Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of MN don’t know what having no money means

531 replies

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 09:42

And that admitting to having none is humiliating.

I see it here all the time. Someone has no money. Someone suggests something to make life easier. The person says again they have no money. MN suggest a cheaper version.

On the thread about dress up so many people were saying to tell the school.

I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?

OP posts:
TheQueef · 18/07/2021 12:28

Oh wind it in Twins you are the example talked about in the OP.

Porcupineintherough · 18/07/2021 12:27

Not only is poverty relative, people's ideas of what constitutes it are relative. I've known some people who feel they live in poverty who are better off than those who consider themselves to be "just getting by".

There is undoubtedly real poverty in the UK but - other than the street homeless- there is far less absolute poverty than is common in many parts of the world (this is a good thing). What there is is lots of huge, in your face, inequality which must be difficult to live with.

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 12:26

Not everyone on benefits gets the same.

Thank you for pointing this out. As an accountant, I sort of get that. And factor in the relevance to my ressponses that people get different amounts. They get what is right for their situation in their area. So whilst someone in London gets more than someone in Norwich, they don't actually benefit more, it's already been accounted for.

Many people live in areas where the benefit cap makes a huge difference, and they have to use money supposed to be for living expenses towards the rent

Yes but the rent is based on the average for that style of property in that area. The average. For their specific area.

or they have massive debts

"I'm poor because I have massive debts" means you've chosen to borrow beyond your means, and need debt management.

or are sanctioned by the job centre for ridiculous reasons

They aren't ridiculous reasons. They stop the system being abused

or are being financially abused by their spouse

Which is horrible, but not one that benefits factor in, there are other organisations to help

or are bound into contracts they took out before they hit hard times etc etc

Yes, and companies can be very reasonable, they are often very accommodating with reduced payment plans etc.

You see, I've heard it all from every angle. And the truth is, it's down to the person. I'm an accountant, (well, SAHM at the mo) DH is an insolvency practitioner. We have so much experience in this. And the same situation, two people will manage very differently. Some won't take any accountability. Feel entitled that they should live beyond what they can afford. There's a big "I deserve" culture. Or excusing their choices. Yes, there's the odd exception. But it's the odd exception

EleanorOlephantisjustfine · 18/07/2021 12:24

I’d have more sympathy if the “I have no money” types didn’t smoke, drink or have sky. I’m sure there are many people who have no money and people who struggle on a monthly basis to balance their money, but in my experience it was often more a case of priorities being skewed. Ie no money for school trips but had nails done every week. No money for book day but drinks like a fish etc etc. Unfortunately it’s the children who suffer.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 12:21

That must have been horrible @FreshFancyFrogglette Flowers

OP posts:
Mummy1232016 · 18/07/2021 12:21

@TwinsandTrifle

"I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?*

For me, two things. Firstly, from having to claim benefits myself and astounded at the amount I was given. We literally lived no differently to when I was in full time work.

The second. I had no money, one month. The clutch went in my car. I had "3p" in the bank that month. What I can't understand is how people only ever have 3p in the bank continually.

So my view, is that I know what you receive, I wasn't special, that's what I received too. I know what average bills are, and if consistently you are left with 3p, then it is not down to lack of initial money, but your own choices on what you've done with it.

The odd month with a surprise large expense can't be helped. The rest of the year? It's down to personal choices. Some months I'd have £300-400 to just spend on whatever, after all bills and food. That's a huge amount. And it wasn't like we lived like misers.

So yes, because of having been in that exact position, and knowing how very easy it was, I question what made me so "lucky" when some people swear they are so hard done by.

But you’re not in ‘the exact’ same condition to pass the judgment you’ve just made there are you? Your post is just another way of summing up what OP is saying
Soberanne · 18/07/2021 12:21

Is being an accountant really of more value to society that someone who meets the needs of our most vulnerable in society. Or should we be as valued as each other for doing very different jobs.

FreshFancyFrogglette · 18/07/2021 12:20

100%!! my daughter was invited to a play with a school friend at the last minute, and i said she could go (didnt think much of it, i guess i assumed it was free), but after id said yes the friends mum then turned around and said "you can transfer me the money" (about £8). i was mortified, not only did i have no money left for the month, i was over my overdraft limit, so in order to do a transfer would've had to pay off bank charges first, so i couldnt even borrow it from anywhere. i had to end up owing it to her, and it was really embarrassing. if she had mentioned the cost when she asked then i wouldve said no and made up an excuse. it baffled me a bit, because its a different world, if i was asking one of my family/friends kids to something the first thing i would say is can you afford it, because i wouldnt want to leave them owing out something that they couldnt affiord!!

Soberanne · 18/07/2021 12:19

@Iquitit i absolutely agree and those shouting retrain, or go to college, how exactly are we going to pay for it, by taking out huge student loans with no guarantee of jobs meaning that we will be further in debt.
Absolutely no respect or consideration in our country for the thousands of people working long hours in piss poor conditions to barely afford to live, to then be accused of being poor with money is highly insulting. The very people who were out there during lock down keeping the whole country moving. We dont want paid for nothing we want paid a decent wage for doing the jobs we are doing. Rather than telling us lot to go retrain as if there is no value in the job why not pay us what we deserve for providing society with a worthwhile, needed valuable service.

IcedSpice · 18/07/2021 12:17

@icecolddrinks

But perhaps the non pride diet sticks in the throat too much.
well if its a choice between food and pride (and feeding my dc) I'll have the food thanks
Bunnyfuller · 18/07/2021 12:16

There’s no obligation to buy a teacher anything. I hate our culture, turning everything into needing to mark it with something material. A home-made card is lovely.

The posts I see here pleading poverty seem to be a call to get posters to send money. Suggestion after suggestion is made and dismissed immediately. The fact that MN has a rider ‘only give what you can afford’ is a nod to acknowledging this practice goes on. There have been times I have been desperate for money. Going to an online forum and telling everyone is not how I deal with it. I’d be saving the electricity from charging devices, for a start! Or following some of the hundreds of threads posted about ways to budget and ways to make a bit extra money. No, not for tomorrow, but there are emergency provisions in place for those type of scenarios.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 12:16

People sometimes bull shit.

OP posts:
melodypondisasuperhero · 18/07/2021 12:15

I'm very surprised about the earlier benefits calculation. I'm funnily enough also a qualified accountant though you don't really need to be to work a benefits calculator. I just ran one to check if we were both unemployed; 2 adults, 1 child. After rent costs we would have £660.58 to pay for all bills, food, transport to look for jobs etc. I'm not saying it's impossible but it certainly wouldn't be easy.

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 12:13

The problem on here is for every thread by a truly skint/desperate poster down to their last 3p, who has tried everything, there are as many by
a) people who drip feed in various details that reveal they are in fact not really budgeting that tightly
b) people who are very skint but are given really good advice eg often arent getting all the benefits they are entitled to, and spend the whole thread whinging but ignoring the good advice

Welcome to my world.

"I'm so poor" You wouldnt be if you weren't blowing money on xyz, let's look at addressing that. (But...my car!....my three dogs...my one night out to socialize) I appreciate it means making sacrifices, often because you're in a position out of your control, but it's your choice. If you insist you have to, eg, keep three dogs and all their expenses, and it's £200 a month, then you're choosing that. Pets are not essentials when money is distributed to you. Whether you like it or not. It's fact.

"I can't afford my rent" Didn't you also just get back from Greece Hmm (usually met with aghast looks that the DC should have been denied their holiday) Rent a smaller place. "There's nowhere" (I will open Rightmove and find three pages of alternatives) "I don't want to live there"

"I've got no money" ah, you're eligible for xyz, this is how you claim. "I'm not shaming myself with benefits." ..... right, your choice. "I'm soooo poor!" Yes, hence the benefits available to you.

33feethighandrising · 18/07/2021 12:12

@TwinsandTrifle

"I know debt and low incomes aren’t ideal but they aren’t uncommon either so why is it so hard to acknowledge that someone might have 3p in their bank account and no money?*

For me, two things. Firstly, from having to claim benefits myself and astounded at the amount I was given. We literally lived no differently to when I was in full time work.

The second. I had no money, one month. The clutch went in my car. I had "3p" in the bank that month. What I can't understand is how people only ever have 3p in the bank continually.

So my view, is that I know what you receive, I wasn't special, that's what I received too. I know what average bills are, and if consistently you are left with 3p, then it is not down to lack of initial money, but your own choices on what you've done with it.

The odd month with a surprise large expense can't be helped. The rest of the year? It's down to personal choices. Some months I'd have £300-400 to just spend on whatever, after all bills and food. That's a huge amount. And it wasn't like we lived like misers.

So yes, because of having been in that exact position, and knowing how very easy it was, I question what made me so "lucky" when some people swear they are so hard done by.

Wow, the ignorance in this post.

Not everyone on benefits gets the same.

Many people live in areas where the benefit cap makes a huge difference, and they have to use money supposed to be for living expenses towards the rent, or they have massive debts, or are sanctioned by the job centre for ridiculous reasons, or are being financially abused by their spouse, or are bound into contracts they took out before they hit hard times etc etc.

Your lack of imagination together with your lack of empathy is a poisonous combination.

FreekStar2 · 18/07/2021 12:10

@1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor

If you are on such a low income and a carer then why do you not get any benefits?

Iquitit · 18/07/2021 12:10

@Soberanne

Sorry but for most benefits is not enough to live on. Like i previously stated, i work full time and get tax credits. I have one child. My rent is not covered and i get minimum tax credits. I get no CT rebate nor do i get free school Meals. I dont have any debt, but by week 3 of the month i have nothing left. Please dont tell me to find another job as i am the person looking after everyone elses kids so they can get to work. If i was paid a decent wage like so many others including carers i wouldnt need to live in poverty nor rely on benifits.
Well said, I'd also add that the people who trot out retrain or go to college, get a better job etc are so shortsighted it laughable. If they all did tomorrow, who do you think is going to do those jobs? There'll be replacements and they'll be paid too little to live on too, so in the bigger picture, what exactly has been solved?

The problem is the piss poor wage paid for doing these jobs, not the fact people are doing them. They are needed jobs, jobs that society would be fucked without, because you'd all be at home looking after your own kids and elderly and vulnerable family members instead of having that 'better job'. You'd have not been able to 'work hard' to achieve what you have. People like me and the quoted poster enable that to happen for so many people, yet are accused of poor spending habits, making excuses, laziness and lack of ambition when we struggle with the cost of living compared to what we earn.
To admit that though, means they are complicit in it all, no one seems to have a problem using elderly or child care for example so they can go out there, or a problem with the price they pay (unless it's moaning it's too much) but they do like to condescend to those doing those jobs and write them off as lazy, uninspired spendthrifts.

icecolddrinks · 18/07/2021 12:09

@Kolo I think the problem is that while that’s all true on a general level, it’s also understandable that people might not want that particular label attached to their child or family.

I would certainly find it easier to say ‘these dress up days are ridiculous’ from a point of view of being middle class and fairly well to do than say it because I couldn’t afford it.

OP posts:
Soberanne · 18/07/2021 12:08

@1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor your situation sounds really difficult but clearly shows that life is not straight forward and no not everyone who should be, is getting support.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/07/2021 12:07

YABU. People don't necessarily tell the truth about themselves on social media, and you don't know what baggage people are carrying around with them.

I live in a situation now which I'm aware would be described as privileged. I've worked hard for it - but others have also worked hard and with less recompense. My DH and I are both senior professionals. We are also from modest backgrounds; both of us went through university and built our way up in our careers without any financial leg-up whatsoever from our families, and with very little emotional support let alone financial (I did have the former from my mother, but she sadly died young).

My father was an abusive alcoholic who drank most of the family's budget. My mother was virtually scruffy: she had no new clothes for years until my grandparents bought her a new wardrobe. My sibling and I were well-turned out purely because she made all our clothes.

We were on free school meals for years. We have also been in intensive trauma therapy as adults as a result of what our father put us through. We rarely had holidays or treats of any kind: those we did have were courtesy of our loving maternal grandparents.

Looking at my life now you'd likely never guess it. But I know exactly what it feels like when your family doesn't have two pennies to rub together.

There are many kinds of poverty. Not all are them fiscal.

exhaustedallthetime · 18/07/2021 12:04

When I grew up I lived in social housing and came from a single parent family (the other parent didn’t contribute ever financially) there was never spare money, I went without a lot, including shoes and clothes that were always too small. Food was basic and wasn’t hugely nutritionally and we rarely had fruit.

I can relate to all of this. My Dad raised me as a single parent. I remember everything in our kitchen cupboards being that brand that Kwik Save used to do - "No Frills" I think? All the packaging was just white with black writing on it, from the cereal boxes to the tins of beans. You opened our cupboards and it was just a sea of black and white, couldn't tell what anything was. I still remember to this day eating the same basic things for tea every night because my Dad had so little money and no idea how to cook nutritious meals. It makes me appreciate very much where I am in life now, with a good job, nice car and savings. It's definitely no resemblance to the background I came from that's for sure.

Kolo · 18/07/2021 12:03

@icecolddrinks

I didn’t mean it was a nationwide thing *@Kolo* sorry - was thinking of different schools I know. They are all different which does mean mn is hard sometimes as you get posters insisting that this is how it’s spent and don’t realise every school is different!

As a general point though I do find that many schools use FSM as a sign of social deprivation which of course it is in a general sense but on an individual level I understand people not wanting their child labelled.

It's is used as an indicator of social deprivation. For one thing, schools are compared to 'similar' schools for their progress and achievement, as you'll know as a secondary teacher. Another of the reasons my school was so desperate to increase the uptake of FSM was because we always felt we were unfairly compared to schools with similar FSM rates, although we knew our intake was more deprived than our FSM rate indicated. Suspect that's a problem nationally, though, for reasons you've stated.

I've worked in a couple of different 'types' of catchment. One thing that I really noticed was that the more deprived the area, the more willing the parents were to contribute to school trips. You know you have to send the letter out with the paragraph saying (paraphrasing here) "it is not compulsory to contribute, but the trip won't go ahead without a certain level of contributions"? It did surprise me how the wealthier catchments seemed much happier to not contribute than the poorer catchments.

RosesAndHellebores · 18/07/2021 12:03

DS once said he didn't want to do dress up day and then changed his mind at bedtime. "With that notice boy, the only option is to go as Mowgli, ie, pretty much starkers. So we ripped an old pair of shorts a bit, dirtied him up with mud from the garden and sent him in with a copy of The Jungle Book. He got a prize for that! It was a warm day BTW and he did have a t shirt.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 18/07/2021 12:02

YANBU, if I say "I have no money" then I mean it, I have 2 autistic adult children that I'm feeding and clothing as well as keeping a roof over all our heads, I am not entitled to benefits and I have an income of just over £1000 per month, I cannot increase my hours at work because there are currently no extra hours available, both of my adult children are in full time education so not entitled to benefits, neither of them could cope with working while studying, neither of them are likely to work full time anyway.

People have told me to look for a full time job, but if I do that I would not be able to give ds as much support as he needs with college, that in turn would make life at home more difficult and would cause us all so much stress (for different reasons) and when I explain why they say "get a weekend/evening job then".

Nothing is ever that easy.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/07/2021 12:01

Might add to my pp that I was once very cross with an early 20s dd, who told me she ‘didn’t care’ about money.

As I very tartly replied, that was because she had absolutely no idea of what it was like to have no money , and no means of begging or borrowing any.