Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Is it rude to only offer guests a set menu?

105 replies

SoLongAsTheresCheese · 17/07/2021 19:15

We're planning on organising a smallish family gathering(within guidelines) as we still haven't met a cousin's almost two year old and haven't seen other family members for some time.

A family member is paying for everyone. It'll be in a local Italian which has very nice food. I suggested they offer the set menu which is quite extensive. But very reasonably priced. But they're concerned that it's rude.

Is it really so rude to offer a set menu and not offer guests the full a la carte experience?

OP posts:
Fiddliestofsticks · 17/07/2021 21:23

@tiredmama2020

That's awful! Was he the son of FIL? Or had he married a daughter? Either way, it's awful but at least if he was a son they could tell him off properly after!

Inthemuckheap · 17/07/2021 21:23

Perfectly acceptable and far easier for all as less dithering!

tiredmama2020 · 17/07/2021 21:17

@SoLongAsTheresCheese Not rude at all! If I know someone else is paying for a meal then I prefer it to be a set menu! Saves me doing the quick scan of the prices and finding the cheapest thing to order 😅🤣 i feel so uncomfortable when I know someone else is paying 🙈

Family meal at a nice hotel once and FIL announced “everyone pick what you want, we’d like to pay for the meal” and I spend the whole meal feeling SO uncomfortable as BIL sat loudly saying “oh excellent - I love a free meal!” then proceeded to order a prawn starter, fillet steak and a whole a bottle of wine as the one he likes only came by the bottle and he declared that it would “ruin” his steak if he didn’t have the wine he liked with it. He then also ordered a dessert and coffee 😬
I know FIL said to order what you want but I feel like the social norm would be to go for a mid-low price option 🙈 or maybe that’s just me!

Sazzlepopz · 17/07/2021 21:17

No I don't think it's rude at all. It's a thoughtful idea to host a meal and generous to foot the bill so think it's perfectly reasonable to offer the set menu.

Igetknockeddown · 17/07/2021 21:14

@IndigoHexagon

Send the set menus in advance and ask for pre orders due to the party size - then on the day no one needs to see the restaurants a ka carte menu
^absolutely this.

The restaurant will also thank you for the pre order.

S111n20 · 17/07/2021 21:11

I don’t think it’s rude at all.

sorryforswearing · 17/07/2021 21:02

I think a set menu with that amount of choices would be fine and personally I’d be happy that my food was being paid for.

BorderlineHappy · 17/07/2021 21:01

No it's not rude.
After all we all have that one person who would order the most expensive thing on the menu.
Then on the other end you have the ones who'd order the cheapest thing with tap water.

This way all angles are covered.

XingMing · 17/07/2021 21:00

@Ozanj, there's a balance somewhere in this. We had a big party lunch celebration some years ago for 70 people and paid, but the menu from which people were asked to make their choices was the standard lunch menu, not the evening a la carte which is more extensive and more expensive. But our guests were only shown/offered one menu. And the wine list was house wines only, not the rare varietal vintages also available. In which world is that rude? Unless you are a Russian oligarch out to impress?

Whiskycav · 17/07/2021 20:57

@Ozanj ops mum is paying for all of it.

And what are the chances your background is theirs?

LimeRedBanana · 17/07/2021 20:53

In my background it would be really rude. You either pay for all of it or you pay for none of it.

Presumably the OP isn’t from your background, so this can safely be ignored.

And her Mum is paying for all of it - all of the set menu.

WombatChocolate · 17/07/2021 20:52

Oranj, but the host WILL be paying for all of it…..it will be a 3 course meal and drinks.

It just so happens that one menu will be offered, when like most restaurants, there are both set and a la crate menus.

Stonerosie67 · 17/07/2021 20:51

In my background it would be really rude. You either pay for all of it or you pay for none of it.

There's always one....🙄🙄🙄

Not rude in the slightest, the total opposite in fact. I hope you have a lovely time

Ozanj · 17/07/2021 20:46

@SoLongAsTheresCheese

We're planning on organising a smallish family gathering(within guidelines) as we still haven't met a cousin's almost two year old and haven't seen other family members for some time.

A family member is paying for everyone. It'll be in a local Italian which has very nice food. I suggested they offer the set menu which is quite extensive. But very reasonably priced. But they're concerned that it's rude.

Is it really so rude to offer a set menu and not offer guests the full a la carte experience?

In my background it would be really rude. You either pay for all of it or you pay for none of it.
XingMing · 17/07/2021 20:44

Who thinks taking the whole group out and not offering the run of the a la carte menu is mean? Only someone really rather spoiled. Unless the host is a multi-millionaire, and even then, I feel the reaction is ungrateful.

WombatChocolate · 17/07/2021 20:44

Good point, that lunch especially, even in top restaurants is far more usually a set menu. Set menus can be EXTREMELY nice and are often not cheap at all.

I suspect the friend who thought it might seem a bit cheap hasn’t been taken out in a larger group on a frequent basis, or seen the set lunch menu at many swanky restaurants.

If you’re the organiser Op, I guess part of your job is to reassure the host. Perhaps neither of you has done this much before, perhaps the guests won’t have been taken out much like this before.

Keeping things simple, where you ask the restaurant to only out the set menu on the table, can make it a simpler experience for yourself, the host and all the guests. The most tricky kind of meals like this are those where it is hoped people will choose from a set menu but that expectation isn’t made clear and lots of different menus are on the table. Generally speaking, guests also like simplicity. Most people are conscious that someone else is hosting them and don’t want to go overboard in choosing really expensive items…the set menu makes this easier for them too. It also removes that worry people have about if it’s appropriate or a bit pushy to order a starter etc too.

The set menu makes everything g clear for everyone. Go for it.

AlCalavicci · 17/07/2021 20:43

I agree with PPs it is absolutely fine to offer a reduced / set menu .

If someone does want a 10oz steak or king prawns for starter and main then they can get their wallet out !

ElephantOfRisk · 17/07/2021 20:41

I had loads of choices at my wedding meal but that's because we limited that to 44 people and my brother was the restaurant manager. think we had about 5 or 6 starters and desserts and about 8 mains. But I've also been at weddings where we've had to pre book a choice of 2 mains with a fixed starter and dessert and some where you just all get served the same. I can't say it's ever made me think they are mean or whatever. They've just bought you a meal so I'd be happy for that.

LimeRedBanana · 17/07/2021 20:40

I asked a friend and she thought it was a bit mean

Your mother is paying for everyone’s food, and the word your friend uses to describe this is ‘mean’?!

I certainly hope she’s not on the invitation list!

FYI - your Mum is being very generous and considerate.

Lweji · 17/07/2021 20:37

I asked a friend and she thought it was a bit mean

Your relative is paying for everyone, it's not mean at all.

Even with no choice, it is still very generous of that relative.
And if anyone complains, they could order a la carte and pay for themselves, I suppose.

ElephantOfRisk · 17/07/2021 20:37

It's perfect and also better for the kitchen for a large group as everyone needs to be served at once.

XingMing · 17/07/2021 20:35

For lunches, unless it's very foodie, the expectation would generally be that 90% of customers would order from the set menu of the day's choices. Maybe not if you have chosen a Michelin starred option but in real life.

Noterook · 17/07/2021 20:30

I would feel more comfortable with a set menu if someone else was paying, none of the awkwardness about being thankful but not sure what is fair to order. As there are no dietary requirements and sounds like they have a good selection, sounds much better.

LimeRedBanana · 17/07/2021 20:29

Absolutely fine.

All wedding breakfasts are a set menu surely. Unless a buffet, I guess.

GreyhoundG1rl · 17/07/2021 20:28

It's absolutely fine.