Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you are that short of staff you should employ 15year olds?

261 replies

SunsetandCupcakes · 17/07/2021 18:19

I'm not that old, still old but in the v late 90s I had a job in the kitchens, my brother had a job selling ice creams at 14.
Catering near me is struggling to fill vacancies, it's the summer in a holiday town, two kiosks have had to close as no staff and yet my 15 year old isn't allowed to work.
How can working be more detrimental than sat at home on the PS4, we've ended up with a funny view on teenagers

OP posts:
Frankley · 17/07/2021 19:54

I started work at a NHS hospital a fortnight before my 16th birthday. The pay scale didn't start till age 16 and l remember my mother saying it was a bit mean that l was paid less that fortnight. I attended classes at another hospital on Wednesday mornings and Thursday evenings. Gained qualifications that now require a University degree and worked for the NHS for 50 years. In past years we were considered to be sensible and soon learnt to take responsibility for what we were required to do. Surely young people have not changed that much?

Sparklingbrook · 17/07/2021 19:53

@IRanSoFarAway1

OP "I don't believe that an entire generation has regressed so much they can't wash pots"

Agree. Lots of us had jobs in the local area, from sweeping up hair at the salon to clearing tables at the cafe etc.

It's nice to earn money at that age too. I think the law is the problem now though.

As I said, it's not really washing pots it's using large industrial dishwashers. It's not like doing the washing up at home in the kitchen.
3Lions · 17/07/2021 19:53

@HaveANiceFuckingDay

I know a15 year old that works in a chip shop they pay here £2.50 an hour as there isn’t a pay bracket under 16;
I used to earn that much washing hair in a hairdressers age 13 in 1989. I told them I was 15. They never checked. Worked there for a couple of years.
gardeninggirl68 · 17/07/2021 19:50

It's very very different these days. Very

Mental health plays a big part in the differences. Resilience isn't the same as when we were teens. Lateness and sickness absences are very high in our younger employees

Throw covid onto the mix and increased health and safety and. It's difficult

purplecorkheart · 17/07/2021 19:50

I wonder is insurance an issue? Say a 15 year old got burnt washing dishes and they sued would the business be covered or would the Insurance company use some loophole not to cover.

IRanSoFarAway1 · 17/07/2021 19:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

careerchangeperhaps · 17/07/2021 19:50

Child employment rules are much more extensive now than they were in the 90s (when I was a teen). Employers will generally struggle to get insurance or have to pay higher premiums.
Even if that hurdle is overcome, there are employment laws that cause issues (children need more frequent breaks, can't work for more than x hours, cannot work later than x hour, need to have x hours between shifts etc.). If it's a venue that serves alcohol they can't do so unsupervised and so on. Often more of a hindrance than a help. In our area they (the children) also need a permit from the council which I believe has to be authorised by their school. Nightmare!

Bargebill19 · 17/07/2021 19:49

It’s catch 22 though for the government/council. If they leave things as they are - people complain that their young person can’t work, can’t get experience. but if they change them and make it easier, then there will be people saying it’s exploitation and too young to working/what about their education. Both valid arguments!
The powers that be can’t win. So leave it as is.

Sometimesonly · 17/07/2021 19:47

My parents have just come back from a holiday in a hotel in the UK. The first thing they were told when checking in was that they didn't have enough staff to clean the rooms. Confused The waiting staff were all very young and nobody had any idea what they were doing. There is nothing wrong with employing teenagers but you need someone in charge and a minimum of training.

FrogWaa · 17/07/2021 19:43

I agree op, people on MN seem keen to treat their near adults like children and then wonder why they're so useless.The laws should be simplified and teens should be encouraged to contribute

Kazzyhoward · 17/07/2021 19:41

@Manista

I was a 15 year old in 1975 working two half days every weekend in a paper shop. Just another member of shop staff, stocking shelves, dealing with customers, using the till and handling cash. Interesting how people's views of older teens has changed.
In 1975, I was only 11, my parents bought a newsagents and I worked in it every weekend, during school holidays, and even a couple of early mornings on school days. Obviously, it's different as I was family, not staff. But even at that young age, I was serving customers, using the till, answering the phone etc. After a couple of years, probably when I was around 13, I started to run the shop single handed, at first just for 30 minutes of so when Mum or Dad nipped out to deliver a paper or whatever, which grew to full days when they wanted a day off, around 14/15 years. Our paper delivery boys would typically start around 12 or 13 years old, stay 2/3 years, and then leave when they were 16 and got other jobs, usually in cafes, shops, etc.

I do think we're holding kids back these days.

Sparklingbrook · 17/07/2021 19:37

'Pot wash' isn't what it sounds like. Generally it's collecting the dirty plates/cups/utensils and loading them into an industrial dishwasher. The cycle takes minutes and is absolutely steaming hot. Then you get that lot out and put the next one in, and the next, and the next. Not really suitable for children.

roarrlikeadinosaur · 17/07/2021 19:34

It’s interesting you say that @catfunk as I do feel like my parents obsession with me working had a negative impact on reversion as when I was home I just wanted to relax.

BournvilleGreen · 17/07/2021 19:34

My 15yo has a PT job, but where she works isn't licensed,.which probably helps, and she doesn't enter the kitchens ever.
I imagine most of this is actually down to commercial insurance- far easier for insurance companies to just say no under 16s than have more complicated policies.

Maggiesfarm · 17/07/2021 19:32

I think 16 is about the right age to start part time work.

catfunk · 17/07/2021 19:32

I also must day it did me lots of favours in terms of dealing with adults, social skills, confidence etc.
I interview graduates these days and the lack of work experience (and life experience that comes with it) is really off putting for an employer

Abraxan · 17/07/2021 19:32

I just find it so sad, we've extended childhood beyond what is acceptable and we've continued to repress those that need to work.

Childhood extended beyond an acceptable range? Because they can't work for pittance before they're 16 and are being protected from exploitive employers?

What's more sad is that a child, any child, NEEDS to work really.
Of course I know some families struggle, but surely that's the real sadness.

In an ideal world no child should need to work. They should be free to enjoy their childhood and their teenage years without the trappings of having to,hold down a job, alongside fitting in their schooling.

hellywelly3 · 17/07/2021 19:31

The laws were brought in because people took the piss with getting young kids to stupid hours for next to no pay. It was exploitation.

catfunk · 17/07/2021 19:30

[quote MythsandSparkles]@catfunk see I read that and wonder where your parents were?

That workload is more than just earning a bit of pocket money which is what the OP is talking about.

And if you were only earning pocket money from seemingly a dawn to midnight workload then you were being exploited…which rather proves the point of why we now have so many regulations.[/quote]
My parents were great, my dad was a police officer and my mum a teacher. It wasn't illegal back then and I wasn't being exploited- it was my choice to work 2 jobs, I was fit and energetic enough to do it (I would be dead on my feet now)
I absolutely loved my jobs and was paid well and earned great tips. Enough to pay for holidays and save up for driving lessons.

GreenLakes · 17/07/2021 19:29

To be frank children have their whole lives ahead of them to work, I just don’t understand the clamour from some to get them out to work as soon as possible.

roarrlikeadinosaur · 17/07/2021 19:29

My mum was obsessed with me having summer jobs and I hated it!

Abraxan · 17/07/2021 19:28

@SunsetandCupcakes

It can help kids to not be exploited

But when do we accept they are not kids? They can have a baby at 16, and a moped, in some parts of the world they would nearly be middle aged.

When do we stop?

Re employment:
Well obviously the rules change hugely once they hit 16y so from then perhaps?
Do you think the laws were put in place just for the fun of it? Or maybe they were put in place because too many children were exploited in their work in the 90s, etc?

JacquelineCarlyle · 17/07/2021 19:28

I'm with you Op - had a part time job when I was 13 (early 1990s in a petrol station!). The work ethic that it instilled and the confidence it gave me as well as the freedom as I was earning my own money (we didn't have a lot so meant I could buy myself some things without having to burden my parents) was phenomenal.

I think it's criminal that the legislation and regulations mean it's pretty much impossible for 14 & 15 year olds to get jobs. Exploitative employers will exploit people regardless of their age, so someone younger with parents who support them are much less likely to be exploited IMHO.

TrixieThunder · 17/07/2021 19:26

I don’t have a problem with 15-16 year olds working (I do for anything lower, though - children are already in school for a lot of their time + homework on top usually resulting in full time adult hours).

However, it’s to exploitable and unfair to the children. The pay - doing the same job as others for a fraction of the pay due to their age. The fact that kids are less likely to speak up about exploitation over adults. Uni students are allowed to work part time but there’s rules on that too (depending on uni) about how much that impedes their study time. These are children we talking about. I don’t understand the problem about ‘extending’ childhood to 15 year olds. They are still in full time education and are in fact CHILDREN.

And furthering the problem - What if the parents demand they work to ‘pay rent’, when the parents should be responsible for housing and food until education ends? There’s a lot of pitfalls so I understand why the rules are so stringent. Work for 15-16 year olds should be more about experience rather than an additional means for money. I’m not suggesting we shouldn’t pay or reward but to force that level or pressure is cruel - it should be for enrichment foremost.

delilahbucket · 17/07/2021 19:23

You try getting employee insurance for under 16s OP and then come back to me. Then there is the council permit to allow you to employ someone under 16...