Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you are that short of staff you should employ 15year olds?

261 replies

SunsetandCupcakes · 17/07/2021 18:19

I'm not that old, still old but in the v late 90s I had a job in the kitchens, my brother had a job selling ice creams at 14.
Catering near me is struggling to fill vacancies, it's the summer in a holiday town, two kiosks have had to close as no staff and yet my 15 year old isn't allowed to work.
How can working be more detrimental than sat at home on the PS4, we've ended up with a funny view on teenagers

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GreyhoundG1rl · 20/07/2021 19:18

@H328

YANBU at all OP. I worked in various jobs from the age of 13 in the 90s (starting with a paper round and moving to waitressing etc) and it was great. I feel a bit sad and frustrated that my DC won't have that same opportunity.
So did I, but I'm not particularly bothered that my kids won't. I didn't see it as an opportunity in that sense.
H328 · 20/07/2021 17:50

YANBU at all OP. I worked in various jobs from the age of 13 in the 90s (starting with a paper round and moving to waitressing etc) and it was great. I feel a bit sad and frustrated that my DC won't have that same opportunity.

Purpl · 20/07/2021 17:36

My 15 yr old has got a job in a shop & getting loads of hours as she is cheap labour. Worth a try apply online via indeed as well as walk round with cv

Maggiesfarm · 20/07/2021 13:31

warmfluffytowels:
I didn't work properly until I graduated at 22 and I was never late to work and knew exactly how to dress! You don't need a job at 15 to learn those things lol.
.....
Agreed.

I don't think there is any right or wrong about this. It all depends on the financial situation of the parents and what the teenager wants to do.

sillybut · 20/07/2021 12:41

By the time I was 13 (late 1980s) I had a weekend job in a pub kitchen - cooking, cleaning, washing up, waitressing and best of all cleaning the deep fat fryer using ammonia (I found mixing it with fairy liquid had great results but it gave off awful fumes!!) Grin

I was paid £2.25 an hour probably about £4.75 in todays money plus lunch and I was RICH. Loved payday handed over in cash in a little money bag every fortnight.

Not sure a child would be allowed to do my job now!!

Lonel · 20/07/2021 12:23

Interesting! I worked in M & S food hall when I was 17 and I had completely forgotten about the alcohol rule but I suppose there must have been a supervisor.

melj1213 · 20/07/2021 12:14

@Lonel

What's the rule that under 18s can't work on the till? Like many pps I worked in a shop from age 15/16. Has the law changed?
If you store sells age restricted products then the checkout person has to authorise the sale. If they are under 18 then they can't authorise the sale and have to have a supervisor be present to authorise the sale instead.

If you work in a book shop or cafe then these issues are unlikely to apply whereas in supermarkets almost every other sale will contain an age restricted product so its not worth putting U18s on checkouts when they have to have a second person present practically the entire time.

Equally, if you work in a small owner run shop then they're more likely to be a bit more relaxed about the age restriction rules (my local shop has the owner sitting in an office in the back so he can "supervise" his 17yr old staff) than large corporate chains.

warmfluffytowels · 20/07/2021 12:09

[quote AiyaNapawithmorenaps]@GreenLakes I honestly think starting work early makes a difference. I noticed a correlation between those of us who had jobs at 16 and those who tried to gain employment at 22 (after Uni.) I think it's so important, if you don't do a vocational degree, to learn about employment prior to starting your first 'proper' job. One of my friends got sacked for being late and not dressing appropriately, as her whole experience had just been uni where you can usually rock up late and wear joggers every day. Didn't wash in a graduate schedule.[/quote]
I didn't work properly until I graduated at 22 and I was never late to work and knew exactly how to dress! You don't need a job at 15 to learn those things lol.

warmfluffytowels · 20/07/2021 12:07

@Lonel

What's the rule that under 18s can't work on the till? Like many pps I worked in a shop from age 15/16. Has the law changed?
Under-eighteens aren't allowed to sell alcohol, tobacco or knives, so if you put a 15/16/17 year old on the till, you need another staff member there who can do all the approvals on age-restricted products.
AiyaNapawithmorenaps · 20/07/2021 11:55

@GreenLakes I honestly think starting work early makes a difference. I noticed a correlation between those of us who had jobs at 16 and those who tried to gain employment at 22 (after Uni.) I think it's so important, if you don't do a vocational degree, to learn about employment prior to starting your first 'proper' job. One of my friends got sacked for being late and not dressing appropriately, as her whole experience had just been uni where you can usually rock up late and wear joggers every day. Didn't wash in a graduate schedule.

sorryforswearing · 20/07/2021 11:44

I have sympathy op. I got my first job in an independent group of newsagents and tobacconists at 13. I simply walked in and said ‘
Do you have any jobs’? I worked holidays and weekends until I left college at 21. Life is much more regulated/complicated now. Maybe some of it is necessary and beneficial but not all.

Comefromaway · 20/07/2021 11:39

@Lonel

What's the rule that under 18s can't work on the till? Like many pps I worked in a shop from age 15/16. Has the law changed?
It depends on what they are selling. Under 18's can't sell alcohol, tobacco, knives, age restricted video games etc etc
Kazzyhoward · 20/07/2021 11:39

@Lonel

What's the rule that under 18s can't work on the till? Like many pps I worked in a shop from age 15/16. Has the law changed?
They're not allowed to sell age-restricted items, such as alcohol, tobacco, knives etc.

Some credit card processors (merchant accounts) prohibit under 18s from accepting cards at the till, so if the business uses one of those c/c providers, they can only handle cash sales.

Lonel · 20/07/2021 11:33

What's the rule that under 18s can't work on the till? Like many pps I worked in a shop from age 15/16. Has the law changed?

melj1213 · 20/07/2021 11:19

And to the person on page 1 who said they’d be more of a hindrance? Jeez.... 🙄 give kids a chance ffs.

Why are people making out like calling them hindrances is a personal attack on specific children?

Having under 16s (as opposed to adults) is a hindrance in many workplaces because they are not allowed to do so many things and there are so many rules that they need constant supervision. it defeats the purpose of employing them to free up other people if those people then have to supervise them the whole time. That is not a judgement on the particular child who is working, but the situation.

I work in a supermarket, we don't employ under 16s because it isn't worth the hassle - the limited hours and roles they can do isn't worth the time it takes to do the paperwork especially especially you can just as easily ask an existing colleague to stay an extra couple of hours on a Sunday etc. We also only employ 16-18yr old as a rarity on the shop floor because, again, it's not worth the hassle since they aren't old enough for us train them on the machinery/checkouts etc and allow them to use them unsupervised... and if we need someone over 18 who is trained to supervise them at all times it's a waste of time when that person can just do it themselves. Similarly when I worked in a hotel as a waitress in the hotel restaurant I got far more hours once I turned 18 and could work till the dining room closed at 10pm and then help out behind the bar if they were busy and/or short handed (or if it was a quiet night with minimal dinner reservations then instead of being sent home they could let me work behind the bar)

Some places, where they literally just need an extra pair of hands to help serve customers between 9-5 in the school holidays but there will always be an adult present probably don't mind having 15yos on staff. But if you need someone flexible, who can be left to work independently and who is legally allowed to do all parts of the job then under 16s aren't viable options, no matter how hard working an individual child is.

Comefromaway · 20/07/2021 11:15

I agree Jesus.

My dd gained experience one summer volunteering at the local library for their Summer Reading Challenge activities. She was then able to put this on her CV as experience of working with children to enable her to get her first job in 6th form assisting with kids drama & dance classes.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 20/07/2021 11:00

If you want an under 16 to get a job hospitality is the wrong place to look. Employing a child in hospitality is not easy, there are lots of rules that make it hard work and inflexible.

Try animal care, hairdressers, newsagents, leisure centres, and if money isn't important charities, e.g. behind the scenes at charity shops sorting deliveries. Sometimes volunteering first helps get a foot in the door or relevant experience.

If the child has any skills look at coaching/teaching qualifications.

My relative had a paid job at 14, it turned into an apprenticeship at 16, then a higher level apprenticeship, and now a career doing something they love and travelling at their employer's expense. There are jobs out there if they are keen.

sleepismyhobby · 20/07/2021 08:54

My son 15 and a desperate for a part time job they said they wouldn't employ him S he would need to get a pvg and no one under -6 can get a pvg! We live in a tiny village so no paper round or anything as no shops

CastawayQueen · 20/07/2021 08:52

[quote GreenLakes]@Maggiesfarm

Which is why I think teens who are still in full time education at that age (who don’t come from a household with a high income) should be paid an allowance by government.

I don’t agree with the situation at the moment where teens from poorer backgrounds are out working to earn money and thereby not as able to focus on their studies (and just enjoying life at that age!).[/quote]
You think the government should give teens free spending money for their wants?
Most of the working teens I know do it because a) their parents want to instil the value of hard work or b)They want extras like a new Xbox. Or pretty clothes and makeup. Neither of which they actually need and could survive without.
Ironically it’s the poorer teens who don’t work because their parents want them to focus on their studies and get a good job (and use the money to help the family) 😂 but I guess they’re also ‘privileged’ because their parents value education, eh?

If families need money then it should be given as a family but money to spend on leisure doesn’t make sense

MeanderingGently · 20/07/2021 02:47

We all had Saturday jobs when I was a teenager, I had mine from around 14/15. Basically it was every Saturday, but being already employed (it was a clothing shop) meant I could work extra in the holidays/Christmas or when they needed stock-taking and so on.

These days under 16 is counted as a 'child'. You can employ youngsters but there are all sorts of extra laws to protect children form being exploited and for safe-guarding reasons. I know of a hotel which will happily employ 15 year olds if they are nearing their 16th birthday; it does someone good to learn good work habits early on in life. However, as that particular job is cleaning rooms, not many 15/16 year olds want to do it, and even if they do, they tend not to work quickly enough.

overnightangel · 20/07/2021 01:57

@SunsetandCupcakes

I get what everyone is saying about 'The Rules' but how can this help anyone?
Your probably post “ To think if you are that short of staff you should employ 15year olds?” Someone pointed out the rules to explain.
GreenLakes · 20/07/2021 01:36

@Maggiesfarm

Which is why I think teens who are still in full time education at that age (who don’t come from a household with a high income) should be paid an allowance by government.

I don’t agree with the situation at the moment where teens from poorer backgrounds are out working to earn money and thereby not as able to focus on their studies (and just enjoying life at that age!).

Maggiesfarm · 19/07/2021 21:13

@GreenLakes

Personally I would totally ban part time employment for under 16s and substantially restrict it to casual arrangements like dog walking for under 18s.

The focus at that age should be on education and enjoying being a teenager, not washing pots or pulling pints.

I agree in principle but some kids don't receive a good allowance because parents can't afford it so they look for jobs to finance their social lives.

It's OK as long as they are doing something they enjoy and the hours aren't too arduous.

GreenLakes · 19/07/2021 18:35

Personally I would totally ban part time employment for under 16s and substantially restrict it to casual arrangements like dog walking for under 18s.

The focus at that age should be on education and enjoying being a teenager, not washing pots or pulling pints.

gabsdot45 · 19/07/2021 18:34

I agree. My son is 17, I work in HR in a factory and we're really struggling to find staff but I can't employ him and his friends because they're under 18.
Employment law is slightly different for minors so it can make things a bit tricky for production in terms of breaks and rest periods

Swipe left for the next trending thread