Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of MN don’t know what having no money means

531 replies

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 09:42

And that admitting to having none is humiliating.

I see it here all the time. Someone has no money. Someone suggests something to make life easier. The person says again they have no money. MN suggest a cheaper version.

On the thread about dress up so many people were saying to tell the school.

I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?

OP posts:
saraclara · 18/07/2021 10:46

@BoredZelda

So poor children whose parents don’t have the money to buy teacher plastic shite or expensive rubbish all live in b and bs?

Some do. Seems people here struggle to accept that is a real situation for many.

Exactly. I taught a kid who lived with his parents in one room with a single hotplate in the corner for cooking.

I'm sure he wasn't the only one. I'd not have known about his situation were it not for me needing to do a home visit for an unrelated reason.

It was a seminal moment for me.

CiaoForNiao · 18/07/2021 10:45

@TwinsandTrifle

You have no idea what it's like today, not a single clue.

I have. I'm an accountant with quite a bit of experience in advising in this area.

And did a calc to see what UC I'd qualify for. 1 adult. 3 kids.

I would get all my rent paid. All bar £8.40 a month council tax paid. And £1373 in UC and child benefit. After bills and food, that leaves me circa £500 per month for non essentials.

I'd get if it left me £50. But £500? And for those who want to claim well that's loads, you've got 3DC. Let me just clarify that the amount drops by about £250 for having one DC instead. So you are actually better off the fewer DC you have.

That's calculation has either ignored the benefit cap, or you have a very low rent ! And hardly anyone gets a 100%council tax reduction these days. I get £7 per week off mine.
Wriggleon · 18/07/2021 10:45

I think sometimes when you have less money you feel more pressure to contribute to some things, I have no problem not buying an end of year present for the teacher, I primary I bought one for class teacher and one for teachers who took the children on the residential, for the whole of primary school. For wearing a specific thing, I use something I already have or borrow, or don't bother, my friends who also can easily afford also borrow. I did find when I was poor, I spent more on take aways as that was my only treat while now I rarely buy takeaways and often spend hours over a Dahl, which I just could not have faced to do while poor.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/07/2021 10:45

I'm not sure it's always that - MN is a goldmine for scammers who love to post begging threads saying they have no money and can't afford this and that
Usually making reasonable suggestions quickly flushes them out

Exactly this - and oddly enough (?) they very often appear late at night or at the weekend, presumably when it's hoped the Mods won't be on the ball

That said, it's a reasonable place to come for those who are genuine, because the advice can be excellent

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 10:45

The amount benefits pay (in most circumstances assuming your rent is covered by the local area housing allowance element of uc) is ok on a short term basis but people have so many loans - cars, pay by the week furniture/white goods, store cards and credit cards, often as much as their uc payment each month.

Yes they want a brand new TV, a better car, new wardrobes from Next/apply any storecard here, new washer, dryer.

So they want all that, take out loans and cards then gripe about it. Oh, I've got no money. As opposed to I can't stop buying things I can't afford and dislike I can't live well above my means.

Do you know why I had £400 left over each month? My perfectly good TV was 8 yrs old. My tumble dryer (which I've still got!) was £50 from the freeads. DS had gorgeous clothes, I got a bit obsessed with everything from Boden. But it all got resold on eBay. £500 worth, he'd wear for a year, and I'd sell for £350! I bought secondhand. I didn't buy a car with repayments I couldn't afford when I had a car that worked. Would I have liked a better one, god yes. Did I go out and get one then moan how I had no more benefits to spend? Jesus wept.

It's a very liveable amount. If its not, then it's down to that individual.

Lockdownbear · 18/07/2021 10:45

Op on the other thread people were suggesting to tell the school, because the school having so many dress up days becomes silly somebody needs to point out to school that these things have a cost. And school need to stop and think about it.

Even homemade outfits aren't free, every thing has a cost, a t-shirt that gets painted or glittered can't be reworn, nor can it be passed down. Not everyone has craft stuff just lying around so that's a cost buying craft stuff to make something.

Some parents are working and struggling for time too, not every parent has time to spend hours making stuff, especially those with multiple kids or other responsibilities.

On another thread a teacher suggested that some kids are so deprived they can't even get a camping holiday. We'll actually camping isn't cheap especially getting started. As for the suggestions borrow how many people know someone they can borrow from? .

Yuckyfinger · 18/07/2021 10:44

Someone poster might post about literally not being able to make ends meet ie no money, and people will always suggest "moving to a cheaper area" as if moving is a) instant and b) without initial cost.
Even the ubiquitous "take in ironing" might require someone to buy an iron or a better iron! And presumably stationary for any admin they might need to do

OneHundredTrees · 18/07/2021 10:43

I remember a poster - it must have been a few years ago now - who said she had no money to buy her kids nice things or go on holiday, while exH was rich, and she felt it was unfair.

Turned out she had £50k+ in savings but didn't want to touch that pot Hmm so people's idea of 'no money' differs!

MonicaGellerBing · 18/07/2021 10:43

I'm constantly skint. My DH works in a good job but we can't seem to ever keep up with our bills and food and the increase in the cost of living. I am looking for a job now my youngest is starting school. DH gets paid on a Friday, by the time I pay all my bills and get food shopping sometimes on a Monday I have £10 left, sometimes £0.

My best friend and her husband both have well paid professional jobs and her husband has just inherited over £150,000 yet I constantly have to listen to her tell me how skint they are. She doesn't live in the real world.

Greenwateringcan · 18/07/2021 10:43

@BoredZelda I know.

I’m pointing out that they may not be living in a crappy b&b. They may be in the rented terrace, the middle class bought semi, the flat on a council estate.

They can be anywhere. It’s not just in a b&b as @LemonRoses inferred.

Kona84 · 18/07/2021 10:43

I hate the suggestions for people to cancel a£5.99 Netflix subscription when this is the only ‘luxury’ no gym membership, no eating out no cinema just Netflix- get rid of it that £5.99 will make the biggest difference.
Yes now they will be skint and bored.

queenMab99 · 18/07/2021 10:42

People do not understand when they have not experienced it, I wince sometimes when I read the 'advice' given on here, when someone desperately posts about a problem, which is the result of having no money to meet expectations of friends or school, or even to just feed their children. I am in a better position now, but still waver over buying things like kitchen bin liners or paper kitchen towel, because they are convenient but not essential.

BoredZelda · 18/07/2021 10:40

So poor children whose parents don’t have the money to buy teacher plastic shite or expensive rubbish all live in b and bs?

Some do. Seems people here struggle to accept that is a real situation for many.

PrettyLittleFlies · 18/07/2021 10:40

A lot of people talk a lot of crap generally. Hardly anyone listens.

There was a woman on here the other day saying she never had money left over. She earned a low wage, had no debt, didn't drink or smoke, rarely went out or bought clothes. Posters lived up to tell her to quit botox which cost her a grand total of £100 a year. Ridiculous. As if that would make a difference. And for the love of god it was her one frivolity. Plus she wasn't complaining, she was just saying how it was and wondering if anyone else experienced the same. But a lot of people cannot hear or accept what is happening for other people.

k1233 · 18/07/2021 10:40

I know what you mean. No money means no money. Not access to an overdraft or just tight. I've been there too. Too poor to afford public transport to get to work. A loaf of bread, carton of eggs and litre of milk to eat for a week (cost at a cheap place was around $3). In my case it wasn't choices. It was illness and only being able to work 3weeks out of 4 and needing to take unpaid leave. Didn't qualify for benefits but bills don't get reduced. Took me years to get out of it once my health improved. To this day I still panic getting mail. So much so I only empty the mail box every couple of months. My bills come electronically, but I still can't open the letter box incase there is something there I can't pay. These days I can pay it but the fear is still there.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 10:40

Scammers tend to start a thread about having no money.

The ones I’m thinking of tend to be talking about something else and then having no money comes up in context.

So things like ‘just take a taxi to your mums’ or whatever.

OP posts:
OlympicProcrastinator · 18/07/2021 10:40

You can't eat pride though, can you?

Eh? Well I certainly didn’t swallow mine down and let anyone know. I’m glad I did go hungry. Even reading these posts demonstrates how many people would have just judged me for making choices. Plus losing that two stone didn’t do me any harm.

OhWhyNot · 18/07/2021 10:40

YANBU

To have no money for the gas meter to be counting your pennies to buy bread and milk it’s fucking miserable

Those who say they could live without money really do not know how miserable it can be it occupies your mind constantly abs drags you down

Thankfully have not had to live like that for years and never with ds (though at times it’s been very difficult financially not that bad)

BoredZelda · 18/07/2021 10:40

I don't mean to sound dismissive. My point is you could have the exact same bank balance as someone else, but one will be judged harsher and find it more humiliating.

Not only dismissive, but ranking poverty and who has it worse based on your marital status or whether you have children really shows a misunderstanding of real life.

Admitting you need help is hard whether you have children or a husband or not.

Greenwateringcan · 18/07/2021 10:39

So poor children whose parents don’t have the money to buy teacher plastic shite or expensive rubbish all live in b and bs?

You must be expressing yourself very poorly. Either that or I need more coffee

Sheerheight · 18/07/2021 10:38

The thread you're referring to the person was saying they can't afford to order a brand new costume , which in all honesty you don't have to do.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 10:37

What, so you actually think poor children all live in grim B and Bs? Hmm what the hell? I’m laughing because it’s so random!

OP posts:
Lockheart · 18/07/2021 10:36

@icecolddrinks

I must admit I’ve found that.

No one has to spend money but the assumption that a poster saying I’m skint = scamming troll has been harmful here I think.

I completely agree, and it's awful that prolific scamming (which MN doesn't do enough to crack down on) has made it so.

I don't think it's impossible to differentiate the scammers from those who really are hard up. Usually the scammers will turn down any suggestion which may help (except of course if someone PMs them offering to credit their PayPal account...) but those who actually need help tend to take the information offered by posters - many of whom are excellent at supporting those in need - and use it.

LemonRoses · 18/07/2021 10:36

@icecolddrinks

I think *@LemonRoses* must be referring to another thread none of us have seen … Grin surely!?

I know the crumbs of poverty are little known in some quarters but it’s not the Gorbals in 1973 Grin

No. She is saying children are still living in appalling poverty. Truly appalling poverty and no, lots of people don’t see that.

I’m not sure that the level of poverty and polarisation of wealth is much to laugh about, personally. I’m very fortunate, but others are not. The idea of using absolute poverty as a source of humour is appalling. No it’s not 1973 and yet across the U.K. poverty is increasingly because of government policy.

The Child Poverty Act pushed through by Blair aimed to virtually eradicate that degree of poverty, even that had a target of less than 5% living in abject poverty. That is a too high target for a civilised society.

In 2016, the Resolution Foundation projected that by 2020, relative child poverty would by 50%. The increase in relative poverty has undone almost all of the work done reducing poverty from 1999-2010. And the increase in absolute poverty (also up from 17.6 per cent in 2010/11) will mean that, over a decade, the income of families at the bottom has actually gone down – something without precedent in modern times.

The teacher expectations was in response to someone pointing out a card was too expensive for some families. They are right.

Soberanne · 18/07/2021 10:35

I agree, on mumsnet there always seems to be a solution thrown in to the comment, i am skint and that solution usually involves money.
And not everyone who is skint has been careless with money, is on benefits or is lying and scamming. Nor do all poor people live in grim b&bs with no cooking facilities. I work 40 hours a week in a nursery, looking after and caring for other peoples children but even working full time, and with no debt to pay off, i still rely on tax credits and can barely meet my bills let alone buy luxuries. I have never had a holiday. Please dont say find another job or open up your prospects as there are very few jobs in the area i live and i cant afford the expense of moving to another area nor should my kids have too. Maybe if people were paid a decent wage they wouldn't be skint.

Swipe left for the next trending thread