Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"

88 replies

rAvan · 17/07/2021 14:33

I am studying politics, and I am particularly interested in different systems operating globally. I was surprised to learn that First past the post, the system we use in General elections is favoured by only one other country in Europe- Belarus.

Yougov conduct research on our electoral system and have been for some time. I was surprised by the gap between men and women's preferance on FPTP and PR, and I wanted to get individual opinions on your views about FPTP vs PR.

Usually cited pros of each:

FPTP- stops coalition governments, keeps extremists out
PR- seats more accuraccurately match votes, voters do not feel their vote is wasted due to safe seats.

I've added the men's one purely for comparison.

There are no wrong answers, I hope as many people as possible giving their opinion!

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
OP posts:
UKSub · 17/07/2021 16:33

@rAvan was there anything else in this poll that further investigated why people had answered how they did? Any space for comments? That would have been useful information to understand why people voted in the poll as they did. Without it, I don’t think you will be able to definitively say why women voted a certain way

lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 16:31

Mightn't those 35% who don't know who their MP is, be the same 35% who don't vote at all?

The people who do care, are likely to be reliable voters.

Anyway, as above, I think you've answered your own question here, with a little help from posters on the 'willingness to say 'I don't know' out loud' issue. Essentially; more information and clarity about the question needed, to arrive at an opinion.

VerticalHorizon · 17/07/2021 16:28

Perhaps more women don't give a toss about polls like this?

rAvan · 17/07/2021 16:28

@lottiegarbanzo

I posted above that I believe that a PR system would force parties to negotiate and compromise and that would be beneficial for our discourse as a country, as things are too polarised at the moment, and there appears to be no room for nuance. I'm not trying to hide that.

I was simply pointing to the information from Yougove indicating that 35% don't know who their MP is, I attached a picture in my post. That's why I pointed out that there are systems of MP that retain the local MP for the 65% who do care.

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 17/07/2021 16:27

Well, I'm a woman and I'd probably say I don't know in answer to this question. That isn't because I'm uninterested or uninformed. It's because I think it's complex and neither system is without flaws.

On balance, I prefer the concept of PR because it's more representative, but I do worry about the potential for more extremist groups to succeed via that route. Perhaps that makes me anti-democratic but that's how I feel.

OneTC · 17/07/2021 16:25

I'd vote if there was PR.

lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 16:24

What is your basis for saying that people don't care about the local MP thing? When I've discussed this topic with people IRL it has definitely been a factor. Especially when people have lived in an area for a while and got to know their MP. Enough people do vote person not party in some constituencies, for it to make a difference to the result.

You seem to be telling us why you think PR is best. That's a very different thing from seeking to understand other people's perspectives, or their answers to pollsters.

UKSub · 17/07/2021 16:22

@warmandtoasty2day

jog right on with the fashion and shite t.v some of us have brains.

So those who like fashion and easy watching television are thick? Nice.

RoseAndGeranium · 17/07/2021 16:22

I’m not sure if FPTP v PR is the right (or only) question to ask about the U.K., actually. I think a more pressing problem at the moment is the power of the government specifically and the HoC more generally. The fact that the Lords now have no absolute veto and diminishing public credibility is a big concern for me. It leaves our political system terribly vulnerable to populism and capture by pushy lobbyists and shouty interest groups. A properly functioning second chamber ought to have been able to moderate the Brexit referendum bill and should also have contributed more usefully to managing the withdrawal process, especially given that the opposition seemed paralysed by it. (I’m not saying it ought to have stopped us leaving the EU, before I get jumped on, just that it could have helped by overseeing the conditions set for the referendum and withdrawal more than it did). As it is, the legal courts ended up getting involved, and I don’t know how healthy that is.
There are a lot of smaller issues where a strong, respected Lords could help to protect the rights of minorities or overlooked areas — rural constituencies and interests in particular have been poorly served for decades, and will suffer further as the Tories refocus on the urban issues of the majority of Red Wall seats.

rAvan · 17/07/2021 16:21

@Lweji

I suppose both really. I want to know which, if either, and I think the reasons follow on from that.

It did start with that somewhat binary question but people have provided really interesting opinions and I am enjoying the conversation! I'm sorry, I'm probably not making things clearer!

OP posts:
Lweji · 17/07/2021 16:17

Still, what do you really want to know, OP?

Why, and if indeed, so many women don't know which they prefer, or which system do we (MNetters who happened to click on your thread and bother to respond) think is best?

rAvan · 17/07/2021 16:16

@lottiegarbanzo

I'm not sure people really care about the local MP thing. Plus, it is certainly possible to have a local MP still within PR, for those who do care.

@bumblingbovine49

AV was a compromise agreed between Cameron and Clegg. It was a compromise noone really wanted, Clegg didn't feel it was really PR (and its not) and Cameron didn't want the system to change because, from a purely data point of view, his party has benefitted 66% of the time.
No really campaigned on it or provided proper information to voters. I think the AV referendum was poorly run.

I also think that a lot has changed in 10 years. I wasn't able to vote on AV, but I am old enough to vote now, and no doubt millions others.

Thank you @YesThisIsMe!

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 16:13

Ah ha OP!

You see, you need to get into a much more nuanced and evidence-based discussion before you can really spell out what aspects of the two systems even differ much, or are more important, before you can get into which system is better.

Higher evidence threshold, as others have said.

Borka · 17/07/2021 16:09

@bumblingbovine49

People often forget we had a referendum on proportional representation during the conservative / lib dem coalition in 2011. 32% voted yes, barely 40% turnout

That is how much people care about the voting system we use. I despair

That wasn't offering true proportional representation, the alternative to FPTP was an alternative vote system.
Lweji · 17/07/2021 16:09

Plus the Iraq war and 2008 crash during that end-of-history-esque stable centrist period.

It is interesting that both were triggered by the US, under a President elected under another FPTP system, and with less votes than his opponent (at least on the first election in 2000).
What would have happened under Al Gore is anyone's guess, of course.

rAvan · 17/07/2021 16:07

For those saying I have not included stability, to be honest whilst it is often cited as a pro, I'm not sure it is as clear a pro as it once was. I would say that in 7 of the last 11 years it failed to provide that.

And to respond to people saying it does keep extremists out, one could argue that extreme positions are already in the House. The reason UKIP and the Brexit Party were demolished was because the Conservative Party moved to the right to align with the voters who had left them for those two parties. Johnson even removed MPs who most considered the moderates in the party in 2019.

And on the Left, you have the Left in the Labour Party who are so Left they can't stand the centre-left! After Batley and Spen they were so angry that they could not now mount a leadership batter against Starmer that they couldn't even say well done on telly!

OP posts:
Lweji · 17/07/2021 16:04

@lottiegarbanzo

You also fail to mention the local and personal link to the MP that FPTP gives, that most forms of PR do not. That's another biggie for a lot of people.
That is probably my only plus point. I do wonder, however, how much it can actually benefit constituents, or if it is just a perception.
lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 16:04

I know Lweji shit did happen!

Plus the Iraq war and 2008 crash during that end-of-history-esque stable centrist period. Events do bugger up a good intention, as Macmillan sort of said.

YesThisIsMe · 17/07/2021 16:02

Here’s an interesting article from the Washington Post giving a little bit of data to support the intuitively appealing hypothesis that women are more likely to admit that they don’t know.
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2014/05/16/are-women-more-likely-to-say-i-dont-know-to-poll-questions-it-appears-so/%3foutputType=amp

bumblingbovine49 · 17/07/2021 16:02

People often forget we had a referendum on proportional representation during the conservative / lib dem coalition in 2011. 32% voted yes, barely 40% turnout

That is how much people care about the voting system we use. I despair

RoseAndGeranium · 17/07/2021 16:01

@sergeilavrov

You should refer to the work of Kristy Parathkis, or experimental work in decision making (lots from the same department). Women have a higher informational threshold to make choices: they are more willing to say they don’t know, whereas men will provide opinion as fact at a far lower threshold (often zero or one piece of information) and rate their confidence in the choice more highly. This is despite women being equally or more well informed on a matter.

This feeds into some of the behavioural Econ literature, as women make better long term investments thanks to their risk alert status pushing them to take informed risks. I’m a little astonished your department hasn’t covered these cognitive sex-based differences if they’re exposing you to polling data! It’s pretty fundamental.

Gosh, thank you for posting this @sergeilavrov ! I often look at YouGov survey results and note the significant difference in the proportion of men and women answering ‘don’t know’, so I was really hoping this thread would shed some light. And thanks to you it has! I’ll do some reading in the author and areas you suggest. Loving the erudition and generosity of MN Talk!
Nightlystroll · 17/07/2021 16:01

@VerticalHorizon

Nightlystroll

Because you like fashion and reality tv doesn't mean you don't have brains. I like both of those things and I am super intelligent.

Not to mention modest!

I never use bushels so there's no point putting my light under one.

lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 16:00

You also fail to mention the local and personal link to the MP that FPTP gives, that most forms of PR do not. That's another biggie for a lot of people.

lottiegarbanzo · 17/07/2021 15:58

Totally agree about many men being unable to utter the words 'I don't know' (and often being happy to talk utter bollocks, even to present said utter bollocks to other people as 'advice', without shame or even the awareness that they don't know).

I wonder (and pollsters must know about this) whether there is any element of women saying 'don't know' and meaning 'please get out of my face and leave me alone'.

I know my own life experience is that when people approach me on the street, demanding my time, or answers to questions, I will usually be preparing a 'no thanks' response, before they've even spoken. Even if I do engage briefly, I am wary and in flight mode.

A lifetime of annoying salespeople with drawn out, faux friendly spiels and arseholes offering 'compliments', in the guise of friendliness or asking a question, is the cause.

Lweji · 17/07/2021 15:57

Especially so in a country like the UK, where from the 1990s to the early 2010s, both main parties tended towards the centre. Stability, without a tendency towards extremism, is quite attractive.

And then shit happened.

Funnily enough most European countries have still tended towards the centre and have been fairly stable. There are exceptions. But the UK is hardly a beacon for the FPTP system.

Swipe left for the next trending thread