Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of MN don’t know what having no money means

531 replies

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 09:42

And that admitting to having none is humiliating.

I see it here all the time. Someone has no money. Someone suggests something to make life easier. The person says again they have no money. MN suggest a cheaper version.

On the thread about dress up so many people were saying to tell the school.

I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 19/07/2021 08:56

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Twins point has been somewhat lost in the to & fro.

There are SOME people in the uk, a tiny minority, who are living in real, hand to mouth abject poverty. Often where its genuinely no fault of their own & typically for a relatively temporary period eg on redundancy or illness or a sanction to benefits.

but there are also some people in the uk, another tiny minority (!) who are poor at budgeting/cutting cloth, and don't always avail themselves of the help available. Pretending this category doesn't exist does the first bunch no favours.

and the reality is the vast majority of the UK either earn enough or obtain enough from benefits to manage, eg affording food/housing/utilities for their families and a few treats. Many of these people are relatively poor, in that the UK has some very wealthy people and lots of people will feel hard done by that they cannot afford the holidays, cars, treats, clothes etc afforded by the better off. But fundamentally real dire absolute poverty is statistically rare in the UK, and even more rare to be stuck in it very long term.

I can only think of a very few households who were unable to learn how to manage money when given support and coaching to do so. Two of them were couples with mild LDs, two were single people with MH issues, a couple had brain injuries and one was where one partner was an alcoholic.

Most people can learn to manage their money with a bit of help. Sadly, funding for that sort of work is rarely available.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 08:40

Your inability to understand that someone who knows the system incredibly well through both personal experience, and advising others is honestly, embarassing. All because the actual experience doesn't suit your theoretical narrative. A little education on the subject would help you here, but you don't want to listen to that.

Incredibly well, @TwinsandTrifle? Given your confusion about what the LHA is and how the benefit cap works, you wouldn't pass the test to get a job on my team of welfare rights staff. And it's not that tough - two recent hires were a solicitor looking for a career change and a housing officer, neither of whom had a background in welfare rights.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 08:25

How can someone realistically spend 35 hours a week job searching if they live in an area with no jobs

I once supported a family whose 19 year old was on JSA (this was pre-UC). His job seeking commitment required him to call at 2 prospective employers every week day to see if they had any vacancies. He lived in a village that only had a shop and a pub, and the bus fare to the nearest town was £6.50 return.

He used to stick his head round the door of the shop and the pub every day, and call out "Got any jobs going?" Grin

He did look online as well, but because of poor public transport he was really restricted as to the hours/days he could work. Even in the nearest town, he couldn't get to work before 8.30 or finish any later than 6 (5 on Saturdays), and Sunday working was completely impossible.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 08:12

[quote FreshFancyFrogglette]@Bunnyfuller save the electric from devices Grin Grin oh yeah that 30p a week is guna make all the difference!!
i regularly pawn my hp laptop, and i get £30 Grin . we are not poor because we use devices !! we are poor because of greedy landlords taking over half our wages before we even start thinking about living... if i was paying a mortage rate, rather than rent, i wouldnt be considered poor. i actually earn a really decent wage, but most if it is being rinsed to someone who gets paid to sit on the arse, and not maintain the building properly,,,[/quote]
Quite! And that greedy landlord may well be having their buy-to-let mortgage paid by UC or housing benefit, and will end up owning a valuable asset that the taxpayer has bought for them.

33feethighandrising · 19/07/2021 08:11

Rightmove currently has one 3-bed property that's not above the LHA for the Brighton Broad Rental Market Area, which extends from Shoreham to Newhaven and a good 10 miles or so inland from the coast.

And I'd bet good money it's not even available to people on benefits. Trying to find a landlord who'll accept benefits is tough.

And I don't blame the landlords. When I was looking for someone to rent my flat for a year or so (while we rented in our new town and house hunted) I didn't want to rent to anyone on benefits - despite knowing what it's like from the other side - because of most council's policy of not rehousing anyone unless they've been evicted. This means that if you give your tennant notice and they can't find another place in time, if they go to the council for help, the council will actually advise them to ignore the notice, stay on and wait until eviction papers have been served and only leave when actually evicted. This costs the owner significant time and money.

In the end, I was talked into renting my flat to a friend on benefits and when we needed the flat back to sell, so we could buy stop renting and buy a family house for ourselves, we ended up in exactly the situation I feared. My friend couldn't find a place and the council wouldn't help.

Instead of evicting my friend (which we would have to do if it came to it) I offered to help with the flat hunt. I looked every day for 4 months, alongside my friend, for a place that would accept benefits. They were like hen's teeth. We eventially found one, my friend moved in for a day, on the first night the ceiling caved in due to damp and the landlord didn't come to fix it! So he was back at mine before he'd even handed the keys over.

In the end, he moved in with another friend when a room became available, so it was luck and not the suppsed safety net that got him a new place. Meanwhile I was looking at not having a house in the town we wanted to live in, in time for school admissions. It was a nightmare.

People who don't have to go through this system have no idea how tough it is and how the cards are stacked against people and the poor are punished for being poor.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 08:08

Sorry, OP, I incorrectly attributed @TwinsandTrifle's comments to you in my previous post. (slaps self on wrist)

rishisboater · 19/07/2021 08:03

@Greenwateringcan

You know what just occurred to me literally right now

I don’t obsessively check my bank account multiple roomed a day anymore. I check it in the morning and that’s enough.

That’s a big mental stress off me. Right there. Because I have enough money now.

I can relate. I check mine multiple times a day and feel physically sick when the notification pings to say something has happened in my account. Regularly hold my breath when waiting to see if my last couple of quid has been taken
LakieLady · 19/07/2021 07:56

Many people live in areas where the benefit cap makes a huge difference, and they have to use money supposed to be for living expenses towards the rent

Yes but the rent is based on the average for that style of property in that area. The average. For their specific area.

OP, you are conflating the benefit cap and the local housing allowance (LHA).

The benefit cap is the same all over the country except for London, where it's higher. It's the same in Bassetlaw as it is in Brighton, but rents in Brighton are 2.5 times those in Bassetlaw. So if two benefit-capped families have identical circumstances other than geography, and therefore rent, the family in Brighton will be far worse off because they will have to pay a lot more towards their rent.

And the local housing allowance is not based on average rent for size of property, but on an average of the bottom 30% of private sector rents for that size of property. In years when CPI inflation is less than the rise in rents, the increase in LHA is restricted to CPI, so it isn't even an average (thank you for that one, Osborne and Cameron) So the shittiest, most run down of properties in the roughest areas are the only ones that are affordable for poor families.

Even so, in much of the SE and other high-rent areas, it is near impossible to find a private rental at or below the LHA rate. Rightmove currently has one 3-bed property that's not above the LHA for the Brighton Broad Rental Market Area, which extends from Shoreham to Newhaven and a good 10 miles or so inland from the coast. People on low incomes are forced to live a long way from the main centre of employment, so if they are in work, they have to pay significant commuting costs and cannot take jobs that involve working unsocial hours because there would be no public transport available for some shifts.

Greenwateringcan · 19/07/2021 07:47

You know what just occurred to me literally right now

I don’t obsessively check my bank account multiple roomed a day anymore. I check it in the morning and that’s enough.

That’s a big mental stress off me. Right there. Because I have enough money now.

Bananarice · 19/07/2021 07:39

I remember when lockdown hit and the libraries closed. It made me very sad. I remember when we used to be on benefits and dm used to take us to the library often, especially during the Christmas holidays. Later on she admitted, the library offers free heating and light. Not to mention free entertainment. But she sent us there mainly for the free heat and light.

I imagine people where using it for more things nowadays. Like the free Internet and activities, which includes children under 5 being offered a piece of fruit after the library official story time. At least our local library did this before lockdown.
I still take my dc to the library, because it is great 👍. So I don't know if they offer more stuff to people who need it now.

RosesAndHellebores · 19/07/2021 06:21

@ELOU1111 I've never known a nurse refuse a box of chocolates/tin of luxury biscuits and the obstetrician who looked after me when pg with dd didn't send back the half case of claret DH sent

echt · 19/07/2021 03:18

@ELOU1111

As an NHS nurse I am not allowed to accept personal gifts which I think is absolutely correct. It is time school heads took this approach and banned the giving of gifts to teachers. Many people cannot afford to be involved in this sycophantic practice.
I don't know where you get the sycophantic aspect from.Hmm

I can assure you no teacher expects a gift. If any gratitude is felt to be needed to be expressed, email the teacher thanking them.

Iquitit · 19/07/2021 02:55

@Maggiesfarm

PrettyLittleFlies: Have you read the full thread? Plenty of posts berating women for frivolities. .......... I've dipped in and out since the thread started.

Nobody should berate someone else for being poor and everyone deserves the occasional treat.

However being resentful of those who are well off is hardly helpful.

I can only speak for myself, but I'm not resentful of others who are well off, I'm sensible enough to realise that we need all levels of society for it to function. What I am resentful of is my level, my contribution, which is not financial but practical in supporting society being dismissed, and me being dismissed as lazy, entitled and uninspired because I do the job I do. It's ironic to say the least when a lot of people are benefitting from the job I do, and get so little in return for. At being the bottom of the pile, but expected to be the most socially responsible. At being sneered at, and lectured about apparently how I would have enough to live on if I didn't squander it all on booze, fags, tattoos, drugs and wide-screen TVs, by people who have no idea what it's actually like and refuse to listen when others who have that experience try to tell them.

I can deal with being paid little to do the job I do, I don't do it for the money, but that doesn't mean my life is free either, I still need to pay bills and have fuel and eat food.
I can deal with the ignorance and sneering too, God knows I'm used to it, but I absolutely will challenge it where I see it, I realise some people think, by virtue of the amount in my bank account, I don't have the right morally, because I'm not supposed to be smart enough or clued up enough to challenge my 'betters' and that by doing so I'm breaking some unspoken rule of the poor just putting up and shutting up, well I don't care about that rule and I will continue to do it.

PrettyLittleFlies · 19/07/2021 02:43

[quote Lockdownbear]@PrettyLittleFlies but is buying a teacher gift any different to tipping a waitress or taxi driver.

I don't remember doing teacher gifts as a child. But I really appreciate a good teacher.[/quote]
I used to buy them but now I wonder why I bothered. Of course they should do a great job, we all should.

Lockdownbear · 19/07/2021 02:37

Giving the gift at the end of the school year, your child is unlikely to be working with them again. So not buying favour.

Iquitit · 19/07/2021 02:35

@ELOU1111

As an NHS nurse I am not allowed to accept personal gifts which I think is absolutely correct. It is time school heads took this approach and banned the giving of gifts to teachers. Many people cannot afford to be involved in this sycophantic practice.
I hadn't even thought of this, but yes absolutely, it's regarded as a safeguarding matter for some situations in care for workers to accept gifts, I assume the same applies in healthcare.

And not just because of the obvious risks of exploitation but because it can also lead someone to believe they are 'buying' your favour, for want of a better phrase, which puts those who can't do it at a potential disadvantage.
Healthcare, social care and education are supposed to be given equally and without bias, it's already not allowed in healthcare and social care - so why is it allowed in education when the same parameters apply?

Lockdownbear · 19/07/2021 02:35

@PrettyLittleFlies but is buying a teacher gift any different to tipping a waitress or taxi driver.

I don't remember doing teacher gifts as a child. But I really appreciate a good teacher.

Maggiesfarm · 19/07/2021 01:08

PrettyLittleFlies:

Have you read the full thread? Plenty of posts berating women for frivolities.
..........
I've dipped in and out since the thread started.

Nobody should berate someone else for being poor and everyone deserves the occasional treat.

However being resentful of those who are well off is hardly helpful.

PrettyLittleFlies · 19/07/2021 00:49

@ELOU1111

As an NHS nurse I am not allowed to accept personal gifts which I think is absolutely correct. It is time school heads took this approach and banned the giving of gifts to teachers. Many people cannot afford to be involved in this sycophantic practice.
I agree with this. Ridiculous to buy gifts for a person for doing their job
PrettyLittleFlies · 19/07/2021 00:48

@Maggiesfarm

Who is having a go at any despairing mother, PickupaPepper?

Goodness me your post smacks of bitterness and a huge chip on your shoulder.

Many of us are or have been extremely hard up, breadline, we don't carry on like you and are not jealous of anyone better off.

Resentment is ugly.

Have you read the full thread? Plenty of posts berating women for frivolities.
LimeRedBanana · 19/07/2021 00:46

Last week we had swathes people absolutely insistent that MOST of MN (and IRL) have several days per week when they have literally no money.

Now, this week, apparently most of MN don’t know what having no money means.

Everyone lives in their bubble and thinks the majority of people live like them, because the majority, if not all, people around them do.

Maggiesfarm · 19/07/2021 00:43

Who is having a go at any despairing mother, PickupaPepper?

Goodness me your post smacks of bitterness and a huge chip on your shoulder.

Many of us are or have been extremely hard up, breadline, we don't carry on like you and are not jealous of anyone better off.

Resentment is ugly.

ELOU1111 · 19/07/2021 00:40

As an NHS nurse I am not allowed to accept personal gifts which I think is absolutely correct. It is time school heads took this approach and banned the giving of gifts to teachers. Many people cannot afford to be involved in this sycophantic practice.

PrettyLittleFlies · 18/07/2021 23:38

@Comedycook

I know a very wealthy family. They travel extensively with their DC. Mum of family constantly goes on about how she doesn't give her children things, she gives them experiences and memories, as if this makes her superior. What she fails to grasp is that I can afford a trip to the toy shop and give my DC £10 to treat them. I can't afford four return tickets to Borneo.

In a similar vein, at my DC school, a group of parents keep organising these competitions and challenges to get kids active. All very laudable and should, in theory, be accessible to all. However, the middle class kids from wealthy families are the kids who overwhelmingly participate. Why? They have all the gear, the outdoor clothing, good quality footwear, bikes etc. People take these things for granted

She sounds like a massive twat. Money certainly does not buy wisdom or tact.
AdobeWanKenobi · 18/07/2021 23:24

When I was 18 I spent a while living in a squat. I accessed this damp hovel through a hole in a window. I was also pregnant.
Back the NFA equalled no benefits and any money I did have was taken by the abusive man I was with for drugs. I lived on tins of french onion soup from the local bargain shop. On a good day I was able to pay for them.

Sometimes I sit and look at my life now, a world away from that one and think how the fuck did I get here. I have a lovely home, a wonderful DH and savings. I appreciate every penny we have because I do know what it’s like to have to count out your last 60p for a can of soup and not know if it’s the only thing you’ll eat that week.