Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"

88 replies

rAvan · 17/07/2021 14:33

I am studying politics, and I am particularly interested in different systems operating globally. I was surprised to learn that First past the post, the system we use in General elections is favoured by only one other country in Europe- Belarus.

Yougov conduct research on our electoral system and have been for some time. I was surprised by the gap between men and women's preferance on FPTP and PR, and I wanted to get individual opinions on your views about FPTP vs PR.

Usually cited pros of each:

FPTP- stops coalition governments, keeps extremists out
PR- seats more accuraccurately match votes, voters do not feel their vote is wasted due to safe seats.

I've added the men's one purely for comparison.

There are no wrong answers, I hope as many people as possible giving their opinion!

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
OP posts:
LadyEloise · 17/07/2021 15:56

I'd prefer "first past the post" Blush
Runs and hides

MildredPuppy · 17/07/2021 15:55

I am now intrigued if women tick i dont more often on lots of other questions not just that one.

VerticalHorizon · 17/07/2021 15:54

@Nightlystroll

Because you like fashion and reality tv doesn't mean you don't have brains. I like both of those things and I am super intelligent.
Not to mention modest!
Lweji · 17/07/2021 15:54

There’s been a few examples of EU countries ungoverned for several months due to PR. I think Belgium ( but might be wrong)

Belgium didn't do too badly out of not having an elected government. At least they managed not to get out of the EU on a whim.

toocold54 · 17/07/2021 15:53

Without sounding sexist I would say a man is more likely to give an answer even if they don’t know as they don’t want to be seen as not knowing (like when asking for directions) whereas a female may not care as much if they don’t know.

Lweji · 17/07/2021 15:52

@Lordamighty

PR gives too much power to minority groups, some of whom have very extreme views. I am a feminist first & foremost & women would suffer most if some of these groups got a sniff of power. In this country I am referring to the LibDems & the Green Party who basically want women to stfu when it comes to the conflict between trans rights & women’s rights to single sex spaces. Take a look at Scotland for example.
As opposed to the Cons, with very middle ground views?? Hmm
sashagabadon · 17/07/2021 15:51

And why I think more women say I don’t know is that they are less afraid to admit when they don’t know something or haven’t given it enough thought to have a considered opinion. Many men, even (or especially) those with no clue, will spout forth their opinions regardless

Lweji · 17/07/2021 15:50

I can't believe that pps didn't realise the reality TV hypothesis was tongue in cheek in the middle of that post. Grin
That someone thought it was the OP is even funnier.

MildredPuppy · 17/07/2021 15:50

Yes i think women say 'i dont know' to mean 'i need more information to make a reasoned choice'

I prefer a system based on PR - i think it was the german system i liked best. I really enjoyed looking at different voting systems and the pros and cons. The best thing about FPTP is people understand it as it seems simple.

Our system is adversarial and people cant cope with working together.

Lordamighty · 17/07/2021 15:49

PR gives too much power to minority groups, some of whom have very extreme views. I am a feminist first & foremost & women would suffer most if some of these groups got a sniff of power.
In this country I am referring to the LibDems & the Green Party who basically want women to stfu when it comes to the conflict between trans rights & women’s rights to single sex spaces.
Take a look at Scotland for example.

sashagabadon · 17/07/2021 15:47

I’ve not given it loads of thought so would probably answer don’t know but on a quick thought if I had to give an answer I would say I prefer FPTP.
I like our definitive system although it can produce hung governments and a tory libdem government in 2010.
There’s been a few examples of EU countries ungoverned for several months due to PR. I think Belgium ( but might be wrong)
On balance fptp is a more stable system imo and keeps out the extremists better.

lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 15:46

You don't mention stability in your pros and cons. That's a biggie.

Especially so in a country like the UK, where from the 1990s to the early 2010s, both main parties tended towards the centre. Stability, without a tendency towards extremism, is quite attractive.

ahoyshipmates · 17/07/2021 15:45

Perhaps it is because many women can see the merits and disadvantages of both systems, and are undecided as to which might be the better option, given the Brexit situation, Covid, Scotland thinking about independence again, you name it.

'Don't know' doesn't equal 'too thick to comprehend'.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 17/07/2021 15:45

I have thought since CSE's in the 1970's that Proportional Representation was the fairest system. I think I was about 15 at the time, so it's not an education issue Hmm

Nightlystroll · 17/07/2021 15:40

Because you like fashion and reality tv doesn't mean you don't have brains. I like both of those things and I am super intelligent.

LimitIsUp · 17/07/2021 15:40

Op didn't suggest that women are too busy watching reality tv and following fashion - that was Lewji!

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 17/07/2021 15:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

NoWordForFluffy · 17/07/2021 15:38

@Crankley

I have no idea why so many women answered don't know.

Like the two main parties of the UK, I prefer FPTP. We had a referendum in 2011 re AV, a form of PR which was rejected. There is unlikely to be another referendum on the subject any time soon,

I dislike PR because we are more likely to end up with a government made up of different parties and nothing is ever achieved. Far better fror one party to have a healthy majority to allow them to get on with the job, hopefully balanced by a strong and effective opposition, something we haven't had in the UK for a long time.

But would you think that if it wasn't your preferred party which benefitted from FPTP?
LimitIsUp · 17/07/2021 15:38

@Lonel

OK - my view on why more women say "I don't know" is because they actually don't know. In fact, a lot (probably the majority) of people have given very little thought to the electoral system. However, men don't like admitting that they don't know something. Grin Even on an anonymous survey. GrinGrin
Absolutely this. Women generally having no problem stating 'don't know' when they haven't got any knowledge on a given subject, but men are happy to express forthright opinions, even when utterly clueless about the matter in hand
lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 15:36

I think 'I don't know' is likely to mean 'I would like more information on the nature and implications of these two options before offering an opinion.'

Also, it's not as if there is only one form of PR. There are many, many electoral systems available.

warmandtoasty2day · 17/07/2021 15:36

@iklboo

Maybe because men tend to read and discuss more politics and women more fashion and reality tv?

I hope this is an attempt at humour. I have zero interest in fashion & reality TV.

jog right on with the fashion and shite t.v some of us have brains.
rAvan · 17/07/2021 15:35

I don't think I indicated that women are too busy watching daytime tell to think about issues like this. If I gave that impression I am very sorry because I don't think that at all! I am generally curious, it's not something I have been asked to look at as part of my course either!

It's just something I've been thinking about because I wondered if it played a role in how increasingly polarised we seem to have become as a country since 2016. Because we have a two party system in essence and it feels like everything has been pitched of late as one side or another. Brexit or remain, Lab or Con, kneel or boo! I feel like FPTP lacks nuance, and I have come to believe that parties being forced to negotiate and communicate would be more beneficial as a whole.

I really appreciate all the (serious) answers, especially your very thought out one @sergeilavrov

And yes, I am in the UK.

And Belarus changed its voting system in 2013 to FPTP

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
OP posts:
Crankley · 17/07/2021 15:28

I have no idea why so many women answered don't know.

Like the two main parties of the UK, I prefer FPTP. We had a referendum in 2011 re AV, a form of PR which was rejected. There is unlikely to be another referendum on the subject any time soon,

I dislike PR because we are more likely to end up with a government made up of different parties and nothing is ever achieved. Far better fror one party to have a healthy majority to allow them to get on with the job, hopefully balanced by a strong and effective opposition, something we haven't had in the UK for a long time.

markmichelle · 17/07/2021 15:27

And men insist that the oven has a microwave function......

Lweji · 17/07/2021 15:15

For the same reason women ask for directions and read instructions and men get lost and break appliances. Wink

Swipe left for the next trending thread