Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To ask if the term Mixed-Race is outdated

466 replies

CambridgeEntry2022 · 18/07/2021 00:42

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms. Would it be more appropriate to use the term multi racial?

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 18/07/2021 09:25

We were told person of colour, diverse racial or enriched racial background.

I'm amazed by this.i think if I referred to my mixed race friend as "person of colour" she would probably punch me/ghost me henceforth.

Triphazards · 18/07/2021 09:24

I seldom need any "taxonomic" adjective for people. It's hardly worth learning the latest ones before they become offensive.

"Dual heritage" is a bit of a mouthful. Anyway, I don't know how many heritages anyone has.

I think I'll just ask your name at an early stage and call you that.

If I've offended anyone, speak up and I'll apologise, as appropriate.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 18/07/2021 09:23

I have a mixed race friend and a white friend with mixed race children and both use mixed race. I've never heard anyone say dual heritage. Also I'm not sure its accurate to say dual heritage re the friend with mixed race kids as both she & husband are multi generation british, middle class, very similar cultural background... just one of them is black and one is white.

WeatherwaxOn · 18/07/2021 09:23

^my post got mangled by autocorrect, but hopefully was understandable. If in doubt, ask the person who you're referring to.

BellH · 18/07/2021 09:23

Diversity training is, sadly, usually a load of bollocks!

andromedana · 18/07/2021 09:22

I'm mixed race and refer to myself as such. Whilst this doesn't mean it is the correct term, I believe it is and haven't come across another mixed race person who has been offended by it.

CatherinedeBourgh · 18/07/2021 09:22

I use just mixed for my children. They look white, but in fact are a mix of several ethnicities and cultures, so mixed anything would be too specific. And people always assume mixed race means mixed with black, which isn’t the case (well not for many generations at least).

WeatherwaxOn · 18/07/2021 09:21

When I was growing up, the term was 'half caste' and whilst it was said with no intended malice, it obviously did cause upset.
In my wider family we have people with what would be deemed 'dual heritage' however they define themselves as "mixed race".
I can't see that this is anywhere near as offensive as the terminology I grew up with, but if I was needing to uses l the definition of people's ethnicity/heritage/skin colour frequently then I would ask what they preferred.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 18/07/2021 09:21

I find it offensive when people try to use all those new random phrases white people invented so as not to offend.

Talk2thehand · 18/07/2021 09:20

@RonaldMcDonald

"I did diversity training recently and the said we should never use mixed race - a complete no no
We were told person of colour, diverse racial or enriched racial background.
My work colleague is bi-racial and said why not use this term?. They said she could of course refer to herself as she pleased but we couldn’t to others"

What a lot of absolute BULLSHIT. Who comes up with this stuff. As the majority of mixed race people have said we want to be called mixed race. We are AWARE there's only one race. So if that's the problem then 'diverse racial' or 'enriched racial background' serve no purpose either.

Also I would NEVER refer to my mum as a 'person of colour' ... she's black.

It's a shame really that society is so confused and embarrassed about what it means to be mixed race or even to say the term out loud for fear of 'offending', to the point that I never once learnt about a high achieving mixed race person in school.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 18/07/2021 09:19

I'm mixed race and say I'm mixed race because I'm mixed races.

TheGumption · 18/07/2021 09:19

@Ursulasunderstudy Don't call me dual heritage. Ever. I'm mixed race.

aspadeaspade · 18/07/2021 09:17

@MolyHolyGuacamole I don't discount you or your experiences either. It probably is a term that means different things to different people, based on what they've personally lived through. I definitely see it as a way to exclude me.

However, as another poster has said, it's a horrible term, because it implies if you don't pass for white, you've failed. I think that's probably the bit we can all agree on. It's a term that does not come from a good place. I don't like the concept of being held out to have won or failed based on your skin colour.

(Even if in some parts of the world, as you say, you will be treated as having passed or failed!)

AlwaysLatte · 18/07/2021 09:17

It's usually not necessary to need to state race at all though is it? For instance my mum's neighbour was talking about a mutual friend and my mum couldn't work out which one she meant, so she said 'number 23 (or whatever) with the two little mixed race girls). But she could have said the two little girls, or that the mum was a florist, etc. There were a number of identifying things she could have said but she immediately picked the race element.

Essentialironingwater · 18/07/2021 09:17

I'm mixed race. My husband is of dual heritage but not mixed race. I think mixed race is fine.

RampantIvy · 18/07/2021 09:16

My kid had mentioned a boy at nursery by name which was let's say Abdul her grandma immediately said ohh is he Indian?
But why comment? Why is the colour of someone's skin so important to people?

You are making assumptions that it is about colour. If DD had come home and said she had made a new friend with, for example, a Russian sounding name I would probably have asked if the friend was Russian, but just out of interest.

changeyourname11111 · 18/07/2021 09:14

@WorraLiberty

Also, I'm of dual heritage but I'm not mixed race.
Good point.

Me too.

My kids are of triple heritage and of mixed race however, so yes I refer to them as mixed race (rarely though as it doesn’t really come up!).

Whiskycav · 18/07/2021 09:12

As above mixed race and dual heritage are not the same thing. They are different things.

My mums parents are Irish and Greek. My dad is Asian. I was born in Ireland and live in England. My heritage and cultures that influence my upbringing are more than 'dual'.

I am not a fan of mixed race. But mainly because I don't like race at all, as a social construct. Some of the suggestions from people on here from peoples employers are that ridiculous I would find them offensive.

Don't like BAME. It makes me think you are either White or Black or other.

If people are describing me I would rather they used my skin colour to describe me. 'Have you seen Whiskey?'
'Who?'
'You know. Tall, dark hair, dark skin...always talking about her dogs'

But then I think mixed race works well if you are talking about groups. I am not a fav of POC, but can see how it could be useful

'How many people of colour did we consult with on our new diversity training?'
'None'

'When we decided to tell people these were the acceptable terms that should replace mixed race, how many people who are mixed race people did we consult'

'None'

I don't find them offensive. But I don't like them and accept is society we still need something.

aspadeaspade · 18/07/2021 09:12

@BrilliantBetty

Mixed race is fine as long as mixed race people are fine with the description. It would help if white people stopped making anything to do with race / race description as awkward and negative.

There's nothing inherently negative about 'mixed race' don't try to make it so by turning it in to a problem word or situation. Can you think of it as positive. It's positive for me. Mixed race and proud??

When I was little, my (also quite little) brother took me aside and very solemnly told me that because we were mixed race, we got the best bits of both races.

He doesn't even remember saying this or what prompted him to do so, but in my mind, I can picture (and hear) him as a little boy making that statement in his high-pitched hadn't-hit-puberty-yet boy voice. The memory brings me a great deal of comfort whenever I'm faced with racism.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 18/07/2021 09:10

[quote aspadeaspade]@MolyHolyGuacamole Except I don't actually look white. I look part-white, which is very different.

Racist people are still racist towards me, because I look foreign enough to them. I assure you, I've had to deal with some pretty appalling stuff in my time.

White-passing is an attempt to tell mixed race people like me that we don't get an opinion on racial matters because we're 'too privileged'. The truth is, when you're mixed race, often all that means is you don't belong anywhere. It can be quite lonely.[/quote]
To be fair, I don't know what you look like, I can only talk form my experience. My cousins have been told many times that people thought they were just 'Spanish' or 'have a great tan'. People are genuinely shocked to find that they have a black mother. They were born and raised in the UK.

I'm also speaking from my experience of growing up in a Caribbean country, where the majority of people are black, and white passing definitely ensures you will never experience certain problems.

I don't discount you and your experiences, and am sorry that you've had racist comments made towards you. It seems that 'white passing' is used to mean different things in different contexts.

AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 09:09

[quote Greenrubber]@Soontobe60

But a person is just a person no matter their skin colour why would they care what colour of skin they have why does it matter?

Other than for medical reasons or describing someone very specifically I don't see the need to even entertain that

Racism is learnt behaviour if we keep labeling everyone it will never stop!

Skin colour is really irrelevant[/quote]
I'm guessing you're white?

Skin colour should be irrelevant but we are not there yet. Nowhere near. It is a very real part of people's day to day experience and we cannot just erase that or pretend it doesn't matter.

It is easy to say that it isn't important from a position of privilege. White people don't have to think about it much. People who regularly experience racism don't have that luxury.

spittycup · 18/07/2021 09:06

Genuine question: Why is half-caste- wrong?
And why is 'coloured' wrong but 'person of colour' okay?
And a general question: why is 'occidental' okay but 'oriental' wrong? Is it my age (60)?

Half caste is wrong because I'm not half anything, I'm not half acceptable [half white]. If an older person used it, I wouldn't get worked up if they're ignorant, but I wouldn't like it

Coloured shouldn't even need explaining when it was used during segregation. Like asking why the n word is offensive, it's obviously because of the historical context

Anyone who uses either of these phrases has either fairly old, poorly socialised or deliberately being a dick, because they're not in common use anymore. Just say mixed or black 🤷🏻‍♀️

ItPearl · 18/07/2021 09:05

It's not necessarily white people making it awkward @BrilliantBetty

On this one snapshot, this thread, I've read that most people are happy with mixed race but then wait, somebody else who is herself ''mixed race'' finds it offensive and prefers inter racial.

It's no wonder white people are at times self consciously ''careful''.

I''ll stick with mixed race if I need to, but it's not ''white people making it awkward'' when there is no hive mind and as this thread shows, and why should there be one hive mine, not everybody is fine with mixed race.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 18/07/2021 09:04

@RampantIvy

Or you could just try not to be several decades behind the times.

Isn't that what she is trying to do on this thread?

That reply wasn't for the OP...
aspadeaspade · 18/07/2021 09:04

@MolyHolyGuacamole Except I don't actually look white. I look part-white, which is very different.

Racist people are still racist towards me, because I look foreign enough to them. I assure you, I've had to deal with some pretty appalling stuff in my time.

White-passing is an attempt to tell mixed race people like me that we don't get an opinion on racial matters because we're 'too privileged'. The truth is, when you're mixed race, often all that means is you don't belong anywhere. It can be quite lonely.