Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I really want to go down this road?

59 replies

ZoinksRun · 17/07/2021 00:37

Sorry for being vague:
Person A is my boss. Person A made a mistake a year ago that caused me a lot of stress and cost me financially. A couple of months ago person B told me that person A had made the same mistake with them and it had effected them negatively, and impacted their career progression. These mistakes are made through carelessness and a disregard for procedures rather than maliciously.
Person B is taking this further. This might result in person A getting dismissed. Person B wants me to tell them what happened with me last year. I'm not sure I could live with partially responsible for someone losing their job. The mistake has had no repercussions for me now. It's not effected anyone else. Person A is a nice person, we get on well. I understand why person B is angry, as I was this time last year. Should I just say that I don't want to speak to HR?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QueenBee52 · 17/07/2021 22:42

@Snog

When I worked for the NHS this kind of behaviour by managers was not uncommon and HR would pretty much always back the more senior person in the organisation regardless of the rights and wrongs of the situation. With a heavy heart I say that this could work out badly for you OP.

this pisses me off... we all know how hard and long the shifts are without this unfair bollocks.. 🌸

Snog · 17/07/2021 21:35

When I worked for the NHS this kind of behaviour by managers was not uncommon and HR would pretty much always back the more senior person in the organisation regardless of the rights and wrongs of the situation. With a heavy heart I say that this could work out badly for you OP.

SeasonFinale · 17/07/2021 15:20

Person A would not have been able to do all this without the support of the more senior managers surely. Thus person A is unlikely to lose her job for something they were already aware of.

CremeEggThief · 17/07/2021 15:18

Obviously it's just my opinion and I can understand it might be a pain in the neck/adding stress to your existing load, etc., but I do feel you should support your colleague.

I have just left a temporary job I was doing, mainly as I was overlooked for promotion for the next level up; despite doing several aspects of it for months and even being given a bonus for exceptional work, that was normally only given to permanent staff. Ultimately, I decided I couldn't live with it and left. However, if it had been a permanent post, I probably would have done what your colleague is doing now and obviously your support would assist them.

SourAppleChew · 17/07/2021 15:08

Actually, I'm being a dumbass. That was clearly a way for my boss to get around paying agency fees.

SourAppleChew · 17/07/2021 15:07

I thought jobs did have to be advertised externally?

I was given a full time job from an agency position, along with a colleague, and the boss advertised it externally. Let us both go and told us he'd advertise in a few weeks and we'd get the jobs.

Mansplainee · 17/07/2021 09:34

Her behaviour is bad but to say it cost you financially is surely a stretch as you weren't guaranteed the job. She shouldn't be doing it the way she is, but I don't understand why you'd have been happy if she'd just done staged interviews for show and then still given the job to somebody else anyway. The end result is the same.

This is my feeling on the situation too. There is no obligation for an employer to advertise a role, they can directly appoint if they want to. It’s bad practice not to run an open recruitment process yes, but I’m not sure it’s likely to be a sackable offence. HR will almost certainly already be aware of it as they’ll have had to process the promotions. So they’re either on board with the steps the manager has taken, or they’re not happy about it but have already whether or not to take action with the manager.

The discriminatory comments are another matter though, and that could be much more serious. That needs to be investigated and I think if you have any information about it you have a moral obligation to share it.

Brefugee · 17/07/2021 09:29

also have now seen the update with the fact they were gossiping about people's circumstances childcare issues are they women? You are shafting another woman because A - who is a fucker, tbh - is "nice"?

This is a site full of mums and you're happy to have mums treated like this in the workplace? REALLY?

Aprilx · 17/07/2021 09:23

This doesn’t look anything like a sackable offence to me. The organisation is already aware of what hiring decisions have been made and will also know whether and what the recruitment process looked like. It isn’t illegal to not follow a fair recruitment process and considering the other people that would have been involved in the appointment I don’t think one person is going to be disciplined over it. There could be a review of process, which would be a good thing of course.

There is maybe a reprimand for some of the things mentioned, but the details are a bit too vague here to say, sounds like hearsay to me. Maybe another employee said they could not take on an increased role because of childcare responsibilities and A repeated that for example.

I think that if somebody asks you about your experience, you should answer the questions. It may be useful feedback. Although I think you are wrong to say she made a mistake that cost you money - you didn’t get a promotion you had hoped for.

Brefugee · 17/07/2021 09:23

Recently she did the same to my colleague, overlooked her for two promotions and then hired someone else for a role which didn't previously exist

She did this to you as well? Have some self respect. She is a user and this is appalling.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 17/07/2021 09:21

Personally I'm sick of getting embroiled in other peoples shit which I often did for the first 10 years at work.
I've been working for 40 years and you can guarantee it will go badly for you.
The only time I got involved with work politics was when my old boss tried to sack me for being pregnant, I took him to a tribunal and he got sacked.
Other than that I don't want to know.

3Britnee · 17/07/2021 09:14

@ZoinksRun

Sorry for being vague: Person A is my boss. Person A made a mistake a year ago that caused me a lot of stress and cost me financially. A couple of months ago person B told me that person A had made the same mistake with them and it had effected them negatively, and impacted their career progression. These mistakes are made through carelessness and a disregard for procedures rather than maliciously. Person B is taking this further. This might result in person A getting dismissed. Person B wants me to tell them what happened with me last year. I'm not sure I could live with partially responsible for someone losing their job. The mistake has had no repercussions for me now. It's not effected anyone else. Person A is a nice person, we get on well. I understand why person B is angry, as I was this time last year. Should I just say that I don't want to speak to HR?
Person A should lose their job Confused

Woman up, ffs.

MrsPinkCock · 17/07/2021 09:06

I wouldn’t go and volunteer the information, but you’ll need to answer any questions asked of you by HR or the investigating manager.

Refusing to comply with the investigation would be a failure to follow a reasonable management instruction (and could be a breach of contract, depending on its terms) so you could face disciplinary action yourself by actively refusing to assist.

PuntasticUsername · 17/07/2021 08:57

Oh, come on. Person A has behaved dreadfully (and she'll do it again if she gets the chance, that's clear). Of course you should support Person B.

Also, you appear to feel an excessive weight of responsibility re whether your boss loses her job. If she does, it'll be because of things she herself did without any input from you. And you won't make the decision, HR will.

Do the right thing. Help stop her getting away with this kind of crap.

Whyo · 17/07/2021 08:51

HR will be absolutely aware of all job roles and employees, I don’t understand how they wouldn’t be aware already of what you’ve described.

If you and B were indeed the best person for the roles then why weren’t you hired for them? I don’t think you not getting a role you think you were working towards could be the basis of someone losing their job.

Were you both explicitly told that such promotion was to occur or has it been assumed?

Carrott21 · 17/07/2021 08:45

Another struggling to see a mistake.

hedgehogger1 · 17/07/2021 08:44

Person A is not a good person. If you are asked tell the truth

SirYawnsAlot · 17/07/2021 08:42

Sounds very malicious to me, she is gaming and structuring a system to benefit herself so doesn't sound absent minded. Support your colleague. Who knows, one of you may get her job.

FrenchBoule · 17/07/2021 08:33

A is not a nice person as you describe it.
You didn’t get a promotion and neither got B.
You say B is still able to work towards promotion? Are they going to get it or not because of A’s “mistake”?
Nobody makes the same mistake twice.
A is crap manager and very unprofessional if they discuss with colleagues who “deserves” promotion and who doesn’t.
People’s childminding shouldn’t come as a factor at all.

Support person B. Person A needs to change their ways.

Ariela · 17/07/2021 08:20

And the next time A wants a load of extra work done and promises you the moon: will you step up and do it on the basis you'll get promoted?

pilates · 17/07/2021 08:14

If HR asked the question then I would answer truthfully but agree it’s weird how they wouldn’t know what’s going on anyway.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 17/07/2021 08:07

Person A sounds like she doesn't give a shit and just does what she wants when she wants, to hell with the consequences for others.

How many other people are you going to watch her impact on the careers of before you'd think it was ok to take a stand?

FrogWaa · 17/07/2021 08:00

How the hell was it a mistake? She didn't trip and land on the 'hire new person' button. She knew exactly what she was doing. Your boss may have not been required to hire you but if you believe you were the Best person for the job you could have discussed it with HR. Hard to do if you don't even know the job exists This is massively out of order and yes,you should help B. She's doing the right thing.

Terhou · 17/07/2021 07:54

I don't understand why HR doesn't already know. Surely when someone suddenly appears in a new position without there having been any proper recruitment process they would notice?

MyriadeOfThings · 17/07/2021 07:49

Support person B.

A has already ignored you for a promotion. A is using reasons such as needing childcare for not giving a job to someone.
Do you really think you have any chance of a promotion whilst working for A???

Rules are there for a reason- to protect people from managers like A. It’s not just a small mistake.

Btw if A was loosing their job,, it would be THEIR fault. Not yours. They know very. Well what they are doing. And if they don’t, they shouldn’t be in that job either.