Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of MN don’t know what having no money means

531 replies

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 09:42

And that admitting to having none is humiliating.

I see it here all the time. Someone has no money. Someone suggests something to make life easier. The person says again they have no money. MN suggest a cheaper version.

On the thread about dress up so many people were saying to tell the school.

I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?

OP posts:
RubyGoat · 18/07/2021 11:25

We've been absolutely stony broke. More than once. Certainly couldn't have afforded botox. Can't afford a car, despite living in a town where there is a fairly basic bus service & we're 2 miles from the train station. And I'm disabled. And DH uses a stick to walk.

When I was on maternity leave our joint income was my maternity pay plus child benefit. We were approximately £150 a month short of being able to pay our rent & bills. Without even considering the question of food. DH had lost his job & because I was employed & technically on full time hours, he wasn't entitled to any jobseekers benefit. We weren't entitled to anything else for the same reason. I got to the limit of my overdraft before my maternity leave ended, the rent bounced & I had to borrow the money. Lied to the bank about my return to work date so I could get a loan in order to pay the rent. Took a year to pay it back. 4 years to pay off the credit card we'd been using to pay for food, I did manage to switch it to 0% after I returned to work so it wasn't accruing further interest. DH lost weight as he didn't eat properly most days, we often went to the supermarket just before closing & if there was stuff knocked down to 10p, we got that - bread, vegetables etc, occasionally meat or tins. Sometimes there wasn't anything. He made me eat more as I was BFing DD. But we couldn't really afford food & had to go to the food bank which is run by the CAB here. They usually give 3 days of food but it was Christmas & they sent us home with a massive bag & another enormous box of food, enough for absolutely weeks because they couldn't believe how completely screwed we were financially. We just weren't entitled to any help at all.

We were homeless last year. Our LL sold our house. No-one would touch us, due to not having 2 incomes. DH was working FT at the time.

DH hasn't had new clothes in years, except for shoes. Occasionally his parents turn up with something they've found at a car boot sale. Sometimes it fits. His 1 jacket he wears for work & job interviews came from a charity shop for about £5 & I repaired the ripped lining.

I think many people think there are cutbacks to be made. If you've already cut everything back to the bone, there's nothing left.

kikisparks · 18/07/2021 11:25

I’ve never been skint, I’m very lucky to have had support from my parents and always been able to work.

I have worked with people who have struggled financially and I can totally see how it happens.

Benefit errors are frequent and leave people getting into debt with horrific payday loans to sort it out.

Zero hours contracts make top up benefits even harder to claim when needed because income is changing all of the time.

Landlords often fail to resolve issues like broken washing machines, damp etc so people had to spend money on it themselves because they couldn’t wait, and had to get into debt to do so.

The wait to receive universal credit often leads to getting into debt.

Personal independence payment and child DLA get wrongly refused all of the time (I used to help appeal these and had 100% appeal success rate) many can’t cope with the process and quit and don’t get what they’re entitled to, having to scrape by for things they need like taxis to hospital, convenience foods when they can’t cook a meal etc. Mental health issues were the hardest to get benefits for, the assessment process often made no sense for mental health issues.

Most fathers didn’t seem to pay maintenance to single mothers, either the father didn’t work or was self employed and hid earnings, leaving her struggling to raise kids alone (there were also very good fathers and single fathers but I saw struggling single mothers the most). I did see fathers who refused to reduce their voluntary maintenance payments even when their hours were dropped at work and they couldn’t afford rent, because they were scared of not getting to see their child.

Obviously there can be alcohol, gambling or drug addictions which have no easy fix.

Asylum seeking families get an absolute pittance which is impossible to live on.

Immigration issues could also lead to a lack of entitlement. There were European single mothers who had lost their job and whilst we tried to argue they should get benefits their only income was £30 a week from social work who were often good but also often grudging to give them that so their children could eat.

Domestic violence where the abused partner fled often meant the need to use up any money they had on a deposit and buying belongings left behind, it’s easy to end up relying on payday loans whilst dealing with that. Spaces in women’s refuges were often few and far between. Whilst in the relationship there could often be financial abuse.

If you are a single healthy jobseeker UC is very low and buying things like interview clothes, haircuts, transport to interviews, paying for decent internet to apply for jobs etc could be very difficult.

Young people get less benefits even when they have the same expenses, it’s often expected that parents will help but many have no parental support.

There’s obviously more restrictions on benefits than ever, such as 2 child cap, benefit cap, bedroom tax. Bedroom tax makes no sense as it often wasn’t possible to find a suitable smaller property for example when an older child moved out. Sometimes for example an autistic child needed their own room but the cap was still applied.

These are just some of the issues. Many of those struggling in poverty were in work. Although budgeting and life skills are not taught enough and are important, they won’t solve all of the systemic issues caused by austerity, zero hour contracts, payday loans with ridiculous interest, high unauthorised overdraft charges, lack of mental health services and support etc.

For more info from a recent objective UN report: www.ohchr.org/documents/issues/poverty/eom_gb_16nov2018.pdf

CiaoForNiao · 18/07/2021 11:24

@icecolddrinks

I teach secondary. I know who the pp children are who I teach and so should everyone.
Why? Why does the maths teacher need to know that PP paid for the revision book not me personally? Why does the English teacher need to know that PP paid for the Macbeth study guide? DS is in school, clean, in correct uniform, homework done etc etc. Nothing else is relevant to the teacher. He doesn't need extra classes on account of being PP. He doesn't need to sit at the front of the class. He doesn't need any extra input at all. We just get help paying for all the things he needs. (Which schools provided to everyone in my day)
WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly · 18/07/2021 11:24

PP money shouldn’t be used generally. It should be used specifically to raise outcomes for those children.

That’s only applicable to the extra pupil premium for LAC. FSM pupil premium can be spent more generally. Our school don’t provide free trips, music lessons etc. I know because I have asked for help with a residential trip and been told no.

I once when I was very skint had to take my jewellery to a pawn shop so my dd could go on a preschool trip that was £15. She was the only one without a parent going with her because I couldn’t find another £15. Thankfully we are not in that position any more. We didn’t get free school meals then either but do now.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/07/2021 11:22

IMO plenty of older MNers will understand it, since we remember an era with no cash machines or ccs - you had to go to your own bank and v likely have a stern interview with the manager if you needed an overdraft, or wanted a loan. I had to see the manager before getting a loan for my first car - £150 for an old Mini - and satisfy him that I was responsible enough to pay it back at £10 a month, IIRC.

So if you had one and four pence halfpenny in old money (about 13p) to last to the end of the month, as a housemate of mine once did, that was it - unless you could sponge off well-off parents, as she so often did.

But many others didn’t and couldn’t. During our seriously skint era dh and I wouldn’t have dreamt of asking our not-well-off parents - it was a case of living extremely frugally - for quite a while we practically lived on homemade veg soups, bread, and the cheapest possible cheese.

wedswench · 18/07/2021 11:21

Maybe it's because I was well off in years gone by but £500 a month after bills and food when you have 3 children isn't "loads".

I'm grateful for my benefits, they put food on the table and I can cover our essentials plus maybe the odd take away or some new undies for myself but it's not loads, it's just not. Enough yes, but it's no way to live long term whether in benefits or in work

Notmoresugar · 18/07/2021 11:21

OP why don't you go to college and do something positive that will benefit you not only financially but also for your mental well-being?

Your energy is very wow is me/negative when it could be so much better and positive.

I did - and it changed my world.

And don't think for one moment I don't know what real poverty is - I do and probably a lot more than you do/are living. I have been on both sides.

And yes a lot of my wardrobe is Boden now.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 11:20

No of course not.

But someone has said children on FSM aren’t singled out. They are.

Positive singling out is still being singled out. That’s really humiliating for some people. And even just being known as someone claiming FSM is for some people.

OP posts:
CiaoForNiao · 18/07/2021 11:20

@TwinsandTrifle

Your rent would have to be paid out of the universal credit. There is no separate housing benefit payment. Or do you mean you'd have £1,373 left after you'd paid the rent?

After I'd paid the rent.

And OP how dare you insult me that I'm some "wind up" because I'm a qualified accountant who has seen enough bad money management and people making excuses that I know it is predominantly not the benefits that are the problem.

You dont like thats the fact of the matter, not my issue. Thank you.

What about the benefit cap? You're either only paying £300 rent, or you're in London with low for London rent.
Tatertot6 · 18/07/2021 11:20

Agree. I had another account I forgot the password to but I needed a pregnancy test and had absolutely no money. People were telling me to go buy a home bargain one for £1. When I didn’t have anything, I still can’t magic up £1

VienneseWhirligig · 18/07/2021 11:20

'using family allowance for baby milk and nappies skint. '

Isn't that what child benefit is for?

@JaniieJones yes, of course, but £12.50 a week didn't cover both either. I had to go back to work when DS was 3 months old because mat leave wasn't that generous 21 years ago. We were both working but nursery fees were ridiculously high, the mortgage needed paying and we genuinely had no money - not just down to our last £20. Often we had pennies left in the third week of the month, the CSA didn't always pay the maintenance to DH even though they collected it from his ex wife, they were bloody useless. It was a difficult time. He used to walk to work because we couldn't afford the bus fare for both of us, and I had to take DS to nursery so I had the bus pass. Gas and electric were on a key and there were times we had to choose between topping up one or the other with £5 (electric won as it was more useful).

OneDayIWillBeOrganised · 18/07/2021 11:19

@icecolddrinks

I teach secondary. I know who the pp children are who I teach and so should everyone.
Do you single them out so others are aware of who they are? Knowing this information and using it to single out a child are two different things.
AlphabetAerobics · 18/07/2021 11:19

@JaniieJones

'It annoys me when people say stuff like 'can't you get an overdraft' or 'get a 0% credit card'. I feel. Like screaming don't you think they would already have done I if they could'

Tbf it is just advice, if people post on a public forum saying they are skint what can they do others will offer advice.

What do you suggest, just lots of 'Sorry to hear that op' replies?!

Tbf - that's a PRIME example.

When you've got less than £5 in your account, your bank DOESN'T offer/extend your OD - and the creditcard companies are offering you a competitive 39%APR (if you're lucky!) - not 0%.

THAT is why people who are desperate USE payday lender types - because the 1.5% loans are only for people with plenty of cash.

hellywelly3 · 18/07/2021 11:19

My MIL was telling me how skint my SIL and BIL were. Their skint was using all their money to build another house in their garden that they were going to move into then sell the house they were in. No mortgage involved!

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 11:17

I teach secondary. I know who the pp children are who I teach and so should everyone.

OP posts:
Meruem · 18/07/2021 11:17

I’ve been on both sides and it is really tough being truly skint. I was a single mum on benefits for a few years. I didn’t get any money from the ex, no family help etc. There were no food banks then either. I’d get paid on a Monday, buy electric and gas for the meters, buy food for the week and then be left with literally a couple of quid for milk and bread later in the week. I did get council tax relief so didn’t have to pay that but honestly I didn’t pay for water in that time. I just didn’t have that extra money (and there was no Netflix, mobile phones etc then so I wasn’t spending on that!).

I’m not “rich” now, but I feel rich. I can pay my bills, buy the food I want, replace something if it breaks etc. Compared to many on MN I might still be classed as poor! In comparison to them I probably am. But I remember being truly poor and the way I live now isn’t it.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 18/07/2021 11:17

@LemonRoses

No reasonable teacher, no reasonable human, would expect a present off a child who was living in a grim bed and breakfast place without access to cooking facilities.
We live in a really nice basement flat with sole use of the garden, in an extortionate area of London, DH has lived here since 1972, we're on WTC, we just about survive. If anyone suggests we move, we wouldn't get anywhere as the waiting lists are so long. We're not what the council deems overcrowded, as we're 4 people in a 2 bedroom flat, even though the DC are opposite sexes and the older is 13.
Alltheprettyseahorses · 18/07/2021 11:17

@TwinsandTrifle

You have no idea what it's like today, not a single clue.

I have. I'm an accountant with quite a bit of experience in advising in this area.

And did a calc to see what UC I'd qualify for. 1 adult. 3 kids.

I would get all my rent paid. All bar £8.40 a month council tax paid. And £1373 in UC and child benefit. After bills and food, that leaves me circa £500 per month for non essentials.

I'd get if it left me £50. But £500? And for those who want to claim well that's loads, you've got 3DC. Let me just clarify that the amount drops by about £250 for having one DC instead. So you are actually better off the fewer DC you have.

The claimant has to pay rent out of the £1373, it's not a separate payment any more.
CiaoForNiao · 18/07/2021 11:16

@icecolddrinks

most of their teachers don’t know

In which case that PP money is being badly spent.

Teachers absolutely should know who is PP in their class.

In secondary schools where they teach hundreds of children? Unlikely.

We can use PP to pay for books, trips etc. It's done through parent pay. So when the teachers have a list of who's paid for a book my dcs names are on it (if we've ordered one). If they know it was paid for via PP they've never let on.
My friend who is a secondary teacher doesn't know who is and isn't PP. He knows who has paid via Parent pay for things. He hands those things out.

Antiqueanniesmagiclanternshow · 18/07/2021 11:16

Pupil premium children are not identified on the register or seating plan at the school i work in. Not in the entire 15 years i have done this job, have i seen that happen.
The pupil premium status is mostly used for data purposes.

When i was at school back in the dim and distant past, free school meal kids had a special pass that they showed at the till in the canteen. THAT was singling out!
Maybe because i have always lived and worked in ares with a lot of economic deprivation, i haven't experienced what you are saying.

CliftonGreenYork · 18/07/2021 11:15

I am often amazed at the huge disparity in wealth on here. There was a post the other day from someone who was 'struggling' to find a home for £900k and other from someone who was taking a pay cut to £125k a year. I do think its great that we have such a wide mix of members, but the rich ones (even though they don't think they are rich) should try and think about what really been poor is.

OneDayIWillBeOrganised · 18/07/2021 11:14

@icecolddrinks

Of course they are *@OneDayIWillBeOrganised*

If you are invited to attend a revision session that is being singled out.

If you are given a free hoodie you are being singled out.

If you are given money to go on a school trip that is being singled out.

Positive singling out is still being singled out.

In a good school these things would be done in a way that is not obvious. Who knows whether you paid for the hoodie, school trip etc other than the school and parent? Being skint is no fun for anyone but there is help out there that can be provided sensitively if people want it.
wedswench · 18/07/2021 11:14

@icecolddrinks

Yes it is *@wedswench*, PP money shouldn’t be used generally. It should be used specifically to raise outcomes for those children. Which is why it is hard to spend in a way that doesn’t single those children out.

If you teach a PP child you should know who that child is.

No that's not right

www.gov.uk/guidance/pupil-premium-effective-use-and-accountability

Soberanne · 18/07/2021 11:11

@TwinsandTrifle i am so glad your experience of being on benefits was a good one and that you are now an accountant. That in itself is a success story but surely you must appreciate that this is not the case for everyone. Benefits for most are hard to come buy, come with some real stringent rules and sanctions, never mind the many who feel ashamed (which they shouldnt) and what that does that do to their mental health. Insinuating that because people who are skint They are bad with money really isnt constructive or a sign that you have any concept of living in the real world.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 11:10

Of course they are @OneDayIWillBeOrganised

If you are invited to attend a revision session that is being singled out.

If you are given a free hoodie you are being singled out.

If you are given money to go on a school trip that is being singled out.

Positive singling out is still being singled out.

OP posts: