He is ignoring what he knows about exploitation etc because he wants to fuck someone for cash.

Long probably but that's why.

tomorrowalready · 26/07/2021 02:04

Why do some people keep referring to sex as a 'need'? Has anyone ever died from lack of sex? No. Many women have died and are dying right now directly and indirectly from sex and of course men also from sexually transmitted disease and I suppose also from violent sexual attacks but from lack of sexual contact with another or others or from denial of masturbation? I am pretty confident that has never happened.

Yes some people male and female may kill themselves from loneliness and part of that may include sexual frustration or relationship breakdown but there probably a lot more to the reasons than lack of sex. Before anyone accuses me of heartlessness. I am a person who has been lonely all my life, still am but have come to terms. When I was younger was I tortured by the sense of exclusion from sexual relationships? Yes. Did I try to remedy it by doing what men imagine is so easy for women , i.e having sex with any man who'd have me regardless of compatibility? Yes. Immediately found that worse than loneliness alone.

Incidentally I know I was not then, and would not be now, the only young woman who had it suggested directly to my face by several men that working as a prostitute would be an easy way to earn and they said could not understand why I did not do it. That was been by work colleagues and part of it they actually thought it was some kind of compliment. And now of course it is all so much more prevalent because of the Internet.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 02:04

Where did you learn that it's a drive that very few men can restrain from acting on?

Did you grow up in a fairly extreme religious group? I can't imagine what circs have made you feel that way.

It's not fair on men and it's not fair on you to believe that.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 02:02

'Sex is very important to men … more so than women. It’s a biological need. They are only a few with strong constitutions who can withstand these urges. Most men would put it’s importance high up, following food, water, shelter, warmth and sleep.'

You don't think much of men as a group do you.

In all the their massive range of personalities etc.

They are all... Essentially driven by their urge to fuck...

All of them. Every single one in the world. Irrespective of age. Sex drive. Etc.
Every single man on the planet.

There seems to be a pretty strong suggestion that if any man, that's any man on the planet. Apart from the very rare ones who are happy with their imagination and a wank and can overcome this apparently overwhelming need to fuck an actual person. Will rape if they can't find another way to fuck into an actual person.

If that's what you meant? I mean it was quite clear to me.

That throws up an array of questions but I won't ask them until I'm sure that's what you meant.

In general you have a really awful view of men.

Most are fine. Pretty much.

Honestly.

Megasausagehead · 26/07/2021 01:59

Because we know what it is like to be in that position and make those "choices".

What I will never understand is how men or women can justify using another person's body like a peice of disposable trash. And thinking that this is ok because you paid money. Without that money, they wouldn't spit on you if you were on fire. It is exploitation.

Don't want my kids to do it, or me to do it personally, but fine to treat others like a wank sock.

Oh and to the PP above SEX IS NOT A BIOLOGICAL NEED FOR MEN. Its 2021, wake up sleepy head. Nobody has a right to sex. Ever.

UpstreamSwimmer · 26/07/2021 01:44

I found it under the trending threads. And because I'm invested in the argument, I keep going. I could ask you the same question, why do you keep posting?

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 01:36

'To be honest I couldn't give a flying fig what you think of me hypothetically using a prostitute. I'm posting because I don't like the false narrative of someone employing a consensual service being lambasted for it.'

Why?
What does it matter to you?
This is a single thread on a single board in a corner of a very large chat site?

How did you even find it?
Why is it so important to you that you decided to post and keep posting? None of this is pointing at any individual. What is said here will have no impact on the freedom to pay for sex here. The vast majority of men whether punters or not would not know or care about what's said here.

What's your interest?

If you can't bear to see groups of people 'lambasted' on the internet then you must be busy! I mean on pretty much every topic you can think of, there's going to be a chatboard somewhere with lambasting going on.

Why this topic? How did you come across this thread? Do you have other topics you get stuck in, on other sites, to protect the innocent?

Guavafish · 26/07/2021 01:30

@NiceGerbil

'Most men think sex is an essential part of their life… hence the entitlement. Those men care nothing but their own satisfaction and gratitude. Part of that … is the self belief they give enjoyment in return! Ha!'

Again I don't think it's most tbh.

With the normalisation of the sex industry it's increasing I imagine. Mainly in situations like stags overseas.

But even with that I wouldn't say most.

And those who do at a stag, it's a very different scenario to booking up for yourself at home.

You miss understand what I mean…

Sex is very important to men … more so than women. It’s a biological need. They are only a few with strong constitutions who can withstand these urges. Most men would put it’s importance high up, following food, water, shelter, warmth and sleep.

The man that do pay for sex … only care for their own sexual gratification. Their justification is that it’s a necessary part of life and it’s an essential entitlement. I don’t know if these men and women that do pay for sex are bad/good… I don’t believe it’s as black/white.

I have read a few ukpunter thread and they are vile. These men are perverts and see women as only sex objects.

I don’t know how I would react if a close friend said she was a sex worker? If I know a male acquaintance paid for sex… I would not want to engage with them alone or ever again.

EmeraldShamrock · 26/07/2021 01:29

Typo above. "When you know better you do better"

EmeraldShamrock · 26/07/2021 01:28

@UpstreamSwimmer It is a pity you won't open your mind to the scenarios posted by pp's.
I'm a firm believer "when you know better, you don't better" every day is a school day, you've been given the opportunity to learn from this thread and you are adamant paying a woman for sex is acceptable.

UpstreamSwimmer · 26/07/2021 01:10

@LimeRedBanana

Upstream whatshisname is just really invested in us thinking you can be a good person and pay for sex.

It really annoys him that most women don’t think this is possible.

To be honest I couldn't give a flying fig what you think of me hypothetically using a prostitute. I'm posting because I don't like the false narrative of someone employing a consensual service being lambasted for it.
NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 01:09

Around the world and all over the place that is the choice.

When universal credit came in there were plenty of press items about women who had started selling sex in order to pay the rent/ feed their children etc.

They made that choice.

UpstreamSwimmer · 26/07/2021 01:07

You have an offer for cash. A massive bloke will pay you in food for an hour with you.

Ok imagine that conversation. How much you need the money.

What do you say and how do you feel about it?*

I wouldn't like it, because a cock up my arse would be quite painful. But would I do it? Who knows, quite possibly. If I was desperate enough. What's your point though?

UpstreamSwimmer · 26/07/2021 01:04

@nicegerbil

You can't make any assumptions about my sexuality or proclivities. For all you know I might be gay and have employed male prostitutes. Or not. What we're discussing is the principle, not my personal activities and potential transactions.

I don't know what I'd do of I hadn't eaten for 3 days and was desperate. Probably very little I wouldn't do to be honest. But how is this relevant?

The fact is there is a person who has chosen to offer sexual services for money, and they have done so out of their own free will. What is your argument for a punter to not employ their service?

Just to be clear, if anyone mistreats a prostitute they are definitely not a good person. But the OP's question wasn't about clear arseholes. It was whether there is something inherently wrong in using a prostitute, and I don't think there is.

By all means, if you have a clear argument why it's wrong, please present it. No silly what if questions, and no loaded terms calculated to evoke an empty emotional response. Just a straightforward moral/ethical/logical argument why it's wrong.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 01:03

I'm not getting what you're not getting.

This is an exercise in putting yourself in someone else's shoes. It's not an unusual thing to do!

Imagine. Ignore thinking that would never happen. It has.

Imagine you have not eaten for 3 days. You have no way of getting money. There is no one you can ask/ no social support / no way of getting cash. No odd jobs. No nothing.

The point is not to think about how that could have happened. It has happened.

I dunno imagine there's been a massive disaster. It's like mad Max or something.

Everything is fucked.

You have an offer for cash. A massive bloke will pay you in food for an hour with you.

Ok imagine that conversation. How much you need the money.

What do you say and how do you feel about it?

Does it feel different than mowing s lawn or similar?

You need the food.

If you say yes it's a fair transaction for a service like any other.

Come on this isn't difficult! Just use a bit of imagination.

UpstreamSwimmer · 26/07/2021 00:53

@Megasausagehead

But YOU will buy it but never consider selling it.

Because YOU are above that. Sex is different for YOU. YET you use other people's bodies.

Nice.

What exactly is your point? At this point in my life I'm fortunate enough to not have to work in a warehouse, say. And I wouldn't take that job if you offered it to me now. But I still buy off Amazon.

The fact that I wouldn't do X for money, doesn't preclude me from employing someone else who would. As long as they choose to do it.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 00:16

I don't think it's about being annoyed.

I get the feeling (may be wrong) it's to do with an underlying discomfort with it. Guilt.

LimeRedBanana · 25/07/2021 23:58

Upstream whatshisname is just really invested in us thinking you can be a good person and pay for sex.

It really annoys him that most women don’t think this is possible.

NiceGerbil · 25/07/2021 23:49

Just seen recent response.

Like a host of other posters in the past with the same view.

They could just say of course I would! Checkmate.

It's anonymous.

But the idea of even lying to say yes on an anonymous forum doesn't happen.

Because they can't even bring themselves to write it...

Or because they're being very honest. Strong possibility.

So on that basis.

Upstream.

Why wouldn't you do it, even to save yourself from going hungry?

You'd do odd jobs. Mow the lawn. Paint a fence. This is no different. It doesn't require qualifications or anything.

So be honest. Why not? Even if you were totally desperate for money, not eaten for 3 days type situation.

Why on earth not?

NiceGerbil · 25/07/2021 23:43

Probably more like wouldn't consider it

For those who wouldn't, and I've never had a poster of the it's just work type say yeah no problem.

The reason given is often well I'm straight.

The answer is of course

So what? For the seller, sexuality is irrelevant. It's about sex you don't want. With men you don't want. For many/ most performing sex acts that they would not want in consensual sex.

That seems to be Different though. How do they know the sexual orientation of the women? They don't.

It's assumed they are straight and therefore 'just' having sex which they would have anyway (??!!) and so.. what's the problem.

Gay for pay is a thing in gay porn, chaps! Why the reluctance?

It's a service like any other.

Megasausagehead · 25/07/2021 23:42

But YOU will buy it but never consider selling it.

Because YOU are above that. Sex is different for YOU. YET you use other people's bodies.

Nice.