Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for DD to be excused from this?

167 replies

TravellingSpoon · 18/07/2021 12:44

DD is in secondary school and this week they will be dissecting chicken wings, not a demonstration, each child is supposed to have their own and will do it as a whole class task.

DD is a vegetarian (her choice) and is really not happy about doing it and has asked that I ask for her to be excused from it, but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

AIBU to ask for DD to be excused from the lesson?

OP posts:
GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 14:04

I actually agree she should observe, just not be forced to physically take part.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 14:03

Does she intend to avoid learning about animal biology altogether?

They will very likely have learnt about the structure of the wing in a previous lesson. I think my sons year was a heart dissection, they learnt the theory in the lesson before the dissection. He didn’t do the dissection and still got a 9 in GCSE Biology so clearly knew all he had to. He’s now doing A level Biology and didn’t do the dissection again, not sure what it was.

EndoplasmicReticulum · 18/07/2021 14:03

I always gave the option to opt out of dissections - better that than someone passing out or throwing up, I reckon.

Trouble is, if she doesn't want to be in the room where can the teacher put her that isn't isolation?

BeenThruMoreThanALilBit · 18/07/2021 14:02

They’re not dissecting in order to eat. They’re dissecting to learn about anatomy. It’s a vital skill on the path to creating veterinary students, an improving outcomes in animal welfare.

Dig deeper with your DD. Ask her why she vegetarian, really probe her. Then ask her why she doesn’t want to dissect a chicken wing. It’s one thing being squeamish, another using her vegetarianism as an excuse.

I’d be interested to know, actually, how many vets are vegetarian.

Babynames2 · 18/07/2021 14:02

YANBU OP, she wouldn’t be put in isolation at the school I work at, just in another classroom/with the head of year with independent work to do. Just the same as the students whose parents refuse to let them do sex ed lessons

donquixotedelamancha · 18/07/2021 14:01

Definitely ask that she be excluded, she won't be the only one.

In all the times I've done this prac I can only ever recall one child not wanting to. I doubt there will be many who opt out.

In my experience kids learn squeemishness. If adults don't make a fuss and deal with things in a factual way, they tend to manage their anxieties very effectively.

Stompythedinosaur · 18/07/2021 13:59

If she has a moral objection about the use of animal parts she should be excused. If she just thinks it is icky she should suck it up. But I can't see the issue with her being in isolation if excused - you have to be willing to stand by your morals if they are important to you (I say this as a veggie you have to fight to be excused animal dissection and cooking meat dishes as a teen).

Clarabellawilliamson · 18/07/2021 13:59

What year is she in? We would never force a student to do a dissection if they didn't want to, and it's always handy to have some notice so you can provide some work for them to do! If she can stay in the room and not take part then that is easier to organise than finding someone to supervise her (which is where 'isolation' might come in if that was the only available system?)
If she is A level and it is the required dissection practical for OCR then there is a celery option but it requires specific stains for the microscopy, so give plenty of notice!

donquixotedelamancha · 18/07/2021 13:58

I don't quite understand what you learn from it if you're never going to do it outside of school.

Anatomy of a human arm. Observation and sketching skills. Safety. The ability to do something outisde your normal comfort zone requiring concentration and fine motor skills. Hopefully a bit of passion for biology.

My answer with stuff like this is that my kids need to speak to the teacher themselves. If she's old enough to do this prac she's old enough to discuss it with the teacher.

Bimblybomeyelash · 18/07/2021 13:58

If your daughter doesn’t want to join in that is fair enough, but she has to go and do the work she is given in the place that the teacher sends her! Isolation won’t be a punishment, it’s just supervision.

Marmaladee · 18/07/2021 13:58

It might sound dramatic to you but I would actually feel it was as gross as cutting up a dead person for me.

Marmaladee · 18/07/2021 13:57

You don't need to cut up dead stuff to learn it FFS!

Haffdonga · 18/07/2021 13:56

You should ask for her to be excused from cutting up the chicken wing herself but not from the whole lesson. That's ridiculous. Does she intend to avoid learning about animal biology altogether?

Buying meat sand so supporting the meat trade and handling meat herself are completely different issues from reading about it, looking at it, learning about wing structure, muscles, feathers, whatever.

Marmaladee · 18/07/2021 13:54

I'm sure there will be plenty of others who won't want to do that! Definitely ask that she be excluded, she won't be the only one. Poor chickens

godmum56 · 18/07/2021 13:52

Yes absolutely right that she should be able to choose but if the knowledge is part of the syllabus then she well have to learn it somehow.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 13:51

Just because she chooses not to eat mean, doesn't mean that she needs to pretend that animals don't exist.

Er..... what????

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 13:46

What does she want to do once she is adult and working?

She can pass the exam without doing the dissection. It's less immediately informative, relying on pictures, video etc. So if she could observe that would be better for her understanding. But yes, she can sit it out. Schools always have alternative sessions ready for this.

As long as she is making an informed decision, being veggie/vegan does restrict job and leisure options, obviously. She can choose how to deal with this and any future similar situations.

warmfluffytowels · 18/07/2021 13:44

We were allowed to opt out of this fifteen years ago - it's a perfectly reasonable request imo.

anothermansmother · 18/07/2021 13:43

I teach science and always ask students if they want to opt out, or go out. Ive had a few vegan students this year done have opted to do it after initially saying they would watch or go into another classroom, the same applied to all dissection practicals.

Chloemol · 18/07/2021 13:38

I take it she doesn’t want to be a vet? Or a doctor? They would cut animals/people up

Depends what they are supposed to get from the lesson

If she has to sit in isolation for that lesson then so be it, it’s the consequences she has chosen, she can do homework or whatever

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 13:38

I wouldn’t ask, just tell the school she won’t be doing it.

WorraLiberty · 18/07/2021 13:37

Unless you've forgotten to tell us it's going to make her vomit her guts up, I see no reason why she shouldn't participate or at least observe.

GreenTeaBlackCoffeeAndRedWine · 18/07/2021 13:33

I don't quite understand what you learn from it if you're never going to do it outside of school.

It's something you have to be comfortable with IMO so she should be excused.

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 13:33

Yes, I would. I'm not vegetarian and I couldn't bear to have to dissect a fecking chicken wing! 🤮
Frogs, fine. Chickens repulse me.

a8mint · 18/07/2021 13:32

Even in the 1980s you could opt out