Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you be a good person if you pay for sex? [Content warning: descriptions of sexual abuse]

582 replies

Lave · 18/07/2021 14:15

Do you think there's a grey area or are all men who pay for sex abusive?

OP posts:
WhiskeyGalore212 · 20/07/2021 23:47

How do you know that most prostitutes 'don't do anal'?

It,'s obvious from the review sites that plenty do.

It's also obvious from.the review sites that the prostitutes are often immigrants, often speak little or even no English, often gave pimps, jokingly referred to as Sergei by punters, sometimes are notes as drug users, and are regularly described as surly, reluctant, detached, and always trying to dodge or minimise doing what is offered in their profiles or what was agreed by text (which they themselves sometimes are not party to.

WhiskeyGalore212 · 20/07/2021 23:42

The high class escort rubbish is always rolled out .... how many people shop in harrods compared to Asda or tesco?

Brief look at UK punting or similar will give you a picture ... and it's asda/tesco.

Fr0thandBubble · 20/07/2021 23:32

Hey OP just wanted to say I agree with everything you’ve said. All the best with moving forward from such a traumatic time.

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:28

You haven't read my posts properly have you.

Because your answer to 2 I predicted Hmm

  1. It's irrelevant is a poor answer! Anyway you confirmed you were thinking of a context where sex acts are on the menu and so I said you didn't need to answer.

Thank you for confirming that male aid workers sent to humanitarian emergencies ARE helping by offering to pay the victims of the emergency for sex.

At least that's an honest answer.

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:23

How do you know that most prostitutes 'don't do anal'?

Do you mean globally or what?

There are plenty of male prostitutes by the way. Do they take that line?

Interested to hear the basis for your statement.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 20/07/2021 23:22

1. It's irrelevant. But just by the way, plenty of prostitutes don't do anal, which is what I'd have to do as a man.

Why is it irrelevant?

Would you give 'happy endings' as a masseuse? No need for penetration there.

If not, why not?

And being straight isn't a viable reason because the women giving 'happy endings' aren't exactly getting their rocks off either so would be as aroused as you would be by a client's penis ie not very.

LimeRedBanana · 20/07/2021 23:17
Grin

It’s only ‘irrelevant’ because it’s you being asked the questions. We see you.

Megasausagehead · 20/07/2021 23:14

@maddy68

A friend if mine has erectile dysfunction. He "uses" sex workers to learn how to perform again.

Another friend of mine is a sec worker. She absolutely loves her job. (She was previously a doctor ). Genuinely she has a spring in het step that had been missing for a long time
Not for anyone to judge

RTFT nobody is judging the women.

Upstream sounds just like Stamford hill

UpstreamSwimmer · 20/07/2021 23:14
  1. It's irrelevant. But just by the way, plenty of prostitutes don't do anal, which is what I'd have to do as a man.
  1. 'Generosity' is irrelevant. Is someone being 'generous' when they buy an apple from a greengrocer, or are they simply engaging in a mutually beneficial exchange? The key question is whether it's consensual.
  1. Age of consent can and should be different for different activities. A 14 year old can legally consent to doing a paper run, but the can't consent to joining the army.
maddy68 · 20/07/2021 23:11

A friend if mine has erectile dysfunction. He "uses" sex workers to learn how to perform again.

Another friend of mine is a sec worker. She absolutely loves her job. (She was previously a doctor ). Genuinely she has a spring in het step that had been missing for a long time
Not for anyone to judge

youvegottenminuteslynn · 20/07/2021 23:06

@Megasausagehead

My friend is a professional mobile masseuse.

She doesn't answer adds asking about her "services " for exactly this reason.

The hours I have spent sitting in her car outside customers houses, having taken her table in. Just to make sure she is safe.

Filthy, dirty men, still try it on! Yuck.

Ugh this is so depressing isn't it? Your poor friend.
NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:05

In countries where it is legal for children to work at various ages under 18. Whether full time, Saturday job. As a child model or actor. That makes it legitimate for them to sell sexual 'services' as work is work? And this work does not afaik have much in the way of health and safety laws or qualifications anywhere afaik so it's not the same as quarrying or flying s plane etc. And I mean some would argue (not me obv) that it's a great job for anyone under 18 as there's lots of demand, and it's not as horrible as some jobs. In countries where it's that or hunt through a rubbish tip for things to sell. Then being paid well to perform a service no different to a massage would be a really lucky break surely.

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:04

So upthread.

Would you asking assuming you're a man, get money by having sex with men who could hurt you, if you needed the money for something a loved one needs?

Do you see the aid workers in Haiti who 'partied' with local women during a humanitarian disaster, as generously giving them money for food or other things their loved ones need

Megasausagehead · 20/07/2021 23:03

My friend is a professional mobile masseuse.

She doesn't answer adds asking about her "services " for exactly this reason.

The hours I have spent sitting in her car outside customers houses, having taken her table in. Just to make sure she is safe.

Filthy, dirty men, still try it on! Yuck.

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:03

The second one you have... Well you have decided it's in s context where sex acts are generally on the menu so you don't need to answer that.

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:02

So in short.

Would you asking assuming you're a man, get money by having sex with men who could hurt you, if you needed the money for something a loved one needs?

Why do you think it's reasonable to ask a female professional masseuse for a hand job.
Do you think it's reasonable for the man being massaged to be asked if he will let/ how much for her male friend on the desk come in and fuck him?

Do you see the aid workers in Haiti who 'partied' with local women during a humanitarian disaster, as generously giving them money for food or

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 23:01

Glad to see you back by the way. I had some questions that you haven't responded to...

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 22:59

'A man can pay a woman to massage him and this is considered consensual. Even though she is only touching him because she is getting paid (and probably needs the money), that is still considered consensual.

He can gain access to her body (hands) and that's ok. It's even consensual if he derives sexual pleasure from being massaged, as long as it's only a professional massage. But the moment she gives him a 'happy ending' for extra money she is somehow being sexually abused and that consent can't be bought?'

Your post says nothing about this being in a massage parlour or venue where sex i acts are on the menu as it were.

When I read professional massage I think of well. A person who earns their living from massage in the context that phrase would mean to most.

A spa in a beauty salon, hotel, spa hotel etc.
A sports massage.
In therapeutic contexts. Physio for example.

What in your words have I missed, that would have made me understand this is in a context where sex acts are to be expected/ not unusual?

UpstreamSwimmer · 20/07/2021 22:44

The way I understand it, the anti-prostitution brigade has basically 3 arguments:

  1. It's an industry that has a good chance of a service provider doing so under coercion, so how can one allow themselves to use this service?
  2. Even if they are not being coerced, consent obtained for money isn't consent. Especially of the provider is desperate for money.
  3. One can't consent to providing a service which might harm them, so by definition prostitution is non-consensual.

As far as I can tell, these are the only actual arguments. If I've missed any, please elaborate.

To the above I counter:

  1. Nail bars (among others) are also an industry with a high chance of service providers doing so under coercion, yet women, even feminists, still frequent them.
  1. All work, be it prestigious or degrading, easy or hard, safe or risky is done in return for money. And as long as the service provider is doing so out of their free will, we consider it consensual. Even when the provider is desperate for money.
  1. We do allow people to venture into services that carry high risks of harm. One such example is the army. Another is professional sports.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 20/07/2021 22:37

@youvegottenminuteslynn

Why would you be so against your daughter offering that to men 'of her own volition, in hope of getting a tip' then OP? If she was a masseuse, genuinely happy to do it and didn't care what society thinks? After all, you don't think it's inherently wrong or that different to other jobs and a massage parlour is somewhere you would presumably seem less dangerous than offering sexual services at private residences? What would be your issue with your own daughter doing it then?
This was to @UpstreamSwimmer in response to their latest post.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 20/07/2021 22:36

Why would you be so against your daughter offering that to men 'of her own volition, in hope of getting a tip' then OP? If she was a masseuse, genuinely happy to do it and didn't care what society thinks? After all, you don't think it's inherently wrong or that different to other jobs and a massage parlour is somewhere you would presumably seem less dangerous than offering sexual services at private residences? What would be your issue with your own daughter doing it then?

LimeRedBanana · 20/07/2021 22:36

Your argument just doesn't hold water.

Oh sweet Lord. Did you actually just post that, at the end of that post, with a straight face?

UpstreamSwimmer · 20/07/2021 22:31

@NiceGerbil

' He can gain access to her body (hands) and that's ok. It's even consensual if he derives sexual pleasure from being massaged, as long as it's only a professional massage.'

I've seen lots of things including on here with women saying they hate the men who come for a massage, get a hard on and then rather than embarrassment are keen for it to be noticed. The ones who try to turn it into a sexual situation.

Women giving massages are generally alone with their client.

They can experience fear for obvious reasons.

Or annoyance, revulsion. If it happens a fair bit I'd imagine it could impact view of men in general.

In a situation where a man has paid for a professional massage, why the fuck would he even be looking for a happy ending? It's not on the menu. She is s trained masseuse. Why would it occur to a man to think right in having a massage. Oh I've got a hard on. Hmm. I'll see if she's amenable to wanking me off.

Your example makes men look even worse. You didn't think that through did you. Your idea that chancing your luck with a woman because you're horny. Prioritises the males 'right' to try it on. And ignores the very possible outcome of the woman being fucked off, horrified, scared etc.

Try again.

There are many massage parlours where you can choose to get a simple massage, even excellent ones, and at the end there's an option of a happy ending tacked on. Usually the masseuse/masseur will offer it of their own volition, in hope of getting a tip. We're not talking about medical massages where there is never an option of happy endings.

In the example of the aforementioned massage parlours, someone may choose to get a nice massage and even as a side bonus derive sexual pleasure from being touched by a pretty woman, yet that is considered consensual. Yet the last 'happy' minute tacked on willingly for a price is somehow rape?

Your argument just doesn't hold water.

Megasausagehead · 20/07/2021 22:04

@NiceGerbil

If you ask if THEY would sell sex to men. I've never seen the answer yes.
THEY don't have to sink so low don't you know.

Absolutely have no idea of the desperation of trauma/poverty.

NiceGerbil · 20/07/2021 22:01

If you ask if THEY would sell sex to men. I've never seen the answer yes.