Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To ask if the term Mixed-Race is outdated

466 replies

CambridgeEntry2022 · 18/07/2021 00:42

I don't want to cause offence by using outdated terms. Would it be more appropriate to use the term multi racial?

OP posts:
Greenrubber · 18/07/2021 11:08

@AlexaShutUp

As @jasmine11 said her skin colour is not what she identifies by she is a londoner

She is an individual

We can't tar everyone who has a darker skin with the same brush

Myself and my siblings are all white but we all hold different believes my skin colour has nothing to do with it

It's not about being colour blind I can see everyone is different it's not even ignoring it it's the fact that everyone is their own person and we need to be open minded about it

I hope when I say that every person who is not white has not suffered racism
Some white people have also suffered from racism

There are alot of different skin colours in Britain and they are still British just because one is darker makes them no less British

We can't judge people by their skin colour

If someone said to me hi I'm peter and I'm Muslim/Christian/vegan/Jedi OK I might ask about their religion out of interest but he could be any colour it's irrelevant

I know racism exists I just don't think we all are going about tlit the right way to eradicate it

MrsMayJune · 18/07/2021 11:07

@Comedycook, why is not being white British offensive? Yes it means minority groups that are at a disadvantage relative to the majority white British population who holds the power (broadly speaking).

If BAME means not white British, why is that offensive? Not being white British isn’t a crime or disgrace.

I can understand the argument that by lumping all minority groups together it avoids shining a light on the diversity with the BAME category. It can hide a multitude of problems especially when statistics are being used. For instance, say BAME people are progressing might hide that some groups with the BAME population are finding processing far more quickly than others.

Offensive I don’t get because it implies some level of internalised embarrassment. I do get that it does not appreciate diversity and diversity of outcomes within that category.

I can definitely see why half-caste is offensive it’s in the very term itself and implies half of you is acceptable.

Comedycook · 18/07/2021 11:03

Because when the language changes (I am in my 60s) as often as it does us white people are terrified of being reported for using the 'wrong' terminology

I'm white and not at all terrified of being reported Hmm

FlyingBattie · 18/07/2021 11:02

I am "dual heritage" in that the two sides of my family come from two very different cultures, despite both my parents being white and brought up in the UK.

Mixed race is on official forms, so I assume is OK, although happy to be corrected!

stillcrazyafterall · 18/07/2021 11:01

@PumpkinKlNG

Same people saying black people should be called bame or person of colour yet every single black person I know calls themselves black just like every single mixed race person I know calls themselves mixed race, why do white people keep telling us what terms we should call ourselves 🤨
Because when the language changes (I am in my 60s) as often as it does us white people are terrified of being reported for using the 'wrong' terminology. When I was young the 'n' word was used (note 'used' not 'acceptable') now it is highly offensive, but not if you're black, then you can use it. Is using BAME acceptable? Or should I use 'people of colour'? I genuinely cannot keep up with what is acceptable and what isn't.
Flowerlane · 18/07/2021 10:58

@Comedycook

I see no problem with BAME. There is nothing offensive about it. It is a shortened form of easily referring to ethnic minorities including white ethnic minorities. It stands for Black, Asian and other minority ethnicities. What’s offensive about that

My black dh dislikes the term and I can understand why. It basically lumps everyone who isn't white British together...so you're either white British or bame thus the only people who have a strong identity when divided in this way are the white British people...it feels like the bame just means not white British, which is not a positive affirmation of identity. Does that make sense?

Totally agree with this! We hate the term BAME for this reason.
GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 10:57

Yes. Perfect sense.

Comedycook · 18/07/2021 10:54

I see no problem with BAME. There is nothing offensive about it. It is a shortened form of easily referring to ethnic minorities including white ethnic minorities. It stands for Black, Asian and other minority ethnicities. What’s offensive about that

My black dh dislikes the term and I can understand why. It basically lumps everyone who isn't white British together...so you're either white British or bame thus the only people who have a strong identity when divided in this way are the white British people...it feels like the bame just means not white British, which is not a positive affirmation of identity. Does that make sense?

Jasmine11 · 18/07/2021 10:51

@MrsMayJune

I see no problem with BAME. There is nothing offensive about it. It is a shortened form of easily referring to ethnic minorities including white ethnic minorities. It stands for Black, Asian and other minority ethnicities. What’s offensive about that?

I think being colour blind or no seeing colour is an offensive idea. A person’s race and ethnicity are incredibly important parts of their identity and the history of their race. To not see a person’s skin colour/race/ethnicity is to not see them and to not understand what life is like for them in places or countries where they are treated unfairly.

I find BAME very offensive actually, I know it's an acronym but the way it is used in every day language and by the media just lumps all non-white people into a homogenous mass, you may as well just go back to calling people 'coloured' as BAME (as it is generally used) fundamentally has the same meaning

A person’s race and ethnicity are incredibly important parts of their identity and the history of their race I completely disagree with this too - I am mixed race (3/4 white and 1/4 asian) and I don't have anything to do with my grandparent's original culture as they chose to leave that behind when they came to the UK, so I may have brown skin, but I don't feel anything other that British, or specifically a Londoner. So if you started trying to be culturally sensitive to me because of my skin colour I would have no idea what you were doing.

Triphazards · 18/07/2021 10:50

@ancientgran

It is offensive if you don't want to be categorised by a series of initials.

I guess my husband is entitled to hate the term being applied to him if that is how he feels.

But earnest undergraduates are ordering us to call people BAME!
AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 10:47

@Greenrubber, I think you're coming at things with the right intentions. You're right that it shouldn't matter, but the reality is that racism is very real. Pretending that we're colour blind and that race/skin colour is irrelevant doesn't address the problem. We need to talk about it and tackle it head on.

Triphazards · 18/07/2021 10:46

@AlexaShutUp

I agree, it doesn't matter if people's skin is black, brown, yellow or normal.

WTF is normal?Hmm

Normal is no acne.
AlexaShutUp · 18/07/2021 10:44

I agree, it doesn't matter if people's skin is black, brown, yellow or normal.

WTF is normal?Hmm

polkadotjersey · 18/07/2021 10:39

Caste comes from the Latin word 'castus', which means pure, so describing someone as half caste is literally calling them impure. If you're a Harry Potter fan, it's akin to calling someone a Mudblood.

SerendipityJane · 18/07/2021 10:39

I think being colour blind or no seeing colour is an offensive idea. A person’s race and ethnicity are incredibly important parts of their identity and the history of their race.

Alternatively, it can be incredibly offensive to a person if other people insist on seeing them as a cipher for history rather than Sue from accounts. And then proceed to lecture them about it too.

Your turn.

ancientgran · 18/07/2021 10:35

It is offensive if you don't want to be categorised by a series of initials.

I guess my husband is entitled to hate the term being applied to him if that is how he feels.

MrsMayJune · 18/07/2021 10:34

I see no problem with BAME. There is nothing offensive about it. It is a shortened form of easily referring to ethnic minorities including white ethnic minorities. It stands for Black, Asian and other minority ethnicities. What’s offensive about that?

I think being colour blind or no seeing colour is an offensive idea. A person’s race and ethnicity are incredibly important parts of their identity and the history of their race. To not see a person’s skin colour/race/ethnicity is to not see them and to not understand what life is like for them in places or countries where they are treated unfairly.

C8H10N4O2 · 18/07/2021 10:32

I had an Indian friend at school. When I invited her round for tea it mattered because her religion (she was a Jain) meant that there were dietary restrictions. The colour of her skin was irrelevant

Dealt with by asking about dietary preferences and restrictions which would also be more accurate.

Greenrubber · 18/07/2021 10:31

@RampantIvy

I have dietary restrictions moral and allergies
Religion is different to skin colour
Cultures are different to skin colour

Grandma was not inviting him around for dinner

@MolyHolyGuacamole

Everyone Is different is the point not that everyone is the same

I can't argue the sex thing because I feel you are born either male or female

You can be any colour and any religion tho you can't assume because someone is say Indian that they are Muslim

I'm not saying everyone should all be the same I'm saying there is so much diversity we can't label it all it's impossible we need to take each person for the individual that they are

PausePlease · 18/07/2021 10:28

I’d take the lead from people who are mixed race on this one!

I’m white and always thought BAME was wanky, but my DH (black) and best friend (mixed race) both hate it and that has consolidated it for me.

My kids are mixed race (teenagers) and think biracial is ‘too American’ and have never heard any of the other terms being used. They are genuinely a mixture of races AND nationalities though - white Irish on my side, black Jamaican / black & Portuguese Guyanese / Guyanese native Wapishani Indian. I mean, that would be ridiculous to try to or need to define every time you announce your heritage, so ‘mixed race’ seems just fine for now!

ancientgran · 18/07/2021 10:20

@PumpkinKlNG

Same people saying black people should be called bame or person of colour yet every single black person I know calls themselves black just like every single mixed race person I know calls themselves mixed race, why do white people keep telling us what terms we should call ourselves 🤨
My DH is black and doesn't really care what he's called (as long as it isn't malicious) with the one exception of BAME. It absolutely gives him the rage.
3Britnee · 18/07/2021 10:17

I don't like bame, person of colour, bi racial, or any of the other tie-yourself-in-knots-avoid-the-obvious bollocks thought up by white people who decide what non white people should be offended by.

With regards to we should all be colour blind, that doesn't work in the real world. There are physical differences that need to be taken account of.

I read Unnatural causes by Richard Shepherd (fantastic book, read it if you can). He's one of the top pathologists. He's been working with law enforcement agencies for quite a while about restraint methods for black people, because risk of asphyxiation or suffocation is higher than for white people. So I assume they are changing the methods as standard for everyone, but you can't just blanket assume everyone is the same in every situation. Sometimes race is relevant.

gogohm · 18/07/2021 10:17

Mixed race is fine, many people have multiple different racial makeups and it covers everything, dual heritage isn't even applicable to many

Runningupthecurtains · 18/07/2021 10:10

@MrMucker

If you need to talk about people you ought to talk about what sort of people they are character-wise, unless you don't know what those people are like, in which case the correct term to use is precisely nothing.
So we should question why death rates from Covid are higher among people who are what jolly? Grumpy? Kind? Forgiving? We should say that X makes delicious, authentic curry/ jerk chicken/ dumplings because they are introverted? We should acknowledge that Y has faced prejudice because they are friendly? Shy? Egotistical? If I see a mixed race/Asian/ black/ white person drop their phone and I pick it up and run after them but they have gone round the corner should I ask a person on the corner if they have seen a delightful/ narcissistic person and if so which way they went or in this situation might some sort of physical description be more helpful than a snap judgment of the character of a person I have never met?
MrsMayJune · 18/07/2021 10:08

It is easy to see why half caste is offensive.