Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for DD to be excused from this?

167 replies

TravellingSpoon · 18/07/2021 12:44

DD is in secondary school and this week they will be dissecting chicken wings, not a demonstration, each child is supposed to have their own and will do it as a whole class task.

DD is a vegetarian (her choice) and is really not happy about doing it and has asked that I ask for her to be excused from it, but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

AIBU to ask for DD to be excused from the lesson?

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 18/07/2021 15:53

It doesn't teach resilience, it teaches cruelty

I don't think anyone is dissecting the chickens alive.

Absolutely, but it's easier to address at 11-12 than in adulthood. I am a squeamish about loads because I was coddled as a child, which is why I don't want to do the same to my kids.

toastantea · 18/07/2021 15:52

@NeverMetANiceOne

Just because she chooses not to eat mean, doesn't mean that she needs to pretend that animals don't exist.

Can you come back and try to make some sense?

toastantea · 18/07/2021 15:51

Not a chance my DD would sit in on something like this. She can learn enough anatomy without seeing a chicken being dissected. It would literally traumatise her.

I'm a bit confused by what you mean when you say she will be made to sit in isolation though? She has to go somewhere 🤷🏻‍♀️

Hoppinggreen · 18/07/2021 15:48

@MotionActivatedDog

but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

Hmm

I think the chicken would rather have sat in isolation
onceivepostedidontcomeback · 18/07/2021 15:46

@donquixotedelamancha

Definitely ask that she be excluded, she won't be the only one.

In all the times I've done this prac I can only ever recall one child not wanting to. I doubt there will be many who opt out.

In my experience kids learn squeemishness. If adults don't make a fuss and deal with things in a factual way, they tend to manage their anxieties very effectively.

Yes, being squeamish is learned behaviour but that doesn't mean it can easily be unlearned. I've got to age 50 being squeamish and I've had cbt, hypnotherapy - lots of things and you know what, I'm still squeamish and have never ever had to dissect an animal in my lifetime!
PattyPan · 18/07/2021 15:46

@user1473276264

i'm a vegetarian and chose to be excused from dissecting a cow's heart in school. i'm also now a medical student, as dissecting a human body feels very different (totally consensual as these people had donated their bodies by choice). so if she doesn't want to, I think she shouldn't have to!
Yes, this! It’s not like anatomy professors have cadavers killed specially for dissection by med students. It’s not comparable at all.
ihtwsf · 18/07/2021 15:41

Just asked for her to be excused. Plenty of people will have been excused before.
I can remember doing it back in 1990 (!). A couple of people were excused as they were vegetarians and didn't want to do it. 3 or 4 people felt squeamish, one fainted. They were all sent out to the school library. They were sent off to learn the parts of the eye from a book and had a worksheet to fill in.

Frootloops4life · 18/07/2021 15:38

Just because she chooses not to eat mean, doesn't mean that she needs to pretend that animals don't exist.

Do you think you said a clever thing? Or something that even made a tiny bit of sense?

Branleuse · 18/07/2021 15:38

i refused dissection lessons in biology at school back in the 90s. They cant force her

Frootloops4life · 18/07/2021 15:37

I opted out nearly 25 years ago. I had no interest in becoming an animal surgeon and 99 percent of kids doing it don't either.

I was a vegetarian and felt strongly I wasn't going to support something that kills animals pointlessly so teenagers can poke them with sticks and giggle . I wasn't squeamish and would happily poke any old dead thing I found dead of natural causes at the beach. I don't believe for a second there is any genuine benefit to the average teenager from cutting up stuff that couldn't be gleaned from a book.

It doesn't teach resilience, it teaches cruelty and teaches kids animals are there for our use, which I don't agree with. We know that dangerous people abuse animals as children, why encourage behavior that isn't beneficial to society.

JM10 · 18/07/2021 15:30

I opted out of frog dissection when I was at secondary school. I'm not sure I even told my mum, I just told the teacher I didn't want to do it or observe it. He did just send me out to walk around school for the whole lesson, which probably isn't what he was supposed to do 😁

I don't believe it is necessary to cut up dead things to learn about them and my objection is less to seeing/touching the dead thing and more about the fact that that animal was killed so that lesson could take place.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 15:28

@AlexaShutUp

The restrictions would ALL be based on DDs choices, preferences.

OK, but that's true for all of us, whether we are veggie or not. Lots of meat eaters would choose not to work in an abbatoir for example. Our dietary choices restrict what we eat - nothing more.

OK. You win!

I'm not explaining the obvious again.

MotionActivatedDog · 18/07/2021 15:28

but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

Hmm
roguetomato · 18/07/2021 15:26

It's part of biology, isn't it? Is it ok for her not to learn it? We would be living in a horrible world if there was no progress of science.
But I think if she doesn't want to participate, she should speak to the teacher.

BarleyMop · 18/07/2021 15:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Polkadots2021 · 18/07/2021 15:23

@TravellingSpoon

DD is in secondary school and this week they will be dissecting chicken wings, not a demonstration, each child is supposed to have their own and will do it as a whole class task.

DD is a vegetarian (her choice) and is really not happy about doing it and has asked that I ask for her to be excused from it, but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

AIBU to ask for DD to be excused from the lesson?

I'd personally take a stand and empower your daughter to do the same. She has proud strong values and good on her, that's an impressive thing. She should go to the teacher and express her unwillingness to participate and see what happens, maybe offer to do whatever alternative assignment they might want to give.

In the ensuing discussion the biology teacher might change her mind or she might successfully end up taking an alternative assignment, or learns the fact that oftentimes standing up for your beliefs can be uncomfortable and not always successful - but it's always worth trying.

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 15:23

The restrictions would ALL be based on DDs choices, preferences.

OK, but that's true for all of us, whether we are veggie or not. Lots of meat eaters would choose not to work in an abbatoir for example. Our dietary choices restrict what we eat - nothing more.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 15:21

My secondary school didn’t even do dissection, how on earth have I got through life without that lesson in ‘resilience’. 🙄

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 15:20

@SupermanWithTheGreyHair

The usual wind up trolls have found the thread. Best ignored.
Yup!
GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 15:17

So? You could say the same about the burgers in the school canteen.
What does that mean? Veggies just don't eat the burgers, they don't insist on eating in a different, burger free environment.

Watching someone else eat a burger is just life 🤷🏻‍♀️

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 15:17

@AlexaShutUp

In quite obvious ways. From restaurant choices to professions. It's not rocket science. As long as DD is informed and is making a choice based on full information then, like everyone else, she will be able to navigate them all.

Not obvious to me, I'm afraid. What professions would not be open to vegans/vegetarians if they chose them?

You seem to be choosing to misunderstand me.

The restrictions would ALL be based on DDs choices, preferences. Not that any would be closed to her because of them.

But I have noticed MN veggies/vegans do that a lot. Unlike those out here in real life.

When I was veggie - 30 years until it transpired I would be healthier eating some meat, I have about 12 syllables worth of anemia and being vegetarian exacerbated it. I chose to work as a cook. I cooked meat. DSis chose not to and so didn't want to join me.

That's what I mean by working from a base if knowledge - work out what you will and won't do based on your choices.

Was that simple enough?

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 15:17

The usual wind up trolls have found the thread. Best ignored.

IAmAWomanNotACis · 18/07/2021 15:16

I was a vegetarian when heart dissections were being done in class at school. We vegetarians weren't made to do any dissecting but we were expected to be mature and to take a look at the dissected hearts, which I didn't have a problem with and found quite interesting. I'd expect the school to have a procedure in place for what they ask vegetarians to do in that class, it's a very common scenario.

From a resilience point of view she's going to come across meat, butchers, dead animals on the road and so on. I think it's good for resilience to be able to at least look at a dissection, and nothing else is quite equivalent in terms of learning. I went on to do an animal biology degree and dissected various body parts of various animals. Its gross, you feel yuck about doing it, but it is worth doing IMO.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 18/07/2021 15:15

@GreyhoundG1rl

Are children not allowed to have principles? The wings are there, available, whether the pupils take part or just watch. They're not being slaughtered to order.
So? You could say the same about the burgers in the school canteen.
GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 15:14

Are children not allowed to have principles?
The wings are there, available, whether the pupils take part or just watch. They're not being slaughtered to order.