Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you are that short of staff you should employ 15year olds?

261 replies

SunsetandCupcakes · 17/07/2021 18:19

I'm not that old, still old but in the v late 90s I had a job in the kitchens, my brother had a job selling ice creams at 14.
Catering near me is struggling to fill vacancies, it's the summer in a holiday town, two kiosks have had to close as no staff and yet my 15 year old isn't allowed to work.
How can working be more detrimental than sat at home on the PS4, we've ended up with a funny view on teenagers

OP posts:
wordsareveryunnecessary · 17/07/2021 19:23

I enquired at Tesco about shelf filling type of work for our 15 year old for the summer.
Not allowed until 16.
Shame as many staff keep going off to isolate and they are busy with home delivery orders too

Bargebill19 · 17/07/2021 19:22

When I was that age I worked in a pub kitchen - there were three or four of us collecting plates and washing up. We were all told to say we were the landlords niece/nephew. 😳
I think it is exploiting a young person to expect them to do a job for under contract he minimum wage, when just because someone is older they are paid more for the same job.

AlexaShutUp · 17/07/2021 19:22

@Regularsizedrudy

As someone who has had to supervise teenagers on work experience… god no. Just no.
In fairness, it does depend on the teenager. My dd is 16 but her boss tells me that she's better than several of his adult staff!!
gardeninggirl68 · 17/07/2021 19:21

Serving ice cream might sound simple to you

Clearly it's not .

Regularsizedrudy · 17/07/2021 19:19

As someone who has had to supervise teenagers on work experience… god no. Just no.

LemonRoses · 17/07/2021 19:18

Many local authorities have a blanket ban on children working in commercial kitchens of any sort.
The law allows over 14s to work in hospitality and shops (with very limited hours) but not in any sort of kitchen area. It’s about twelve hours they can work in any school week, with limits of 2 hours on a Sunday and five on a Saturday with an hours break. Employers need a permit.

Then there is H&S legislation around hazardous work, using machinery and liabilities. Letting a child use a barista machine in a busy cafe is a negligence claim waiting to happen.

SunsetandCupcakes · 17/07/2021 19:17

@properg

It's harder to exploit kids now hence why they are unattractive. I kinda think that's a good thing.
Why do we have to exploit kids? Less than a 100years ago 15years Old were signing up to fight. Whilst I'm not encouraging this I struggle to see how serving ice cream is similar
OP posts:
gardeninggirl68 · 17/07/2021 19:17

We take them from 16..... non food retail. It's hard work!!

Being short staffed would make you shorter the amount of work that goes in. And the mobile phone usage is off the scale!

VladmirsPoutine · 17/07/2021 19:14

And this is exactly why the tories will always be in power. They've totally skewed people's perception of normality. A lot of hospitality venues are struggling to hire at the moment, in fact a lot of low paid jobs are struggling to recruit. Not because people don't want to work but because people don't want to work for poverty wages. So instead of suggesting that these companies up their pay; you look at other avenues of exploitation i.e. employ a 15yr old.

Manista · 17/07/2021 19:11

I was a 15 year old in 1975 working two half days every weekend in a paper shop. Just another member of shop staff, stocking shelves, dealing with customers, using the till and handling cash. Interesting how people's views of older teens has changed.

stellaisabella · 17/07/2021 19:08

I was waitressing at 14! Yanbu

AlexaShutUp · 17/07/2021 19:05

[quote ChrissyPlummer]@AlexaShutUp some of them do need to work. Like the OP, I didn’t get much pocket money as my DPs couldn’t afford it. I ended up with a paper round just to get a few extra quid, it was weekly delivering the local free paper. I hated it, tramping round the cold, dark streets in pretty terrible weather, sometimes for an extra £3 (the pay depended on if there were any leaflets to go in). I think the most I ever got was £12.

My parents were contrary in that they wouldn’t let me work in a shop etc until I was 16, but also expected me to not ask for money. One of my friends relatives had a catering contract for the local Masonic hall and said I could wait on with my friend, my dad wouldn’t let me as I was only 13/14.

I don’t see why a paper round is OK; going about in the cold and dark but working in a pub/shop where it’s warm and safe (if well managed) is deemed to be unsafe.[/quote]
I'm well aware that some children are living in poverty, so might feel that they need to work, but I don't think that the solution to that is to change the law in order to push them into paid employment at such a young age. I'd rather that the state provided a proper safety net for families so that the needs of all children are fully met.

If we're talking about wants rather than needs, then I think it's fine for them to wait until they're 16.

TheGlassBlowersDaughter · 17/07/2021 19:05

Catering can be tricky. Quite often they want people who have a food handling qualification. Underage teens don't tend to have that. I'm sure your DC could find a different job.

properg · 17/07/2021 19:01

It's harder to exploit kids now hence why they are unattractive. I kinda think that's a good thing.

ChrissyPlummer · 17/07/2021 19:01

@AlexaShutUp some of them do need to work. Like the OP, I didn’t get much pocket money as my DPs couldn’t afford it. I ended up with a paper round just to get a few extra quid, it was weekly delivering the local free paper. I hated it, tramping round the cold, dark streets in pretty terrible weather, sometimes for an extra £3 (the pay depended on if there were any leaflets to go in). I think the most I ever got was £12.

My parents were contrary in that they wouldn’t let me work in a shop etc until I was 16, but also expected me to not ask for money. One of my friends relatives had a catering contract for the local Masonic hall and said I could wait on with my friend, my dad wouldn’t let me as I was only 13/14.

I don’t see why a paper round is OK; going about in the cold and dark but working in a pub/shop where it’s warm and safe (if well managed) is deemed to be unsafe.

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 18:59

@Echobelly

It is sad that so many people seem to think anyone who hasn't finished education is a useless liability! I never had jobs as a teenager, but I can see them being good for development - and teenagers can be perfectly competent.

Obviously, employers shouldn't be able to exploit young workers, but young people should still be allowed to work at an appropriate level.

It's not they're a liability because they're incapable - it's because hiring a 15yo often creates more work - it doesn't solve the issue of low staffing.

They need lots of breaks (way more than even a 16yo), can't work early in the morning or in the evening, can't work more than 2 hours on Sundays etc.

In my experience of retail management, hiring them just creates more problems and requires more staff to provide supervision, training and cover.

Kanaloa · 17/07/2021 18:59

Although a friend of mine (20s) was saying recently how she’s applied for loads of different jobs and is really struggling to get something, maybe there is just more people going for jobs so they have their pick of adult candidates who can do full hours, shorter breaks etc.

Kanaloa · 17/07/2021 18:57

If he’s really wanting to work perhaps he could look for something casual? Babysitting maybe, or dog walking, something like that?

To be honest I can see why places do this, there needs to be a minimum age and they’ve decided it’s 16/18. That’s just how it is.

properg · 17/07/2021 18:57

There's all sorts of rules now that make it unattractive.

TotorosCatBus · 17/07/2021 18:57

The 15 year olds that I know who are in work are often weekend help for adults teaching kids sport. They help referee footie matches, extra pair of hands for training etc

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 18:57

Link: www.gov.uk/child-employment/restrictions-on-child-employment

Echobelly · 17/07/2021 18:57

It is sad that so many people seem to think anyone who hasn't finished education is a useless liability! I never had jobs as a teenager, but I can see them being good for development - and teenagers can be perfectly competent.

Obviously, employers shouldn't be able to exploit young workers, but young people should still be allowed to work at an appropriate level.

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 18:57

The government website says the following about hiring 15 year olds:

  • During school holidays, 15 to 16-year-olds can only work a maximum of 35 hours a week. This includes a maximum of 8 hours on weekdays and Saturdays, and a maximum of 2 hours on Sunday.
  • and they must have an employment permit issued by the education department of the local council, if this is required by local bylaws
in places like a factory or industrial site

They also can't work:

  • before 7am or after 7pm
  • for more than one hour before school (unless local bylaws allow it)
  • for more than 4 hours without taking a break of at least 1 hour
  • in any work that may be harmful to their health, well-being or education
  • without having a 2-week break from any work during the school holidays in each calendar year

The times, break restrictions and hours on weekends (Sundays especially) means hiring a 15yo is pointless for many companies.

cariadlet · 17/07/2021 18:57

I think it's a shame. There must be plenty of 15 year olds who are desperate for a summer job and would be reliable. Even if there's a limit to the hours which they are allowed to work, you could employ a couple of young part-timers if you can't find an adult wanting full time work.

Dd is 18 and waitresses at a local restaurant. She's worked there for a few years so was probably about 14 or 15 when she started.

MythsandSparkles · 17/07/2021 18:57

@catfunk see I read that and wonder where your parents were?

That workload is more than just earning a bit of pocket money which is what the OP is talking about.

And if you were only earning pocket money from seemingly a dawn to midnight workload then you were being exploited…which rather proves the point of why we now have so many regulations.