Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you say something?

133 replies

Sexnotgender · 17/07/2021 15:33

Walking with my dogs and children and saw a dad and I assume older sibling swinging 3/4 year old by her arms.

I mentioned in passing that it’s advised not to swing young children by their arms until at least 7 as there’s a risk of dislocation of elbows.

I try not to interfere with other people’s parenting generally but I would have hated them to accidentally hurt her.

Should I just have left them to it?

OP posts:
Sexnotgender · 17/07/2021 17:27

@Flibbitygibbit

Did he tell you not to walk your dogs in this heat ?
Did you not read the thread? It was 16 degrees when I walked them.
OP posts:
Undersnatch · 17/07/2021 17:24

I don’t think this is something so dangerous that it would be appropriate to comment on. And that’s the point - parents should be free to make their own risk assessments without feeling judged, bar abusive situations. We tend to be less risk averse than many about letting kids climb and explore and it amazes me how many people feel that whatever their belief on what is ok is correct and we need told. DH gets it more than me tbf, he often finds women in the park feeling free to tell him off.

Badgercity · 17/07/2021 17:22

I think you need to look at the worst case scenario and decide how vital it is you intervene on people’s parenting.

Worst thing that could happen is a dislocated arm, which would be painful but no ones going to die are they?

There is probably equal risk of a child falling and breaking a wrist at a park. Or what about parents that take small children skiing or rock climbing? Paddling in the sea can be very risky, in Cornwall they have a weaver fish problem that apparently causes extreme pain for days.

Life is risky and you can’t go about informing every person of every risk they are taking.

Flibbitygibbit · 17/07/2021 17:13

Did he tell you not to walk your dogs in this heat ?

PinniGig · 17/07/2021 17:11

@Jjjayfee

Well I am grateful for your post. I did this with my toddler granddaughter in the park recently but won't do it again and I will tell her parents when I see them. I had no idea it was a bad thing to do so thanks
Your granddaughter is at greater risk just being at the park than she is having the old 1-2-3 swing.
Quackajack · 17/07/2021 17:10

I had my shoulder dislocated many times as a child due to this and similar things but I think I had a predisposition for it. Saying that I still wouldn't comment on anyone else doing it and I also swing my daughter at her request.

TowandaForever · 17/07/2021 17:06

Funny how when people see abuse and don't report it they get totally called on it but potentially hurting a child and the op should have said nothing?!

Somethingsnappy · 17/07/2021 16:57

I sympathise OP. Elbow dislocation occurs ridiculously easily in young children and is very very painful. It happened to a little boy in my family, whose parents didn't know about it (not many do). They wished they had known. I always wince when I see parents doing this now. And yes, I want to say something, but don't because I worry about how the 'interference' will be perceived. And rightfully so, according to this thread. I think you were brave actually.

PinniGig · 17/07/2021 16:57

@vodkaredbullgirl

When mine were young, we would hang them upside down swing them by their legs. Also throw them up in the air as toddlers.
I know what you mean but I'm properly laughing at the mental images that immediately brought to mind. Kids picked up and either hung by their feet on the back of the door as a makeshift darts board or stuck to a large wheel with prizes and pounds for people to spin and win big money

When the darts and wheel of fortune is finished, a good old underarm sling to see who can get them stuck over the telephone wires like trainers tied together and given a real launch Grin

UrAWizHarry · 17/07/2021 16:53

@Greenwateringcan

We used to talk along with a child between us and swing them.

I honestly think elf and safety has gone mad at times.

As do countless parents. The risk is no higher than a kid hurting themselves in countless other ways.
Mpsister · 17/07/2021 16:52

I wouldn't have said anything but you did nothing wrong
I love greyhounds 🐶

UrAWizHarry · 17/07/2021 16:52

[quote Sexnotgender]www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.scarymommy.com/dont-swing-your-kid-by-the-arms/%3famp=1[/quote]
In the same article the write says she uses a leash, instantly invalidating her opinion.

At best I think most people will just ignore interfering busybodies, at worst you'll get told to fuck off.

Mollymalone123 · 17/07/2021 16:51

We used to do it with our kids- had no idea- until my eldest DD said please don’t do it Mum with ours and she explained why- and I didn’t do it! No one got upset by it.Sorry people are being so mean! Trouble is how you say something or explain something never comes across well in text-it’s a had to be there moment- but I’d like to think your average person would have said exactly the same as the Dad you spoke to.Rationally 😂

Sexnotgender · 17/07/2021 16:50

@MrsElijahMikaelson1

YANBU-we did this with DD and popped her elbow out-DH is an orthopaedic surgeon as well 😵
Well at least he could put it back in I suppose!
OP posts:
Comeondoit · 17/07/2021 16:49

You guys are weird, is it the heat

Funny, the same thought occurred about you

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 17/07/2021 16:48

YANBU-we did this with DD and popped her elbow out-DH is an orthopaedic surgeon as well 😵

Jjjayfee · 17/07/2021 16:48

Well I am grateful for your post. I did this with my toddler granddaughter in the park recently but won't do it again and I will tell her parents when I see them. I had no idea it was a bad thing to do so thanks

Greenwateringcan · 17/07/2021 16:47

*walk

Greenwateringcan · 17/07/2021 16:47

We used to talk along with a child between us and swing them.

I honestly think elf and safety has gone mad at times.

vodkaredbullgirl · 17/07/2021 16:46

When mine were young, we would hang them upside down swing them by their legs. Also throw them up in the air as toddlers.

Sexnotgender · 17/07/2021 16:46

I’m literally thanking them for their concern. You guys are weird, is it the heatConfused

OP posts:
DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 17/07/2021 16:45

@Sexnotgender

My 2 very placid greyhounds were both in harnesses but thank you for your concern.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Comeondoit · 17/07/2021 16:45

@Sexnotgender

My 2 very placid greyhounds were both in harnesses but thank you for your concern.
Oh the delicious irony of this comment Grin
Sexnotgender · 17/07/2021 16:43

My 2 very placid greyhounds were both in harnesses but thank you for your concern.

OP posts:
DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 17/07/2021 16:42

@Sexnotgender

My dog on a lead was dangerous how exactly?
The dog could have slipped the lead and savaged the kid. It happens, and is probably more likely than your scenario.