Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where are kids supposed to play?

338 replies

lazylump72 · 18/07/2021 08:05

Hi
I am having a bit of a barny with my DH and well quite frankly he is trying to be thoughtful of the neighbours etc and he does work 12 he shifts but
whilst I do think he has a point and I might be being a bit unreasonable
I don't know how to approach this so thought I would see from the wise mumsnetters where you stand on this,All suggestions will be helpful!
So it's the start of the school holidays,beautiful weather,garden full of toys and pool out,happy days!This is the first year our DD 9 yes has has friends on our estate and it's wonderful.Thereis a little group of 5 and they get on amazingly and play really well,They have been round our house in the garden playing for a week,They are safe and enclosed and well a bit demanding and noisy.I get this,I do I have to sit and listen to it but they are having such a Fab time safely and under supervision I have no issues except I will try to shut them up when it gets too loud! Now I am the one listening to it all day not DH he is at work but he gets home and the garden is full of kids and he doesn;t want it, I am trying to find a balance here but what do I do? There is nowhere else for the kids to play,I don't want them out on the road it's not safe,I don't mind them here really.Its not ideal for the neighbours either but it's summer,.Am I being the neighbours from hell? Where do your kids and their friends play? Given there ages of 8 and 9 years Ithought I was doing the right thing...am I? Do people expect quiet between 11 and 7 ish? I know it's a pain hearing kids for a lot of people but where do you all stand on this?

OP posts:
Bythehairywartsonmywitchychin · 18/07/2021 10:51

Your DD’s friends are taking advantage of your kind nature and free childcare. You need to set some boundaries as other posters have mentioned.

I’d send them home at every meal and snack time. I’d also perhaps let your DD go call on the nearest child after every meal and snack time, or let her meet them somewhere neutral so they aren’t all coming back to your house. This might break the habit of them always being at your house.

Whoopsmahoot · 18/07/2021 10:49

I see both sides- it’s brill to hear the kids having a great time laughing and carrying on. I also was in this position but came to realise that the other parents were taking the piss too - why should they have hassle if some other parent is willing to do their baby sitting and feeding their kids? Also the WFH for neighbors would b an issue for them. Encourage the use of parks and def have a phone. Keep having them but don’t let other parents take advantage.

FlyingBattie · 18/07/2021 10:47

If you are happy to have them round, the easy solution would be they are gone before your husband gets back, surely?

NooNotJohnAmaechi · 18/07/2021 10:45

This would absolutely drive me mad. I don't mind a quiet hum of noise but relentless screeching and squealing gets my back up. And some of these stories about what are essentially 'party houses' and playing up and down the street I'd bet not all neighbours were so enthusiastic for those antics.

5lilducks · 18/07/2021 10:43

Lots of great advice on here OP and I've not got anything to add but just wanted to say you sound lovely Flowers

areyouadogperson · 18/07/2021 10:41

I always have an open house for my kids friends and would likely feed them lunch too. That’s not all day every day. You need to send them home. I’d likely be ok with an extra sandwich but I’d certainly be sending them home half 4/5 to their own properties. You are unpaid childcare. No wonder the other parents aren’t chipping in to take a turn.

You are being taken for a mug.

When do you want mine for the day tomorrow 😂

Daenerys77 · 18/07/2021 10:38

If you want to run a free holiday club/child care service, it's a matter for you-though I think you are being exploited. If the kids are too noisy tell them to STFU and if they don't, eject them from your garden.

RaraRachael · 18/07/2021 10:35

This used to happen to us all the time as we had the biggest garden in the street. The kids didn't wait to be invited - they just turned up every day until I'd had enough. None of the other parents took a turn as they probably saw me as the free childminder (teacher, so I'd all the time in the world and obviously had nothing better to do). Eventually I said that they couldn't come any more unless their parents took a turn - they all just played in their own gardens after that and I got peace Grin

StapMe · 18/07/2021 10:28

Screechy and screamy kids in the neighbours' gardens do my head in anyway, let alone when a person has to work from home. Kids can - and should be - taught to play reasonably quietly, ask any night shift worker! And these days, any home worker too. What happened to good old fashioned consideration for other folk?

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 18/07/2021 10:22

@mm8989

I host like you OP, but a more toned down version. Once or twice a week for a group of 4 and a single friend twice a week at most. (school holidays) I make sure they leave before five. your husband doesn't deserve to come home to it (especially as he has stated he doesn't like it)

But as the poster above said there's lots fun had in our garden and the children will always remember that. Plus I have lots of happy memories.

As children we played out on the street, we can't do that here, so I host. Just get some boundaries in.

This sounds like an excellent balance Wink
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 18/07/2021 10:21

@warmfluffytowels

If you live in a residential street, the kids playing outside or in your garden will make zero difference. As a parent your husband needs to put the needs of his child and happiness first.

Of course it makes a difference - if they're playing in the street, you don't have to pay for their food, drink and ice cream for the entire summer.

Agree. And there needs to be a balance surely? To just put the child's needs and happiness first every time is not necessarily a healthy attitude
megletthesecond · 18/07/2021 10:20

I wasn't drinking cocktails when mine were out in neighbours gardens. I was always trying to tidy up before mine got back and trashed the place again.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/07/2021 10:20

The other parents are taking you for a mug I’m afraid. Is your garden more child-friendly, with paddling pool etc.?

I don’t think it’d hurt to say now and then, ‘I think it’s time you all went and played in someone else’s garden - Daddy would like a bit of P and Q sometimes.’

Though having said that, unless they’re doing that appalling high-pitched screaming (enough to make anyone murderous IMO, and def. shouldn’t be happening with kids of 9 ish) it doesn’t sound too bad. . If they are, it needs to be banned PDQ - anyone who screams goes straight home.

jerometheturnipking · 18/07/2021 10:19

We're on an estate and the kids from about 6 upwards all play out. Sometimes they'll spend some time in one of the gardens but normally they're all at the wee park with their footballs/bikes/scooters. It's evolved to the point where there's now a "kids" group chat that the mums are all on so we can say "x y and z are in my garden, give me a shout if you need them sent home", "b is at his gran's today and I'm on nightshift so can you tell the kids not to come knocking on him today" or whatever.

Other than the group chat element of it, it feels very 90s. The kids are just "out" and they know that the mums can contact each other so that generally prevents any issues with fall outs/taking the mick with their behaviour.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 18/07/2021 10:19

To those posters declaring how wonderful it is to be the house the kids flock to and are provided with a free holiday club ... a huge difference this summer and for those in the foreseeable future, there are likely to be many neighbours WFH.

Do they not deserve any consideration?

Fretfulagain · 18/07/2021 10:18

I agree with your plan to get to know the other parents better, they aren’t necessarily taking the piss, kids love being at someone else’s house and likely they’ve been saying to parents ‘no it’s fine, x’s Mum doesn’t mind and she’s got the pool out and everything’ when they say ‘are you sure x’s mum is ok to have you again?’. They might be nice and you could find some new friends too - not impossible that you can figure out a sharing plan and one have kids while another hosts a coffee break - might be good! Don’t assume the worst just yet. I’d be suggesting a WhatsApp group and take it from there.

Plus, on the neighbour issue, I was so grateful to have considerate neighbours who took their bbq friends indoors before 11:30 last night, I’ve had a tough week with a very unwell parent and couldn’t face a sleepless night - so just a reminder that close neighbours could be going through stuff, you just don’t know so a bit of consideration goes a long way.

Good luck!

Topseyt · 18/07/2021 10:10

I'm with your DH. I certainly wouldn't want to come home from work to a garden full of random neighbourhood children.

You are also allowing yourself to be taken for a mug. Stop feeding them regularly. Send them home when it suits you. Just say something like "DD will be having her lunch now, so time to go home for your own."

In the afternoon suggest that DD will be available from say 2pm and will come along herself to knock for them. Then you will be happy for her to play at theirs, go to the park etc. and you will come and call for her when her dinner is ready later.

I know it is hard, but I sometimes had to do this. My DD2 was rather a soft touch and easily manipulated by the neighbourhood children. Some of them I literally had to turf out of my house as they didn't seem to have to go at any time. One even said she would sit in the kitchen corner and wait while we had our evening meal. I told her that it was time to go home now as she left me no other choice.

Boysnme · 18/07/2021 10:09

@lazylump72 my DS is just turned 10 and has been allowed to go out and about around the house for the last couple of years. This year he got a phone so we now allow him to go a bit further with his friends.

Same as another poster, unless he is coming from or going to a friends house, he must be with a friend at all times. He’s loving his freedom and they all go between all of our houses so not one of us constantly has the noise in our garden.

I do send them home at lunch though, mainly because we are wfh so it’s better to only have to deal with our own kids then but they all just meet back up after it.

We have a tracker app on his phone as well so we can always check where he is. It is difficult to learn to give them their freedom just make sure she knows what to do if a situation were to arise.

saraclara · 18/07/2021 10:07

Also there's a lot of unconscious sexism, lots of thinking if the poor husband

No. There's sympathy for the poor PERSON who has to get up at 4am, do a 12 hour shift, and come home at 7:30pm to a garden full of excitable kids.
It wouldn't matter which sex they were. In fact if this OP was reversed with the mother being the one in that position, she'd get even more sympathy.

HerMammy · 18/07/2021 10:07

So the other kids in the group go off on scooters and your DD gets kept in?
If you don’t relax she will soon lose her friends as they get independent and your DD is tied to mummy.
The take over the lounge was the 🙄 moment for me, you’re allowing a group of kids to take over your home and garden, no wonder your DH is pissed off.
Let her go out to play, as in out of the garden!!

TSSDNCOP · 18/07/2021 10:06

Apologies OP, I crossed posts.

May I have the extra egg for my face please?

Anotheruser02 · 18/07/2021 10:04

@lazylump72

The food thing too ..when Iam doing my daughter lunch if there are kids here I couldn't just give her lunch I would feel mean so as do one lunch I knock up the same for who ever is here, Its not a money issue it's fine to do that I think some kids must end up with 2 lunches but their parents didn't seem to mind,if they did they didn't say anything! I have decided to let them play a few hours and let my daughter go with them to their houses with her new phone \i\ am going to buy today and give her a bit of freedom like they have and get to know the parents better and ask if they would keep an eye on my daughter when she is at their end of the estate and I will do the same when they are up our way, This should give our lovely neighbours some peace and me to be honest and Iwill learn how to give my daughter some freedoms too,She would love to go out with them on the bikes and scooters it's been me that said no and Isee how Ihave been holding her back.It was done with the best intentions though but I will address my issues over the summer with regards to my daughter being allowed a bit more space. And as for the husband..an apology is in order and an extra egg with his chips tonight! He is right I do really see it but I will find it hard to let go a bit but will do my best,,,,its going to be a long summer I think with lessons being learned for both me and my daughter! Thank you all so much for your views I really appreciate it,
That sounds like a plan. Sorry I crossed posts with you there. My point was mainly to people suggesting the other parents are cheeky, I bet they would be happy to have the kids in too but that is all reliant on your DD turning up at their door.
Notaroadrunner · 18/07/2021 10:04

@lazylump72

Well that's what I hoped but sadly the other parents don;t seem to want this.The other parents all seem happy to let them be here but never have them. It's disappointing and I don;t want a full summer of being childminder and being known as that house on the street either but it's so lovely to have my DD have friends and being happy outside,
Well it looks like you are setting yourself up for a summer of unpaid childminding. Nip it in the bud now. You a being very foolish as next thing you know Mary's mother will text you to say she's just nipping into town for a couple of hours and telling you she'll see Mary later, or Kate's dad will call dropping her off and saying he's just off out to the barber but will be back shortly - he'll be back about 3 hours later. Meanwhile you are left entertaining and feeding these kids. Send your dd round to their houses and tell her they cannot play in your garden all the time. I don't blame your Dh - the last thing I'd want after a days work is to come home to a garden full of other people's kids making noise.
TSSDNCOP · 18/07/2021 10:02

If I worked a 12 hour shift I would want to come home to a peaceful house.

Your neighbours will be thrilled they now inadvertently live next door to a childminder.

Whilst all these kids are round at yours, their mothers are sitting in another garden having a lovely time with cocktails.

33feethighandrising · 18/07/2021 10:01

OP, beware listening to Mumsnet too closely on this issue!

Mumsnet is full of some very anti-social people who don't basically don't much like having other people round at all.

Have a look at a thread on having people to stay over. You'll get loads of people saying they hate hosting others, don't feel they should, why can't visiting family stay in a hotel etc etc. I don't know anyone like this in real life, but I suspect the nature of this, an online forum, means you're less likely to get those busy socialising as they're often off out being busy with other people not posting on a forum!

And asking if you're insured?! Give me strength.

Also there's a lot of unconscious sexism, lots of thinking if the poor husband and ignoring the nerds of mothers, we're socialised to out others first and that really comes over IMO.

If it suits you to have the local kids over and you feel it benefits your DC, please don't be put off.

Yes, it's wise not to get into a position where everyone expects it and you feel you can't say no, but if you want to in the daytime,why not, as long as neighbours aren't upset by it. Do you know them well enough to ask?

As for when your DH gets home I think he's being entirely unreasonable if he expects to never see other DC when he gets home. Part of being a parent is dealing with other people's DC, and putting your DC first!

If he wants some peace and quiet and family time that's nice, and I'm sure you can come to a compromise where this is happening on a regular basis, but if what he wants is for you to deal with things related to children and him to be lord of the household where his needs are put above others,he need to get with the times!