Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reporting someone for failing to isolate

357 replies

WouldYouShouldI · 17/07/2021 00:44

Under what circumstances would you report someone for failing to isolate? Would you report any breach, no breach, or would it depend on circumstances?

I've been told by a friend that a family member of theirs (should be isolating because someone they live with has tested positive) is not isolating, and is even going out to work- and they work with vulnerable people in a medical environment!

Should I report them regardless of the possible consequences on my friend (who will be blamed if they get caught)? Or encourage my friend to do the same, again despite the consequences?

I'm torn!

OP posts:
Bonjourfern · 17/07/2021 07:23

@nancywhitehead Completely agree with your post and thank you for someone finally saying about the ignorance in the comparison to Nazi Germany and fascism!

warmfluffytowels · 17/07/2021 07:23

@minatrina so what's the solution, live in and out of lockdown forever?

What about for flu? Should we start having lockdowns for that as well? Or stomach bugs?

Maybe we should all just live inside our own four walls for the rest of our days Hmm

COVID is here to stay. We have to learn to live with it like we live with numerous other virus's, all of which have the potential to kill people.

User5827372728 · 17/07/2021 07:23

Yes it’s an major major insult to Jewish families and other victims such as homosexuals who’s loved ones were murdered, used as human medical experiments, locked in ghettos by Nazis for the comparison to be made.

minatrina · 17/07/2021 07:22

@aubreyii

Report. Definitely. The fuckwits who cannot see that what person A does affects person B,C,D etc are idiots. "Mind your own business" was also used in Weimar and Nazi Germany by those willing to turn a blind eye to the atrocities going on.

Jewish neighbour being beaten up? Mind your own business, keep your nose out, it doesn't affect you" was the far far too frequent view.

Thank you omg

Position A in this scenario is people concerned with minding their own business at the expense of others

Position B is people being concerned about the fate of other people

Which one of this sounds more welcoming to a fascist regime?

aubreyii · 17/07/2021 07:21

@jumpbounce

And quite frankly the UK situation during a pandemic, (and let's not forget we are not the only country in the world with restrictions, infact we probably are the only one having a 'freedom day') is not comparable to nazi Germany. Wise up
It's not comparable to Nazi Germany, but there are parallels with Germany during the 1920s as it moved slowly TOWARDS Hitler taking power. That's the point. No one is saying we are living under a Nazi state but that things are moving that way - read up on the Weimar Republic
Cam2020 · 17/07/2021 07:21

Nazi Germany comparisons are very odd too and clearly not very well-informed.

Really? How about Alan Bennett's A Lady of Letters, then?

No one here, including the OP, is fully aware of the facts.

HankMarvinjg · 17/07/2021 07:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

StealthPolarBear · 17/07/2021 07:19

@Cam2020

Don't they have to do regular lateral flow tests if they're working with vulnerable people? Perhaps they think if they had Covid, it would show up there?

Don't 'report'. I agree with PP this has echoes of Nazi Germany.

Except those tests have high false negatives rates. Which is why the rules about testing and isolation are as they are.
jumpbounce · 17/07/2021 07:18

And quite frankly the UK situation during a pandemic, (and let's not forget we are not the only country in the world with restrictions, infact we probably are the only one having a 'freedom day') is not comparable to nazi Germany. Wise up

luckylavender · 17/07/2021 07:18

@Crazycakelady17 - the rules aren't changing until mid August

aubreyii · 17/07/2021 07:17

Report. Definitely. The fuckwits who cannot see that what person A does affects person B,C,D etc are idiots.
"Mind your own business" was also used in Weimar and Nazi Germany by those willing to turn a blind eye to the atrocities going on.

Jewish neighbour being beaten up? Mind your own business, keep your nose out, it doesn't affect you" was the far far too frequent view.

AvaCallanach · 17/07/2021 07:17

@mrsnoodle55

My daughter had covid several weeks ago; I was invited to join a government study whereby 50% of participants (close contacts) would isolate for the 10 days as per the current rules, and the other 50 % would take LFT’s daily and continue going to work etc unless positive on the daily LFT.

If they asked me, boring old little me, it’s highly possible many others are being invited too. So it may well be this person is going to work completely legitimately. This is the way it is (hopefully) heading anyway from August for the double jabbed.

I am on this same study. DD has covid; I am allowed out for essential purposes (including work) as long as I return a negative LFT each day.
minatrina · 17/07/2021 07:16

@warmfluffytowels

I wouldn't report anyone as I think the entire thing is bonkers.

I get the distinct impression it would be some MNetters dream to live under permanent restrictions Hmm

No we just care if people die unnecessary??
Cam2020 · 17/07/2021 07:16

Don't they have to do regular lateral flow tests if they're working with vulnerable people? Perhaps they think if they had Covid, it would show up there?

Don't 'report'. I agree with PP this has echoes of Nazi Germany.

HankMarvinjg · 17/07/2021 07:15

Carry on curtain twitching hun

frumpety · 17/07/2021 07:15

There would be a lot of things I would have to be absolutely sure of first, is the 'positive' person definitely positive ? not just isolating because they have been pinged ? How long ago did they test positive ? Is the person going to work, part of a trial where they test regularly and only isolate if they get a positive result ? What is the relationship of friend to family member ? do they live in the same house, town, country ? Do they usually get on well or could there be a malicious element to the tale telling ?

jihhy · 17/07/2021 07:15

Thank you 😘

HankMarvinjg · 17/07/2021 07:14

@jihhy

True though, can you imagine.

What in case you are found guilty? Best way to avoid that is not end up in court...

Lolz. You funny
DrJump · 17/07/2021 07:14

I would report but I am in Australia and we are always aiming for zero cases. Particularly with the Delta strain which seams to infect whole households fairly quickly.

Hellcatspangle · 17/07/2021 07:14

I’m aware of people who are meant to be self isolating have not symptoms and they are going out to the park/walks

Hardly the same as going to work with vulnerable people is it?

jumpbounce · 17/07/2021 07:14

Yes I would as someone with a vulnerable child who shielded and is now back shielding due to high cases who isn't vaccinated then this idiot could be working with my child in a medical environment and pass covid on!

I can't believe how many people would just let it go, yet it is currently still the law to self isolate as a close contact, where do you draw the line with the law breaking and not reporting it?

jihhy · 17/07/2021 07:13

now not know

jihhy · 17/07/2021 07:13

@Superfoodie123 do you know feel better about yourself?

OceanTurtles · 17/07/2021 07:13

@WeGoHigh

It baffles me that people could defend this with the circumstances the OP has set out. If your vulnerable family member was being cared for by someone living with someone who’d tested positive would you be so blasé? I know everyone is exhausted at this stage but come on
Agree.
Superfoodie123 · 17/07/2021 07:12

Get a life OP. Go and help some homeless people with no where to sleep tonight and maybe you'll feel better about yourself

Swipe left for the next trending thread