Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you be a good person if you pay for sex? [Content warning: descriptions of sexual abuse]

582 replies

Lave · 18/07/2021 14:15

Do you think there's a grey area or are all men who pay for sex abusive?

OP posts:
Guavafish · 27/07/2021 01:16

Sex is intimacy

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:16

My comments:

Regarding the sex/need issue, indeed as you noted I've never said it's a need. It most certainly is an extremely strong urge and drive, and men as a class can be swayed by sex or the promise thereof.

Not all by any means. I know we often and you specify class terms and that's a good basis generally. However in this conversation the fact that there are a good number of men who don't feel/ feel but don't act in that way. The portrayal of men with these conversations is deeply around stereotypes of a particular type of masculinity. And the number of men who aren't that way is not small enough to ignore IMO.

Eg men who

Want an emotional connection with their partner
Are uncomfortable with one offs. Because of things like shyness, religion, personal feelings of what's right/ wrong, a knowledge that it would in the end make them feel crap about themselves, concern about the industry, finding the idea seedy/ desperate/ sad, low sex drive, asexuality (talked about a lot at the mo), being an old school romantic (men used to pine and write poetry etc I'm sure they've not vanished!), being concerned about STDs Pregnancy.

I know there are men who would not drop their trousers and dive in because well. Any hole's a goal.

'As with all generalities, there are those for whom this statement will be either more or less valid, but as a generality it holds water. You only have to see how many men have risked/lost everything for a lay (when cheating on their OH for example).'

Women cheat as well.

'And while you may counter that this is because those men were arseholes, it is still the case that the medium through which they stumbled was sex.'

People are people. Relationships are complex. If the woman isn't single then it's the same both ways.

'Truth be told this isn't simply due to such men being disgusting, but it's an actual biological drive. No different than any other species which has the instinctive urge to procreate and propagate its seed. So of course nobody is saying 'men' can't keep it in their pants, but as a generality, it is extremely difficult.'

Women have sex drives as well you know! Around the world our sexual behaviour is controlled and judged in a way men's is not. We also have more risk- pregnancy, rape, these days risks around being filmed and pasted all over the net. The consequences of sexual activity with the 'wrong' bloke or at the 'wrong' time range from boys and sometimes girls at school calling you awful names and bullying you, to being raped, murdered, imprisoned etc. This all makes us understandly rather more cautious.

'Now coming back to the 'need' question, we would first have to define 'need'. If it is simply that which without having it we would die, then no, sex isn't a need.'

A PP likened it to food. Amnesty Ireland had a policy proposal that referred to sex as a right/ human right (see old threads). In general in human rights stuff etc certain needs should be met. Viewing sex as a need needs to be approached with caution given eg amnesty.

'But if you broaden out the term to mean whatever is necessary for one to be physically and emotionally happy and healthy, then sex is a need. At least for men (and I'm speaking as one).'

It's a want not a need.
And where is the consideration of the physical and emotional happiness of the seller? Is theirs less important? Is that s fair exchange? Also. Sounds different to mowing a lawn to me.

'To be clear, by 'sex' I don't mean just an ejaculation, for that can easily me self-administered. What I mean is an intimate relationship with another person. This is as much a need as any other of our so called needs that help us thrive emotionally.''

Intimacy? That's a big ask. Relationship??? The women are being paid to be fucked. The vast majority do not like the men. They do not like the men. Plenty hate the men. How can anyone see that as emotionally enriching intimacy? They are acting. They are working.

And that's one hell of a service just the same as doing warehouse work, surely?

UpstreamSwimmer · 27/07/2021 01:12

paid for consent is not consent, no consent is rape.

This is patently false and no amount of repeating it will make it true.

To be clear, I'm not justifying engaging sex workers because men are wired etc. On the contrary, I don't think any justification is needed. As long as the user has no reason to suspect the SW is acting out of coercion, they are free to engage SW's services. A transaction into which both parties freely enter, is 100% consensual.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 01:09

Who is justifying anything?

I’m trying to understand why men disproportionately paid for sex, watch pornography, paid for webcams?

I think men see sex and acts of sex as an important need. Of course it’s not all men. Hence why they can pay for it.

BlatantlyNameChanged · 27/07/2021 01:01

Intimacy isn't the same as sex and you'll sure as shit aren't going to get intimacy from a prostitute. "We're biologically wired to want sex more than women do" is a cop out and does not justify what is essentially rape - paid for consent is not consent, no consent is rape.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 00:41

Sex is an important need for men. More so than women.

I have read many threads on this website where men are arguing with female partners due to lack of sex..

Is it is the 21st century but it doesn’t change biology or the human nature. And for most men sex is an important need…if you look at Maslow triangle of needs .. once the basics are meet then the next important need is intimacy. I know its very hard for women to understand and they may never understand it as a need.

UpstreamSwimmer · 27/07/2021 00:11

@NiceGerbil

What about paying...

Nobody is saying there aren't cases where using a prostitute is clear abuse and exploitation, nor that there aren't horrible men who use prostitutes (and for whom it's solely about power).

The question posed in the OP was whether there was anything inherently abusive in engaging the services of a willing sex worker. Let's say poor women in a waitress job decides she could make her weekly wage in a few hours by opening an OnlyFans or by turning tricks, and she decides to go for it of her own volition, are those who use her services abusive? And why?

UpstreamSwimmer · 27/07/2021 00:06

@NiceGerbil

Regarding the sex/need issue, indeed as you noted I've never said it's a need. It most certainly is an extremely strong urge and drive, and men as a class can be swayed by sex or the promise thereof.

As with all generalities, there are those for whom this statement will be either more or less valid, but as a generality it holds water. You only have to see how many men have risked/lost everything for a lay (when cheating on their OH for example). And while you may counter that this is because those men were arseholes, it is still the case that the medium through which they stumbled was sex.

Truth be told this isn't simply due to such men being disgusting, but it's an actual biological drive. No different than any other species which has the instinctive urge to procreate and propagate its seed. So of course nobody is saying 'men' can't keep it in their pants, but as a generality, it is extremely difficult.

Now coming back to the 'need' question, we would first have to define 'need'. If it is simply that which without having it we would die, then no, sex isn't a need.

But if you broaden out the term to mean whatever is necessary for one to be physically and emotionally happy and healthy, then sex is a need. At least for men (and I'm speaking as one).

To be clear, by 'sex' I don't mean just an ejaculation, for that can easily me self-administered. What I mean is an intimate relationship with another person. This is as much a need as any other of our so called needs that help us thrive emotionally.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 23:10

Interesting to get a real example!

Can I ask some questions? I'm assuming she's seeing men here sorry if that's not correct.

Does she stick to one for a while? IME for women it's better if you know what each other like (or in this case he does).

How does she find them? Do they come to her home, is she ever concerned for her safety?

Why not go out and get a random to shag and never see him again?

Why doesn't she have concern about their circs?

Does she worry about STDs?

Does she worry about blackmail/ robbery etc?

In the end she's just as bad.

robotcollision · 26/07/2021 23:05

@tomorrowalready

Religion does not come in to it for me, I was using moral in the sense of how each one of us treats other people. In this instance whether it can ever be morally right to choose to pay to use another person's body for your sexual satisfaction, directly or indirectly. As others have said we are non of us wholly 'good' or 'bad'. Personally it would never be how I would describe any adult. I feel sympathy for those who have to deal with the question in their own lives.

I should not have said I 'know' that the view that sex is a need is prevelant in society as I don't know that . I haven't conducted a survey, don't know if anyone ever has or how reliable that would be anyway. It is just the impression I have formed from my experience and from the general looseness of conflating the terms 'need' and 'desire ' in so many areas.

Good points. Why discuss this in the abstract when it is a very physical issue.
IncorrigibleTitmouse · 26/07/2021 23:05

I realise you're referring to men here, but I have a friend that has. She is staunchly single for myriad reasons and doesn't want any complications in her life. I admit I was very shocked when she first told me (probably a decade ago) but she's still my friend and her reasoning made me check my judgment, if you will.

I could never in a billion years, but she sees it as a 'service' same as getting a pedicure or a massage or a haircut.

JHchristsendhalp · 26/07/2021 22:33

Hunting the sex traffickers on channel 4 at the moment.

Unsurprisingly adultwork is a platform they use to flaunt the women.

The profiles featured (albeit faces blurred to protect the women's identity) appear carefully curated with professional photos. All very 'high class' looking.

The reality behind the facade is a group of aging, ugly men profiting from trauma.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 20:18

' In this instance whether it can ever be morally right to choose to pay to use another person's body for your sexual satisfaction, directly or indirectly'

This is about directly. Paying for sexual contact with another individual.

Your first part is not well defined.

What about paying a child or the person selling their body? (Happens all the time).

What about 10 men paying a fragile 85 to woman? And it will cause her serious injury?

What about the aid workers paying local women in Haiti. In the middle of a crisis?

What about a woman being procured for a man known to be violent and interested in throttling?

What about men oversees who are very big tall westerners finding a tiny woman because they know she will be hurt and that makes them feel like big men? (Read a vile story about this once. The woman was injured and crying. The man was upset about that. Apparently although he wanted to feel like he was making her 'take' him and he had a big penis it didn't cross his mind the damage he could do).

So many scenarios!

And the term morality is tbh just not in my thinking, I know what it means but... I'm not. Sort of. It's not a word I use. Others like harm I do kind of have in my standard way of thinking. For me using that word is more of a philosophical thing and I don't really... I know what it means but not intrinsically etc so it's really hard to talk around that concept.

Like if I said. Random example. Let's think about this maths problem in multiple dimensions (more than 4). You would understand the words but conceptually you'd find it difficult to get to grips with the essential meaning. (Unless you did maths to a fairly advanced level... It's the example that's the thing here not whether that means something to you or not!).

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 20:08

They are conflated by men who like to be able to buy sex

tomorrowalready · 26/07/2021 16:27

Religion does not come in to it for me, I was using moral in the sense of how each one of us treats other people. In this instance whether it can ever be morally right to choose to pay to use another person's body for your sexual satisfaction, directly or indirectly. As others have said we are non of us wholly 'good' or 'bad'. Personally it would never be how I would describe any adult. I feel sympathy for those who have to deal with the question in their own lives.

I should not have said I 'know' that the view that sex is a need is prevelant in society as I don't know that . I haven't conducted a survey, don't know if anyone ever has or how reliable that would be anyway. It is just the impression I have formed from my experience and from the general looseness of conflating the terms 'need' and 'desire ' in so many areas.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:58

Is 'goodness' in a moral (religious?) sense what the OP meant?

I doubt it.

The introduction of the concept of morality is... Interesting. Probably not helpful.

Most people in society aren't taking s moral stance in the way previous generations would have used the word moral.

It's s word that has become very loaded TBH.

I mean if I say I dunno. Robbing elderly people is not good.

Sure that's a moral view. It's immoral. But it's more than immoral. It's cruel and unconscionable and... Wrong.

I think the moral thing is a side track TBH. An interesting one. Maybe another thread?

In general no I don't think that society believes that sex for men is an essential need. Nor do I believe that it's used as a justification for men paying for sex, generally.

I think it was in the past, maybe. This is about now though.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:50

' I know it is an argument made generally in society also as a justification for prostitution and pornography. So I think the definition of 'need' and how that relates to the moral question of 'goodness' (as referenced in the op) is very pertinent to this thread.'

First off I don't think that sex as a need for men- in the sense of its a necessity like food etc is prevalent in society.

If it were genuinely seen that way by society (are we talking about the UK? Good to understand the context) then that would have immense repurcussions.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:48

Apologies if that was how my post came across.

I've not seen it as a theme on this thread at all.

One poster with very strange ideas generally mentioned it.

Certainly upstream hasn't.

I don't think there've been that many other posters on that 'side' tbh.

So I'm really not getting why it's s point you're pushing.

But anyway.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:44

Oh sorry take it back- got you confused.

Ignore that sorry!

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:43

Shelddd I don't recognise your name from this thread!

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:41

This thread is about selling sex- in the prostitution sense.

Not about other things.

Megasausagehead · 26/07/2021 04:30

It's quite an old fashioned, misogynistic view that just won't go away.

That men NEED sex is so ingrained in our society that it doesn't really need to be explicitly stated. Actions scream it.

Like the fact that a person can be sent for sex therapy and surrogate partners for sexual dysfunction. Like wives being expected to give sex to their husbands on demand.

It's insidious. It's vile.

Shelddd · 26/07/2021 04:29

I don't know.. maybe it's been covered this is a long thread.. there are varying levels to this. Can you really say the 20 something year old woman who doesn't do drugs, drink or have any history of abuse who enters into a sugar baby type relationship with a man is being exploited? I know it's a relatively new thing with technology but it's becoming quite widespread. I could see this soon becoming the dominant form of sex work.

Obviously traditional sex work is extremely exploitive... but it's not all equal and likewise the men who are customers are not all equally bad depending on what type they engage with. Porn is sex work too and any man who consumes porn is guilty of exploitation as well. Like I said there are levels to it.

tomorrowalready · 26/07/2021 04:04

I am sorry NiceGerbil, I am trusting that you don't mean to be patronising by assuming I am somehow disturbed ("put your mind at rest") because I have stuck to one point in 2 posts but that is how your response is coming across. I have actually followed this thread at a distance so to speak so I have noticed that the sex/need argument has arisen several times. I know it is an argument made generally in society also as a justification for prostitution and pornography. So I think the definition of 'need' and how that relates to the moral question of 'goodness' (as referenced in the op) is very pertinent to this thread.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 03:16

I've only seen one poster say it's a need (although it's been a long thread!).

It doesn't feel like a theme that either 'side' are. Well. Even mentioning to be honest!

The poster who said it recently had very peculiar ideas generally.

'So I don't think it is a trivial mistake some posters are making here and it is generally assumed in society'.

Like I said I've not seen it. It would be those arguing that (in various situations) it's fine I think? Upstream has been the main poster with that view and I'm pretty sure he's not said that.

Given that I don't think it's really been said on the thread, does that put your mind at rest?