Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reporting someone for failing to isolate

357 replies

WouldYouShouldI · 17/07/2021 00:44

Under what circumstances would you report someone for failing to isolate? Would you report any breach, no breach, or would it depend on circumstances?

I've been told by a friend that a family member of theirs (should be isolating because someone they live with has tested positive) is not isolating, and is even going out to work- and they work with vulnerable people in a medical environment!

Should I report them regardless of the possible consequences on my friend (who will be blamed if they get caught)? Or encourage my friend to do the same, again despite the consequences?

I'm torn!

OP posts:
StepAwayFromTheEcclesCakes · 17/07/2021 09:53

@TSSDNCOP if i tested negative then i would welcome it i think, son is positive too but DH so far is negative and i am sure he would love to be out and about, logistically him going for a walk or cycle in the open air is not a big risk to anyone but he is a stickler for the rules so is isolating as per guidelines. inconvenient and boring for us all but we would hate to just ignore and pass it on. Thanks for the good wishes, fortunately so far my symptoms are mild and DS is rough but not too ill, hopefully this is as bad as it gets fingers crossed.

To those saying there should be some financial support i think if you work and cant there is a one off £500 payment.

I do find it interesting how we were led to believe the vax was our salvation from all this but even the double vaxxed are still testing positive, i guess the saving grace is that perhaps without them i would be much iller than i am.

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 09:50

@Iquitit

"There should be isolation pay that employers pay and claim back from the government. IMO it should be full pay each time someone isolates."

Thing is, that's completely financially unviable and would be easy to abuse too

It's financially unviable at the moment with people constantly having to miss out on work, though.

And the current system is also being abused by people refusing to isolate as they can't afford to.

Well according to this thread and others like it, it's perfectly ok for it to not be financially viable for the individuals that need to isolate, but don't earn when they do, that's acceptable collateral damage apparently, but not for the tax payer or government or providers or society to have to have to worry about - let's just keep shouting "duty of care" and ignore the reasons why people may not self isolate - they don't matter at all.

I can see why we have staffing problems in healthcare and social care, if it's expected that duty of care extends to workers getting into debt or worse, but not as far as the government or providers meeting their duty of care by ensuring people aren't pushed into debt, or risk losing their homes because they need to self isolate to protect the vulnerable.

I can't believe some people are expecting individuals to pick up the tab for this, all in this together my arse.

Well said.

If the government can't afford to pick up the bill, how can you expect Jane on minimum wage to do so?

Iquitit · 17/07/2021 09:45

"There should be isolation pay that employers pay and claim back from the government. IMO it should be full pay each time someone isolates."

Thing is, that's completely financially unviable and would be easy to abuse too

It's financially unviable at the moment with people constantly having to miss out on work, though.

And the current system is also being abused by people refusing to isolate as they can't afford to.

Well according to this thread and others like it, it's perfectly ok for it to not be financially viable for the individuals that need to isolate, but don't earn when they do, that's acceptable collateral damage apparently, but not for the tax payer or government or providers or society to have to have to worry about - let's just keep shouting "duty of care" and ignore the reasons why people may not self isolate - they don't matter at all.

I can see why we have staffing problems in healthcare and social care, if it's expected that duty of care extends to workers getting into debt or worse, but not as far as the government or providers meeting their duty of care by ensuring people aren't pushed into debt, or risk losing their homes because they need to self isolate to protect the vulnerable.

I can't believe some people are expecting individuals to pick up the tab for this, all in this together my arse.

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 09:45

[quote jihhy]@warmfluffytowels who is judging though? The OP sounds like she is a quandary & is uncertain. [/quote]
Have you not read the thread? It's full of judgement lol.

ladybugsrock · 17/07/2021 09:42

I'm shocked that in the circumstances that OP has stated more people aren't annoyed by this. I'm sure if it was your family member they were looking after and they caught covid and died (esp. as they are vulnerable) you would be up in arms or would you go 'oh well freedom of choice and all that'

jihhy · 17/07/2021 09:39

@warmfluffytowels who is judging though? The OP sounds like she is a quandary & is uncertain.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 17/07/2021 09:29

Hmm at a someone living with a COVID positive person and going out being compared to BIL art, drink driving and domestic violence

TSSDNCOP · 17/07/2021 09:29

@StepAwayFromTheEcclesCakes

If you were contacted to participate in the trial of daily LFT and go about your essential business, would yup agree?

Sorry you are all shut up, and hope your +ve case feels better soon.

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 17/07/2021 09:27

I’m pretty sure that if you report someone you get a special stamp to put in your Covid Dibbers Annual AND a gold badge. Can someone confirm? I’d love to collect the whole set!

LittleBearPad · 17/07/2021 09:25

Reporting" is absolutely the top MN hobby

Very true.

StepAwayFromTheEcclesCakes · 17/07/2021 09:24

Well attitudes on here show exactly why cases are rising, i say this as a double vax who has just tested positive and yes the household is isolating as that is the responsible thing to do so we don't pass it on.

TSSDNCOP · 17/07/2021 09:23

A child at my dd’s school did not isolate when there sibling tested positive, it resulted in half the school having to isolate when he then tested positive, if he had isolated then all those kids wouldn’t have had to miss out on yet another week of school?

An exaggeration surely? It would've only taken out his class/year group at worst. Schools are very good at narrowing isolation requirements now.

We must move to a position of daily LFT and continue about your business. This will enable assistance to be given to employees that cannot WFH. It will enable kids to resume education.

There are at least 3 posters I have counted on this thread participating in such trials. This must be the way forward.

To the question, would I report? Absolutely not when I have no direct knowledge of the circumstances.

"Reporting" is absolutely the top MN hobby.

LittleBearPad · 17/07/2021 09:23

@TheReluctantPhoenix

People still don’t realise that COVID is the most serious illness Europe and the US has dealt with for several generations.

The fact that its effects are variable does not change this. The facts are the facts.

Deliberately risking infecting vulnerable people with COVID is no different from screwing around without protection, knowing you have HIV, something people should also report.

I think we may have noticed!
LittleBearPad · 17/07/2021 09:22

Bugger bold didn’t work on the second quote!

LittleBearPad · 17/07/2021 09:21

I have always cared about people dying, I'm sorry if you haven't I guess?

Really? All people? What form did this caring take? What did you do to show you cared.

Yes any time I have a flu or a cold I would absolutely stay at home, that's how I was brought up. But covid is not comparable to the flu anyway and I'm sick of the comparison being made.

Again really? Every sniffle meant you stayed home. I don’t believe you.

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 09:21

@jihhy

absolutely but it also may not be
But don't let that get in the way of a good judge.

We don't know the circumstances. She could be allowed to work as long as she produced a negative test. She could be on her fourth or fifth required isolation this year and maybe she can't afford anymore. Who knows.

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 09:19

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

There should be isolation pay that employers pay and claim back from the government. IMO it should be full pay each time someone isolates.

Thing is, that's completely financially unviable and would be easy to abuse too

It's financially unviable at the moment with people constantly having to miss out on work, though.

And the current system is also being abused by people refusing to isolate as they can't afford to.

newmummy16 · 17/07/2021 09:18

Note from LBC- website

But the requirement to self-isolate if pinged by the NHS Covid app is not law.

It’s government guidance.

There’s an important difference between the two.

In the context of most Covid laws, if you breach them, you can be fined. But with guidance, although it’s recommended that people it, there's no legal penalty if you choose not to.

So, if you're pinged by the app, there is no legal obligation to self-isolate.

Government guidance encourages you to do so. But there is no criminal offence committed if you don't.

The relevant law is regulation 2 of The Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) (Self-Isolation) (England) Regulations 2020.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 17/07/2021 09:18

People still don’t realise that COVID is the most serious illness Europe and the US has dealt with for several generations.

The fact that its effects are variable does not change this. The facts are the facts.

Deliberately risking infecting vulnerable people with COVID is no different from screwing around without protection, knowing you have HIV, something people should also report.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 17/07/2021 09:10

@Cam2020

Of course those “we’re no better than the Nazis” criers would be the FIRST to scream and shout and sue if their loved one died or was extremely ill in this situation. 100% shit for brains when the replies are Carry on curtain twitching hun same shit fir brains who were probably smashing pans every week for the NHS but now they’ve “had enough”. Shame it doesn’t target these morons.

While we're in tbe subject of 'shut for brains', how intelligent would you be to report someone on hearsay? Few poters seem to be able to grasp that part. Do you think he said/she said gossip is credible enough to 'report' someone on?

Indeed.

I didn't bang pans or even clap and I also don't think death is something unnatural or offensive so whilst I'd be sad I'd accept death is part of life and wouldn't 'rage' or similar.

Honestly some people

MissJeanBrodiesprime · 17/07/2021 09:07

No, mind your own business.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 17/07/2021 09:07

There should be isolation pay that employers pay and claim back from the government. IMO it should be full pay each time someone isolates.

Thing is, that's completely financially unviable and would be easy to abuse too

jihhy · 17/07/2021 09:06

People are only getting cross because they've been fed the narrative that COVID is something to get angry about

But we are living during a time when Covid has required schools to close & people to wfh, self isolated if contacted, you can't have big weddings, etc. Whether you think that's unnecessary because covid is just like the flu & we don't do the above things for the flu is a separate point to the OP.

minatrina · 17/07/2021 09:03

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop

No we just care if people die unnecessary??

I really hate this catastrophising attitude.

Tell me when you cared before COVID about people dying unnecessarily?

Did you isolate all winter lest you get the flu virus and pass it on?

Did you report every person, including family and friends, you knew were speeding?

If you've ever taken drugs (and I know a huge amount of MNers have and still do), or even hear of someone being a drug dealer, did you report them to the police immediately?

All the above very much lead to people dying unnecessarily. But what annoys me is that people who make out they care only do now because it's quite an easy win isn't it - I stay indoors therefore I save lives and others don't so they contribute to deaths.

Boring, busybody virtue signalling. I cannot wait for it all to end, and everyone can go back to being unremarkable

I have always cared about people dying, I'm sorry if you haven't I guess?

Yes any time I have a flu or a cold I would absolutely stay at home, that's how I was brought up. But covid is not comparable to the flu anyway and I'm sick of the comparison being made.

No I've never taken drugs. I don't know any drug dealers. Again, if that applies to you then I think it says more of you than anyone else.

Just admit you're selfish and go Grin

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 17/07/2021 09:02

We are the only country currently taking this "let it rip" approach. We've been widely denounced by major organisations and other governments as immoral and stupid for this.

No we are really, really not

Swipe left for the next trending thread