Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To ask if the term Mixed-Race is outdated

466 replies

CambridgeEntry2022 · 18/07/2021 00:42

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms. Would it be more appropriate to use the term multi racial?

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 19/07/2021 15:52

All those terms, Caucasian, white and I don't know what solely belong to a racist world. Nobody referred to Europeans as white until around the time when the slave trade started.

I am proudly a Celt and that has nothing to do with racial purity, which never did exist

SJaneS49 · 19/07/2021 15:14

Obviously @Coyoacan in terms of our origins. Caucasian might be an outdated term I don’t disagree but it’s definition does very much include the Celts.

Coyoacan · 19/07/2021 14:52

@SJaneS49, well you might as well call us Africans then, as that is where we all started out from.

SJaneS49 · 19/07/2021 14:45

@Coyoacan, where on earth do you think the Celts originated from? Central Europe not in Europe then?

Freecuthbert · 19/07/2021 13:54

Racism very much exists and some people experience this as part of their daily lives, and some have lost their lives over this. So claiming everyone is mixed race or that race doesn't exist, we are all human blah blah is rather unhelpful and I would think problematic.

ItPearl · 19/07/2021 13:39

Caucasian is understood to mean white these days though so saying Irish / Welsh people not caucasion (but English people are?) sounds a bit odd. Who cares but in some of those dna tests, they just lump all Great British and Irish dna in to one.

Coyoacan · 19/07/2021 13:02

Welsh and Irish are the same race (white/Caucasian) so no, you are not mixed race

The Welsh and Irish are Celts, not Caucasian and yes, everyone is mixed race.

Ironically enough, when people genuinely from the Caucuses bombed the Boston marathon, they were not considered to be white/Caucasian.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 19/07/2021 12:30

@EllaBlaire I also found that odd! I have a red haired sibling with a recessive gene that appears to be from grandparents/ great grandparents, one with a particularly unusual mix to have auburn hair in Central Asia.
I also have a blue-eyed child. From my understanding it’s the other way round with recessive genes, it’s very very unlikely for two blue eyed people to have a brown eyed child.
Genes though are quirky. My mixed race friends, one of whom is very dark in her skin tone, have 4 children ranging from fair white in appearance to darker than either parent. Same heritage, yet treated differently. Another couple I know who identify as a black, though I understand they have a mix in their heritage, have a blond fair child. He’s already been told in a lesson he isn’t black, which is a headfuck when your sister and parents are viewed as, and call themselves, black. It’s a topic I’ve learnt it be quiet and just listen on, it’s both complicated and very personal to describe someone’s identity. It’s hugely important never to question someone or make an assumption based on skin tone or colouring alone.

Whiskycav · 19/07/2021 11:35

@claralara42 you are so right. Dual heritage is really only a term you should use for yourself. Or use for someone you know well enough to know that's their preferred option.

claralara42 · 19/07/2021 11:09

@wordsareveryunnecessary

My SIL says it is dual heritage. She is herself dual heritage
Then it's dual heritage for her, if she likes. Neither you nor your SIL can say what other people should be using though, especially when it's already been explained that dual heritage is not at all accurate for a lot of mixed race people.
EllaBlaire · 19/07/2021 10:53

@mustlovegin

I think I did not explain myself very well.

The mutated MC1R gene (which needs to be inherited from both parents, as it's recessive) is responsible for red hair colour (and several other characteristics, like skin tone).

So I understand it's not possible for a red-haired (and in particular blue-eyed) person to be what most understand as mixed race (at least in relation to hair, eye and skin colour)

Maybe both the parents are mixed race? Fancy that! There must be more of these exotic types around than you thought!
EllaBlaire · 19/07/2021 10:49

I’m mixed race and I call myself mixed race.

Dual Heritage makes me cringe… “heritage” is such a euphemism when you’re clearly talking about race. It sounds like you’re talking about an heirloom. And dual implies you can only have two “heritages”.

Whiskycav · 19/07/2021 10:43

@mustlovegin

I think I did not explain myself very well.

The mutated MC1R gene (which needs to be inherited from both parents, as it's recessive) is responsible for red hair colour (and several other characteristics, like skin tone).

So I understand it's not possible for a red-haired (and in particular blue-eyed) person to be what most understand as mixed race (at least in relation to hair, eye and skin colour)

Both parents can have the recessive gene and not be the same race.

What do you believe most people understand as mixed race?

Freecuthbert · 19/07/2021 10:34

@mustlovegin

I think I did not explain myself very well.

The mutated MC1R gene (which needs to be inherited from both parents, as it's recessive) is responsible for red hair colour (and several other characteristics, like skin tone).

So I understand it's not possible for a red-haired (and in particular blue-eyed) person to be what most understand as mixed race (at least in relation to hair, eye and skin colour)

Do you not believe my daughter is mixed race then? You insist it's not possible. Confused
wordsareveryunnecessary · 19/07/2021 10:22

My SIL says it is dual heritage. She is herself dual heritage

ancientgran · 19/07/2021 10:11

I used to live near a couple she was Irish he was Afro caribbean. They had 2 daughters and they were both a visible mix of both parents. The older one was tall like dad, black hair like dad, straight hair like mum, facial features like mum, Meghan Markle colouring. The younger one was short like mum, red haired like mum, afro hair like dad, facial features like dad, very pale skin with freckles.

You'd never guess they were sisters but both looked perfectly matched with the parents. I assumed dad had a red haired ancestor.

CecilyP · 19/07/2021 09:55

I'm not sure that is why many black/mixed race people don't like it. For my DH he doesn't want to be an acronym. He finds it rude, dehumanising and it annoys him.

I don’t blame him as it is not a term that should be used for any one individual. However it is useful for statistical purposes eg BAME people suffer discrimination; BAME people are more likely to suffer from certain illnesses etc.

CecilyP · 19/07/2021 09:42

How can a red-haired, blue-eyed person be multiracial? This combination is the most recessive and genes from both parents need to be the same for these characteristics to manifest themselves.

Quite possible if both their parents have one black parent and red-headed parent. It wouldn’t be the most likely colouring but it’s certainly possible.

Brainwave89 · 19/07/2021 09:42

I am Indian, my kids have Indian/British white parentage. Mixed race for us is fine. We also use Eurasian or Anglo Indian. Neither of which we would find offensive. Half Caste definitely would not be unacceptable and coloured is also unacceptable. To posters suggesting colour does not matter and colour should not be discussed I do not agree on a couple of grounds. Firstly, racism is a real tangible issue in the UK as the weekend's events demonstrate. If we do not measure outcomes for against race then we cannot generate actions to address racism. As a mixed race family there can be comedy gold moments where white people feel unable to mention that a person is brown or black. I remember hearing someone needing to speak to my son on a football pitch. He was one of two mixed race players. The white person did not feel comfortable saying yes he is the tall mixed race fellow, so started talking about him being tall, dark haired etc. Oversensitivity feels slightly excluding as well.

mustlovegin · 19/07/2021 09:15

CutePanda I was responding to a PP and highlighting the complexities regarding hair, eye and skin colour in a red-haired person. In this particular instance they are due to a gene mutation which also impacts other areas of physiology (which - in my view- is what the PP should be focusing on in order to better support her child)

CutePanda · 19/07/2021 09:03

@luckylavender

But aren't we all mixed race? I'm Welsh and Irish
Welsh and Irish are the same race (white/Caucasian) so no, you are not mixed race.
CutePanda · 19/07/2021 08:58

@mustlovegin

I think I did not explain myself very well.

The mutated MC1R gene (which needs to be inherited from both parents, as it's recessive) is responsible for red hair colour (and several other characteristics, like skin tone).

So I understand it's not possible for a red-haired (and in particular blue-eyed) person to be what most understand as mixed race (at least in relation to hair, eye and skin colour)

You said they have 38% Saharan African in their DNA. This suggests that a parent or grandparent is African. Did you do one of those sketchy home DNA kits or do you know their family tree? If their parent or grandparent isn’t of a different race then I wouldn’t class your DC as mixed race.
mustlovegin · 19/07/2021 07:56

I think I did not explain myself very well.

The mutated MC1R gene (which needs to be inherited from both parents, as it's recessive) is responsible for red hair colour (and several other characteristics, like skin tone).

So I understand it's not possible for a red-haired (and in particular blue-eyed) person to be what most understand as mixed race (at least in relation to hair, eye and skin colour)

Mummasdiary2021 · 19/07/2021 01:45

@Ursulasunderstudy

You need to use Dual Heritage not mixed race.
No not true. Dual refers to two of something. Every mixed race person isn't a straight simple mix of A+B... They might me a mix of multiple. There is nothing wrong with the term "mixed race". It's not a racial slur or inappropriate etc, it's a fact. The person is a mix-of-races
SourAppleChew · 19/07/2021 01:36

I’m multi ethnic having both Celtic and Anglo Saxon ancestors.