Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To ask if the term Mixed-Race is outdated

466 replies

CambridgeEntry2022 · 18/07/2021 00:42

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms. Would it be more appropriate to use the term multi racial?

OP posts:
Ilovecaviar · 18/07/2021 08:45

Mixed race implies a non mixed race is a pure race. Latest term I heard was inter-racial. Mixed race is quite offensive and I speak as someone who is ‘mixed race’.
Never heard of duel heritage though, not sure that implies you’re talking about race specifically so I wouldn’t have used that term for kyself personally.

beigerocket · 18/07/2021 08:43

I’m mixed race and refer to myself (and my mixed race children) as mixed race.

I’ve yet to meet any other mixed race person who takes offence at being referred to as mixed race.

Bi-racial and dual heritage wouldn’t work for us as I am a combination of black, asian and white.

Greenlittle · 18/07/2021 08:43

@BellH, yes, I guess I would prefer a fully descriptive term. Or it the word minority is used, minoritised may be more accurate?

Soontobe60 · 18/07/2021 08:42

@Ursulasunderstudy

You need to use Dual Heritage not mixed race.
That only works if you are from 2 different heritages. If a child has one parent who is dual heritage, say White British and Indian, and the other is dual heritage Black / south East Asian, their heritage is from 4 different ones.
ItPearl · 18/07/2021 08:40

[quote Milesbennettdyson]@ItPearl I don’t take offence to POC I just don’t like it. I’m not sure where I said it was white peoples who came up with it. A lot of assumption in your post.[/quote]
That second part of the post wasn't in response to you. I should have put in a new paragraph.

Somebody upthread said white people come up with these labels and a few other posters quoted it with ''this'' underneath.

ThinWomansBrain · 18/07/2021 08:39

given that everyone has two parents, unless the result of an incestuous relationship, doesn't that make everyone dual heritage?

YouJustFoldItIn · 18/07/2021 08:38

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms.

You've got fuck all chance of that. May as well just take yourself outside and self flagellate in penance now. If you haven't used the wrong term yet then trust me - you will eventually.

BellH · 18/07/2021 08:37

@Greenlittle

I actually prefer the term BAME to “ethnic minorities”. In many contexts these ethnicities are not minorities, they are together a majority. Certainly in the world population and in parts of UK as well.

BAME lumps groups together, but disaggregates a bit. Just like LBGTQ. It is descriptive without putting any value judgment as such (other than lumping together. But then most terms do that, including ethnic minority)

The ME part of BAME stands for 'minority ethnic', so I'm not sure I understand your point. Are you saying that BAME is preferable because it adds Black and Asian to the phrase 'ethnic minorities'?

Just trying to make sure I've understood...

Milesbennettdyson · 18/07/2021 08:37

@ItPearl I don’t take offence to POC I just don’t like it. I’m not sure where I said it was white peoples who came up with it. A lot of assumption in your post.

Simbacatisback · 18/07/2021 08:35

@whistlers

The term h.... c.... is extremely offensive and has been recognised as such for decades. It is up (or down!) there with the n word.

Is it? Really?

It has a historic context - from India One of my older family Uses it to describe themselves with no hesitation
ItPearl · 18/07/2021 08:34

Well, I see what you mean @Milesbennettdyson but it's the beige default. we don't need a descriptor ? because we are the beige default. And that's nice for ''us'' but, the suggestion that it's ''white people'' coming up with all of these labels, i don't think it is.

I think these labels emerge in America mostly and white people are the ones who are the most self-consciously trying to keep up and use the right ones.

And it might not be possible to 100% use the right label because there is no hive mind. One white person might cause offensive with mixed race and find themselves corrected where it had been the correct label before. That doesn't mean white people are inventing new labels.

CutePanda · 18/07/2021 08:33

@whistlers

The term h.... c.... is extremely offensive and has been recognised as such for decades. It is up (or down!) there with the n word.

Is it? Really?

Look into the history of “half caste.” It’s horrific. The word itself is derived from the term caste, which comes from the Latin castus, meaning pure. The term basically means that mixed race people are not pure. Mixed race children have been demonised in different countries (not just predominantly white ones) for centuries.
RampantIvy · 18/07/2021 08:31

I would assume anyone who used it in this day and age was deliberately trying to cause offense in a passive aggressive manner.

I think it depends on the age of the person. I would give someone in their 80s or 90s a bit more leeway. If they don't use the internet and don't watch much news they may not be aware that terminology has changed. There is no excuse for someone my age (62) and younger though.

Greenrubber · 18/07/2021 08:30

I was thinking about this the other day! My kid had mentioned a boy at nursery by name which was let's say Abdul her grandma immediately said ohh is he Indian?
But why comment? Why is the colour of someone's skin so important to people? I teach my child that everyone is different some have darker skin some dark or light hair different eye colour some are fat or thin so many variations of people but we only want to label the skin colour.
Why do we need to label people in this world now anyone can be born in any country and could be any colour so labelling seems very pointless
My kid doesn't care that some of her friends have different colour of skin so why do we as adults feel we need to?
Probably extremely naive but just wondering why we would even feel the need to call someone other than their name

Milesbennettdyson · 18/07/2021 08:24

Also I despise the term “person of colour”.

To me it implies that white people are bland, beige boring people!!

Greenlittle · 18/07/2021 08:23

I actually prefer the term BAME to “ethnic minorities”. In many contexts these ethnicities are not minorities, they are together a majority. Certainly in the world population and in parts of UK as well.

BAME lumps groups together, but disaggregates a bit. Just like LBGTQ. It is descriptive without putting any value judgment as such (other than lumping together. But then most terms do that, including ethnic minority)

bibliomania · 18/07/2021 08:23

Also in a university setting, we've taken disciplinary action against a student who repeatedly used the term half-caste towards another student. The other student had very patiently explained more than once why this wasn't appropriate, so when he persisted in using it, it was viewed as intentional harassment.

TotorosCatBus · 18/07/2021 08:23

@TipseyTorvey

I'm mixed race. Totally fine with this expression, my children are also mixed race. I hate BAME with a passion. Also to pp asking why half caste is offensive its because its how slavers referred to mixed race stock to get a higher price. It's also bound up in all kinds of historical colonial negative descriptors. I would assume anyone who used it in this day and age was deliberately trying to cause offense in a passive aggressive manner.
I did not know that.

As soon as I learned about the caste system in India, I found the term half-caste unacceptable.

MrsMop1964 · 18/07/2021 08:23

on the subject of h...c....I recommend a poem by John Agard. A friend of mine who is mixed race says how much it speaks to her.
www.amnesty.org.uk/files/2019-01/Half-caste%20by%20John%20Agard.pdf

ItPearl · 18/07/2021 08:21

oh wow, I didn't know that that HC word meant a more expensive slave Shock it is shocking how long it takes for a word to fall out of use completely. Even when I was a child in Ireland in 70s & 80s I knew it was bad but I didn't know why.

RampantIvy · 18/07/2021 08:21

Why do perfectly inoffensive, valid descriptors suddenly become problematic?
It's hard to keep up these days

I agree. I grew up in the 1960s and 1970s. Back then it was offensive to describe a black person as black. The correct term at the time was coloured. DH is nearly 70, and I have to keep reminding him not to say coloured. He really isn’t racist, he just has memory problems (stroke related).

Also, I'm of dual heritage but I'm not mixed race

So am I @WorraLiberty

I am mixed race and think it is a fucking horrible term. So we are not all OK with it. Would far prefer mixed or dual heritage

And this is why a lot of people struggle. I’m sure that sometimes a description comes across as a racist slur where none is intended.

I've also used the term mongrel to refer to my background.

So have I @Rheia1983. My mum’s side of the family come from different parts of Europe.

It seems that while white people tiptoe round the various terms in order to not sound offensive someone is bound to upset somebody else regardless.

Isn't it easier just to avoid any mention of race or colour. That's what I do

I would usually try to do that, but then it can come across as try too hard when a simple descriptive term is so much easier.

Orangecinnamon21 · 18/07/2021 08:20

@bibliomania

In defence of using labels, universities are being encouraged to look at how they're doing in relation to race - are white applicants more likely to be hired and promoted? Are there patterns of concern in relation to student progress and outcomes? What happens during the student journey, eg are black male students. more likely to face disciplinary action due to stereotypes? You can't tackle a problem unless you identify it and you can't identify it unless you put a name to it.
Yes and universities have been doing this for year's, it is not a new thing. The data they use is from the self-declared identity from the student themselves, albeit they are.encouraged to pick from the list of terms prescribed by the government.
Milesbennettdyson · 18/07/2021 08:19

I don’t like the term dual heritage. I think you can be dual heritage and still be white (e.g one parent spanish and one parent Scottish) or black and be dual heritage (one parent from Zimbabwe and one from Jamaica) for example.

Your heritage is nothing to do with race.

I’m fine with being called mixed race. I find half caste out dated but don’t take offence if someone over 70 uses it. I just correct them!

SJaneS49 · 18/07/2021 08:18

Complete minefield when so many of us in modern Britain are a bit of this and a bit of the other. Mixed heritage and bi-racial don’t adequately cover a lot of people with multiple heritages and multi racial backgrounds.

My eldest DD refers to herself as mixed race (her grandmother is from Trinidad and has an Indian/African/French background). My DD’s skin colour is white so terms like POC do not adequately cover her. She is also pan sexual so when it comes to DI forms she ends up ticking the ‘Other’ box more than once.

TipseyTorvey · 18/07/2021 08:17

I'm mixed race. Totally fine with this expression, my children are also mixed race. I hate BAME with a passion. Also to pp asking why half caste is offensive its because its how slavers referred to mixed race stock to get a higher price. It's also bound up in all kinds of historical colonial negative descriptors. I would assume anyone who used it in this day and age was deliberately trying to cause offense in a passive aggressive manner.