Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Little girl in beautiful dress scolded for jumping up and down.

271 replies

0None0 · 17/07/2021 14:40

They were at the bus stop. She was about 5 It was a beautiful white dress with embroidery, and matching shoes She had a carton of juice, and was told off for a little skip of pleasure at the sight of their bus coming, in case the juice splashed on her dress or her shoes. Brother that looked the same age, maybe twins, or just very small age gap, in dark clothes and trainers, also drinking a carton of juice with a straw, leaping up and down like a show jumper, without attracting comment.

WIBU to say something?

OP posts:
Whiskycav · 17/07/2021 15:16

@megletthesecond

There was a few families at the DC's primary school like this. Always nicely turned out but had to keep clean and weren't allowed to tear around. They used to drive me nuts over the years.
Does op know this family? Or known them for years?
Whiskycav · 17/07/2021 15:15

Its really not your business because you have no idea about what goes on in that family, what the situation was or actually anything.

I wouldn't want either of my kids jumping with juice in their hands I clean clothes.

Both my kids wore clothes, they picked. Dd would sometimes want to dress right up for the supermarket or sometimes not. If she wanted a dress in, she had it. She also had lots of dark, more practical clothes. But if she had light coloured clothes on I would be worried about her making a mess.

We went to Disney when my dd was young and she spent most of the day chasing too and from a princess dress she wanted AND shorts and a t shirt that was better for running about it. I preferred the shorts and t shirt, but she also wanted a princess dress.

Same as ds, when he wanted to keep wearing a shirt we got for my sils wedding that was light coloured, for months after. I would be worried about him making it dirty. In case we needed it for another time.

This family could have been going somewhere she was being dropped off at.

You have assumed some sort of sexism in a family when you actually have no clue what's going on. And I think you really need to look at job judgmental you are of first inpressions, if you work with young kids. You may miss alot.

Babyroobs · 17/07/2021 15:13

I hate to see parents scolding little kids for every little thing. Some of them never let up. I probably wouldn't say anything though.

x2boys · 17/07/2021 15:11

I'm not sure what the parent has done wrong here, why are you making it into something it isn't Confused

megletthesecond · 17/07/2021 15:08

There was a few families at the DC's primary school like this. Always nicely turned out but had to keep clean and weren't allowed to tear around. They used to drive me nuts over the years.

VerticalHorizon · 17/07/2021 15:07

Why is this not everyone’s business?

Because if it was everybody's business, children wouldn't have a bloody clue who to listen to.
Parenting is absolutely full of choices to make, and this parent made a fairly reasonable choice to admonish their daughter. I might not agree, you might night agree, but why should my opinion count? I don't know the full context, and neither do you.

We should all be mindful of abuse. We really shouldn't be deciding how to parent other folks kids.

ahoyshipmates · 17/07/2021 15:07

'Told off' can come in many forms. If it was just a "Be careful sweetie and try not to get any drink on your dress, there's a good girl" then it's not a problem. If she was shouted at, then that's another matter altogether.

When girls are told that their appearance is more important than having fun, there's something wrong somewhere. I don't much like it when little girls are dressed up like fairy dolls and aren't allowed to play or get messy because it will spoil their clothes. Dress them in something practical.

sadperson16 · 17/07/2021 15:05

Yes , you should immedicately say something... possibly SS or the Police. Its a disgrace.

Oh hang on a minute......thousands and thousands of kids are living in poverty in places you wouldn't house a dog, they have had no education for months and child abuse cases have rocketed.

Lilypansy · 17/07/2021 15:05

Oh, for heaven's sake, why on earth would you even think of commenting? Children get told off. Maybe she was on her way to a party, or a wedding even.
Clearly, it's not a good idea to jump up and down whilst carrying a drink. Most parents would tell a child off for that. As others have said, it's none of your business.

SmidgenofaPigeon · 17/07/2021 15:04

Say what?!

Blimey it must be hard to leave the house with that level of over-analysis over everything. Exhausting.

I’m a nanny and if I’d turned out my charges nicely I’d scold for jumping up and down while drinking 😂

Butchyrestingface · 17/07/2021 15:04

It sounds like it's because she was wearing a white dress and her sibling was in clothes that were less easy to see stains. It's a bit like comparing apples and oranges.

If they had BOTH been dressed in similar apparel, I'd think you had a stronger case.

Kanaloa · 17/07/2021 15:03

How stupid of them, different if they were all in their posh clothes so being careful but why can brothers jump up and down and not the girl?

But yes, you’d be unreasonable to say something really. We all see parenting that we disagree with, different if it’s abuse where we have a duty to step in and report but this is just not my type of parenting. It’s not for me to say they’re wrong and I’m right.

Geamhradh · 17/07/2021 15:03

Because juice is hard to get out of white fabric?

Tistheseason17 · 17/07/2021 15:02

The 5yr old was in a white dress. She told her off because she did not want orange on it - other child in dark clothing so less of an issue.
Or did she eff and jeff at her?

Nancydrawn · 17/07/2021 15:00

Echo what everyone else said. Unless you actually know what's happening, there's zero evidence that this was Sexism that you Must Undo with Righteous Intervention.

She could very well be, I don't know, going to a special event. She could be a child who actually gets really upset when things spill and they were trying to head it off at the pass. She could someone who has to drink her entire juice for blood sugar reasons and they didn't want it to spill all over. She could have spilled the juice a million times in a row and the parents were being short-tempered.

Who knows. You certainly don't. I'd concentrate your energies on situations where you know what's going on.

cariadlet · 17/07/2021 14:59

I get where you're coming from. The children were clearly dressed impractically but were presumably going somewhere special.

I would be irritated that the mum had given the children a carton of juice if she was that bothered about the clothes staying clean and would be seriously unimpressed that the girl and boy were treated differently.

But I wouldn't say anything. It's a different style of parenting and one I don't approve of but I would only intervene if I felt that a child was being abused.

Stichintime · 17/07/2021 14:57

White dress and shoes? Did she have white socks as well? Most mums of girls don't dress their daughters like that every day. Sounds like she was off somewhere special. To even think of making a comment is ridiculous.

IHaveBrilloHair · 17/07/2021 14:53

Oh don't be ridiculous.
Maybe they were going to a special occasion.
FWIW I often put dresses on my Dd, also shorts/leggings m/hand me downs from the boy twins next door...

Wife2b · 17/07/2021 14:53

I don’t think you had any right to say anything. They could be off to a party for all you know. The little boy was wearing dark clothing so spillages would be less noticeable.

PumpkinKlNG · 17/07/2021 14:52

How do you know it’s everyday it’s Saturday maybe they were off to a party

AnUnoriginalUsername · 17/07/2021 14:52

Absolutely wouldn't say anything but I do think it's sad when people dress their kids in nice clothes every day they can't play in.

Direstraitsmates · 17/07/2021 14:51

That's not sexism. That is someone not wanting white fancy clothes wrecked and not caring if dark clothes get wet. I wouldn't want either of my toddlers drinking juice out of a carton when they were wearing white clothes and I would ask them to be careful and not jump up and down until they had finished drinking the carton. I can't get the stains out of white clothes. It wouldn't matter what sex they were. Generally I don't put them in white clothes but maybe the child really wanted to wear the dress. You would have looked like an overbearing fool had you challenged them.

PumpkinKlNG · 17/07/2021 14:50

Don’t be ridiculous

ThatsNicePet · 17/07/2021 14:50

Not quite the same but I always find it strange when primary-aged girls are dressed in December in school skirts, ankle socks and open/t-bar style shoes, walking to school in the freezing cold, while their brothers are in trousers and regular school shoes. They can walk in puddles and have covered legs while the girls must be freezing! I wouldn’t want to walk about in December with bare legs. It seems like some people don’t even consider warmth or practicality when dressing girls

0None0 · 17/07/2021 14:50

@00100001

What did you say?
I didn’t say anything. But I’m wondering if I should have. We end up trying to u do the damage with these girls sitting in front of us in the classroom, eventually, but by secondary school it can be very deeply ingrained
OP posts: