Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you be a good person if you pay for sex? [Content warning: descriptions of sexual abuse]

582 replies

Lave · 18/07/2021 14:15

Do you think there's a grey area or are all men who pay for sex abusive?

OP posts:
Megasausagehead · 27/07/2021 02:17

So is this how you justify paedophilia in the clergy?

Utter twaddle with no scientific foundation. Asexual men exist you know. So do hands.

No point in arguing with the deluded however.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 02:06

I believe it’s their need rather than want

MorriseysGladioli · 27/07/2021 02:05

Well, if they're doing it just because they want to, then they're just nasty bastards, but my point was that good people sometimes stray, for many complex reasons.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 02:05

The need for sex … as a need like eating, sleeping, money. Housing

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 02:02

@MorriseysGladioli

Cross posts, *@nicegerbil*. No distinction; I should have been clearer - men and women. Perhaps some may have their interest piqued by a workmate, others will pay for any kind intimacy, and some will suffer in silence. All questionable things, but driven by a need.
Driven by a WANT.

In general those who have affairs are still having sex with their partner.

They tend to lie about that obv.

Which reminds me.

Can't remember the stat. But many men who pay for sex are in relationships and having sex with their partners.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 02:00

'SW like men enter into this for many different reason'

And men who sell sex as well. Obviously. Example being 'gay for pay' in porn. That must happen with those selling sex as well. Esp in certain countries where children are available.

'Drugs, addiction, poverty, cohesion, rape - I would imagine they would need enjoy the acts but doing it for other reasons.'

I assume you mean would not enjoy the acts.
If you're the person being penetrated and you are not into it, the risk of injury is higher. Just as a thought.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 01:57

It can work both ways

MorriseysGladioli · 27/07/2021 01:56

Cross posts, @nicegerbil.
No distinction; I should have been clearer - men and women.
Perhaps some may have their interest piqued by a workmate, others will pay for any kind intimacy, and some will suffer in silence.
All questionable things, but driven by a need.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:56

Everyone's relationships are different.

Many/ most are not 100% operating on how it should be done at all times.

If either partner is not happy they can leave.

And we're heading way off topic here!

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 01:55

@NiceGerbil

Although a few observations.

If men want sex way more than women. And a woman's job is to have sex with men, possibly multiple times a day.
Then logically she's not happy with it. Is she.

  1. If a point of paying for sex is to feel connected, intimacy. For the buyer. And that's important for physical and emotional health. What of the effect on the person being paid? In terms of their emotional and physical health?

Also what about the point that asking others to understand and empathise with the buyers while refusing to even try to empathise with the sellers is hypocritical.

SW like men enter into this for many different reason

Drugs, addiction, poverty, cohesion, rape - I would imagine they would need enjoy the acts but doing it for other reasons.

But I’m sure some enjoy the sex. Therefore the effects, mental and physical, will depend on the SW and the reason for doing it.

MorriseysGladioli · 27/07/2021 01:52

I thought a relationship was about working through issues, not sweeping them under the carpet.
To me, it's fairly obvious that unless both are happy to live as housemates then Somethings gotta give.
Of course, I've seen women post about how utterly lonely and sad they feel that their partner is no longer interested in them, too.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:50

And the women who complain no sex?

Plenty of those threads as well...

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:49

@MorriseysGladioli

I think "good" people can do all manner of questionable things. I often see women on here saying they thought their relationship was good, even though they haven't had sex for 5 years. To me, that is also a questionable thing to do, to know that there is a gaping chasm in terms of closeness, and allow it to carry on that way.
Yikes.

The partner can leave if they wish

I thought lie back and think of England was dying out.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 01:48

@MorriseysGladioli

I think "good" people can do all manner of questionable things. I often see women on here saying they thought their relationship was good, even though they haven't had sex for 5 years. To me, that is also a questionable thing to do, to know that there is a gaping chasm in terms of closeness, and allow it to carry on that way.
I agree… sex in relationship is the glue (not all) and when it been absent for so long.. and they are surprised their partner has been cheating 🤷‍♂️
NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:47

Although a few observations.

If men want sex way more than women. And a woman's job is to have sex with men, possibly multiple times a day.
Then logically she's not happy with it. Is she.

  1. If a point of paying for sex is to feel connected, intimacy. For the buyer. And that's important for physical and emotional health. What of the effect on the person being paid? In terms of their emotional and physical health?

Also what about the point that asking others to understand and empathise with the buyers while refusing to even try to empathise with the sellers is hypocritical.

MorriseysGladioli · 27/07/2021 01:42

I think "good" people can do all manner of questionable things.
I often see women on here saying they thought their relationship was good, even though they haven't had sex for 5 years.
To me, that is also a questionable thing to do, to know that there is a gaping chasm in terms of closeness, and allow it to carry on that way.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:41

They'll stop and talk to a pretty chugger (charity mugger) when they wouldn't have given a male one the time of day, they'll be willing to help carry stuff for women etc

As women and older girls will be more likely to stop for an attractive young man...

And for sure if a smiling good looking man say. Asks me for a cigarette.

Then he's very likely indeed to get one. And I'll light it for him too!

We seem to have veered off into a conversation focussed on men and how they feel about sex.

And churning out 'facts' about male v female sexual behaviour which I mean we can all chat about. But in the end in the world as it is, no one really knows.

And the focus is off the well known massive harms that selling sex results in.

UpstreamSwimmer · 27/07/2021 01:40

@NiceGerbil

What I would point out upstream is you FLATLY REFUSED to try and put yourself in the shoes of someone selling sex because they were desperate for money.

And yet now you're expecting others to be empathetic and understanding towards those who pay for sex.

Maybe have s think about that. It's revealing, surely.

You keep coming back to whether I would or wouldn't sell sex, but I refuse to engage because it's irrelevant. The fact is there are people (women and men) who do agree to sell sexual services. And my argument is that since they do so willingly, there is nothing morally wrong with using these services.

And nowhere have asked for empathy and understanding. What I wrote was an academic exercise, just to explain why things are how they are. But I'm not asking for any empathy.

My posts here are about the cut and dry question of whether it's moral to use sexual services that are being sold willingly. That's it. Anything else is a distraction.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:36

Sex is intimacy

For those being paid?

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:36

They can pay because there are men and women (and boys and girls) available to buy. Surely.

UpstreamSwimmer · 27/07/2021 01:34

*Not all by any means. I know we often and you specify class terms and that's a good basis generally. However in this conversation the fact that there are a good number of men who don't feel/ feel but don't act in that way. The portrayal of men with these conversations is deeply around stereotypes of a particular type of masculinity. And the number of men who aren't that way is not small enough to ignore IMO.

Eg men who

Want an emotional connection with their partner
Are uncomfortable with one offs. Because of things like shyness, religion, personal feelings of what's right/ wrong, a knowledge that it would in the end make them feel crap about themselves, concern about the industry, finding the idea seedy/ desperate/ sad, low sex drive, asexuality (talked about a lot at the mo), being an old school romantic (men used to pine and write poetry etc I'm sure they've not vanished!), being concerned about STDs Pregnancy.

I know there are men who would not drop their trousers and dive in because well. Any hole's a goal.*

There are many men, perhaps even the majority of men, who wouldn't just dive in at the drop of a hat. That's true. But the vast majority of men can be lured by sex appeal. They'll stop and talk to a pretty chugger (charity mugger) when they wouldn't have given a male one the time of day, they'll be willing to help carry stuff for women etc.

This is even men who wouldn't dream of actually doing anything with said woman. Yet the biological instinct still pulls them to do stuff they wouldn't otherwise do. That's what I meant about sex being an extremely powerful urge.

As to needs vs wants, it comes down to how you define a need. If it's merely about survival, then the argument could be made that all human interaction is a want. But most people would see it as a need. Anyway, I'm not arguing semantics, what I'm saying is that sex (at least for men), is almost on par with human interaction.

Guavafish · 27/07/2021 01:30

@NiceGerbil

I don’t believe all men are they same and only a small portion of men pay for regular sex. I’m discussing only this small portion.

Of course men pay for sex for different reason ..it’s not complicated, different women, reduces risk of boredom, sex when you need and want it, it’s thrilling and they enjoy it. I still think these men see it as a need. Hence why they can pay.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:30

What I would point out upstream is you FLATLY REFUSED to try and put yourself in the shoes of someone selling sex because they were desperate for money.

And yet now you're expecting others to be empathetic and understanding towards those who pay for sex.

Maybe have s think about that. It's revealing, surely.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:28

How can we know about women's sex drives v men's in a world which has massively different attitudes to sexual activity in the sexes? And can have such massively different consequences for women?

Have you lot never met any of the very common randy middle aged women around the place???

Do women not have such demanding sex drives?

Or do they look different?

In addition to my points above about risk etc.

I would add.

Most men are shite in bed. Esp on a ONS where he's not even going to bother.

We have cycles - it's up and down. Around ovulation many women are very... Interested !

We have certain life events that effect it. More up and down.

Pregnancy. Breastfeeding. Birth injury. Etc.

On top of the fact that so many threads on here the woman isn't interested because the man is being a total arse.

I read a study (there's always a study!) that in long term relationships men tend to be happy with sex all through. While women get bored with it.

Upstream you might be interested in reading testosterone rex. Seriously. It's a good book and very interesting. Whether you think some or none makes sense it's worth s read.

Because you say men just have this urge to fuck.
But then you're talking about human connection. Relationship. Intimacy.

The book has interviews with men and it turns out it's a thing. For men to buy sex but what they really want is something else. Maybe for men sex is the way many think to experience intimacy?

I mean I don't know. Just a few thoughts.

NiceGerbil · 27/07/2021 01:17

Sorry took me ages to write bedtime in the middle.

Need to catch up.