Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you are that short of staff you should employ 15year olds?

261 replies

SunsetandCupcakes · 17/07/2021 18:19

I'm not that old, still old but in the v late 90s I had a job in the kitchens, my brother had a job selling ice creams at 14.
Catering near me is struggling to fill vacancies, it's the summer in a holiday town, two kiosks have had to close as no staff and yet my 15 year old isn't allowed to work.
How can working be more detrimental than sat at home on the PS4, we've ended up with a funny view on teenagers

OP posts:
pinkcircustop · 19/07/2021 18:24

@MrsDThomas

Obviously you are employing the wrong people then.
We regularly employ lots of all types from various backgrounds and have done for many, many years. They’re not all “the wrong people”.

It’s simply that the overwhelming majority of under 18s are a hindrance.

MrsDThomas · 19/07/2021 18:15

Obviously you are employing the wrong people then.

warmfluffytowels · 19/07/2021 18:09

The kids who feel they need to earn some money (because their parents can’t afford to subsidise them ) are probably the ones least likely to have nice, middle class neighbours who pay for dog sitting and car washing or even have gardens.

I mean, the last time I checked, kids have legs and can walk to different neighbourhoods.

There's plenty of casual work out there for teens who are willing - I live in a town that's definitely not middle class and plenty of teens earn money doing odd jobs like the ones I mentioned.

pinkcircustop · 19/07/2021 17:59

@MrsDThomas

I’m from the era when i worked in a pub kitchen from the age of 12 until 16. Its a shame times have changed. Gives kids sone kind of work ethic.

And to the person on page 1 who said they’d be more of a hindrance? Jeez.... 🙄 give kids a chance ffs.

I manage a business that regularly employs 16 -18 year olds. The overwhelming majority of them are more of a hindrance than a help.
MrsDThomas · 19/07/2021 17:55

I’m from the era when i worked in a pub kitchen from the age of 12 until 16. Its a shame times have changed. Gives kids sone kind of work ethic.

And to the person on page 1 who said they’d be more of a hindrance? Jeez.... 🙄 give kids a chance ffs.

Comefromaway · 19/07/2021 17:41

@warmfluffytowels

But if the 15 year old feels they cannot enjoy their summer because they need more money to do so, then what is the solution?

They could offer their services around the neighbourhood for money - mowing lawns, washing cars, walking dogs, babysitting etc.

When I was fourteen I worked on Friday nights dog-sitting for our neighbours' dog who had separation anxiety. They paid me £10 an hour to sit in their house and watch TV while their dog snored on the sofa next to me Grin

I also did babysitting for other neighbours, and washed cars occasionally.

The kids who feel they need to earn some money (because their parents can’t afford to subsidise them ) are probably the ones least likely to have nice, middle class neighbours who pay for dog sitting and car washing or even have gardens.

Dh was brought up in a street (& his dad still lives there) where the neighbours are more likely to get a teen drug dealing than dog sitting.

DysmalRadius · 19/07/2021 17:14

@warmfluffytowels and @CastawayQueen

I agree, and suggested self employment upthread, but was responding to a poster who said that 15 year old shouldn't work at all.

Maggiesfarm · 19/07/2021 16:51

If they want to work and find something that suits them, fine. Mine did that. There was no compulsion from me or their dad, it was their choice. What they earned supplemented their allowances and they enjoyed it but they were lucky to find part time employment in areas that interested them.

I never worked while at school, liked being in bed too much in the morning at weekends and during the holidays.

As for babysitting, my mother would never have allowed me to babysit at 15. I don't know why and it still rankles a bit because I was asked and had to turn it down. However I wouldn't have been paid, just food provided for me to pick at. Paid babysitting wasn't such a thing back then, it was usually for friends and relatives.

CastawayQueen · 19/07/2021 15:45

@DysmalRadius

Again, I just don’t get the desperation for DC to be working as soon as possible.

Teenagers want to work and earn their own money - 'twas ever thus.

15 year olds should be enjoying their summers- not packed into commercial kitchens.

But if the 15 year old feels they cannot enjoy their summer because they need more money to do so, then what is the solution?

Surely they can be creative - lots of ways to make money online including tutoring, transcribing videos for subtitling, etc. Or informal, cash in hand jobs like babysitting or weeding gardens as pp have mentioned
warmfluffytowels · 19/07/2021 15:38

But if the 15 year old feels they cannot enjoy their summer because they need more money to do so, then what is the solution?

They could offer their services around the neighbourhood for money - mowing lawns, washing cars, walking dogs, babysitting etc.

When I was fourteen I worked on Friday nights dog-sitting for our neighbours' dog who had separation anxiety. They paid me £10 an hour to sit in their house and watch TV while their dog snored on the sofa next to me Grin

I also did babysitting for other neighbours, and washed cars occasionally.

DysmalRadius · 19/07/2021 15:31

Again, I just don’t get the desperation for DC to be working as soon as possible.

Teenagers want to work and earn their own money - 'twas ever thus.

15 year olds should be enjoying their summers- not packed into commercial kitchens.

But if the 15 year old feels they cannot enjoy their summer because they need more money to do so, then what is the solution?

BiBabbles · 19/07/2021 15:31

Every employer has to balance the risk, benefit, and responsibilities of taking on young staff. Even if short staffed, they make judge it not worth it. I'm not going to make their risk assessments for them to say they 'should'.

It's quite possible to be engaged in something worthwhile and develop skills without it being paid employment. If the entire reason someone is 'incapable' or 'infantilized' is because they don't have a job, they'd likely be a crap employee anyways (and there are definitely people who remain that way while in work).

My DS1 had over 100 hours of community volunteering under his belt at 15. During the last year when most youth volunteering was shut, he worked on learning SQL and developing programming & other skills that he could then offer, but is back to more practical things now that it's slowly starting to open up again. He's spent the last week helping in allotments.

There are options for most teenagers to broaden their skill sets, way more than what we had in the '90s. They just take a bit more to look for than the local hospitality area which already have enough to deal with.

in some parts of the world they would nearly be middle aged.

No, they wouldn't. Living in an area with a low life expectancy doesn't mean people age faster - it means more children die, some from unsafe work.

See I think if you are already dodgy, age wouldn't make a difference

Yes it does make a difference, because other people can then intervene. 'The Rules' make intervention possible.

If you or your child want to campaign to change the laws around child labour or to make work more accessible for teenagers, go for it, that's how changes are made. Employers may still not want to hire them and that would still be within their rights, they have other options now too like automation, but if you feel strongly about it, go for it.

warmfluffytowels · 19/07/2021 14:39

Don't see too many restrictions, though they aren't allowed to work in kitchens.

They also can't work all day on Sundays (two hours only) or all day on Saturdays unless it's the school holidays. Or before 7am or after 7pm.

Most hospitality places need weekend staff who can work long shifts - including Friday and Saturday nights, or they need cover for weekends when full-time staff may be off. You can't cover a Sunday shift with a 15yo who can only be there for two hours.

You can't cover a shift that doesn't finish until 11pm with someone who needs to leave and go home at 7pm. You can't cover a busy weekend with someone who needs an hour break for every four hours they work - it's just not practical.

jasjas1973 · 19/07/2021 14:18

[quote Kazzyhoward]**@GreyhoundG1rl* Why did you need the school's permission for your dd to do Saturday work?*

There was a time (maybe there still is) where an employer needed an approval form signed by the school before they could legally employee a child.[/quote]
Sorry if this has already been posted.

Don't see too many restrictions, though they aren't allowed to work in kitchens.

childlawadvice.org.uk/information-pages/child-employment/

My DD is 21, she worked as a 15yo, many of her friends did too.

GreenLakes · 19/07/2021 14:12

Again, I just don’t get the desperation for DC to be working as soon as possible.

15 year olds should be enjoying their summers- not packed into commercial kitchens. They have decades ahead of them to work!

warmfluffytowels · 19/07/2021 14:06

@gingganggooleywotsit

I absolutely agree op. Teenagers are more than capable. My dd is desperate to earn some money but there’s nothing for that age group these days.
They are capable, but the laws in place mean that it's almost impossible to hire a fifteen year old.
DysmalRadius · 19/07/2021 14:00

It sounds like he needs to go self employed - helping him start his own business might be the best thing you can do OP, as the economy is moving more towards that model and its much less restrictive for ambitious kids!

Kazzyhoward · 19/07/2021 13:57

@gingganggooleywotsit

I absolutely agree op. Teenagers are more than capable. My dd is desperate to earn some money but there’s nothing for that age group these days.
Whilst teens are more than capable, it's the laws that make it hard for employers to take them on. Health & Safety, child protection, licensing laws, etc can sometimes be double edged swords.

It's asking a lot of an employer to make a written request to a child's school asking for permission, and then waiting, and waiting, and waiting for their response. (They're highly unlikely to get a response if they submit the form at the start of the Summer holidays until schools return in September, for example!).

Same with the restrictions, i.e. all the jobs/environments that they're not allowed to work within.

I remember a while ago, at a shop checkout, with some alcohol in my basket, and the shop assistant had to ring for someone else to come to take over the till as they were too young to "sell" alcohol.

When you look at all the things they can't do, and then all the rules/regs around the things they can do, it's not really worth the employer bothering at all!

gingganggooleywotsit · 19/07/2021 13:47

I absolutely agree op. Teenagers are more than capable. My dd is desperate to earn some money but there’s nothing for that age group these days.

Kakey1294129 · 19/07/2021 13:44

I believe it's more complicated for under 16ms to work now. They can but have to fill out paperwork. It's doable though and I do agree! Summer jobs was the best and great memories for me! My partner was working at 12 in the early 90's, I was a bit later. definitely more complicated now though!

GCmiddle · 19/07/2021 13:25

We live in a popular seaside town and my 18 year old can't get any work in local shops, cafes etc, because they all want someone with experience. I saw an advert in the local newspaper for support assistants to work with people with learning disabilities. As I have worked in this field all my life, I suggested it to him a possibility. It turns out that they will only take applications from those with prior experience and those who can already use Makaton (a kind of simplified sign language used by some people with learning disabilities). They are paying minimum wage, yet are demanding skills and experience. How is someone to get their first step on the ladder ?

wordsareveryunnecessary · 19/07/2021 10:25

My son read that Tesco are really needing staff but they won't take any under 16's. So he's stuck at home when could be helping out

Kazzyhoward · 19/07/2021 10:04

@statetrooperstacey

Hrtft but if he really wants to work he could try your local market if you have one, stall holders will often give a couple of hours cash in hand. Also Chinese takeaways pretty universally will have an early evening slot often paid cash in hand , certainly in our area, so possibly worth a try. My 15 year old often gets a bit of private labouring at the weekends and holidays. Patios, garden clearing, etc do you know any builders?
Sadly that is true. But "cash in hand" goes hand in hand with fewer (if any) safeguards, such as proper health & safety, insurance if something goes wrong, safe working policies, etc etc. Personally, I wouldn't want a child of mine working somewhere that doesn't follow employment laws, as if they don't care about one law (i.e. children working regulations) then they're probably not bothering about other laws either, such as food hygiene, fire precautions, etc.
statetrooperstacey · 19/07/2021 06:40

Hrtft but if he really wants to work he could try your local market if you have one, stall holders will often give a couple of hours cash in hand. Also Chinese takeaways pretty universally will have an early evening slot often paid cash in hand , certainly in our area, so possibly worth a try. My 15 year old often gets a bit of private labouring at the weekends and holidays. Patios, garden clearing, etc do you know any builders?

Comefromaway · 18/07/2021 15:44

Child employment

Many children work part-time, it can be a helpful source of extra money and good preparation for the future. But many jobs are illegal without a licence from the Local Authority.

The basic rules

Under national laws and County Council by-laws, licences can only be issued within strictly defined limits:

All work must be "light duties" only.
Children must be at least 13 years old to be employed.
13 year olds can only do a job on a specified list.
No child under school leaving age can work before 7am or after 7pm on any day (including school holidays).
No child can be employed for more than 2 hours on a school day and certainly not during school hours.
No child can be employed for more than 12 hours in a school week (including the weekend).
Sunday employment is restricted to 2 hours only between 7am and 7pm.

Saturdays and in school holidays

13-14 year olds can work a maximum 5 hours per day; up to 25 hours in total per week, (with a one hour break after 4 hours)

15-16 year olds can work up to 8 hours per day; up to 35 hours in total per week, (with a one hour break after four hours)

Work falling outside these restrictions is illegal and cannot be licensed.

County Council Byelaws Regulating the Employment of Children (216 KB)
If you want to employ a child you must:

Apply to for a work permit, for each child you wish to employ.
Adhere to the byelaws regulating the employment of children.
Carry out a risk assessment which takes into account the child’s age and maturity.
Tell the children’s parents about any risks and measures put in place to protect children from these.

Jobs that must have a licence

Any employment of a school aged child in a "trade or occupation carried on for profit" is illegal without a licence. This includes parents employing their own children in their business, even if they are not paid. Examples of work a child could be licenced for:

Paper rounds
Shop work
Cleaning
Work on farms
Clerical/office work
Leaflet delivery
Waiting at tables

Jobs that don't need a licence

Not all work is covered by the law on part-time jobs, itemised below are examples of part-time jobs that do not require a licence:

Children doing odd jobs around the house or for neighbours.
Babysitting
Work experience organised by your child's school.
Parents are strongly advised they know what their child Is responsible for doing and that they are safe.

Illegal employment

Some work cannot be licensed at all and cannot be legally done by school-age children, including any work in:

Factories
Building site
Serving alcohol
Milk deliveries
Sorting refuse
Working with food in commercial kitchens (including chip shops and take-away establishments).

This is not the complete list.

What should you do if your child wants to work?

Satisfy yourself the job is safe for your child - a paper round on dark mornings or nights may not be suitable.

Satisfy yourself the employer is reputable and the job is legal.

Ensure the employer applies for a licence and obtains your signature.

If you are the employer as well as the parent, make sure you get a licence if required.

Raise any concerns you may have, either with the employer or Families First.

Make sure your child has a licence to work until they are old enough to leave school - in most cases this will be after they become 16!
School leaving age

From 1998 onwards all children reach school-leaving age on the same date, no matter when they are 16. This is the last Friday in June of their final school year.