Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for DD to be excused from this?

167 replies

TravellingSpoon · 18/07/2021 12:44

DD is in secondary school and this week they will be dissecting chicken wings, not a demonstration, each child is supposed to have their own and will do it as a whole class task.

DD is a vegetarian (her choice) and is really not happy about doing it and has asked that I ask for her to be excused from it, but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

AIBU to ask for DD to be excused from the lesson?

OP posts:
AlmostSummer21 · 18/07/2021 16:56

@Laserbird16

Why not discuss it with her teacher.

I don't want to isn't a reason I could support as this an educational activity but surely there is an acceptable alternative. Why can't she observe? Could she draw and label a diagram. I'm sure the teacher would be happy to discuss

You're minimising her beliefs.

Are you always so dismissive?

thedarkling · 18/07/2021 16:53

She's not going to eat it, so I don't know why it makes a difference that she's a vegetarian. However I managed to do my science GCSEs and two science A levels without ever dissecting anything as far as I remember, it's a bit unnecessary and I don't think she'll be the only one who doesn't want to do it.

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 16:53

@DelphiniumBlue

Why are you asking for her? She's the one in school. Actually she should say she's not doing it, rather than asking for permission. If she asked for permission they would have the option to say no. She has strong principles and now is the time for her to practice standing up for them. No need for you to get involved at all.
Strong principles, or a strong sense of drama? She wants to avoid the possibility of sitting in isolation as it would be "a fate worse than death", rather than defend her principles at all costs Grin I'm inclined to agree with Lucking's summing up.
DelphiniumBlue · 18/07/2021 16:48

Why are you asking for her? She's the one in school.
Actually she should say she's not doing it, rather than asking for permission. If she asked for permission they would have the option to say no.
She has strong principles and now is the time for her to practice standing up for them. No need for you to get involved at all.

Luckingfovely · 18/07/2021 16:47

I think the child perhaps has greater issues to address then being vegetarian, if sitting out of one lesson is a fate worse than death. And also worse than sitting in the class observing something new and interesting.

I'm very much on the side of not mollycoddling kids or pretending that real life doesn't exist or matter. Or that their own, immature, developing thoughts and fads make them more important than and different to everyone else, and deserving of special attention.

Had we not gone so far down this path our culture would be in a much better place and the whole woke nightmare would not be as prevalent.

memberofthewedding · 18/07/2021 16:44

I would go with the posters who say let her be in the room and observe rather than sit in isolation. The are too many kids who think meat comes from "the supermarket" and do not appreciate about animal produce. He rviews as a vegetarian should be respected. At the same time its important that she develop a realistic appreciation of where animal products some from and what the food chain involves.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 16:42

@PattyPan

Pernicious anemia is actually a great reason to give up eating animal products IMO, B12 is the only nutrient you can’t get from vegan food so if you can’t absorb it from food anyway there’s no need for meat.
Sadly it's the mix that made that impossible for me. So I am now a low meat eater and felt the benefits in days. And that's after relying on B12 injections and now the tablet 'overdose'.

I didn't do it in a whim. I was more than happy being vegetarian from aged 8 to mid 40s and had no thoughts of not continuing to be. But when a consultant gives you the relevant literature to read and his best advice you'd be daft to ignore it based on anyone else's opinion based on their personal preferences.

BiBabbles · 18/07/2021 16:35

I'd support my child in asking their teacher to opt out. If I needed to send in a letter or email saying I supported that, okay, but I wouldn't be making the first request (I would help them write an email to the teacher if they wanted my help).

I'd also support the school if they said my child had to observe or otherwise stay in the classroom or sit in isolation (which I've not heard of schools doing) or whatever the policy was for it whether or not my child liked that. Principled actions in life often have unpleasant consequences, and she won't know what the choice is until she asks.

The first high school I went to tried to sell our dissecting flowers as a way to include vegetarian and vegan students, not sure how truthful that was though or if other schools do that.

donquixotedelamancha · 18/07/2021 16:33

So anyone who doesn't eat a live chicken isn't supporting animal cruelty? Watching abusive pornography isn't supporting an abusive industry because it's not happening as you watch it?

They're not just collecting dead chickens who died from old age

You quoted me above this reply, frootloop, but perhaps you meant it to someone else?

If not, I'm not really sure of your point. The chickens (prior to) being dissected are no more, they have ceased to be, bereft of life, they rest in peace- they are ex-chickens. They feel no pain.

PattyPan · 18/07/2021 16:32

Pernicious anemia is actually a great reason to give up eating animal products IMO, B12 is the only nutrient you can’t get from vegan food so if you can’t absorb it from food anyway there’s no need for meat.

toocold54 · 18/07/2021 16:30

YANBU I am a science teacher and often dissect hearts, lungs, kidneys etc and I always have a couple that don’t want to take part even if they’re not vegetarian as it makes them feel sick - which is no problem and I’m happy for them to be excused.
Tell her not to feel embarrassed or anything as there will be other things that her classmates opt out of too one day.

PattyPan · 18/07/2021 16:30

I have a friend who is a research scientist in immunology, not sure if that counts as a life science. Being vegetarian doesn’t seem to be holding him back.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 16:29

Oh, and the health issue I have isn't down to my choices or poor food management.

Should any vegetarian or vegan be diagnosed with any form of anemia they will have to make changes. Unfortunately for me megaloblastic and pernicious anaemia on top of ME meant that I was in serious danger of incurring irreversible neurological damage, premature death. Really, no hyperbole, just a medical fact.

Which is why it is essential that an informed decision is made and nobody pretends not to understand that.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 16:24

As I said. Never mind. You win.

The ethics and philosophy that often accompany vegetarianism has absolutely no impact.

The specific impacts I considered are of no interest to anyone and anyway are not specific to vegetarians.

Is that better?

Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 18/07/2021 16:22

She has every right to be excused. I refused to participate in animal
Dissection in science and I was at school a very long time ago!

Celyon · 18/07/2021 16:20

In an era of 3d printing etc, it's utterly ridiculous that animals are being slaughtered for this. I stood my ground back in year dickety doo over a luckless frog and put him out of the window before I could be stopped, and took a harsh punishment for it. My kids refused one after another but thankfully were met with more understanding..
As long as your DD has made an informed and rational choice understanding what it might affect exams wise, she has every right to say no.
If she honestly thinks being in isolation is the bigger deal here, then she doesn't feel that strongly about the morality and shouldn't pretend otherwise. Good luck.

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 16:12

If DD has no interest in any of the life sciences and would be happy to work through every day compromises, accepting the inconveniences specifc to being veggie, then she'll be fine.

But again, why does being veggie impact on pursuing a career in the life sciences? I'm not aware that you need to eat meat in order to work in these fields?

As for the health issues, if you eat a properly balanced vegetarian diet, it's perfectly possible to get the nutrients that you need. The fact that you didn't manage to get the balance right really doesn't mean that others won't.

I don't really know what other "inconveniences specific to being veggie" you are talking about. The only thing specific to being veggie is not eating meat/meat products, which many people don't find inconvenient at all, but each to their own!

ChloeCrocodile · 18/07/2021 16:09

Ask for her to be excused. But if she is GCSE age she will need to be supervised and the isolation suite may be the only realistic option for the school if she won’t even be in the classroom. She may ultimately have to choose between staying in the classroom or going to isolation, but she should have the choice.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 18/07/2021 16:07

@GreyhoundG1rl

So? You could say the same about the burgers in the school canteen. What does that mean? Veggies just don't eat the burgers, they don't insist on eating in a different, burger free environment. Watching someone else eat a burger is just life 🤷🏻‍♀️
It means that the fact that dead animals are available (to eat, dissect or anything else) doesn't mean a vegetarian should just forget their principles and partake in whatever the purpose of the dead animal is.
donquixotedelamancha · 18/07/2021 16:07

That’s up to the parents and kids to decide.

Of course. I and many, many others pointed out she can opt out.

You were saying this prac was unnecessary because it's a small part of the GCSE content. I was replying to that point about why schools should do 'unecessary' but different and interesting things.

My secondary school didn’t even do dissection, how on earth have I got through life without that lesson in ‘resilience’.

Presumably you had lots of other encouragement and challenging experiences. Sadly some kids don't and it can make them into whiney, neurotic adults.

Frootloops4life · 18/07/2021 16:05

They're not just collecting dead chickens who died from old age

Frootloops4life · 18/07/2021 16:04

@donquixotedelamancha

It doesn't teach resilience, it teaches cruelty

I don't think anyone is dissecting the chickens alive.

Absolutely, but it's easier to address at 11-12 than in adulthood. I am a squeamish about loads because I was coddled as a child, which is why I don't want to do the same to my kids.

So anyone who doesn't eat a live chicken isn't supporting animal cruelty?

Watching abusive pornography isn't supporting an abusive industry because it's not happening as you watch it?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 16:01

I'm a teacher, or was. Forgive me for knowing that many teenagers make decisions without thinking about all the possible future ramifications.

Which is why my first question, and a later explanation, was about jobs

And also why my second explanation was about long term health. I only got the medical help I needed because I was properly informed about the possible negatives of a veggie diet.

If DD has no interest in any of the life sciences and would be happy to work through every day compromises, accepting the inconveniences specifc to being veggie, then she'll be fine.

But if she hasn't thought about things like that then this would be a good time for that discussion.

SuperCaliFragalistic · 18/07/2021 15:57

I opted out of this stuff at school as I would have fainted definitely. I managed to pass my GCSEs with good grades and never went on to do any science subjects at A Level or otherwise.

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 15:54

I'm not explaining the obvious again.

Your main point seems to be that our personal preferences and values will impact on our choices. That is indeed obvious, to the point that I'm not quite sure why it needs to be said at all. My point is merely that this applies to vegetarians and non-vegetarians alike.