Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you be a good person if you pay for sex? [Content warning: descriptions of sexual abuse]

582 replies

Lave · 18/07/2021 14:15

Do you think there's a grey area or are all men who pay for sex abusive?

OP posts:
UpstreamSwimmer · 20/07/2021 03:51

@Twinkletwinklelittlecar

Yes *@UpstreamSwimmer* because rape is not the same as answering the phone or vacuuming. Sex requires enthusiastic consent, anything else is rape.
All work requires enthusiastic consent, otherwise it's slavery.
SourAppleChew · 20/07/2021 03:45

It's not as simple as 'good' or 'bad'.

An entrepreneur might occasionally sleep with escorts but donate hundreds of thousands to charity via a business fund.

Another person might never sleep with escorts but also do nothing whatsoever to help anbody in need.

The first person has questionable morals but has helped more people than he's hurt in balance.

Twinkletwinklelittlecar · 20/07/2021 03:27

Yes @UpstreamSwimmer because rape is not the same as answering the phone or vacuuming.
Sex requires enthusiastic consent, anything else is rape.

UpstreamSwimmer · 20/07/2021 03:14

And it's not a woman's 'body' any more than any manual worker is selling their 'body'. As a matter of fact you can 'buy' people's bodies by employing them as actors. You can even do intimate scenes (I'm talking about mainstream acting).

It's possible to pay someone to professionally massage your body, even though they would never do it if it weren't for the money. Just as you can get someone to wait on you, clean your house, be your PA and much more. All things that people do solely for the money.

But we don't call those jobs rape or slavery. Yet if you pay someone for sexual gratification, somehow this is equivalent to rape? Is there something special about sexual services that you can't buy consent, unlike any other manual service no matter how gross?

UpstreamSwimmer · 20/07/2021 03:09

Nail salons is also a profession where there are a lot of trafficked women, yet I don't see bi-weekly threads on MN railing against women who get their nails done.

As long as the prostitute claims she is acting of her own free will, and there aren't any signs that clearly point otherwise, there is no reason to assume she is being coerced.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 19/07/2021 21:56

No.

People who pay for sex are rapists.

NiceGerbil · 19/07/2021 21:55

The fact that so many girls and women have been abused raped or just never been with anyone who didn't just focus on their own pleasure is terrible of course.

The fact is that those men especially the abusers essentially groom women to see being paid in a different way. I can totally see why might as well make some money from it is a natural response.

That's another angle on the harm caused to so many women and girls due to men and sex.

The abusers groom the next group of women who will because of that be more likely to accept being paid by essentially the next abusers down the line.

It's horrific.

rishisboater · 19/07/2021 18:30

100% agree

Wallpapering · 19/07/2021 18:26

I don’t judge the women @rishisboater who do, my judgement is all directed at the men.

rishisboater · 19/07/2021 18:01

That's exactly the kind of scenario I mean... when sex has been something that's been taken from you for a long time, it can feel like it's preferable to take payment

Wallpapering · 19/07/2021 17:56

It’s hasn’t @rishisboater as at age of 11 sex is neither enjoyable nor had my consent, same when I was 13 or when in my 20’s.

However it was seen as free sex to those men

Boood · 19/07/2021 17:45

Yet again I’m amazed by the knots people will tie themselves into, thinking up increasingly bizarre and unlikely scenarios that would mean paying for sex was the mark of a good person.

Taking the time to find a prostitute who met all the requirements that would classify her as a free agent happy hooker? Respectfully agreeing to her conditions about what she will and won’t do, even in the heat of the moment? All this in a person whose personal qualities aren’t so repellent that no woman would want to have sex with him without being paid? Come on. This is not the reality, nobody believes this for a second. Even in Pretty Woman, this was one man against a backdrop of hundreds of abusive, disgusting monsters.

Maireas · 19/07/2021 17:08

My last point was in agreement with@Wallpapering

Maireas · 19/07/2021 17:08

Indeed. So offensive. Some people need to watch the Last Leg. Or the Paralympics. Or just open their eyes to the amazing, gorgeous, funny, clever people who happen to have a disability.

rishisboater · 19/07/2021 17:06

What should happen is that the women who feel like that up their standards and set boundaries and learn to enjoy respectful sexual relationships but it's not that easy. Extremely sad but true.

And this is another reason why I judge men who pay for sex.

Wallpapering · 19/07/2021 17:02

Yes @Maireas the comments regarding disability have without doubt been 100 offensive as if been disabled means you some unfuckable dregs of society.

rishisboater · 19/07/2021 17:02

@Wallpapering

I don’t understand the giving away for free concept as sex is supposed to mutual enjoyable experience plus free suggests don’t value my body or self regardless of what state it in.

Something women who are married or in relationship are told it’s not obligation to shut up and put up.

Even when I had fuckbuddy for a year (he got to clingy in end) I wasn’t giving it away free as purpose was to have mutually consented enjoyable experience.

I could of made lot of money had he had to pay me for the sex but then mutual consent isn’t anymore and what would of happened at times when for various reason I stopped the sex mid way, there was also things didn’t want to do would I have been obligated to for fill his needs still.

This term free sex doesn’t sit well with me, as usually directed at women. When has man last been said he gives away free sex

Lots and lots of women for one reason or another end up feeling like sex isn't mutually enjoyable.

Self esteem issues, abuse, mental health problems, coercion.

When you've been with enough men who've made you feel utterly shite, it can feel that well, if you're giving them all that pleasure and getting nothing in return then you may as well at least make some money out of it.

You're fortunate if sex for you has always been mutually enjoyable

BlatantlyNameChanged · 19/07/2021 16:54

It really does.

NiceGerbil · 19/07/2021 16:52

@BlatantlyNameChanged

Women have a product called sex. Men want it. Women give or withhold for various reasons related to controlling men, that sort of thing.

The idea that men have sex for pleasure and women have sex for personal gain is both misogynistic and outdated. Women are not the gatekeepers of sex and this gatekeeper model props up societal attitudes around rape, sexual violence, and consent - the idea that it wouldn't have happened if the woman had been a better gatekeeper by not wearing a short skirt, not drinking, not walking alone, etc.

Yes, this essentially male view of women and sex, which runs throughout society, causes massive harm to women and girls all over the world.
Wallpapering · 19/07/2021 16:52

I don’t understand the giving away for free concept as sex is supposed to mutual enjoyable experience plus free suggests don’t value my body or self regardless of what state it in.

Something women who are married or in relationship are told it’s not obligation to shut up and put up.

Even when I had fuckbuddy for a year (he got to clingy in end) I wasn’t giving it away free as purpose was to have mutually consented enjoyable experience.

I could of made lot of money had he had to pay me for the sex but then mutual consent isn’t anymore and what would of happened at times when for various reason I stopped the sex mid way, there was also things didn’t want to do would I have been obligated to for fill his needs still.

This term free sex doesn’t sit well with me, as usually directed at women. When has man last been said he gives away free sex

rishisboater · 19/07/2021 16:24

Yes if you're in a bad way, having unfulfilling sex with people who dont respect you then I can see that being paid for it rather than giving it for free is preferable to some people.

But that's a sad situation in itself.

BlatantlyNameChanged · 19/07/2021 16:24

Women have a product called sex. Men want it. Women give or withhold for various reasons related to controlling men, that sort of thing.

The idea that men have sex for pleasure and women have sex for personal gain is both misogynistic and outdated. Women are not the gatekeepers of sex and this gatekeeper model props up societal attitudes around rape, sexual violence, and consent - the idea that it wouldn't have happened if the woman had been a better gatekeeper by not wearing a short skirt, not drinking, not walking alone, etc.

NiceGerbil · 19/07/2021 16:16

Not to direct this at the poster as how they feel is up to them obv.

In general though their feelings

Rather be paid for sex than giving to away for free

I think encapsulate the male approach.

Women have a product called sex. Men want it. Women give or withhold for various reasons related to controlling men, that sort of thing.

Sexual desire, pleasure on the woman's side, for those men, does not come into it.

Maireas · 19/07/2021 15:48

There was a good post above about it "women are not service animals"

Maireas · 19/07/2021 15:47

I was about to post the same, @Wallpapering!
Being sad, lonely, shy or having a disability does not excuse the exploitation of women.