Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for DD to be excused from this?

167 replies

TravellingSpoon · 18/07/2021 12:44

DD is in secondary school and this week they will be dissecting chicken wings, not a demonstration, each child is supposed to have their own and will do it as a whole class task.

DD is a vegetarian (her choice) and is really not happy about doing it and has asked that I ask for her to be excused from it, but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

AIBU to ask for DD to be excused from the lesson?

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 18/07/2021 15:13

Dd is vegetarian and her class cut up a heart last term.All the dc were given the opportunity to opt out but she didn’t - as she said she wasn’t planning on eating it!
If your child doesn’t want to do it for whatever reason then they shouldn’t have to

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 18/07/2021 15:12

@drpet49

*I'm a veggie and I would encourage her to be in the room for it, even if she doesn't want to touch the meat. Not approving of something shouldn't stop you learning about it and there is so much learning from that.*

^This. I take it children can pick and choose what school activities they can take part in on moral grounds?

If they have strong ethical objections why on earth shouldn't they be able to abstain from some activities? Are children not allowed to have principles?
user1473276264 · 18/07/2021 15:09

i'm a vegetarian and chose to be excused from dissecting a cow's heart in school. i'm also now a medical student, as dissecting a human body feels very different (totally consensual as these people had donated their bodies by choice). so if she doesn't want to, I think she shouldn't have to!

1starwars2 · 18/07/2021 15:08

DS is vegetarian but I suspect he would chose to do it, rather than sit out. His logic being he wouldn't be saving any chickens lives by opting out.
I was a vegetarian and was allowed to opt out of this, 30 years ago for ethical reasons. I suspect her teacher will understand. I would email her science teacher now so they know in advance.

BewareOfTheAgapanthus · 18/07/2021 15:02

I can’t tell from your post whether she really wants to opt out or if so why.
If she thinks it’s evil to cut up chickens, but is afraid of isolation for an hour or so, then encourage her to opt out. If it’s just a yuck thing, then encourage her to take part.

Nightlystroll · 18/07/2021 15:01

I didn't take biology o level because I knew I'd have to cut something up. I had to do a non exam course and had to cut up a cows eye. I said I didn't want to. I was asked to sit at the back of the classroom while everyone else got on. If they'd said go to isolation, I'd have gone because it was the principle. If your daughter has a principle, she sbould be prepared to go to isolation. I never asked my mum for a note. I know you want to protect her but can't she fight her own battles? School is a good place to start finding your own feet.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 15:00

You could (and some parents do) say that about every single bit of every subject. No school trip or practical activity is 'necessary', they are about teaching kids a range of skill and building resilience and independence.

That’s up to the parents and kids to decide. If a school trip made my child uncomfortable, I wouldn’t send them. The only thing my kids have wanted to opt out of is dissection or cooking and preparing meat, both very resilient and independent, they just don’t want to cut up animals. Having principles and realising your parents will support your well thought out decisions can be just as beneficial to children as resilience and independence. My children seem to be coping with the world just fine, in fact better than most in the current climate.

drpet49 · 18/07/2021 14:55

I'm a veggie and I would encourage her to be in the room for it, even if she doesn't want to touch the meat. Not approving of something shouldn't stop you learning about it and there is so much learning from that.

^This. I take it children can pick and choose what school activities they can take part in on moral grounds?

QueenBee52 · 18/07/2021 14:53

@AlexaShutUp

anywhere that serves sells supplies meats ... perhaps ?

Being vegan/vegetarian doesn't stop you from working in those places, though. You might choose not to work in them, but your choice is no more restricted than anyone else's.

DD has grown up vegetarian and increasingly chooses vegan options for herself, but she handles meat at work. As long as she doesn't have to eat it, she doesn't really care if other people do and she doesn't mind cooking it for them. She can't afford to be squeamish tbh as she is aspiring to a career in medicine.

Unlike her mother who threw up in school when forced to dissect a sheep's eye.

I agree... 🌸

TakeYourFinalPosition · 18/07/2021 14:53

@CloseYourEyesAndSee I imagine it depends what type of career you want.

But I didn’t mean it as a criticism, it was a genuine question for OP - it probably won’t be a one off dissection, so there’s probably better things that can be arranged for her DD if she doesn’t want to do any of them. It was a whole module while I was at school, and a lot of the lessons between dissections were photos/videos of the dissections and lessons around them - you’d hope if she won’t be doing that, the school and OP could have a better plan than spending time in the library or whatever.

I was trying to be helpful, not critical, it may well be best for OPs DD not to do them.

daisypond · 18/07/2021 14:52

I don’t think this is an appropriate activity and I’m quite surprised that schools would do this. I would support my child to object.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 18/07/2021 14:51

And by the way that's why I'm not a doctor but a lowly paid scientist instead!

MotherOfCrocodiles · 18/07/2021 14:51

Actually perfectly reasonable to skip it if squeamish. I Faint if I have to watch stuff like that and indeed have fainted in a similar class. People think I'm exaggerating til they see it happen. It's no joke!

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 14:49

In quite obvious ways. From restaurant choices to professions. It's not rocket science. As long as DD is informed and is making a choice based on full information then, like everyone else, she will be able to navigate them all.

Not obvious to me, I'm afraid. What professions would not be open to vegans/vegetarians if they chose them?

ahoyshipmates · 18/07/2021 14:49

@godmum56

Yes absolutely right that she should be able to choose but if the knowledge is part of the syllabus then she well have to learn it somehow.
Yes, how about from a diagram in a book? That's what we used to do.

You don't have to dissect something to learn how its skeleton is put together. There are so many resources available now that she doesn't need to participate if she doesn't want to.

Notwavingbutdrowing3 · 18/07/2021 14:49

If your DD has an ethical concern about dissecting an animal for biology at school, of course you can ask for her to be excused stating that reason.
As long as she isn't planning to enter the medical or a related profession that may require these skills in biology, it shouldn't harm her.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 18/07/2021 14:48

@TakeYourFinalPosition

Will you ask for her to excused from every dissection?

We did a chicken wing, an eyeball, a fish, lamb lungs, a pig foetus and something else… or that’s all the ones I can remember! I hated doing most of them; have never liked the feel of meat, I hate eyes and fish make me feel sick, but I learned loads from them.

I've lived an entire 40 years without needing any kind of knowledge that can be gleaned from cutting up dead things. It's not life altering knowledge.
CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 14:47

@AlexaShutUp

As long as she is making an informed decision, being veggie/vegan does restrict job and leisure options, obviously.

How so?

In quite obvious ways. From restaurant choices to professions. It's not rocket science. As long as DD is informed and is making a choice based on full information then, like everyone else, she will be able to navigate them all.
GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 14:47

preserved rats are bright yellow.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 14:47

Do you think vegetarian med students are excused practical anatomy sessions?

What a silly comment. I think people who object to it, don’t do medicine. 🤷🏻‍♀️ She’s doing her GCSEs, not a degree in medicine.

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 14:46

anywhere that serves sells supplies meats ... perhaps ?

Being vegan/vegetarian doesn't stop you from working in those places, though. You might choose not to work in them, but your choice is no more restricted than anyone else's.

DD has grown up vegetarian and increasingly chooses vegan options for herself, but she handles meat at work. As long as she doesn't have to eat it, she doesn't really care if other people do and she doesn't mind cooking it for them. She can't afford to be squeamish tbh as she is aspiring to a career in medicine.

Unlike her mother who threw up in school when forced to dissect a sheep's eye.

Battleofwhocouldcareless · 18/07/2021 14:46

I did a biology degree and never needed to take part in dissection. I was vegetarian and chose my course based on Universities and modules I could
opt for where animal testing/dissection etc weren't carried out. I would be very surprised if there was a problem with her abstaining at school.

MikeWozniaksGloriousTache · 18/07/2021 14:46

We had to dissect a rat in biology once. A friend sat out of the practical exercise, but completed written work that complimented that is using technical diagrams. Funnily enough she is a biology lecturer now so it’s not impacted her job or career choices. It was certainly a learning experience for me, I learned that preserved rats are bright yellow, fucking stink and after 10 minutes of trying to cut into one I will faint and need to go to hospital after splitting my head open. Could have learned what I needed to without being subjected to it tbh.

donquixotedelamancha · 18/07/2021 14:45

I just find that so unnecessary. At GCSE level the amount of detail about this is very little. It can definitely be learnt from a book.

You could (and some parents do) say that about every single bit of every subject. No school trip or practical activity is 'necessary', they are about teaching kids a range of skill and building resilience and independence.

Time for her to be a bit less precious and a bit more brave and amazing. Please don't be "that" parent

I've reported that post for deletion as it's not in the spirit of the site :-)

TakeYourFinalPosition · 18/07/2021 14:45

Will you ask for her to excused from every dissection?

We did a chicken wing, an eyeball, a fish, lamb lungs, a pig foetus and something else… or that’s all the ones I can remember! I hated doing most of them; have never liked the feel of meat, I hate eyes and fish make me feel sick, but I learned loads from them.