Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of MN don’t know what having no money means

531 replies

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 09:42

And that admitting to having none is humiliating.

I see it here all the time. Someone has no money. Someone suggests something to make life easier. The person says again they have no money. MN suggest a cheaper version.

On the thread about dress up so many people were saying to tell the school.

I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?

OP posts:
RandomCatGenerator · 19/07/2021 19:40

@PrettyLittleFlies

I get that people don't understand, what I don't get is why they offer advice. It's laughable. What on earth could a financially secure person know about dealing with poverty? The level of arrogance and smuggery is breathtaking. Rather like the social media nobodies lining up to tell epidemiologists how to manage a virus outbreak. It's so delusional as to be cringey.

If you are genuinely curious about something, ask someone who knows - and listen when they tell you. Try really hard not to talk over them (I'm looking at you @TwinsandTrifle)

YES. Spot on.
RandomCatGenerator · 19/07/2021 19:37

And I agree with PP. Always having had the fallback of family money, this - as well as things like the Rashford FSM campaign which led me to research much more - has opened my eyes.

RandomCatGenerator · 19/07/2021 19:35

@Amaya89 thank you for sharing. I’m so glad you’ve got out of that situation. It does sound like hell Flowers

cricketmum84 · 19/07/2021 19:32

No I think you are right, I see that a lot.

Im really fortunate to now have a really good job and good household incomebut back when my eldest was a baby and I was a single parent I had a part time minimum wage job and childcare fees. I used to cut open the bottom of the sofas to find enough loose change for a pint of milk. My nursery fees were always late and my dad had to help me with rent on his credit card.

I do think it's hard to empathise if you haven't been there though.

ReluctantNomad29 · 19/07/2021 19:29

@TwinsandTrifle Strange that you qualified for benefits when on another thread you were apparently a successful model for 20 years, making big bucks off your amazing looks Grin
You've also apparently been an accountant for ages. That's quite some CV Grin
Weren't you also berating a mum for buying too many clothes for her DD's play dates and calling her shallow/wasteful, but you spent £500 on kids' clothes at Boden?

Otherwise, this thread has been interesting and informative. I grew up in extreme poverty in a developing country so I do know what it's like to have no money, literally. I always used to think the Uk didn't have "real" poverty but my eyes have been opened. Thank you to the posters who have shared their stories. I hope you're all in a better position now Thanks

kazillionaire · 19/07/2021 17:59

I have the grand total of 164 in my bank, no savings and bills to pay. I also have two children to feed and benefits won't help because I'm a student and should happily live on 500 a month of my student loan 😂😂😂 I have had money in the past and yes I've probably wasted alot of it but it's swings and roundabouts and you cut your cloth according to what you have at the time, however I never thought I would be cancelling direct debits in order to pay my mortgage and buy food, so when I say I have no money, that's literally having no money - roll on September when I get some more student loan! 🥰

MildredPuppy · 19/07/2021 17:52

I find a lot of people look at poverty from a place of already having a lot of stuff. Its hard to explain but my sister fled her abuser in the middle of the night and had nothing but the clothes she wore. She had to get everything and yes its really exprnsive to be poor as you have exprnsive electricity rates and can only get cheap things that need replacing a lot. I had a rough financial patch but already had a winter coat and a pot to cook in etc. It was only when things started to wear out/ need replacing that things started to feel tight. But i had an in built buffer of stuff and could carry on all my cheap deals. Luckily i found work again but the buffer collapsed..

Soberanne · 19/07/2021 17:36

There also isnt always the correct support to get people out of poverty. Sanctions dont work and there's not enough access to decent training. Qualification can be expensive to get and like mentioned earlier force employers to pay a decent wage, pay our carers, childcare staff etc a decent wage. Put decent limits on rental charges, provide grants etc so people can afford to move Areas.

user1471538283 · 19/07/2021 17:16

Unless you have lived it I think most people dont get it. When I had very little one ex friend thought getting a credit card was a good idea! All she ever thought about what the here and now. She couldnt understand that I had to budget very finely. Then when she was in my position her answer was payday loans and eventually a man to keep her.

I get having no money at the end of the month and the stress of having an additional expense no matter how small.

ELOU1111 · 19/07/2021 17:15

I said personal gifts. Any gift given to a nurse personally eg box of quality street would be shared with the ward and put in this office (maybe 30 people!). It is in our code of conduct to not accept gifts. As for the consultants claret that was totally unnecessary and was most likely also shared with secretarial staff from my experience. A letter to the hospital would have been far more appreciated im sure.

SciFiScream · 19/07/2021 17:10

I read threads like this and I wish, wish, wish, there was a legitimate, ethical, dignified and legal way to partner up people who want to help with people who need a little bit of help.

I don't have much spare but I have enough that I could help out someone with a bus pass for the first month, or pay for a month's WiFi or buy a pair of shoes for school.

Those little things could help. It's a pipe dream isn't it?

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/07/2021 12:12

Also Lakielady the stats you link to include that 15% of people who own their own home outright are living in poverty. There's a big choice being made by those people not to liquidate a huge financial asset to meet your income needs. It's not absolute poverty if you own a house outright.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/07/2021 11:39

33feethighandrising

I totally agree. But being able to afford a cinema ticket but not to be able to get popcorn as well, is not absolute poverty.

Sometimesonly · 19/07/2021 11:22

I hate the idea of every pupil buying teachers thank you gifts anyway. Where we are, we do a gift from the class - maximum 5 euro donation, but you don't have to donate anything or you can put in a euro and it doesn't make any difference - the gift is from the class so nobody is left out. That means the teachers get a decent present instead of tat and everyone is happy.

33feethighandrising · 19/07/2021 11:09

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

My point being lakielady that I think trying to classify people who feel relatively poor, and are managing on a tight budget, struggling to afford treats, in the same bucket with people who are missing meals & malnourished due to poverty, does a disservice to that latter group.
Being unable to afford shoes for DC when they need them, for example, is poverty. You don't need to be malnourished to be in poverty.
1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 19/07/2021 10:50

@tomorrowalready any mention of the MP and the duck house really makes me laugh. Don't think he will ever live that one down.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/07/2021 10:33

My point being lakielady that I think trying to classify people who feel relatively poor, and are managing on a tight budget, struggling to afford treats, in the same bucket with people who are missing meals & malnourished due to poverty, does a disservice to that latter group.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/07/2021 10:31

Lakielady those statistics are relative poverty, which is really just measure of wealth disparity as it's based on the proportion of people who have incomes under 60% of the median income.

The reality is in the UK a low percentage of people live in truly abject poverty.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_percentage_of_population_living_in_poverty

It does not mean that those people don't matter. There may be tens or even hundreds of thousands who are very poor. But there are tens of millions in the UK who are not, therefore, true absolute poverty in the UK is rare and where it does exist its often circumstantial and short term in nature.

Amaya89 · 19/07/2021 10:05

I've been in an actually broke situation.. I've been a young mother with a baby and a toddler, a partner desperately looking for work and £20 a week to do everything. Rent was covered back then by housing benefit, as was council tax, but £20 a week didn't cover food, nappies and gas and electric on token meter, let alone actually needed extras like travel to job interviews or babygrows. All because my partner lost his job for taking a week off when i almost died during pregnancy, tax credits couldn't seem to work out what our entitlement was and it took 8 weeks to sort out child benefit for the baby. Our only option to eat was to go to my parents house and when the fridge broke it was hell. In the end I resorted to using the self service checkouts that had just been introduced to do my shopping as healthy start vouchers don't just deduct the cost of fruit, veg and milk on those, but take it off the total. The guilt genuinely kept me up at night.
Benefits were sorted out, but the depression of still living week to week, using our last bit of money to top up the 3g dongle for job hunting and trying to provide for our boys was soul destroying. We didn't have a food bank within walking distance then either.

There are definitely options for making things better, but when you're struggling like that all your energy goes on just surviving. There's nothing left. You cant see the forest for the trees, and outgoings get higher every time you need something. Sure, you could get that bed for your kid from Facebook, assuming it's still there in a couple of months when you've saved up enough money, but what do you do in the meantime when their cot broke and they have nothing but a basic cot mattress to sleep on? You go to somewhere like brighthouse. Where you not only pay higher than the cost on ebay, you also pay a tonne in interest. We live in a world where only the rich can afford to be poor.

It took 5 years to drag ourselves out of that situation. And the main reason we were able to is someone gave me a chance and saw that I was hardworking, ambitious and determined. I'm incredibly lucky and so many people don't have that someone.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 09:51

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland, approx 20% of people in the UK are in poverty.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn07096/

I think that's a significant proportion, personally.

LakieLady · 19/07/2021 09:23

@melj1213, I'm sorry you've had such a tough time.

Your experience is a good example of how decisions that were the best at the time can end up like a millstone round your neck by just one change of circumstances.

I hope that things soon improve for you.

PickUpAPepper · 19/07/2021 09:15

@Maggiesfarm

PrettyLittleFlies: Have you read the full thread? Plenty of posts berating women for frivolities. .......... I've dipped in and out since the thread started.

Nobody should berate someone else for being poor and everyone deserves the occasional treat.

However being resentful of those who are well off is hardly helpful.

Let me translate that last. “Aiming and redirecting criticism away from the internecine war of division, of those who have to fight over the tiny bit of wealth that’s left, set up by our lords and masters who are raking more of it in every day and laughing at everyone who is fool enough to work for their money on ridiculously inadequate wages, is not what I want to see. How dare you see through the imperialism and new slavery that’s being re-established.’

For your petty minimising ‘resentment’ and ‘chips on your shoulder’ I give you fully legitimate anger at the way we are all being duped and taken for fools. At the degeneration into crime and turbulence on our streets, legitimised by those at the top, who bear no consequence for it. There’s only so much wealth to go round, why do you feel the need to defend 1% of the population taking so much directly away from the poorest?

YesIDoLoveCrisps · 19/07/2021 09:14

I haven’t read every comment so sorry if someone has already said this but it’s always more expensive to be ‘poor’. If you have some spare money you can stock up on buy one get one free offers, you don’t have pay on credit cards or take out loans to pay for necessary things.

Debt is expensive. Not being able to plan for the future because you can’t afford today is expensive.

Auntienumber8 · 19/07/2021 08:59

DS school had a lot of dc living in poverty, so had high rates of pupil premium. The town I live in has huge pockets of deprivation. Really poor, I was involved with a study of this area about a decade ago regarding grant funding, it’s not just a guess.

I don’t remember the exact scenarios but the school used this money for free trips and activities to all children so there was absolutely no difference between anyone. It meant the dc like mine who didn’t need it free got it free but it stopped any kind of singling out. I think that head teacher did a really good job of inclusivity.

emmetgirl · 19/07/2021 08:58

I have money now but I have experienced have none for quite a few years in the past so I do!