Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"

88 replies

rAvan · 17/07/2021 14:33

I am studying politics, and I am particularly interested in different systems operating globally. I was surprised to learn that First past the post, the system we use in General elections is favoured by only one other country in Europe- Belarus.

Yougov conduct research on our electoral system and have been for some time. I was surprised by the gap between men and women's preferance on FPTP and PR, and I wanted to get individual opinions on your views about FPTP vs PR.

Usually cited pros of each:

FPTP- stops coalition governments, keeps extremists out
PR- seats more accuraccurately match votes, voters do not feel their vote is wasted due to safe seats.

I've added the men's one purely for comparison.

There are no wrong answers, I hope as many people as possible giving their opinion!

To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
To wonder why so many women answered "don't know"
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VerticalHorizon · 18/07/2021 14:37

I don't think men especially care more about politics, but there is certainly a societal expectation of men to be knowledgable about such things (when often they are far from it).

Men are not particularly good at saying 'I don't understand'. They'll often take a view without researching things. In a sense 'I don't know' could be interpreted as being much more open and honest.

NiceGerbil · 18/07/2021 03:37

Personal view

The different systems had very brief explanations. Unless there was more detail elsewhere.

Many people would not really know what it meant.

Men IME feel they have to have an opinion on everything. Even things they know sweet fa about. Plenty see not knowing something as a weakness. The many I've met who will not ask for directions even if horribly lost springs to mind.

Women do not tend to have that trait nearly so much.

I don't think it's more than that TBH

Megasausagehead · 18/07/2021 02:40

Why should men care more about politics? What nonsense.

Every person who has a vote should ensure that they know what they are choosing.

DamsonJammyBastard · 18/07/2021 02:37

@TangledUp789

Perhaps it's just because men are more interested in politics than women. They're better informed about FPTP vs PR and are therefore more able to give a proper answer to the question.
good little girl. you will get several head pats tonight from your menfolk.
DamsonJammyBastard · 18/07/2021 02:34

@bumblingbovine49

People often forget we had a referendum on proportional representation during the conservative / lib dem coalition in 2011. 32% voted yes, barely 40% turnout

That is how much people care about the voting system we use. I despair

but that was not a referendum that offered PR, and it was also a referendum that was given little to no publicity (by design) and was tucked away with UK wide local elections.
TangledUp789 · 18/07/2021 02:26

Perhaps it's just because men are more interested in politics than women. They're better informed about FPTP vs PR and are therefore more able to give a proper answer to the question.

Megasausagehead · 18/07/2021 02:00

The question is being asked at a time where there is only one semi credible political party in the UK.

Labour are diabolical on women's rights and/or sending out a cohesive message. It is a non entity.

Right now, despite the efforts of the suffragettes, I wouldn't vote FPTP or PR.

If there were actually a valid choice PR all the way.

entropynow · 18/07/2021 01:52

@FuzzyPuffling

And also, stop with your misogynist nonsense about women not being well read and preferring fashion and reality TV.
Quite. I can't think of anything I am interested in less than those last two things. Same goes for pretty much all my female friends.
Alviona · 18/07/2021 00:37

I would vote for FPTP. I do not believe that the case for change is made adequately, and I am not convinced that either FPTP or PR would be notably more beneficial than the other. Therefore, the status quo should take precedence.

Nightlystroll · 18/07/2021 00:35

VerticalHorizon

groundcontroltomontydon

It's yougov, according to which Sean Connery is the seventh most popular contemporary actor, so I'd take it with a pinch of salt.

Yesh!

😂😂😂

Sparrowsong · 18/07/2021 00:31

PR all the way! FPTP is archaic and broken!

QueenCarrot · 18/07/2021 00:06

PR

FPTP means that you can have a Government that has been voted for by fewer than half of the people voting, even in a two party system. It discourages and stifles minority parties.

hennaoj · 17/07/2021 23:55

Were the people conducting the survery doing it outside supermarkets/town centres? If so, I bet thats were most of the 'don't know' answers came from. If I'm in hurry, or being constantly hassled by my children, my standard response to any question (especially 'What are we having for dinner?') is 'don't know'!

MakkaPakkas · 17/07/2021 23:03

At a guess I'd say more women put 'don't know' because they don't feel informed enough to give an opinion. Men tend to be more confident in their own knowledge and opinions even when education and experience levels are the same on all sorts of surveys. The Wellcome trust did one on vaccination/ trust in science/ Medicine and found similar.

thegcatsmother · 17/07/2021 22:56

I was living in Belgium when there was no government for over a year, and yet it all still functioned, so do we need the politicians?

A Dutch friend was at the point she was going to give up on voting as the coalitions they ended up with, didn't reflect what she had voted for, and she felt disenfranchised. This was a woman whose husband,was on the military diplomatic circuit, and who was very well informed. If she felt like that, then maybe FPTP has advantages?

Lordamighty · 17/07/2021 20:52

As for extremists, UKIP still managed to get MP’s elected

In 2015 UKIP came third in terms of overall votes with 12.6% but only got 1 MP elected. The Greens won 3.8% of the votes, their best ever result, but still only got 1 MP elected.
Under PR both would have had much more influence.

therocinante · 17/07/2021 17:31

OP, I think it's because quite a surprising number of people just don't know anything about politics at all. My sister could name you the prime minister and that's about it - she's just got no interest whatsoever. I know lots of people like her, they don't know or care or understand that politics affects every aspect of their lives. None of her friends - late 20s, mostly married, business owners, children, etc - vote or know much about politics at all. I tried explaining once to her and her friend while we were having tea that the amount of child benefit her friend got for her children and the free hours she gets and the tax they both pay as self-employed business owners and a million other things that affect them every day are affected by politics. They were just of the opinion it's something that happens way over our heads and isn't worth getting involved in.

And as PP said, I think there is a societal expectation that men feel like they can't say they don't know because they're expected to be authoritative, whereas women are (very very broadly) more likely to be scared to have a firm opinion on something for fear of being wrong. Which is depressing, but I see it 100 times a week at work - male colleagues confidently offering completely wrong opinions over just saying they don't know, while the women are less likely to do the same.

therocinante · 17/07/2021 17:25

jog right on with the fashion and shite t.v some of us have brains.

Enjoying fashion and television doesn't make you stupid and it's a peculiar form of 'I'm not like the other girls' to insist you're superior because you don't care what your clothes look like. I've got 2 degrees and own a business, I also really love fashion. Newsflash: the reason these things are derided as less important is because women like them, don't let the misogyny come from inside the house.

rAvan · 17/07/2021 17:21

@UKSub unfortunately not, that would have been bloody helpful!

@ThinWomansBrain I mean, I'm literally starting...but I hope that asinine comment made you feel better.

@lottiegarbanzo that is an interesting question. Voter turnout is another area of interest. And particular concern. Why don't 35% of our population vote, and how do we improve that

@Lweji loads of great points, and indeed UKIP had an MP.

I would argue that they deserve MPs according to their vote share. I don't think a few UKIP MPs would have that much power in parliament, and quite frankly we are naive to think they didn't influence parliament from outside. The last 10 years have been dictated by what they wanted, that's how the Conservative got rid of them as a threat, by subsuming their agenda.

OP posts:
VerticalHorizon · 17/07/2021 17:06

@groundcontroltomontydon

It's yougov, according to which Sean Connery is the seventh most popular contemporary actor, so I'd take it with a pinch of salt
Yesh!
groundcontroltomontydon · 17/07/2021 16:59

It's yougov, according to which Sean Connery is the seventh most popular contemporary actor, so I'd take it with a pinch of salt

Lweji · 17/07/2021 16:45

Another thought, through FPTP people are supposed to feel closer to their MP, and, thus Parliament.
But, as a pp suggested, many people don't vote because they are in safe seats, and feel that their vote doesn't count (that could be debated). Under PR, more votes count.

As for extremists, UKIP still managed to get MPs elected.

I think it would be possible to keep individual constituencies and more direct representation without the current FPTP system, if people, for example, voted for 2nd preferences and those were counted if none of the candidates got more than 50% at the first count.

ThinWomansBrain · 17/07/2021 16:44

You're studying politics and didn't know that crappy first past the post isn't widely used?
What level are you studying at - pre GCSE?

Lweji · 17/07/2021 16:35

I think it's difficult for people to have a balanced view about either system unless they have experienced both, or have a grasp of international politics (or internal politics in other countries).
Some opinions pro FPTP seem fairly unaware of what happens in other countries, other than soundbites or more extreme cases that have been on the news, and only superficially, even on this thread.

On a side note, I do wonder if the opinions expressed on the polls reflect discontent with the current government and its majority. And if under a more centrist government, people will be happy again with the current system.
People tend not to want to change things unless there are clear advantages. Even Brexit was sold with a few key ideas that suggested clear benefits (whether right or wrong).

mellicauli · 17/07/2021 16:34

I would have answered I don't know.

The reason is that there are pros and cons to both systems, and neither seems overwhelmingly better than the other.

Also there's no reason for me having to take a position on an issue that would need a lot more information to decide.