Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I really want to go down this road?

59 replies

ZoinksRun · 17/07/2021 00:37

Sorry for being vague:
Person A is my boss. Person A made a mistake a year ago that caused me a lot of stress and cost me financially. A couple of months ago person B told me that person A had made the same mistake with them and it had effected them negatively, and impacted their career progression. These mistakes are made through carelessness and a disregard for procedures rather than maliciously.
Person B is taking this further. This might result in person A getting dismissed. Person B wants me to tell them what happened with me last year. I'm not sure I could live with partially responsible for someone losing their job. The mistake has had no repercussions for me now. It's not effected anyone else. Person A is a nice person, we get on well. I understand why person B is angry, as I was this time last year. Should I just say that I don't want to speak to HR?

OP posts:
AbsolutelyPatsy · 17/07/2021 07:49

surely there are procedures to follow to employ someone?
HR need some sort of involvement otherwise what is to stop people just giving jobs to their friends.
they need to prove who is the best candidate and why

Peoniesandpeaches · 17/07/2021 07:43

@ZoinksRun

The thing is though, if person A just put out a job advert, she could have hired anyone she wanted anyway! She didn't have to hire person B or me, if she'd just gone down the official channels she could have done exactly the same.
Not quite. She would then need to justify the decision based on points scored against certain criteria and it can be audited. It’s not impossible to fudge but certainly harder than her current method of “because I say so.” She’s opening up the company to a host of potential lawsuits with her actions.
Cam2020 · 17/07/2021 07:41

Aren't you just assuming she will be sacked? Aren't HR more likely to give a warning and offer recruitment training?

I was thinking the same thing. Sacking seems dramatic, unless this person is already under a warning.

MartyHart · 17/07/2021 07:32

How can you accidentally mislead someone that they will be promoted? How can you accidentally not follow recruitment procedures? A mistake would be forgetting to send an email or losing a file.
OP, she's well aware of what she is doing and is continuing to do it.
If the time with you (probably not the first time she's done it) she didn't learn anything then you are letting your colleagues and the company down if you don't speak when asked.
The company could be left open to legal action because of her recruitment M.O.

Sweak · 17/07/2021 07:31

Aren't you just assuming she will be sacked? Aren't HR more likely to give a warning and offer recruitment training?

Two things stuck out for me:
suitable for promotions, childcare responsibilities ruling them out etc. - this is terrible, and surely if all employers took such an approach working parents wouldn't get far in the work place (let's be honest largely working mothers)

Secondly, if you do X,y,,z you will get a promotion and then it never happens...are you sure this carrot isn't being dangled intentionally to get you to do work either outside of your job description or working hours? Are you really sure it's not intentional?

LakeShoreD · 17/07/2021 07:26

It doesn’t sound like a mistake at all. It sounds like person A knew exactly what they were doing- they didn’t accidentally hire another candidate for those new job roles did they? Like oops didn’t mean to send the hiring paperwork to that email address but now they’ve signed it there’s nothing I can do. All the extra work you did because you were expecting a promotion, I’m sure that benefited A. They really don’t sound like a nice person. By the account given here it seems like they have manipulated and taken advantage of you and B by dangling a promotion in front you that you were never ever going to be considered for. Absolutely I’d give HR a factual account and let them decide.

Cloudninenine · 17/07/2021 07:13

How did it cost you financially if it was a work mistake? Not being snarky at all, just curious as to how it unfolded!

It’s really up to you - if you think it’s likely to happen again (and I suspect it would since it has happened twice) I would be inclined to report.

Jent13c · 17/07/2021 07:08

I feel like even with procedures in place this kind of thing often still happens. Years ago I was phoned by a district manager and asked if I wanted to interview for a role which I knew a colleague had applied for and done the training course for. I obviously got the job but they put them through the process of the application and interview knowing they would never employ her.

Your boss is setting the company up for legal action, these procedures are in place for a reason. If they are not following them then it should be reported and the consequences that she faces are not because you added your grievance but because she did it in the first place. Your colleague feels her career has been impacted by this poor practice so she should complain and if you feel the same you should to. The only awkward thing would be if she had actually done things right and your colleague had read the situation wrongly and the boss would find out your complained but obviously still be your boss.

PopcornMuncher · 17/07/2021 06:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NoMoreCovidPlease · 17/07/2021 03:44

I think you're a mug. This person isn't just careless, it's very much intentional.

0None0 · 17/07/2021 03:25

Don’t think of it as being on this person or that persons side

Think of it as being on the side of the truth

HR needs the full truth to make fair decisions. It’s not your place to withhold or cover up the truth.

If you do, you are colluding with the abuse

SourAppleChew · 17/07/2021 03:22

Her behaviour is bad but to say it cost you financially is surely a stretch as you weren't guaranteed the job. She shouldn't be doing it the way she is, but I don't understand why you'd have been happy if she'd just done staged interviews for show and then still given the job to somebody else anyway. The end result is the same.

AmberIsACertainty · 17/07/2021 03:07

[quote ZoinksRun]@AmberIsACertainty I'm not really happy to shaft person B but they still have a job, they're able to carry on working towards promotion. It's not great but they're not worse off. If person A loses their job, that will wreck their life. And they have some positive traits.
I will probably speak to HR if they ask me to, and just state the facts.[/quote]
But, who made you God? That's my question. It's not for you to decide whose life gets ruined due to their own actions, is it? You've got a warped sense of responsibility.

I'm glad you're going to support your colleague.

NumberTheory · 17/07/2021 03:04

You would be very unreasonable to protect person A by refusing to tell HR what happened to you in the circumstances you describe.

LemonViolet · 17/07/2021 02:18

Ignoring established recruitment policies, gossiping about potential internal candidates’ chances and openly discriminating against employees based on childcare responsibilities (remember, marriage/civil partnership, pregnancy/maternity and sex are all protected characteristics, and ‘childcare responsibilities’ could be argued to function as discrimination on these grounds) - these are not “mistakes”. This isn’t that she got some maths wrong or lost some paperwork. These are deliberate acts and clearly a consistent pattern of behaviour. Just because she’s perhaps pleasant to work with at other times doesn’t mitigate this.

Please support person B. You would NOT be responsible for any outcome. Person A is responsible for her own behaviour.

ZoinksRun · 17/07/2021 02:06

@Wingedharpy I have wondered that myself. It's not completely new rules, it's more 'we've looked at this persons job and decided it's actually a pay grade above' but the job is actually a completely different job and this existing employee is being sort of shoehorned into it. For example, I've been at an interview and they've said 'you didn't get this one but this job is coming up, you can do that if you want' so the other job doesn't go to advert, and it isn't open to everyone. It's so bizarre.

OP posts:
Wingedharpy · 17/07/2021 02:01

HR sound sloppy to me OP.
Are they not involved in recruitment?
Are they not concerned about equal opportunities?
Do they no wonder where these new folk have come from when they suddenly appear on the payroll?
Is person A giving these jobs to their own friends/family?
Do they work in Politics?

ZoinksRun · 17/07/2021 01:53

@AmberIsACertainty I'm not really happy to shaft person B but they still have a job, they're able to carry on working towards promotion. It's not great but they're not worse off. If person A loses their job, that will wreck their life. And they have some positive traits.
I will probably speak to HR if they ask me to, and just state the facts.

OP posts:
QueenBee52 · 17/07/2021 01:52

@ZoinksRun

It was to do with a promotion opportunity. She has form for creating jobs for people, not advertising them, not offering them to existing staff nor external candidates. She was mentoring me, I did a lot of extra work on the understanding that when there was going to be a permanent post soon and that I would be considered. She then created the post and gave it to someone else, no interview, no advert. Recently she did the same to my colleague, overlooked her for two promotions and then hired someone else for a role which didn't previously exist. It's not her business and there are HR guidelines she should follow. Other things which are being looked at are her discussing with colleagues why others aren't suitable for promotions, childcare responsibilities ruling them out etc. It may sound like sour grapes but it affected my confidence at the time.

Oooft ... ignore my previous post ..

Support Person B

QueenBee52 · 17/07/2021 01:51

Person A made a mistake a year ago that caused me a lot of stress and cost me financially.

The mistake has had no repercussions for me now. It's not effected anyone else

so, you would blindly go through that stress and financial loss again, because there has been no repercussions for you and tbh why would there be.. this was not your error .., so Im also a bit confused 🌸

Is there anyone you could confide in at work besides Person B ..

just out if curiosity.. how does Person B know this happened to you, do others also know?

AmberIsACertainty · 17/07/2021 01:46

I would do the decent thing and tell HR. You don't want to be responsible for someone "losing their job" ie negatively impacting their career, but you're happy to be responsible for your colleague having a negatively impacted career. If you'd told about the mistake when it happened to you, person A might have been dealt with sufficiently that they didn't go on to make a similar mistake with your colleague. Of course you're not actually responsible for either impacted career. Person A is responsible for their own actions and the consequences of those. If they've done nothing wrong then you telling what happened won't have any effect on them will it and if it does have an effect then it's their own fault. I can't see why you'd be happy to shaft a colleague to protect the person who shafted both you and them.

ZoinksRun · 17/07/2021 01:45

The thing is though, if person A just put out a job advert, she could have hired anyone she wanted anyway! She didn't have to hire person B or me, if she'd just gone down the official channels she could have done exactly the same.

OP posts:
Snoozer11 · 17/07/2021 01:45

You gave your support to person A by not escalating your situation further when they made the mistake with you.

The situation is different now that you're aware the same thing has happened to someoje else.

I'd argue to being a nice person is subjective. We can all be nice people but at the same time we can be dicks. This conversation is about her ineptitude and her behaviour in essentially stringing people along.

Mrbob · 17/07/2021 01:40

Yes. Support person B. This is really bad behaviour and not ok. Basically you are saying it’s fine for A to just hire whoever she wants? If you don’t say something you are complicit

Sleepingdogs12 · 17/07/2021 01:40

I would think if asked formally you could share the bare facts without all of your views and opinions about it added, I think that would be reasonable. Supports the other person but doesn't drag you into it more than you want to be.