Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To ask if the term Mixed-Race is outdated

466 replies

CambridgeEntry2022 · 18/07/2021 00:42

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms. Would it be more appropriate to use the term multi racial?

OP posts:
Greenrubber · 18/07/2021 09:03

@Soontobe60

But a person is just a person no matter their skin colour why would they care what colour of skin they have why does it matter?

Other than for medical reasons or describing someone very specifically I don't see the need to even entertain that

Racism is learnt behaviour if we keep labeling everyone it will never stop!

Skin colour is really irrelevant

pangolina · 18/07/2021 09:01

One of my best friends refers to herself as mixed race, so that's how I would describe her (in the unlikely event that I would need to). Hilariously, another friend's (white) 12 yr old daughter tells us we can't say this as it is racist and we HAVE to say mixed heritage or mixed ethnicity.
Imagine telling another human how they HAD to describe themselves so as not to offend themselves Hmm

Teabag55 · 18/07/2021 09:01

I find it safer to never utter words any more. I really don't want to offend anyone or get into an argument about what's right or wrong. Even on this thread people are arguing about it so it's not as if there is any one description that's correct.
I've realised that over time I have become almost mute in real life. I think a lot, but most of it doesn't get said. It started out as a habit, but it's got to the point where I find it quite hard to speak at all.
I mean about everything, not solely about racial heritage.

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 08:57

My 16yo is mixed race and dual heritage. As far as she is concerned, both terms are fine but they refer to separate things. It's possible to be mixed race but not dual heritage and it's possible to be dual heritage but not mixed race. Race is an important aspect of people's experience and identity. We should not attempt to erase it.

Half caste is dreadful and should not be used. Enriched racial heritage sounds fucking ridiculous. BAME is unhelpful and potentially offensive because it lumps all non-white people together as if they were one single category. And personally, I can't bear the phrase "white passing" because I always feel that the unspoken implication is that people are somehow "failing" if they do not "pass" as white. Horrible.

BrilliantBetty · 18/07/2021 08:57

Mixed race is fine as long as mixed race people are fine with the description. It would help if white people stopped making anything to do with race / race description as awkward and negative.

There's nothing inherently negative about 'mixed race' don't try to make it so by turning it in to a problem word or situation. Can you think of it as positive. It's positive for me. Mixed race and proud??

MolyHolyGuacamole · 18/07/2021 08:54

[quote aspadeaspade]@Esspee I agree. White-passing feels like an attempt to erase my ethnic origins - like I'm not quite foreign enough to count as mixed race.

It feels like an attempt to shut me out.[/quote]
It's absolutely isn't, it's not an official identification term either (I have mixed race cousins who are 'white passing', but refer to themselves as mixed race). It's simply recognition that you won't face the same barriers than others because to the outside, you look white.

Like it or not, a 'white passing' footballer wouldn't be called a n* for missing a penalty 🤷🏽‍♀️

FreekStar2 · 18/07/2021 08:54

The problem with dual heritage though is it doesn't make allowance for the fact many people have more than two 'heritages'?

backtonormalonedaysoon · 18/07/2021 08:53

We say mixed race in our (mixed) house. But I wonder whether mixed ethnicity is more accurate. On the forms the question is what ethnicity would you say you are, not what race. And then we'd tick eg mixed other. Personally I dislike biracial. Dual heritage sounds ok to me as it sounds less 50/50 and more 100/100.

I've read/said the word "mixed" so many times now it's gone weird and lost all meaning!!!

ItPearl · 18/07/2021 08:53

@Ilovecaviar

Mixed race implies a non mixed race is a pure race. Latest term I heard was inter-racial. Mixed race is quite offensive and I speak as someone who is ‘mixed race’. Never heard of duel heritage though, not sure that implies you’re talking about race specifically so I wouldn’t have used that term for kyself personally.
This is what I mean.

Many people have confirmed that they are fine with ''mixed race'' and now we read this.

How does the term mixed race imply that one race is ''pure'' any more than inter racial implies it.

I don't think these labels can control how you define pure

Soontobe60 · 18/07/2021 08:53

@Greenrubber

I was thinking about this the other day! My kid had mentioned a boy at nursery by name which was let's say Abdul her grandma immediately said ohh is he Indian? But why comment? Why is the colour of someone's skin so important to people? I teach my child that everyone is different some have darker skin some dark or light hair different eye colour some are fat or thin so many variations of people but we only want to label the skin colour. Why do we need to label people in this world now anyone can be born in any country and could be any colour so labelling seems very pointless My kid doesn't care that some of her friends have different colour of skin so why do we as adults feel we need to? Probably extremely naive but just wondering why we would even feel the need to call someone other than their name
Surely it’s important to the person themselves.
whistlers · 18/07/2021 08:53

@ThinWomansBrain

given that everyone has two parents, unless the result of an incestuous relationship, doesn't that make everyone dual heritage?
I'm 0.25% Welsh, does that count?!
RampantIvy · 18/07/2021 08:52

Or you could just try not to be several decades behind the times.

Isn't that what she is trying to do on this thread?

Soontobe60 · 18/07/2021 08:50

@Ilovecaviar

Mixed race implies a non mixed race is a pure race. Latest term I heard was inter-racial. Mixed race is quite offensive and I speak as someone who is ‘mixed race’. Never heard of duel heritage though, not sure that implies you’re talking about race specifically so I wouldn’t have used that term for kyself personally.
Whilst I can see your point, ultimately as all humanity is supposed to have originated in Africa, does than not make everyone mixed race? Also, what is the definition of race?

I have a nationality which was determined by where I was born. My parents were both born in the same country as I but my 4 grandparents were born in 3 different countries.

aspadeaspade · 18/07/2021 08:50

@Greenlittle

I actually prefer the term BAME to “ethnic minorities”. In many contexts these ethnicities are not minorities, they are together a majority. Certainly in the world population and in parts of UK as well.

BAME lumps groups together, but disaggregates a bit. Just like LBGTQ. It is descriptive without putting any value judgment as such (other than lumping together. But then most terms do that, including ethnic minority)

I don't mind being referred to as an ethnic minority, because I am.

I think BAME irks me so much because it's basically 'black and other' and makes me feel marginalised as someone who isn't black.

Which circles nicely back to mixed race. It's accurate and isn't offensive. Why do people tie themselves up in knots trying to find some other term?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/07/2021 08:49

I think some other terms are offensive and outdated because they have derogatory meanings (eg half caste = not 'pure') or have negative connotations (not going to name them here but words that are nickname type words that have become used as insults by racists).

But the words mixed and race are used in everyday language, by all races, and they are clear and at the moment anyway don't have any alternative meanings. So I don't see what the issue is with this term as its pretty factual and there isnt an easy alternative (eg the issues people have described with using the term dual heritage)

WhenwillSleephappen · 18/07/2021 08:49

@eekbumbler

Can I ask in what context would this come up?

I cannot imagine a situation where you are with a person and you have to describe them other than by name. If for some bizarre reason you do have to address their heritage/race/being... then surely just ask them.

I'd really like to know what scenario you foresee OP. Or is it more of a written thing where you do not want to use an incorrect term.

Or maybe a baby coming - in which case ask the parents.

I dunno.

If you are describing someone perhaps?

It appears that different people find different terms
Offensive, so hopefully they’ll just correct a term they find offensive to something they don’t.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 18/07/2021 08:49

@RonaldMcDonald

I did diversity training recently and the said we should never use mixed race - a complete no no We were told person of colour, diverse racial or enriched racial background. My work colleague is bi-racial and said why not use this term?. They said she could of course refer to herself as she pleased but we couldn’t to others
'Enriched racial background' sounds so condescending. Bet the person devised the training is white.
CutePanda · 18/07/2021 08:49

@Ilovecaviar

Mixed race implies a non mixed race is a pure race. Latest term I heard was inter-racial. Mixed race is quite offensive and I speak as someone who is ‘mixed race’. Never heard of duel heritage though, not sure that implies you’re talking about race specifically so I wouldn’t have used that term for kyself personally.
No, mixed race/biracial means that a person’s parents are of different races. I am mixed race/biracial as I am a mixture of 2 races. Half-caste means “half pure” so I think that’s what you’ve confused the term mixed race with. I have never ever known a mixed race person (living in Britain) who is offended by the term mixed race.
BellH · 18/07/2021 08:49

@YouJustFoldItIn

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms.

You've got fuck all chance of that. May as well just take yourself outside and self flagellate in penance now. If you haven't used the wrong term yet then trust me - you will eventually.

Or you could just try not to be several decades behind the times.

Most people with social awareness don't find it that hard.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 18/07/2021 08:47

@Fauvist

I am mixed race and think it is a fucking horrible term. So we are not all OK with it. Would far prefer mixed or dual heritage.

There is just one race, the human race.

'We are all one race' has 'all lives matter vibes'.

I'm black and there's nothing wrong with that, if we can see the differences in others, we can't fix issues that some people face because of them.

BellH · 18/07/2021 08:47

[quote Greenlittle]@BellH, yes, I guess I would prefer a fully descriptive term. Or it the word minority is used, minoritised may be more accurate?[/quote]
Thanks! I know others who'd agree with you.

Personally, I find BAME far from a fully descriptive term. It's almost worse, to me, in someways to only pull out two groups, label one by skin colour and the other by geography, and then lump everyone else 'not white' in together.

Orangecinnamon21 · 18/07/2021 08:47

@YouJustFoldItIn

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms.

You've got fuck all chance of that. May as well just take yourself outside and self flagellate in penance now. If you haven't used the wrong term yet then trust me - you will eventually.

Yes because that would be awful wouldn't it! Someone correcting you for using an outdated term?!

As opposed to...

beigerocket · 18/07/2021 08:46

@whistlers

The term h.... c.... is extremely offensive and has been recognised as such for decades. It is up (or down!) there with the n word.

Is it? Really?

Very.

Look it up.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 18/07/2021 08:45

You're never going to get a single term that everyone is happy with.
My eldest son describes himself as black. My younger son says he is mixed race. They both have the same parents and therefore racial background.

Soontobe60 · 18/07/2021 08:45

@RonaldMcDonald

I did diversity training recently and the said we should never use mixed race - a complete no no We were told person of colour, diverse racial or enriched racial background. My work colleague is bi-racial and said why not use this term?. They said she could of course refer to herself as she pleased but we couldn’t to others
What ethnicity was the person delivering the training?