Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To ask if the term Mixed-Race is outdated

466 replies

CambridgeEntry2022 · 18/07/2021 00:42

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms. Would it be more appropriate to use the term multi racial?

OP posts:
Orangecinnamon21 · 18/07/2021 08:17

Hope you have your answer now @CambridgeEntry2022? You can see mixed race people don't have an issue being called mixed race. There are other boards on Mumsnet where you can ask such a question that are perhaps more suitable for such questions AIBU tends to encourage quite inflammatory debate.

bibliomania · 18/07/2021 08:14

In defence of using labels, universities are being encouraged to look at how they're doing in relation to race - are white applicants more likely to be hired and promoted? Are there patterns of concern in relation to student progress and outcomes? What happens during the student journey, eg are black male students. more likely to face disciplinary action due to stereotypes? You can't tackle a problem unless you identify it and you can't identify it unless you put a name to it.

ItsSnowJokes · 18/07/2021 08:09

@PumpkinKlNG

Same people saying black people should be called bame or person of colour yet every single black person I know calls themselves black just like every single mixed race person I know calls themselves mixed race, why do white people keep telling us what terms we should call ourselves 🤨
This!
GraduallyWatermelon · 18/07/2021 08:07

@Ursulasunderstudy

You need to use Dual Heritage not mixed race.
What if you have more than 2 heritages?
bibliomania · 18/07/2021 08:07

Dd is mixed race. I use this term but I get the impression that in a few years it won't be acceptable.

My inclination is to say dd is half x and half y just because it's an unusual mixture and I marvel at how people from different parts of the world came together (no pun intended...) to make her. I realize it would be intrusive and long-winded to expect people to give a run-down of their genealogy (but if they want to, I'm up for it).

KarlUrbansWife · 18/07/2021 08:06

BAME means I look a bit foreign, but you have no idea what kind of foreign. If you're so unsure you have to lump me in other ethnic origins, you probably shouldn't be referring to my ethnic origins in any capacity.

THIS with Bells on. BAME is outdated and incredibly offensive. You're "something other than white, it's not important what". Some so-called corporate diversity champions need to educate themselves before attempting to educate others.

I describe myself as mixed race as do most others. It's not offensive at all.

NCwhatsmynameagain · 18/07/2021 08:04

Don’t understand why mixed race is problematic and I describe myself as such on a regular basis

whistlers · 18/07/2021 08:03

Interesting. Never heard that before.

HmmmmmmInteresting · 18/07/2021 08:03

@whistlers

The term h.... c.... is extremely offensive and has been recognised as such for decades. It is up (or down!) there with the n word.

Is it? Really?

Yes. Really.
ItPearl · 18/07/2021 08:00

I disagree that it's ''white people'' coming up with all the labels. I think it's Americans!

My x MIL who was adopted used to love the label coloured. It fitted, for her, and she kept going with it long after it was unacceptable. I would have felt embarrassed correcting her label to person of colour!

I think the Americans say bi-racial and think that mixed-race is offensive even though logically, the words have the same meaning (except that 'bi' is limiting it to just two, so if you correct somebody who said mixed race and insist that bi racial is the word now it makes an assumption)

whistlers · 18/07/2021 07:59

The term h.... c.... is extremely offensive and has been recognised as such for decades. It is up (or down!) there with the n word.

Is it? Really?

BellH · 18/07/2021 07:57

I agree with the others who say mixed or dual heritage and mixed race are different things, although both can be applicable to some people (e.g. me) they are not equally applicable and sometimes mixed race is applicable but not mixed heritage.

Jasmine11 · 18/07/2021 07:56

@whistlers

I'm more confused after reading this thread!

Can I continue to use mixed race?

If you really need to refer to someone's race on a day to day basis of course you can. As you see from the vast majority of mixed race posters on this thread it's not a problematic term.
BellH · 18/07/2021 07:56

(name changed as this could be outing.)

I'm mixed race.
I'm also a race scholar/researcher and and an antiracist activist.

The term mixed race is most definitely not outdated and is a term many use to describe themselves.

Personally, I used mixed race to describe myself and my children generally (or when talking about race specifically.)

I'd use mixed heritage if that seemed more applicable or relevant to the context. (E.g. maybe talking specifically about migration, nationality, or culture).

The term h.... c.... is extremely offensive and has been recognised as such for decades. It is up (or down!) there with the n word.

Orangecinnamon21 · 18/07/2021 07:55

@FeelingLikeAnAlien

NC’d as potentially outing. One of my white friends called me ‘light skinned’ the other week. As in ‘oo you can wear that as you are light skinned’ Confused. This is a very odd comment and a problematic term for me as I feel it reflects colourist prejudice I.e light skinned black people face less difficulties than dark skinned black people. So it is seen as more desirable to some people. Also I’m mixed and therefore not really ‘light skinned’ but mixed. Not to mention my skin is a lot darker than the friends who made the comment. Apparently it’s a big thing on tiktok now to identify as ‘light skinned’. I prefer mixed myself as I have a range of cultural identities in my family, all with strong identities. I will just stick to mixed personally.
Yeah that is becoming more of a problem in the UK. It's basically saying you're still black, but a bit lighter...but still different and I'm going to let you know. Similar to the 'one drop' rule.
TotorosCatBus · 18/07/2021 07:54

You need to use Dual Heritage not mixed race

That assumes your parents are one heritage each. What happens if your parents are both dual but different heritages?

TotorosCatBus · 18/07/2021 07:52

We were told person of colour, diverse racial or enriched racial background.

Are there white people with jobs where they have to twist themselves into knots thinking of ways that people might be insulted by the English language ?

If so it's so easily sorted by talking to non-white people or hiring them to do this job in the first place. Maybe they can start compiling lists of what words can be kept rather than which ones need to be replaced.

Enriched is bizarre. It suggests that it is superior to being from one race. Person of colour is an American term that I increasingly hear or see and I find it strange since there is so such a wide range of colours that people in this category could be and it suggests that white people are colourless which is strange.

whistlers · 18/07/2021 07:50

@FeelingLikeAnAlien

NC’d as potentially outing. One of my white friends called me ‘light skinned’ the other week. As in ‘oo you can wear that as you are light skinned’ Confused. This is a very odd comment and a problematic term for me as I feel it reflects colourist prejudice I.e light skinned black people face less difficulties than dark skinned black people. So it is seen as more desirable to some people. Also I’m mixed and therefore not really ‘light skinned’ but mixed. Not to mention my skin is a lot darker than the friends who made the comment. Apparently it’s a big thing on tiktok now to identify as ‘light skinned’. I prefer mixed myself as I have a range of cultural identities in my family, all with strong identities. I will just stick to mixed personally.
Tik tok is huge on the light skinned memes
ItPearl · 18/07/2021 07:49

@Ursulasunderstudy

You need to use Dual Heritage not mixed race.
But that's not to do with race! Irish American or Italian American would be ''dual heritage''
Hobbitfeet32 · 18/07/2021 07:48

Mixed race and refer to myself as mixed race as I have done all my life. Not offensive.
I would be offended if someone wrote that I ‘identified’ as being mixed race because that would be inaccurate. I am mixed race.

FeelingLikeAnAlien · 18/07/2021 07:48

NC’d as potentially outing.
One of my white friends called me ‘light skinned’ the other week. As in ‘oo you can wear that as you are light skinned’ Confused.
This is a very odd comment and a problematic term for me as I feel it reflects colourist prejudice I.e light skinned black people face less difficulties than dark skinned black people. So it is seen as more desirable to some people.
Also I’m mixed and therefore not really ‘light skinned’ but mixed. Not to mention my skin is a lot darker than the friends who made the comment. Apparently it’s a big thing on tiktok now to identify as ‘light skinned’.
I prefer mixed myself as I have a range of cultural identities in my family, all with strong identities. I will just stick to mixed personally.

whistlers · 18/07/2021 07:47

I'm more confused after reading this thread!

Can I continue to use mixed race?

Xenia · 18/07/2021 07:46

Ah I don't think dual heritage is quite accurate. Eg there are white people from Antigua who have been there for hundreds of years (and South Africa for that matte) and their heritage is clearly Antigua or South African but their race is not. Mixed race is more accurate but as people say it is hard to keep up. May be the state should issue a list once a year of the words we need to be careful
not to use so as not to upset someone as most of us want to ensure we do not use the wrong terms. Also a lot of people watch too much US TV and think US words are what we use in the UK which also causes confusion as they have different words yet again for things and different things which you should not use

Jasmine11 · 18/07/2021 07:45

@Ursulasunderstudy

You need to use Dual Heritage not mixed race.
That's maybe what your prefer but OP doesn't 'need' to use it. Lots of people have a mix of more than two races so 'duel' is not actually appropriate.
Orangecinnamon21 · 18/07/2021 07:44

@aspadeaspade

I'm mixed race.

Dual heritage and multiracial are both offensive to me.

Dual heritage assumes I was raised in two distinct cultures. I wasn't. It makes a lot of assumptions about who I am as a person.

Multiracial assumes I don't know my origins. I do. I'm half one race, half another.

BAME means I look a bit foreign, but you have no idea what kind of foreign. If you're so unsure you have to lump me in other ethnic origins, you probably shouldn't be referring to my ethnic origins in any capacity.

Person of colour is no different to coloured IMHO. Everyone has a colour of some kind. It's just a stupid, clumsy way of describing people.

Half-caste is offensive as it suggests the one side of me is OK and the other side is bad. It's also inaccurate as caste system is not used in either of my races.

Mixed race is just fine. It's accurate, it's not offensive, and I've used the term my whole life long.

Muggleborn is also OK given it doesn't pass judgement on either race, and I was only really raised in one culture, despite belonging to two.

Mudblood is offensive. Only people with the same ethnic origins as me are allowed to use it when referring to each other - we can reappropriate the term if we choose, but you're not allowed to.

Love this