Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of MN don’t know what having no money means

531 replies

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 09:42

And that admitting to having none is humiliating.

I see it here all the time. Someone has no money. Someone suggests something to make life easier. The person says again they have no money. MN suggest a cheaper version.

On the thread about dress up so many people were saying to tell the school.

I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 18/07/2021 11:43

The problem on here is for everything thread by a truly skint/desperate poster down to their last 3p, who has tried everything, there are as many by
a) people who drip feed in various details that reveal they are in fact not really budgeting that tightly
b) people who are very skint but are given really good advice eg often arent getting all the benefits they are entitled to, and spend the whole thread whinging but ignoring the good advice

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 11:39

You are on a bloody wind up grin you just wanted to tell everyone you shop at Boden!

If your capabilities are that limited to only understanding "trilling on about Boden" (and not the benefit of the £350 resale value) from what I've written, then it fully explains why you don't get the rest.

You're certainly something dear, and it's not a "wind up"

DancesWithTortoises · 18/07/2021 11:39

You are absolutely right, OP.

Most of us are lucky enough to not understand the unhappiness of constant poverty.

Fizbosshoes · 18/07/2021 11:39

There were lots of posters on here recently bemoaning poor people for making bad food choices and trotted out the MN favourite "batch cooking"
Not taking into account that even if batch cooking is more economical per portion you need to be able to buy all the ingredients (and "store cupboard " type items if you dont already have them) in one go. (More expensive than buying a bag of chips or pizza) And have the utensils and adequate gas/electric to do so.

andweallsingalong · 18/07/2021 11:39

@TwinsandTrifle

"I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?*

For me, two things. Firstly, from having to claim benefits myself and astounded at the amount I was given. We literally lived no differently to when I was in full time work.

The second. I had no money, one month. The clutch went in my car. I had "3p" in the bank that month. What I can't understand is how people only ever have 3p in the bank continually.

So my view, is that I know what you receive, I wasn't special, that's what I received too. I know what average bills are, and if consistently you are left with 3p, then it is not down to lack of initial money, but your own choices on what you've done with it.

The odd month with a surprise large expense can't be helped. The rest of the year? It's down to personal choices. Some months I'd have £300-400 to just spend on whatever, after all bills and food. That's a huge amount. And it wasn't like we lived like misers.

So yes, because of having been in that exact position, and knowing how very easy it was, I question what made me so "lucky" when some people swear they are so hard done by.

Lol, no it's not the same for everyone.

15 years ago I was single, had a cheap mortgage, 3 cats, no children.

Had recently taken a pay cut to change career direction to what would eventually be a better paying job. No insurance because when I got my mortgage and wanted to take out insurance I wasn't eligible (working fixed term contracts linked to gvt funding - secure employment in reality, but not on paper)

I had an accident, dropped to half pay. Looked into benefits - not eligible, earn too much, come back when you drop to SSP.

Dropped to SSP. All saving gone. Mortgage company were amazing, let me drop to interest only. £121 per month. Tried to get a lodger no joy - nice cul de sac in very rough area.

Somewhere along the lines I managed to claim industrial injuries disablement benefit. Iirc about 20 quid a week. Total £83 per week.

Reapplied to benefits - "a single person only needs £45 per week to live on. With SSP and IIDB you earn too much" come back in x weeks when we can consider your mortgage payment.

Came back in x weeks - you're not eligible because you remortged after x date. Erm yes remortgage regularly for best rates. Ironically if I'd been renting I would have got well over 200 paid!

Not eligible for DLA as didn't think I'd be in the same position for at least 12 months. Later got around 20 quid a week until criteria changed and I lost it.

Remember walking over 15 miles round trip to visit an elderly family member because I couldn't afford to put petrol in my car and too ashamed to admit it.

Got my shopping budget down to £15 per week and lost weight - didn't have any to lose.

Could have sold the car but wouldn't have helped for long and needed it to return to work. Couldn't afford to sell the house (no money for costs) and would have been long term financial suicide as renting was far more expensive than my mortgage.

So no, sorry, you don't have a clue what it was like for me and can't speak for me or others who have been in my position.

£83 per week income to pay:-
121 mortgage
60 per month food, cleaning, toiletries
10 per month cat food and litter
5 Petrol
15 per month cat insurance for 3 cats - 1 had expensive recurring condition so no way I could drop this
40 gas and elec
0 clothes
20 water
Car insurance
House and contents insurance
Telephone
= nothing left for emergencies, fun, etc

TableFlowerss · 18/07/2021 11:38

Poverty is a very complex issue. I’ve been on both sides of the spectrum. When I was younger I didn’t have a pot to piss in. Life was hard. I had tax credits and worked but I was at uni with a toddler and it was tough. I was always in to my overdraft. I didn’t even see it as debt, it was part of my available funds ☹️ Credit cards had a few grand on.

No mammy and daddy to help me. Just me and my partner who worked in a petrol station, so was also on NMW.

It was grim.

Thankfully I qualified and stared earning more. He got an apprenticeship and things stated looking up. Fast forward 14 years and I’m in a very different place. I don’t worry about money now and I’m thankful to have been released of that burden.

I certainly don’t think it’s a simple as saying get a better job etc that’s ignorant. Poverty is often a cycle and some people can escape it but luck plays a huge role in my opinion.

Some that have never experienced it will assume it’s as simple as getting a better paid job etc as if it’s that easy to just get a job.

Having said that, I also think there are some people that don’t help themselves and make bad decisions and waste money.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 11:37

@Hamnetssister

One of our performance management indicators is the performance of the PP children in our class. So we are absolutely expected to know who they are and in the data analysis, the progress of the PP students is a key performance indicator.
Same.
OP posts:
TheLovelinessOfDemons · 18/07/2021 11:37

@TheQueef DH is 67 and in a manual job, he can't physically work more hours, if I worked more than 10 hours a week, they'd just take the difference off our WTC, what do these people expect us to do?

PickUpAPepper · 18/07/2021 11:36

Completely agree op, and it's not just MN. Britain contains many worlds, and they don't meet. No one with money has ever understood what it is to have none - not 'but it's only a tenner' or 'but it's only for a short time', but but but it's only or just this that or the other, but NONE. No one who has been sheltered and had a nice upbringing ever understands that Britain isn't a nice place for everyone, and not everyone has choices. It's pathetic, but that's the way it is.

BoredZelda · 18/07/2021 11:35

Someone poster might post about literally not being able to make ends meet ie no money, and people will always suggest "moving to a cheaper area" as if moving is a) instant and b) without initial cost.

This is also suggested to people who were high earners but lose that income. Any suggestion that this isn't an easy move is treated with derision.

Hamnetssister · 18/07/2021 11:35

One of our performance management indicators is the performance of the PP children in our class. So we are absolutely expected to know who they are and in the data analysis, the progress of the PP students is a key performance indicator.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 11:35

I think a few people are missing the point with ‘your child won’t be treated negatively’

I’d bloody hope not.

But that’s not really the point here. I’ve worked in a few schools and they all do it differently, sure, but if the money is being spent properly it should be about targeting those pupils and making the gap smaller. It’s hard to do that without some singling out, even in a positive sense.

If you use SIMS which I think about 98% of schools do, a quick look at a class register will tel you who is PP, who is EAL and the ethnic background of a child. It’s nonsense to say schools don’t know. Yes the kids don’t walk round with a tattoo Grin but it’s still fairly public knowledge and not everyone is OK with that, especially if they have strong links to the local area.

OP posts:
BlatantlyNameChanged · 18/07/2021 11:34

Right so, your situation is not reflective at all of the norm. I'm an accountant. I know the "system" so to speak, and your tax credits should have taken no more than a month to instate.

You had no money because you had an almost unheard of administrative wait of 8 months. You weren't receiving anything. This is not what we're talking about.

I worked in Tax Credits back when it first began right up until around five or six years ago.

The eight month wait? Not at all uncommon especially in the first five years of the scheme, in fact it was so common that we had a team dedicated to dealing with those claims who would try to get them processed. It still took ages though because their worklist was so long (which tells you in itself how many claims they were dealing with). There were also claims that went into what was called 'Out Of Payment' (or OOP because HMRC loves an acronym). OOP meant that the system was recording payments as due but not actually issuing them to BACS so people were getting no money at all. The solution was to make an M1 referral to my team who would attempt to force the claim to update and issue payment (alongside the backpayments), if that didn't work then it had to be escalated to TCO who would put the claim into manual payments (a giro through the post every week) but that wouldn't include the backpay and there was always a chance the giro would go missing in the post too. We dealt with a lot of those. A claim could sit in the unprocessed stage for months due to VF failures (basically information the system didn't recognise or couldn't verify) and the call centres lacked the functionality to clear these so they would have to be referred to back office staff, again this had a massive worklist so would take ages to be cleared. Initially Working Tax Credit was paid via employers, we told them how much to pay and they added it to the employees wages then claimed it back. A lot of employers didn't properly understand this so paid the wrong amount or didn't pay it at all, some didn't want the hassle so would tell the employee to request manual payments from us, others would do things like dock the Working Tax Credits for all sorts of (not allowed) reasons.

We used to get accountants calling in who thought they knew the system better than us. We had a name for them. It wasn't complimentary.

depthdespair · 18/07/2021 11:34

I was talking to somebody the other day who said they were struggling to pay their bills. They are single with no children and earn $110k/year Angry

OneDayIWillBeOrganised · 18/07/2021 11:33

@OlympicProcrastinator

In a good school these things would be done in a way that is not obvious. Who knows whether you paid for the hoodie, school trip etc other than the school and parent

The office staff. And if you think they don’t treat you differently, just look at some of the comments on here. People from all walks of life think ‘that parent is just making the wrong choices’ ‘that parent if just a benefit scrounger. That parent should get a better paid job’ etc etc.

When you have so much shit to deal with you just don’t need anyone else’s judgment or pity. Some people don’t care. For others it’s just too much to deal with.

I did say 'in a good school'. Sadly not the case in all schools but the same could be said about how many other places don't treat people with respect, eg, drs receptionists (not all - I have experienced fantastic ones and the not so good!)
Iluvfriends · 18/07/2021 11:33

Being 'skint' has different meanings to people. To me (i've been there) that's having not a penny, no savings, no overdraft or credit card.....absolutely no access to money.
To a friend it's having a few hundred left after buying £150 jeans, £80 tshirt and £500 to menage that month. No i'm sorry but that's an insult to those who really are skint.

sempiternal · 18/07/2021 11:32

I agree. I also think it's silly when people comment to say that their income is similar to the OP's and they're fine so the OP must be doing something wrong. It's not just about income, it's about expenditure too! Rents vary massively for a start, along with council tax and water rates. There's very little you can do about that without moving to a cheaper area- which I know is often suggested, but really isn't that straightforward.

Then there's those that think people just need to work harder if they want to earn more money. It's like they're suggesting that those on minimum wage don't work hard, and those earning millions do. We all know that's absolutely not the case!

NailsNeedDoing · 18/07/2021 11:32

@icecolddrinks

But they are singled out.

They are identified as pupil premium students and different schools spend this money differently but it always involves singling out.

They are not singled out in a way that is noticed by anyone who doesn’t need to know for the child’s own benefit. The school staff working directly with a child will know if they are pupil premium, but that doesn’t tell us whether the parents are on benefits now or not, seeing as children who have been on FSMs are considered to be pupil premium for six years after their parents stop being eligible. Other children that are considered PP are adopted, or looked after, or from service families. There’s isn’t a separate list of children whose parents are struggling in benefits, and the only reason teaching staff would know that a child is PP is because they are held accountable for their education, so need to know of the potential barriers to learning.

The is no need for anyone to be put off claiming help they are entitled to though schools. The end goal of both the school and the parent is to do the best they can for the child.

BoredZelda · 18/07/2021 11:32

It’s not just in a b&b as @LemonRoses inferred.

She didn't infer all people in poverty live in B&Bs. She clearly gave a situational example.

Kolo · 18/07/2021 11:31

Just wanted to say that your child would NOT be treated differently at all.
A teacher would only be aware if they looked it up for data reasons. Please, please, anyone reading this who might be in a similar situation, apply!

Absolutely! One school I worked at, in one of the most deprived areas of UK, had a real problem with parents who were eligible for FSM not applying for it. We were desperate to encourage them to apply for a number of reasons, one of them being that we could attract more funding the more FSM we had.

wedswench · 18/07/2021 11:29

@LegoCaltrops

We've been absolutely stony broke. More than once. Certainly couldn't have afforded botox. Can't afford a car, despite living in a town where there is a fairly basic bus service & we're 2 miles from the train station. And I'm disabled. And DH uses a stick to walk.

When I was on maternity leave our joint income was my maternity pay plus child benefit. We were approximately £150 a month short of being able to pay our rent & bills. Without even considering the question of food. DH had lost his job & because I was employed & technically on full time hours, he wasn't entitled to any jobseekers benefit. We weren't entitled to anything else for the same reason. I got to the limit of my overdraft before my maternity leave ended, the rent bounced & I had to borrow the money. Lied to the bank about my return to work date so I could get a loan in order to pay the rent. Took a year to pay it back. 4 years to pay off the credit card we'd been using to pay for food, I did manage to switch it to 0% after I returned to work so it wasn't accruing further interest. DH lost weight as he didn't eat properly most days, we often went to the supermarket just before closing & if there was stuff knocked down to 10p, we got that - bread, vegetables etc, occasionally meat or tins. Sometimes there wasn't anything. He made me eat more as I was BFing DD. But we couldn't really afford food & had to go to the food bank which is run by the CAB here. They usually give 3 days of food but it was Christmas & they sent us home with a massive bag & another enormous box of food, enough for absolutely weeks because they couldn't believe how completely screwed we were financially. We just weren't entitled to any help at all.

We were homeless last year. Our LL sold our house. No-one would touch us, due to not having 2 incomes. DH was working FT at the time.

DH hasn't had new clothes in years, except for shoes. Occasionally his parents turn up with something they've found at a car boot sale. Sometimes it fits. His 1 jacket he wears for work & job interviews came from a charity shop for about £5 & I repaired the ripped lining.

I think many people think there are cutbacks to be made. If you've already cut everything back to the bone, there's nothing left.

Thank you for sharing Flowers
OlympicProcrastinator · 18/07/2021 11:27

In a good school these things would be done in a way that is not obvious. Who knows whether you paid for the hoodie, school trip etc other than the school and parent

The office staff. And if you think they don’t treat you differently, just look at some of the comments on here. People from all walks of life think ‘that parent is just making the wrong choices’ ‘that parent if just a benefit scrounger. That parent should get a better paid job’ etc etc.

When you have so much shit to deal with you just don’t need anyone else’s judgment or pity. Some people don’t care. For others it’s just too much to deal with.

OneDayIWillBeOrganised · 18/07/2021 11:26

@icecolddrinks

No of course not.

But someone has said children on FSM aren’t singled out. They are.

Positive singling out is still being singled out. That’s really humiliating for some people. And even just being known as someone claiming FSM is for some people.

It's only the school and parent that knows. If you think that it's humiliating that the school knows then there's no solution for that really- they have to know. Most schools work hard to make sure there is no noticeable difference in how the children are treated regardless of circumstance (PP LAC etc). If it is just down to personal pride I guess there's no solution for that either 🤷
Kolo · 18/07/2021 11:26

@Soberanne

Sorry but for most benefits is not enough to live on. Like i previously stated, i work full time and get tax credits. I have one child. My rent is not covered and i get minimum tax credits. I get no CT rebate nor do i get free school Meals. I dont have any debt, but by week 3 of the month i have nothing left. Please dont tell me to find another job as i am the person looking after everyone elses kids so they can get to work. If i was paid a decent wage like so many others including carers i wouldnt need to live in poverty nor rely on benifits.
👏🏼
x2boys · 18/07/2021 11:26

I remember being on a, thread about people buying goods at places like bright house, some posters just didn't understand how some people don't have savings as surely everybody can afford to put a few pounds away a week, I tried explaining that yes on payday I could put a few pounds away, but come the end of the month, when I have no money in the bank and it's a couple of days before payday, my kids still need feeding, so I'm going to use the few pounds to buy food.

Swipe left for the next trending thread