Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult stepson & summer hols

267 replies

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 17/07/2021 09:43

Posted in step parenting but didn't get any replies so taking my life into my hands here....

SS is 20 and in second year at uni, he has a house for the summer in his uni town. Last summer he came home and spent time between his mum's (main residence) and our house. He had to be strongly encouraged to get a job but when he wasn't working he basically laid around in his room all day and did nothing around the house to help out. Also expected to be driven back and forth all the time as he doesn't drive.

A month or so ago he announced he was staying in uni town for the summer and had big work plans. We were pleased that he was making his own way in life a bit. But yesterday he announced that he wanted to come home - he's done nothing to find work apparently. DH has encouraged him to find work in his uni town as he doesn't really want a repeat of last summer. I feel a bit guilty but I can't help thinking that unless he's strongly encouraged he will still be living at home when he's 30. I can't face running round after another grown adult. Also I really need the room he stays in as office space as I've been told I'm not going back into the office at all.

Are we being unfair on him?

OP posts:
rookiemere · 17/07/2021 15:07

Your DH needs to start working in the bedroom and you downstairs.
It's possible for the box room to get a fold up desk and fold down bed, that way both needs can be accommodated.

But yes the bottom line is that a student should be able to stay with his DF in the holidays. Doesn't mean he shouldn't get a job or do his share of chores though.

TheWatersofMarch · 17/07/2021 15:06

I was a step child. My step mum, though brilliant in some ways, didn't understand that part of being a proper parent is to provide a home for your child and my father, who I think did, did not continue to provide a home for us as the house was the home of my half siblings. Children of separated parents should have two parents and two homes. My brother and I were always guests at our Dad's home and because of that our visiting dropped significantly in our teens and beyond. Your DH needs to make sure he is providing a home for his DS until DS has his own home. I know this is a nuisance for you, but that box room is your DSS's bedroom. Fair enough to use it as an office when he's at Uni but don't kick him out of it.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 17/07/2021 15:03

I can't get on board with charging 'board and lodgings' either. He's not moving to a B&B with a total stranger landlady - this is his father's house.
I would work from the bedroom or get DH to, for the summer. It's not ideal, but better than making one of your kids feel unwelcome. Get him to clear up after himself, encourage a summer job - you don't have to top up his income or ferry him around anymore than you would your daughter. But you should feed and house him - that's basic parenting.
What you do now will set the tone for the future relationship between your step son and you and his dad. It will also have implications for your marriage if you treat your husband's son as less than your daughter. And tbh would you want a man who was happy to let that happen?
Your DD should have a space in her father's house. Doesn't matter that he's NRP, he's still her dad.

Hankunamatata · 17/07/2021 14:59

Could you out a high sleeper in his room so your desk could go underneath?

Hankunamatata · 17/07/2021 14:58

He should have a bed at his dad until he is working with his own place.

cadburyegg · 17/07/2021 14:57

Sorry OP but a lot of students come home from the summer holidays and even - shock horror - after graduation, not all of them get jobs straight away.

I don’t think the “resident parent” term is useful here, generally that term is used when talking about younger children in regards to maintenance, benefits etc?

I wfh in my bedroom and it sucks but I do it so my DC can have their own bedrooms.

Lovesacake · 17/07/2021 14:55

I think you’re being v harsh, it’s normal to go home from uni in the holidays. Why can’t your husband swap with you so he works in the bedroom and you get the downstairs space?

Nancydrawn · 17/07/2021 14:42

There are several different factors at play here.

First, it's not at all unreasonable that he comes home for the summer. This is to be expected of all uni students; many of them don't have summer leases anyway.

Second, it's also not unreasonable to expect that he finds some sort of occupation for the summer, paid or unpaid. He needs it for his CV as much as anything else. If he doesn't need funds and doesn't like the paid work options, he needs to be doing unpaid work (either as an intern or a volunteer).

Third, there's a bit of logical tension in what you're saying. On one hand, you want him out of the house and working; on the other, you don't want him in a place with a higher Covid risk because of your husband.

If shielding is important, then #2 goes out the window. You can't simultaneously be annoyed with him for not working and be annoyed that he might work outside the home. Well, I suppose you can, but that's only if you don't think he should be anywhere near your house in the summer at all, and that's not a fair solution.

CaraherEIL · 17/07/2021 14:41

So when your DD is 20 if she wants to come home from uni in the holidays you will tell her no. I don’t believe that, I believe you will remove your SS from the equation and then by the time DD is 20 it will be fine for her to come home every holiday and your SS staying there will be old news.

ohthatbloodycat · 17/07/2021 14:41

YABU and unfair. This would be a very different story if he was your child.

TillyTopper · 17/07/2021 14:34

You sound a bit towards him OP, sorry if I have that wrong and you don't think that's the case. I have 2 sons, both at uni. One has 'found his way' more quickly and has a job, enjoys earning money, does lots of stuff. The other seems to just like being with us, he'll cook the odd meal for us, he sweet to his gran (who lives here), but no job. I think that's fine, I'm happy they want to be here with us and enjoy having them around. Perhaps he just wants the comfort being being near his dad?

Zilla1 · 17/07/2021 14:29

Perhaps they can see a difference, OP, just don't agree that this should still lead to your DP and you choosing to do what you want. Perhaps their judgment and experience can see the possible consequences although it will depend on your DP and his son's relationship and your relationship with him.

Regarding your DD, you might be surprised. IME, almost all returned home for at least part of the Summer between Y1 and Y2 and between Y2 and Y3 of their undergraduate degrees unless they worked in an internship for the whole Summer. COVID has perhaps changed some things but might have made a return home more likely given it's relative impacts on travel, employment in university towns, homestudy and suchlike.

I've seen students spend the whole of the last year studying from home. Before that, I've seen students returning home to save for deposits or to make internships or badly paid entry-level work affordable.

Good luck though you seem convinced you're right. Why did you post? Were you expecting everyone to agree with you? How much are you hanging on your presumptions about what a student should do and how much about your expectations of rooms for non-resident children across households?

CaraherEIL · 17/07/2021 14:27

Asking for help around the house, tidying up, being respectful all very normal expectations, removing his right to stay there is not.

ForgotAboutThis · 17/07/2021 14:26

But does staying during the holidays mean he has to have his own room? Can he share with someone?

CaraherEIL · 17/07/2021 14:24

Your SS didn’t choose to have two homes his parents made that choice so that isn’t a factor. Choosing to remove one of those homes when he wants to come home is mean.

30degreesandmeltinghere · 17/07/2021 14:24

Still confused!!

0None0 · 17/07/2021 14:23

Have you thought about where he will live when he graduates? It’s common for any young professionals to need to live at home with parents while saving up for a deposit on a house

Nanny0gg · 17/07/2021 14:23

@30degreesandmeltinghere

Surely it isn't much to expect a 20 yo to get a summer job and contribute to his board and lodgings? Confused
Not when he already has student loans
Nanny0gg · 17/07/2021 14:22

@chocolatesaltyballs22

Do people not see a difference between the fact that I am the resident parent for my daughter, but DH is not RP for his son? I just seriously wonder why a 20 year old needs a room in two houses.

My DD goes to uni in Sept. I expect she'll come home the first summer like SS did but when she's 20? Not so much.

Well no. Not if you make her as welcome as your SS
30degreesandmeltinghere · 17/07/2021 14:22

Surely it isn't much to expect a 20 yo to get a summer job and contribute to his board and lodgings?
Confused

CaraherEIL · 17/07/2021 14:22

No there is no difference your SS should be able to reside full time with his dad through uni holidays until her graduates the same as your daughter can. Everyone I knew went home for the holidays all through uni. Because your ex has absented himself doesn’t mean that your SS shouldn’t be able to live with his dad.

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 17/07/2021 14:19

Do people not see a difference between the fact that I am the resident parent for my daughter, but DH is not RP for his son? I just seriously wonder why a 20 year old needs a room in two houses.

My DD goes to uni in Sept. I expect she'll come home the first summer like SS did but when she's 20? Not so much.

OP posts:
TiredButDancing · 17/07/2021 14:17

I do think you're being a bit mean. Expecting a young adult to contribute to the household by not making life harder for the parents/step parents is completely different to basically telling him "that's it, you can't come back." It's really not his fault that you want a room for your work. Was you r plan that he just would never sleep over ever again? Like, "you're 20 now, so that's it, you can visit, by appointment, that's it."

Agree with PP that I don't understand the attitude of just tossing kids out when they're 18. I'm not saying that he should still be treated like a child (and the lifts would be an absolute no brainer - they have to stop. He learns to drive and gets a car, gets a bicycle, walks or takes the bus - he can't be using the lift club of mum and dad forever), but that doesn't mean he should be relegated to occasional visitor.

I'm 45 and obviously don't have a room in my parents house, but I can still "go home" and be treated as more than a guest!

CaraherEIL · 17/07/2021 14:16

So your daughter lives with you full time, when she leaves for uni, will you bag up her room and turn it into something else or because she has a shared house at uni will you still allow her to come home?
If she is 18 when is she leaving for uni? Why are there not the same question marks over her ongoing living situation. Using your criteria if you really do treat them equally then you will have 2 rooms free in Sept. Or is your biological daughter getting preferential treatment. You need to really examine your motivation here.
It is not your SS fault that your ex has not provided space for his own daughter.

ForgotAboutThis · 17/07/2021 14:13

Why can't he share with his brother?