Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for DD to be excused from this?

167 replies

TravellingSpoon · 18/07/2021 12:44

DD is in secondary school and this week they will be dissecting chicken wings, not a demonstration, each child is supposed to have their own and will do it as a whole class task.

DD is a vegetarian (her choice) and is really not happy about doing it and has asked that I ask for her to be excused from it, but is worried that she will be made to sit in isolation for that lesson which is a fate worse than death.

AIBU to ask for DD to be excused from the lesson?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Looubylou · 19/07/2021 11:20

We did bulls eyes, and white rats. The smell was deplorable from the rats - what I had in my sandwiches for lunch that day, reminded me of the kidneys. It was 36 years ago and I've never eaten it since, or forgot the smell. Although I was OK to do it at the time, it affected me afterwards. I'm not "precious" or squeamish (nurse of 34 years experience), but I feel this is totally unnecessary experience.

IAmAWomanNotACis · 19/07/2021 11:06

It doesn't teach resilience, it teaches cruelty and teaches kids animals are there for our use, which I don't agree with.

I mean, I think the burgers (likely halal slaughtered) in the school canteen do that...

To me, being vegetarian based on principals means you don't want animals to suffer on your behalf. Fairly standard belief for vegetarians, isn't that? So you don't want the school to procure you a chicken wing for your personal dissection even though they probably buy them in packs of 24 from asda - that doesn't mean you can't watch what somebody else is doing with theirs. I understand you might find it gross, distasteful, upsetting even, but if you can sit at the same table as them in the canteen, I honestly don't see the difference. And If you can't sit at the same table in the canteen then you really DO have a resilience problem. One is being used by humans as food (which you don't agree is necessary), one is being used for education (which you also don't agree is necessary). I mean, the main difference as far as I'm concerned is the salmonella risk!

claralara42 · 19/07/2021 10:10

@Marmaladee

It might sound dramatic to you but I would actually feel it was as gross as cutting up a dead person for me.
You're right, that does sound dramatic. And ridiculous
Frootloops4life · 19/07/2021 10:01

You're missing the point. There are vegetarian medical students.

Humans give consent for their body to use and are not killed for that purpose! Nothing like the same.

There are computer programs and aids for people who choose to not use animals though.

Frootloops4life · 19/07/2021 09:58

It wasn't the typo that was the issue. I didn't even notice the typo. It just didn't make any sense.

Not wanting to participate in an activity that involves a murdered animal isn't the same as pretending they don't exist! Confused

beentoldcomputersaysno · 18/07/2021 19:02

I'd ask for her to be excused

TSSDNCOP · 18/07/2021 18:51

In my class the girls that didn't participate sat at the back making gagging noises and faux swooning, which absolutely fucked it for the rest of us that wanted to do it.

I think she'd be better off out of the class, let the others concentrate and she can concentrate on her work too.

I also think she should be the one to make the case to her teacher as an informed decision and having worked out what she can do theoretically to compensate for the practical.

LolaSmiles · 18/07/2021 18:35

I felt uncomfortable with dissections at school and requested to be excused. The teacher gave me and another student the required textbook pages and we sat in the next classroom for the duration of the dissection.

Personally I'd suggest she asks in the first instance and then you provide your support/add to the request if required. If she is excused the lesson then she will need to work somewhere there's appropriate supervision and that might be the school isolation room. I don't think she gets to be excused and then start deciding how and where school should accommodate her request

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 18/07/2021 18:02

I think we did litter picking instead

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 18/07/2021 18:01

Opt out, we could in the 80s, she should be able to excuse herself.

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 17:31

That makes sense.

NeverMetANiceOne · 18/07/2021 17:27

"Just because she chooses not to eat mean, doesn't mean that she needs to pretend that animals don't exist."

To those posters unable to understand my typo - I meant - just because the OP's child does not wish to eat meat, does not mean she cannot learn about practical anatomy at school.

Hope that's clear enough this time round Smile

diddl · 18/07/2021 17:19

If it's 2ndry school I would have thought that your daughter should be asking herself.

Is it definitely not optional?

It was for me more that 40yrs ago!

You could wait outside, be in the room peering from the sidelines, take it in turns with partner or watch whilst partner did all.

SupermanWithTheGreyHair · 18/07/2021 17:13

I don't want to isn't a reason I could support as this an educational activity but surely there is an acceptable alternative.

You won’t need to support it. Kids can opt out without parents being involved, just that some parents would speak to the school. It’s your child’s choice.

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 17:11

Are you vegetarian?
You're missing the point. There are vegetarian medical students.

AlmostSummer21 · 18/07/2021 17:06

@mynameisbrian

she isnt eating it, humans are dissected by medical students etc for education purposes, we learn through research and looking at tissue etc as it helps us explore new treatments etcs.. I dont see the issue myself
Are you vegetarian?
Derrymum123 · 18/07/2021 17:05

Daughter doing biology A level. Vegetarian. She too was excused. There are plenty of videos to show this. I would feel proud of her principles. Maybe she could read a book or complete the task by observation of the others.

Frootloops4life · 18/07/2021 17:04

@memberofthewedding

I would go with the posters who say let her be in the room and observe rather than sit in isolation. The are too many kids who think meat comes from "the supermarket" and do not appreciate about animal produce. He rviews as a vegetarian should be respected. At the same time its important that she develop a realistic appreciation of where animal products some from and what the food chain involves.
I'm assuming because she's a vegetarian she's exactly not that sort of child! So she doesn't need to be exposed to something like that. Also how the hell does one learn about the food chain from dissection??
CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 17:03

All of which my vegetarian self would have considered but my vegetarian DSis would not.

It's all about being informed of the consequences of choices made.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 18/07/2021 17:02

Tell that to any wannabe vet or surgeon. Pathologist. Orthodontist. Medical specimen dissection, a prosector. Physical therapist. Embalmer.

Many more or less esoteric careers that society has need for.

Frootloops4life · 18/07/2021 17:01

"She's not going to eat it, so I don't know why it makes a difference that she's a vegetarian"

Because she has an ethical objection to the animal being murdered for her to have a rummage. These animals don't appear magically. I don't know why people are cofused that a vegetarian wouldn't support cruelty to animals.

"You quoted me above this reply, frootloop, but perhaps you meant it to someone else?

If not, I'm not really sure of your point. The chickens (prior to) being dissected are no more, they have ceased to be, bereft of life, they rest in peace- they are ex-chickens. They feel no pain."

Well as I responded to your specific quote I think you know exactly who I was responding to. Don't be passive aggressive it's boring. You've also ignored my point. Do you understand why vegetarians don't eat meat, even though it's already dead? Hmm

AlmostSummer21 · 18/07/2021 17:00

@PersonaNonGarter

You don’t want to be the kind of person who doesn’t do this. She should be in the room at least.

It’s a bit ‘special, special’ not to take part in an actual science class.

What?

The kind of person that had morals?

Oh god that would be awful wouldn't it 🙄

Lovinghannah · 18/07/2021 16:59

@a8mint

Even in the 1980s you could opt out
Just what I was going to say.
toastantea · 18/07/2021 16:58

She's not going to eat it, so I don't know why it makes a difference that she's a vegetarian.

Really? You really don't know there is more to vegetarianism than simply not eating meat? Really?

AlmostSummer21 · 18/07/2021 16:57

@negomi90

I'm a veggie and I would encourage her to be in the room for it, even if she doesn't want to touch the meat. Not approving of something shouldn't stop you learning about it and there is so much learning from that.
There is no need to dissect animals at all.

Plenty of teaching visuals already available.

Swipe left for the next trending thread