Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else feel like they can’t afford much?

207 replies

Kitten189 · 17/07/2021 16:44

I earn around 19.5k a year which is low, but I have no dependants.
I live with my partner and he earns slightly lower, our rent isn’t that high between us but sometimes I just feel like I can’t afford to live very well.

I used to go shopping with friends and they would be spending hours buying quite high-end things and I could just about afford something from primark.
Virtually all my clothes are from Primark, charity shops, EBay, Tesco etc.

I don’t drink or smoke, I have a basic gym membership, a phone contract and Netflix but that’s it.

I get my hair cut every 6 weeks at £25 and I very occasionally get Botox or a facial, but I get it cut price.

I have zero debt which is good, no overdraft etc. As until last year I was in debt, I paid it off with birthday money from my parents.

I just don’t seem to save anything and don’t know where it all goes. I see people going out to fancy places, wearing nice clothes etc and still managing to save money.

I recently went for a meal with friends. It was at a fancy restaurant one of them had chosen, I just had one main but they were all ordering cocktails, desserts etc like it was nothing.

I shop in Poundland, Wilkos and mainly Aldi etc.

Just don’t know where I’m going wrong, I can’t seem to afford anything and never seem to save. I used to have a friend who was out drinking twice a week yet still managed to save £200 per month.

Anyone else feel like this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SpeckledlyHen · 18/07/2021 18:31

@firstonealong

Yes your spending is fine and I think you sound very switched on to your money but...

You absolutely need a better paying job

In 1998 I was on your wage as a PA

It makes me so angry the rubbish wages that are being paid, they seem to have just stagnated for the past twenty years

This.. I was just remembering my first "proper" job back in 1991 (Sales I think it was then) and I remember being delighted to be earning 19k a year when I was then 21.
CastawayQueen · 18/07/2021 13:47

@WombatChocolate

To me, that income doesn’t sit with £100 nights out.

This is the issue….the expenses are behind the means….likely to be the case for many of your friends too in reality u less they earn well more than double what you have.

I earn more than double what you do and so does my DH. We are not hard up, but if one of us went out for a night out, we wouldn’t expect it to cost more than £30 unless it was something pretty special…..and only £50 perhaps once or twice a year. We would expect to both go out for a friends birthday on a so-called big night and it to be around £50-60 for the pair of us. It does help that I don’t drink much, but DH would probably have half a bottle of wine if we were out for a meal with friends, or two or three beers.

These nights out which involve expensive rounds, taxis, both a meal and then some kind of extra late night meal etc etc seem an awful lot for just a standard Friday night out. But I guess if the company you keep like to do this and it’s the norm in your circle, then it’s hard to participate and not do it. I said before, but I do think for most people these kind of lifestyles have a limited shelf life. By the time you’re 30 people will be dropping off to save for houses or having kids.

This. Don’t know why so many people are complimenting OP on her great attitude towards money or suggesting ways to increase her income. It’s her attitude to money that’s the problem and even if she had more money she’d probably just spend it all and be in the exact same position as she is now.

Most of my high earning friends spend at most £300 a month on personal things. And they all prioritise. Some people like dining out, maybe others have a specific hobby. Nobody gets to have everything they want when they want it. If your friends are spendthrifts OP maybe you need new ones?

wedswench · 18/07/2021 13:39

@WombatChocolate

To me, that income doesn’t sit with £100 nights out.

This is the issue….the expenses are behind the means….likely to be the case for many of your friends too in reality u less they earn well more than double what you have.

I earn more than double what you do and so does my DH. We are not hard up, but if one of us went out for a night out, we wouldn’t expect it to cost more than £30 unless it was something pretty special…..and only £50 perhaps once or twice a year. We would expect to both go out for a friends birthday on a so-called big night and it to be around £50-60 for the pair of us. It does help that I don’t drink much, but DH would probably have half a bottle of wine if we were out for a meal with friends, or two or three beers.

These nights out which involve expensive rounds, taxis, both a meal and then some kind of extra late night meal etc etc seem an awful lot for just a standard Friday night out. But I guess if the company you keep like to do this and it’s the norm in your circle, then it’s hard to participate and not do it. I said before, but I do think for most people these kind of lifestyles have a limited shelf life. By the time you’re 30 people will be dropping off to save for houses or having kids.

You're right it's all about what those around you are doing. In the context of OP, it can feel like everyone around you is doing so much more than you can afford and it's sucks.

I just don't do the nights out (apart from when friend gifted me the cash because she wanted me there) because I'd rather not go at all than have to nurse a cheap drink while everyone else knocks back cocktails. Or that horrible moment when the food bill comes and everyone naturally wants to split it equally and you're sat there thinking oh lord I had a small salad and I hope someone notices before I have to say something about only paying by share.

Yeah, there are bigger problems but it still sucks.

My friends didn't cut down when they hit 30... if anything they spend more these days. Maybe I need new skint friends!

WombatChocolate · 18/07/2021 13:10

To me, that income doesn’t sit with £100 nights out.

This is the issue….the expenses are behind the means….likely to be the case for many of your friends too in reality u less they earn well more than double what you have.

I earn more than double what you do and so does my DH. We are not hard up, but if one of us went out for a night out, we wouldn’t expect it to cost more than £30 unless it was something pretty special…..and only £50 perhaps once or twice a year. We would expect to both go out for a friends birthday on a so-called big night and it to be around £50-60 for the pair of us. It does help that I don’t drink much, but DH would probably have half a bottle of wine if we were out for a meal with friends, or two or three beers.

These nights out which involve expensive rounds, taxis, both a meal and then some kind of extra late night meal etc etc seem an awful lot for just a standard Friday night out. But I guess if the company you keep like to do this and it’s the norm in your circle, then it’s hard to participate and not do it. I said before, but I do think for most people these kind of lifestyles have a limited shelf life. By the time you’re 30 people will be dropping off to save for houses or having kids.

CastawayQueen · 18/07/2021 11:57

@2orangey

OP I understand what you are getting at and so would most people in the country. You work hard for 40 hours a week and can just about afford a few extra treats, yet some people spend lavishly without seemingly a care in the world.

Mumsnet is such an upper middle class enclave. (How many times can PPs repeat 'you are on a very low income' and reel off their high salaries FFS).

To all those suggesting you get your NQT and all will be peachy: I have the NQT and now work in a non-teaching role for even less than OP (quelle horreur!).

Just because there are TV adverts for new teachers people seem to think you can just waltz into a teaching career. It very much depends on your subject area, part of the country etc. My school seemed to get new NQTs every year rather than employ permanently. You will have missed this boat unfortunately as there are more NQTs every year.

If you aren't 100% enthusiastic about being a teacher, it isn't worth the stress. And teaching is SO incredibly stressful. Talk to any group of teachers and at least 1 will be looking to leave. A big percentage of my PGCE cohort aren't in teaching for various reasons. You aren't alone basically!

Anyway the money thing. I think you are doing really well to stay out of debt. I do all the same things as you - Aldi, Primark. 25 pounds is a good price for a haircut!

What are your money goals? I am a few years older than you (late 30s) and have bought a small property with my (also low wage) partner in Greater Manchester. If you are looking to do this then try and figure out how much you can put aside each month for a deposit. Maybe use the money you would have spent on the gym? I downloaded one of those apps that links to your bank account and shows you how much you spend each month on different categories such as food, transport etc. This might help you see if there is anything you could cut. (Fewer nights out if you aren't enjoying them?).

If I’m being perfectly honest a lot of people in the country wouldn’t understand the OP at all. In what world is £400 (being very conservative) personal spending classed as ‘just able to afford a few treats’?
2orangey · 18/07/2021 11:31

OP I understand what you are getting at and so would most people in the country. You work hard for 40 hours a week and can just about afford a few extra treats, yet some people spend lavishly without seemingly a care in the world.

Mumsnet is such an upper middle class enclave. (How many times can PPs repeat 'you are on a very low income' and reel off their high salaries FFS).

To all those suggesting you get your NQT and all will be peachy: I have the NQT and now work in a non-teaching role for even less than OP (quelle horreur!).

Just because there are TV adverts for new teachers people seem to think you can just waltz into a teaching career. It very much depends on your subject area, part of the country etc. My school seemed to get new NQTs every year rather than employ permanently. You will have missed this boat unfortunately as there are more NQTs every year.

If you aren't 100% enthusiastic about being a teacher, it isn't worth the stress. And teaching is SO incredibly stressful. Talk to any group of teachers and at least 1 will be looking to leave. A big percentage of my PGCE cohort aren't in teaching for various reasons. You aren't alone basically!

Anyway the money thing. I think you are doing really well to stay out of debt. I do all the same things as you - Aldi, Primark. 25 pounds is a good price for a haircut!

What are your money goals? I am a few years older than you (late 30s) and have bought a small property with my (also low wage) partner in Greater Manchester. If you are looking to do this then try and figure out how much you can put aside each month for a deposit. Maybe use the money you would have spent on the gym? I downloaded one of those apps that links to your bank account and shows you how much you spend each month on different categories such as food, transport etc. This might help you see if there is anything you could cut. (Fewer nights out if you aren't enjoying them?).

wedswench · 18/07/2021 10:21

Yeah it doesn't help I love a drink and seemingly so does everyone around me!

kowari · 18/07/2021 10:20

I couldn't spend £100 because two pints of cider is my limit without being ill.

kowari · 18/07/2021 10:18

The OP doesn't drink though, so she could go out with friends and even if she had a few non alcoholic drinks and a coffee and dessert, then it would still be substantially cheaper than £100.

CastawayQueen · 18/07/2021 10:10

[quote wedswench]@CastawayQueen

Night out, 3 friends:

£5 bus there
£14 meal
£46 first round (bottle of wine and 3 cocktails)
£28 bottle of wine to share
£7 G&T
£6 chicken shop
£15 taxi home

= £121

and that's without the pre kids class As

That was my last night out. They had shots too which I didn't get involved in. Nor did I get a new outfit.

I'm not working and have no money thankfully my lovely lovely friend gave me £100 for this night.
[/quote]
Ah ok that explains it I’d only have 3 drinks the whole night 😂

wedswench · 18/07/2021 10:03

@CastawayQueen

Night out, 3 friends:

£5 bus there
£14 meal
£46 first round (bottle of wine and 3 cocktails)
£28 bottle of wine to share
£7 G&T
£6 chicken shop
£15 taxi home

= £121

and that's without the pre kids class As

That was my last night out. They had shots too which I didn't get involved in. Nor did I get a new outfit.

I'm not working and have no money thankfully my lovely lovely friend gave me £100 for this night.

Imcatmum · 18/07/2021 09:46

One thing Ive learned is that putting effort into earning more is far more valuable than putting effort into saving more. So earning an extra £10 is worth way more than cutting back for that £10.

Your salary is very low. Work on increasing that.

CastawayQueen · 18/07/2021 09:40

Also to add OP you can try getting a prepayment card for going out or putting it in a different account so once you’ve spent your allocation it’s gone

CastawayQueen · 18/07/2021 09:39

@Apocalypse10

I know how hard it is, I used to struggle too and it’s not realistic to say you won’t spend 100 on a night out…that’s very easily done!

I think as others have said you need to budget. Make a spreadsheet and work out your long term plan. Is it to save for a deposit or just have a better standard of living? Realise that you might be talking about a five year plan but the longer it takes you to start the more you’re delaying your goal.

Work out how much you can reasonably afford to save after all of your outgoings including social spends. Then stick to it.

When I was on your salary I had to be strict with myself. If say I allowed 200 for food per month but wanted a splurgy night out then I’d be eating baked beans on toast for the last few days before pay day….you can steal from your food budget to pay into your social budget…and -not- buy clothes one month for example….

It’s do able but is hard….and maybe for some people when they earn more they don’t face these struggles but I have found that the more I earn the bigger my outgoings so I still have similar issues now!

How do you spend 100 on a night out genuine question I couldn’t even if I tried
OceanTurtles · 18/07/2021 08:36

Firstly, you're trying your best. You sound really sensible. Low wages are absolutely shit. Everything rises but the low earners are expected to just get on with it! Shocking.

If you're on regular medication if you haven't already get a prescription pre payment card. It's around £10 per month I believe and renews yearly and works out so much cheaper. My partner is on daily medication and has the pre payment card. I wouldn't like to think what the cost would be without the card.

Also, in shops like Poundland be wary of some things. What you think you're getting a great deal on is not always the case. Shop around a bit if you can.

Some people just live off credit cards so don't compare yourself to others. I know it's tough not to but you have no debt and budget your wage. This is really sensible.

Clothes and alcohol might make someone happy short term but I'd much rather have no debt and Primark clothes!

R0undandR0und · 18/07/2021 08:32

Having no debt is great !

I earn more, but I still buy clothes from çharity shops, because I love a bargain & the unusual treasures that I find

I don't get the feeling that you really want to progress. All the people that I know who have changed career have been 100% focused & have all succeeded. Perhaps it is a case that you don't believe in yourself /confidence ?

I know 3 people that don't have teaching degrees, but they teach children & adults ( not in school setting)

dottiedodah · 18/07/2021 08:28

Some of these threads are so condescending! So what if you earned what OP is now in 1996 or whatever? Of course not everyone on here is a millionaires wife,or earning 100k .Twice in the last few months ,people have been asking about housing and facing Eviction! Its why I like it here as there is a good spread of different people!

burnoutbabe · 18/07/2021 08:02

If teaching isn't for you, then isn't it time to look for other professional jobs to apply for?

You don't seem to be coping now beyond keeping head above water, which is good, but what about savings for a house/flat, paying for maternity leave, pensions?
Upping your income seems the most logical option. I assume your friends have got on with using their degrees, had a few promotions and that's what is paying for nights out, not necessarily debt.

Ohanaa · 18/07/2021 07:50

@firstonealong

Oh and if Botox makes you feel good - keep doing it
100% agree
Beachbabe1 · 18/07/2021 07:45

Hi. You have very very low rent, very little outgoings, no car, no kids and you have 'little spare money'. Where is your money going?? Forget about buying designer clothes. Primark etc is perfectly fine. Stop comparing yourself to friends. Write down both your outgoings, see what's left and save the whole lot! You have to be strict.

illiteratticom · 17/07/2021 22:38

Really keen to know if you enjoy teaching and do want to be a teacher but have lost confidence as you haven't as yet been offered a job?

Knowing how to successfully budget is a good skill for everyone whatever your income. It's just that you're currently working 40 hours a week, have the qualification, so if you did want to be a teacher, then imo your focus should be on improving your chances of being recruited. If your heart's not really in teaching, then that's another matter.

I'm a professional (not teaching) and took a significant drop in salary moving sideways for a decade while DC were young. When DC older, it took a year to retrain and salary increased significantly.

My point is if you feel teaching really is for you, then doing everything you can to get a teaching job is likely to - in addition to the short term benefit of increasing your expendable income - also give you more options and have longer term financial/ lifestyle benefits too.

Apocalypse10 · 17/07/2021 22:00

I know how hard it is, I used to struggle too and it’s not realistic to say you won’t spend 100 on a night out…that’s very easily done!

I think as others have said you need to budget. Make a spreadsheet and work out your long term plan. Is it to save for a deposit or just have a better standard of living? Realise that you might be talking about a five year plan but the longer it takes you to start the more you’re delaying your goal.

Work out how much you can reasonably afford to save after all of your outgoings including social spends. Then stick to it.

When I was on your salary I had to be strict with myself. If say I allowed 200 for food per month but wanted a splurgy night out then I’d be eating baked beans on toast for the last few days before pay day….you can steal from your food budget to pay into your social budget…and -not- buy clothes one month for example….

It’s do able but is hard….and maybe for some people when they earn more they don’t face these struggles but I have found that the more I earn the bigger my outgoings so I still have similar issues now!

firstonealong · 17/07/2021 21:30

Oh and if Botox makes you feel good - keep doing it

firstonealong · 17/07/2021 21:28

[quote FlaminEckVera]@FrownedUpon

Surely it’s because you’re on a really low wage. I save & spend quite a lot but I earn over 60k. Not really rocket science.

What a vile condescending post. Hmm

@firstonealong

You absolutely need a better paying job.

In 1998 I was on your wage as a PA.

Wow. I bet the OP and everyone on this thread is bowing at your amazing and awesome response. You are a font of great knowledge.

WOW!!! Shock

Hmm

#sarcasm

You win the award for the most spectacularly useless post on the thread.

Can people stop giving the OP a hard time for spending on botox? If it makes her feel better about herself, so what? She isn't spending a lot, and it's not like she is spending £150 a month on cigarettes!

@Kitten189 YANBU. But it's like this for many people unfortunately. I don't think you sound like you're doing too bad tbh. Gym, haircuts, botox and other treats, no debt, a partner to share finances with, and on a similar wage to probably half the country!

And as a few posters have said, many people (who appear to be 'rich',) are VERY much in debt, and lots of it. It's not until one of them (if they are a couple,) loses their job, that their life goes tits up, and the house of cards built on sand, comes tumbling down.

And yes yes YES, I know not ALL people who are solvent/who flash the cash are in debt, but many are!

And also, as a few others have said, stop comparing yourself to others, and don't take any notice of what you read on here. Contrary to what people want you to believe, MOST people on here are not on £50K a year, (for a 3 day a week job,) with a husband on £100K a year... There are a lot of fantasists on here.[/quote]
Love that you only quote part of my post
It was not condescending to OP but rather "you are worth more" and a rage against the system that she is so low paid
Me pointing out my salary in 1998 was to illustrate how fucked up the economy is and against the normal person and greet for a high earner - I assumed that people reading would see that, clearly I was wrong
OP you are worth more than what you are earning - some great suggestions by people here you should action some

CherryPieface · 17/07/2021 21:20

You sound like you have a great attitude to money, you live well, but within your means. I’d really recommend a Monzo card or similar, it’s really helped me manage my spending.